SCORE_SCORECARD.md

music/pass3/SCORE_SCORECARD.md

Pass 3 — the score-side scorecard

Honest tier: STRUCTURE. Every number below is a property of the WRITING, computed from the plans through the renderer's own compiler before a sample was played. Nobody has heard any of this music. The targets are PROPOSED by the motivic-development lane's section 3.6 and carry no calibrated null; clearing them is evidence the writing changed and never evidence that the music is good.

Targets, per cue

target	floor	round 2	FALLS	ROAD	ROUNDS
theme_bars_max	>= 8	2	10 PASS	18 PASS	18 PASS
min_post_plant_bars	>= 4	2	4 PASS	8 PASS	8 PASS
melodic_ideas	>= 2	1	2 PASS	2 PASS	2 PASS
operations	>= 10	8	35 PASS	35 PASS	35 PASS
spine_changing	>= 6	3	28 PASS	28 PASS	28 PASS
chain_depth_mean	> 1.5	1.0	2.2857 PASS	2.2857 PASS	2.2857 PASS
chain_depth_max	>= 4	1	4 PASS	4 PASS	4 PASS
chain_resets	>= 1	0	1 PASS	1 PASS	1 PASS
theme_bar_share	>= 0.5	0.28	0.8966 PASS	0.8889 PASS	0.8333 PASS
theme_notes_per_bar	>= 2.0	2.6	4.423 PASS	3.802 PASS	4.21 PASS
evaded_cadences	>= 1	0	1 PASS	1 PASS	1 PASS
near_plain_arrivals	== 1	0	1 PASS	1 PASS	1 PASS
counter_onset_coincidence	<= 0.35	1.0	0.3571 MISS	0.0 PASS	0.0 PASS
counter_exclusive_fraction	>= 0.1	0.0	0.0553 MISS	0.3031 PASS	0.35 PASS
theme_distinctness	< 0.8	1.0	0.5 PASS	0.5 PASS	0.5 PASS
ornament_at_goal_share	<= 0.15	None	0.0 PASS	0.0134 PASS	0.0 PASS
hold_share	>= 0.3656	0.061	0.5862 PASS	0.4444 PASS	0.4667 PASS
energy_min_vs_class_floor	>= 0.5018	None	0.38 PASS	0.4 PASS	0.52 PASS
valleys_with_a_melodic_layer	== 0	None	0 PASS	0 PASS	0 PASS

PASS3_FLORES_FALLS — Flores Highlands -- the light on the water

193.33 s, 58 bars, 29 cycles at 72.0 bpm, class SANCTUARY; targets 17/19
theme: 2 melodic ideas, longest phrase 10 bars, phrase lengths {'4': 1, '6': 1, '8': 4, '10': 1}, shortest post-plant statement 4 bars
operations: 35 named, 28 spine-changing (augmentation, contrapuntal_combination, evaded_cadence, fragmentation, intervallic_expansion, liquidation, modal_mutation, phrase_expansion, rhythmic_displacement, sequence_tonal)
derivation chain: 7 statements, mean depth 2.2857, max 4, resets 1
cadences: 7 ({'HC': 1, 'evaded_then_PAC': 1, 'IAC': 2, 'none_withheld': 3}), evaded 1
melodic density: theme layers sound in 0.8966 of bars at 4.423 notes per sounding bar; 0.1134 of all composed notes carry the theme (round 2: 0.021-0.046)
counter-melody: worst onset coincidence 0.3571 (round 2: 1.000), best exclusive-sounding fraction 0.0553 (round 2: 0.000)
ornament: 40 events, 0.69 per bar, 0.0 of them landing on a declared goal tone
dynamic arc: min 0.38 mean 0.6062 max 0.74, 4 peaks and 2 valleys; valleys with no melodic layer none
BUILD AND HOLD: 3 holds, longest 40.0 s, hold share 0.5862 against this class's corpus median 0.501 and round 2's INTENDED {'PASS2_FLORES_CACI': 0.061, 'PASS2_FLORES_REST': 0.0, 'PASS2_FLORES_WATERFALL': 0.0} — round 2's plans contained no plateaus at all, which is why it did not build and hold
composed silence: 2 windows, 7.5 s clean, fraction 0.03879 (round 2: 0.0 exactly, on 0 of 62 reference tracks)
leitmotif reference [near_plain_arrival]: the theme, near-plain, in the widest registration of the cue at cycle 22 — the arrival span; the parent quotation is NOT used here -- it belongs to the road cue and is spent once across the region

PASS3_FLORES_ROAD — Flores Highlands -- the road that keeps count

223.45 s, 108 bars, 27 cycles at 116.0 bpm, class EXPLORATION; targets 19/19
theme: 2 melodic ideas, longest phrase 18 bars, phrase lengths {'8': 1, '12': 1, '16': 4, '18': 1}, shortest post-plant statement 8 bars
operations: 35 named, 28 spine-changing (augmentation, contrapuntal_combination, evaded_cadence, fragmentation, intervallic_expansion, liquidation, modal_mutation, phrase_expansion, rhythmic_displacement, sequence_tonal)
derivation chain: 7 statements, mean depth 2.2857, max 4, resets 1
cadences: 7 ({'HC': 1, 'evaded_then_PAC': 1, 'IAC': 2, 'none_withheld': 3}), evaded 1
melodic density: theme layers sound in 0.8889 of bars at 3.802 notes per sounding bar; 0.0869 of all composed notes carry the theme (round 2: 0.021-0.046)
counter-melody: worst onset coincidence 0.0 (round 2: 1.000), best exclusive-sounding fraction 0.3031 (round 2: 0.000)
ornament: 149 events, 1.38 per bar, 0.0134 of them landing on a declared goal tone
dynamic arc: min 0.4 mean 0.6822 max 0.88, 4 peaks and 3 valleys; valleys with no melodic layer none
BUILD AND HOLD: 3 holds, longest 41.38 s, hold share 0.4444 against this class's corpus median 0.3347 and round 2's INTENDED {'PASS2_FLORES_CACI': 0.061, 'PASS2_FLORES_REST': 0.0, 'PASS2_FLORES_WATERFALL': 0.0} — round 2's plans contained no plateaus at all, which is why it did not build and hold
composed silence: 2 windows, 8.275 s clean, fraction 0.03703 (round 2: 0.0 exactly, on 0 of 62 reference tracks)
leitmotif reference [parent_quotation]: JOURNEY_WORLD's four head notes, verbatim, with the licensed +9 leap at cycle 23 — the arrival span, where the road opens onto the lingko fields and the count the chapter is named for is kept -- one scheduled moment, in one cue of the three, which is what the registry's transformation_plan asks for
leitmotif reference [near_plain_arrival]: the theme, near-plain, in the widest registration of the cue at cycle 21 — plant-then-never-neutrally, with its one licensed exception at the arrival

PASS3_FLORES_ROUNDS — Flores Highlands -- the caci rounds

194.59 s, 120 bars, 30 cycles at 148.0 bpm, class BATTLE; targets 19/19
theme: 2 melodic ideas, longest phrase 18 bars, phrase lengths {'8': 1, '16': 4, '18': 1, '24': 1}, shortest post-plant statement 8 bars
operations: 35 named, 28 spine-changing (augmentation, contrapuntal_combination, evaded_cadence, fragmentation, intervallic_expansion, liquidation, modal_mutation, phrase_expansion, rhythmic_displacement, sequence_tonal)
derivation chain: 7 statements, mean depth 2.2857, max 4, resets 1
cadences: 7 ({'HC': 1, 'evaded_then_PAC': 1, 'IAC': 2, 'none_withheld': 3}), evaded 1
melodic density: theme layers sound in 0.8333 of bars at 4.21 notes per sounding bar; 0.0926 of all composed notes carry the theme (round 2: 0.021-0.046)
counter-melody: worst onset coincidence 0.0 (round 2: 1.000), best exclusive-sounding fraction 0.35 (round 2: 0.000)
ornament: 180 events, 1.5 per bar, 0.0 of them landing on a declared goal tone
dynamic arc: min 0.52 mean 0.7533 max 0.94, 3 peaks and 2 valleys; valleys with no melodic layer none
BUILD AND HOLD: 3 holds, longest 32.43 s, hold share 0.4667 against this class's corpus median 0.3656 and round 2's INTENDED {'PASS2_FLORES_CACI': 0.061, 'PASS2_FLORES_REST': 0.0, 'PASS2_FLORES_WATERFALL': 0.0} — round 2's plans contained no plateaus at all, which is why it did not build and hold
composed silence: 2 windows, 6.486 s clean, fraction 0.03333 (round 2: 0.0 exactly, on 0 of 62 reference tracks)
leitmotif reference [near_plain_arrival]: the theme, near-plain, widest registration, phase two's last round at cycle 24 — the arrival after the collapse; the parent quotation belongs to the road cue and is not repeated here

Cross-cue theme distinctness

Josh, 2026-08-07: do not use the same exemplar melodies across all tracks, even in the same region. Region identity is carried by instrumentation, mode, register, rhythmic dialect, ornament practice and the colotomic frame -- not by the tune. Round 2's three cues were three arrangements of ONE head cell and scored 1.000 here by construction.

a	b	interval LCS	contour LCS	chroma best of 12	max	verdict
FALLS	ROAD	0.4	0.4	0.942	0.4	DISTINCT
FALLS	ROUNDS	0.1667	0.5	0.7314	0.5	DISTINCT
ROAD	ROUNDS	0.1667	0.5	0.7942	0.5	DISTINCT

Worst pair 0.5 against a floor of 0.8; all distinct = True.

Generated by harness/site/structure_site.py — the URL path is the repo path. review root