SCORE_SCORECARD.md

music/pass5/SCORE_SCORECARD.md

Pass 3 — the score-side scorecard

Honest tier: STRUCTURE. Every number below is a property of the WRITING, computed from the plans through the renderer's own compiler before a sample was played. Nobody has heard any of this music. The targets are PROPOSED by the motivic-development lane's section 3.6 and carry no calibrated null; clearing them is evidence the writing changed and never evidence that the music is good.

Targets, per cue

target	floor	round 2	PASS5_FLORES_FALLS	PASS5_FLORES_ROAD	PASS5_FLORES_ROUNDS
theme_bars_max	>= 8	2	10 PASS	18 PASS	18 PASS
min_post_plant_bars	>= 4	2	8 PASS	8 PASS	6 PASS
melodic_ideas	>= 2	1	2 PASS	2 PASS	2 PASS
operations	>= 10	8	28 PASS	35 PASS	38 PASS
spine_changing	>= 6	3	22 PASS	28 PASS	31 PASS
chain_depth_mean	> 1.5	1.0	2.1667 PASS	2.2857 PASS	2.625 PASS
chain_depth_max	>= 4	1	4 PASS	4 PASS	5 PASS
chain_resets	>= 1	0	1 PASS	1 PASS	1 PASS
theme_bar_share	>= 0.5	0.28	0.8519 PASS	0.8889 PASS	0.9113 PASS
theme_notes_per_bar	>= 2.0	2.6	3.261 PASS	2.531 PASS	2.655 PASS
evaded_cadences	>= 1	0	1 PASS	1 PASS	1 PASS
near_plain_arrivals	== 1	0	1 PASS	1 PASS	1 PASS
counter_onset_coincidence	<= 0.35	1.0	0.1538 PASS	0.0 PASS	0.0 PASS
counter_exclusive_fraction	>= 0.1	0.0	0.1071 PASS	0.316 PASS	0.4043 PASS
theme_distinctness	< 0.8	1.0	0.5 PASS	0.5 PASS	0.5 PASS
ornament_at_goal_share	<= 0.15	None	0.0139 PASS	0.008 PASS	0.0 PASS
hold_share	>= 0.3656	0.061	0.5926 PASS	0.4444 PASS	0.5484 PASS
energy_min_vs_class_floor	>= 0.5018	None	0.4 PASS	0.4 PASS	0.52 PASS
valleys_with_a_melodic_layer	== 0	None	0 PASS	0 PASS	0 PASS

PASS5_FLORES_FALLS — Flores Highlands -- the light on the water

180.0 s, 54 bars, 27 cycles at 72.0 bpm, class SANCTUARY; targets 19/19
theme: 2 melodic ideas, longest phrase 10 bars, phrase lengths {'8': 4, '10': 2}, shortest post-plant statement 8 bars
operations: 28 named, 22 spine-changing (augmentation, contrapuntal_combination, evaded_cadence, fragmentation, intervallic_expansion, liquidation, modal_mutation, phrase_expansion, rhythmic_displacement, sequence_tonal)
derivation chain: 6 statements, mean depth 2.1667, max 4, resets 1
cadences: 6 ({'evaded_then_PAC': 1, 'HC': 1, 'IAC': 2, 'none_withheld': 2}), evaded 1
melodic density: theme layers sound in 0.8519 of bars at 3.261 notes per sounding bar; 0.0816 of all composed notes carry the theme (round 2: 0.021-0.046)
counter-melody: worst onset coincidence 0.1538 (round 2: 1.000), best exclusive-sounding fraction 0.1071 (round 2: 0.000)
ornament: 72 events, 1.333 per bar, 0.0139 of them landing on a declared goal tone
dynamic arc: min 0.4 mean 0.6133 max 0.76, 4 peaks and 1 valleys; valleys with no melodic layer none
BUILD AND HOLD: 3 holds, longest 53.33 s, hold share 0.5926 against this class's corpus median 0.501 and round 2's INTENDED {'PASS2_FLORES_CACI': 0.061, 'PASS2_FLORES_REST': 0.0, 'PASS2_FLORES_WATERFALL': 0.0} — round 2's plans contained no plateaus at all, which is why it did not build and hold
composed silence: 1 windows, 4.167 s clean, fraction 0.02315 (round 2: 0.0 exactly, on 0 of 62 reference tracks)
leitmotif reference [near_plain_arrival]: the theme, near-plain, in the widest registration of the cue at cycle 13 — span 4, and in this cue the arrival comes BEFORE the withdrawal: the light reaches the water and then the pool is quiet again

PASS5_FLORES_ROAD — Flores Highlands -- the road that keeps count

223.45 s, 108 bars, 27 cycles at 116.0 bpm, class EXPLORATION; targets 19/19
theme: 2 melodic ideas, longest phrase 18 bars, phrase lengths {'8': 1, '12': 1, '16': 4, '18': 1}, shortest post-plant statement 8 bars
operations: 35 named, 28 spine-changing (augmentation, contrapuntal_combination, evaded_cadence, fragmentation, intervallic_expansion, liquidation, modal_mutation, phrase_expansion, rhythmic_displacement, sequence_tonal)
derivation chain: 7 statements, mean depth 2.2857, max 4, resets 1
cadences: 7 ({'HC': 1, 'evaded_then_PAC': 1, 'IAC': 2, 'none_withheld': 3}), evaded 1
melodic density: theme layers sound in 0.8889 of bars at 2.531 notes per sounding bar; 0.0599 of all composed notes carry the theme (round 2: 0.021-0.046)
counter-melody: worst onset coincidence 0.0 (round 2: 1.000), best exclusive-sounding fraction 0.316 (round 2: 0.000)
ornament: 125 events, 1.157 per bar, 0.008 of them landing on a declared goal tone
dynamic arc: min 0.4 mean 0.6822 max 0.88, 4 peaks and 3 valleys; valleys with no melodic layer none
BUILD AND HOLD: 3 holds, longest 41.38 s, hold share 0.4444 against this class's corpus median 0.3347 and round 2's INTENDED {'PASS2_FLORES_CACI': 0.061, 'PASS2_FLORES_REST': 0.0, 'PASS2_FLORES_WATERFALL': 0.0} — round 2's plans contained no plateaus at all, which is why it did not build and hold
composed silence: 2 windows, 8.275 s clean, fraction 0.03703 (round 2: 0.0 exactly, on 0 of 62 reference tracks)
leitmotif reference [parent_quotation]: JOURNEY_WORLD's four head notes, verbatim, with the licensed +9 leap at cycle 23 — the arrival span, where the road opens onto the lingko fields and the count the chapter is named for is kept -- one scheduled moment, in one cue of the three
leitmotif reference [near_plain_arrival]: the theme, near-plain, in the widest registration of the cue at cycle 21 — plant-then-never-neutrally, with its one licensed exception at the arrival

PASS5_FLORES_ROUNDS — Flores Highlands -- the caci rounds

201.08 s, 124 bars, 31 cycles at 148.0 bpm, class BATTLE; targets 19/19
theme: 2 melodic ideas, longest phrase 18 bars, phrase lengths {'6': 1, '16': 6, '18': 1}, shortest post-plant statement 6 bars
operations: 38 named, 31 spine-changing (augmentation, contrapuntal_combination, evaded_cadence, fragmentation, intervallic_expansion, liquidation, modal_mutation, phrase_expansion, rhythmic_displacement, sequence_tonal)
derivation chain: 8 statements, mean depth 2.625, max 5, resets 1
cadences: 8 ({'HC': 2, 'evaded_then_PAC': 1, 'IAC': 2, 'none_withheld': 3}), evaded 1
melodic density: theme layers sound in 0.9113 of bars at 2.655 notes per sounding bar; 0.0638 of all composed notes carry the theme (round 2: 0.021-0.046)
counter-melody: worst onset coincidence 0.0 (round 2: 1.000), best exclusive-sounding fraction 0.4043 (round 2: 0.000)
ornament: 136 events, 1.097 per bar, 0.0 of them landing on a declared goal tone
dynamic arc: min 0.52 mean 0.7677 max 0.94, 5 peaks and 3 valleys; valleys with no melodic layer none
BUILD AND HOLD: 4 holds, longest 38.92 s, hold share 0.5484 against this class's corpus median 0.3656 and round 2's INTENDED {'PASS2_FLORES_CACI': 0.061, 'PASS2_FLORES_REST': 0.0, 'PASS2_FLORES_WATERFALL': 0.0} — round 2's plans contained no plateaus at all, which is why it did not build and hold
composed silence: 2 windows, 2.432 s clean, fraction 0.01209 (round 2: 0.0 exactly, on 0 of 62 reference tracks)
leitmotif reference [near_plain_arrival]: the theme, near-plain, widest registration, phase two's last round at cycle 25 — the arrival after phase two's own full ascent; the parent quotation belongs to the road cue and is not repeated here

Cross-cue theme distinctness

Josh, 2026-08-07: do not use the same exemplar melodies across all tracks, even in the same region. Region identity is carried by instrumentation, mode, register, rhythmic dialect, ornament practice and the colotomic frame -- not by the tune. Round 2's three cues were three arrangements of ONE head cell and scored 1.000 here by construction.

a	b	interval LCS	contour LCS	chroma best of 12	max	verdict
PASS5_FLORES_FALLS	PASS5_FLORES_ROAD	0.4	0.4	0.942	0.4	DISTINCT
PASS5_FLORES_FALLS	PASS5_FLORES_ROUNDS	0.1667	0.5	0.7314	0.5	DISTINCT
PASS5_FLORES_ROAD	PASS5_FLORES_ROUNDS	0.1667	0.5	0.7942	0.5	DISTINCT

Worst pair 0.5 against a floor of 0.8; all distinct = True.

Pass-4 additions (reported beside the base battery, never in it)

operations the pass-3 battery has no opinion about, reported BESIDE it and never folded into it -- folding them in would move the denominator and end the before-and-after comparison

cue	target	value	pass	asked by
PASS5_FLORES_FALLS	rotation_inside_every_declared_hold	0	PASS	build/audio/pass3/PASS3_VERDICT.md section 4; docs/work_queue.json WQ_0086; the spine clause added after instr_dynamic_arc measured 0.0 s of hold under uniform rotation against its own 22.287 s floor
PASS5_FLORES_FALLS	hold_spine_reaches_the_dynamic_arc_floor	26.67	PASS	harness/music_gen/instr_dynamic_arc.py :: floor_longest_hold_s = 22.287, calibrated on 28 corpus hits against 716 within-album controls; the file-reading route was forced by the pass-4 critic's forged-waiver probe
PASS5_FLORES_FALLS	rotation_changes_no_energy	0	PASS	WQ_0086.note -- 'WHILE THE DECLARED ENERGY STAYS FLAT'
PASS5_FLORES_FALLS	rotation_block_length_one_to_two_cycles	2	PASS	WQ_0086.note -- 'every one to two cycles'
PASS5_FLORES_FALLS	all_three_axes_rotate	3	PASS	WQ_0086.note -- 'rotate the carrier, the instrument family and the irama level'; a block where an answering voice runs holds the carrier by design and says so
PASS5_FLORES_FALLS	span_schedule_is_DECLARED (the distinctness property is the gate's form diff)	6	PASS	docs/work_queue.json WQ_0085; renamed on the pass-4 critic's MEDIUM finding that the old name claimed a property this predicate does not test
PASS5_FLORES_FALLS	carrier_keeps_the_skeleton_and_the_ornament_part_takes_the_division	72	PASS	build/audio/pass3/PASS3_VERDICT.md section 2 -- the named repair
PASS5_FLORES_FALLS	counter_melody_derived_against_the_carrier_it_is_measured_against	4	PASS	PASS3_VERDICT.md section 2 -- 'leave the carrier nearer its skeleton'
PASS5_FLORES_ROAD	rotation_inside_every_declared_hold	0	PASS	build/audio/pass3/PASS3_VERDICT.md section 4; docs/work_queue.json WQ_0086; the spine clause added after instr_dynamic_arc measured 0.0 s of hold under uniform rotation against its own 22.287 s floor
PASS5_FLORES_ROAD	hold_spine_reaches_the_dynamic_arc_floor	24.83	PASS	harness/music_gen/instr_dynamic_arc.py :: floor_longest_hold_s = 22.287, calibrated on 28 corpus hits against 716 within-album controls; the file-reading route was forced by the pass-4 critic's forged-waiver probe
PASS5_FLORES_ROAD	rotation_changes_no_energy	0	PASS	WQ_0086.note -- 'WHILE THE DECLARED ENERGY STAYS FLAT'
PASS5_FLORES_ROAD	rotation_block_length_one_to_two_cycles	2	PASS	WQ_0086.note -- 'every one to two cycles'
PASS5_FLORES_ROAD	all_three_axes_rotate	3	PASS	WQ_0086.note -- 'rotate the carrier, the instrument family and the irama level'; a block where an answering voice runs holds the carrier by design and says so
PASS5_FLORES_ROAD	span_schedule_is_DECLARED (the distinctness property is the gate's form diff)	7	PASS	docs/work_queue.json WQ_0085; renamed on the pass-4 critic's MEDIUM finding that the old name claimed a property this predicate does not test
PASS5_FLORES_ROAD	carrier_keeps_the_skeleton_and_the_ornament_part_takes_the_division	125	PASS	build/audio/pass3/PASS3_VERDICT.md section 2 -- the named repair
PASS5_FLORES_ROAD	counter_melody_derived_against_the_carrier_it_is_measured_against	3	PASS	PASS3_VERDICT.md section 2 -- 'leave the carrier nearer its skeleton'
PASS5_FLORES_ROUNDS	rotation_inside_every_declared_hold	0	PASS	build/audio/pass3/PASS3_VERDICT.md section 4; docs/work_queue.json WQ_0086; the spine clause added after instr_dynamic_arc measured 0.0 s of hold under uniform rotation against its own 22.287 s floor
PASS5_FLORES_ROUNDS	hold_spine_reaches_the_dynamic_arc_floor	34.92	PASS	harness/music_gen/instr_dynamic_arc.py :: floor_longest_hold_s = 22.287, calibrated on 28 corpus hits against 716 within-album controls; the file-reading route was forced by the pass-4 critic's forged-waiver probe
PASS5_FLORES_ROUNDS	rotation_changes_no_energy	0	PASS	WQ_0086.note -- 'WHILE THE DECLARED ENERGY STAYS FLAT'
PASS5_FLORES_ROUNDS	rotation_block_length_one_to_two_cycles	2	PASS	WQ_0086.note -- 'every one to two cycles'
PASS5_FLORES_ROUNDS	all_three_axes_rotate	3	PASS	WQ_0086.note -- 'rotate the carrier, the instrument family and the irama level'; a block where an answering voice runs holds the carrier by design and says so
PASS5_FLORES_ROUNDS	span_schedule_is_DECLARED (the distinctness property is the gate's form diff)	8	PASS	docs/work_queue.json WQ_0085; renamed on the pass-4 critic's MEDIUM finding that the old name claimed a property this predicate does not test
PASS5_FLORES_ROUNDS	carrier_keeps_the_skeleton_and_the_ornament_part_takes_the_division	136	PASS	build/audio/pass3/PASS3_VERDICT.md section 2 -- the named repair
PASS5_FLORES_ROUNDS	counter_melody_derived_against_the_carrier_it_is_measured_against	4	PASS	PASS3_VERDICT.md section 2 -- 'leave the carrier nearer its skeleton'

Additions passed: 24 of 24.

Base battery: 57 of 57 — pass 3 scored 55 and round 2 scored 7 on the same code.

Generated by harness/site/structure_site.py — the URL path is the repo path. review root