music/pass2/verdicts.json
{
"_doc": "the pass-2 cues, scored on the IDENTICAL filter round 1 was judged by",
"_honest_tier": "STRUCTURE. A CC0 sampler render is not a scoring session and nobody has heard these cues -- not Josh, not the director, not the lane that made them.",
"_filter_authority": "build/audio/generated/slice_v1/verdicts.json -- the constants are READ out of round 1's own cells and proved uniform before use, never re-typed and never re-chosen after seeing these tracks.",
"_what_a_keep_means": "NECESSARY, NEVER SUFFICIENT -- exactly what it meant in round 1. Inside the box means not unlike the tracks Josh named. It has never meant good.",
"_structural_yield": {
"hits": 0.76,
"siblings": 1.0,
"round_1": 0.22,
"auc_vs_round_1": 0.911,
"auc_vs_siblings": 0.437,
"honest_label": "a GENERATION-DEFECT detector, never a taste oracle -- near chance against the corpus's own album siblings (0.437), near-perfect against our own generator's output (0.911)"
},
"emitted_at": "2026-08-08T00:19:46+00:00",
"n_cues": 3,
"refusals": [],
"cues": {
"PASS2_FLORES_CACI": {
"artifact_id": "PASS2_FLORES_CACI",
"verdict": "KEEP",
"rejected_on": [],
"unmeasurable": [],
"joint_box": {
"melody_span_semitones": {
"value": 54.0,
"lo": 19.67,
"hi": 57.0,
"inside": true
},
"section_mean_s": {
"value": 21.6217,
"lo": 7.145,
"hi": 63.3454,
"inside": true
},
"X_rest_grammar": {
"value": 10.4833,
"lo": 2.6757,
"hi": 17.4281,
"inside": true
}
},
"heldout_rules": [
{
"feature": "section_count",
"threshold": 15.0,
"op": ">=",
"value": 9.0,
"fired": false,
"heldout_test_auc": 0.783
},
{
"feature": "total_length_s",
"threshold": 140.6,
"op": ">=",
"value": 194.595,
"fired": true,
"heldout_test_auc": 0.71
},
{
"feature": "n_drops",
"threshold": 17.0,
"op": ">=",
"value": 34.0,
"fired": true,
"heldout_test_auc": 0.696
},
{
"feature": "bars",
"threshold": 110.0,
"op": ">=",
"value": 80.0,
"fired": false,
"heldout_test_auc": 0.672
},
{
"feature": "note_count",
"threshold": 268.0,
"op": ">=",
"value": 200.0,
"fired": false,
"heldout_test_auc": 0.602
},
{
"feature": "tempo_adjust_n",
"threshold": 11.0,
"op": ">=",
"value": 32.0,
"fired": true,
"heldout_test_auc": 0.594
}
],
"rules_fired": 3,
"bar_axes": [
{
"feature": "section_count",
"value": 9.0,
"direction": "above",
"sibling_median": 9.0,
"hit_median": 17.0,
"on_hit_side": true
},
{
"feature": "total_length_s",
"value": 194.595,
"direction": "above",
"sibling_median": 96.2,
"hit_median": 196.6,
"on_hit_side": true
},
{
"feature": "bars",
"value": 80.0,
"direction": "above",
"sibling_median": 52.0,
"hit_median": 114.0,
"on_hit_side": true
},
{
"feature": "repeat_sim_mean",
"value": 0.8584,
"direction": "above",
"sibling_median": 0.855,
"hit_median": 0.902,
"on_hit_side": true
},
{
"feature": "n_drops",
"value": 34.0,
"direction": "above",
"sibling_median": 6.0,
"hit_median": 19.5,
"on_hit_side": true
},
{
"feature": "novelty_mean",
"value": 0.5212,
"direction": "below",
"sibling_median": 0.678,
"hit_median": 0.556,
"on_hit_side": true
}
],
"axes_on_hit_side": 6,
"v3_envelope": {
"available": true,
"verdict": "REJECT",
"outside_on": [
"drop_depth_max_db"
],
"axes": {
"X_rest_grammar": {
"value": 10.4833,
"lo": 2.6757,
"hi": 17.4281,
"inside": true
},
"section_count": {
"value": 9.0,
"lo": 4.0,
"hi": 35.0,
"inside": true
},
"drop_depth_max_db": {
"value": -6.35,
"lo": -101.86,
"hi": -10.73,
"inside": false
}
},
"note": "V3 re-derived the envelope at the live pool (30 hits / 927 controls) and changed TWO of its three axes. It is the current filter; round 1's box is the one these cues are compared on, because that is the box round 1 faced. Both are printed and neither is hidden behind the other."
},
"structural_yield": {
"value": 0.2353,
"boundaries": 8,
"drops": 34,
"boundaries_per_min": 2.467,
"hits": 0.76,
"siblings": 1.0,
"round_1": 0.22,
"auc_vs_round_1": 0.911,
"auc_vs_siblings": 0.437,
"honest_label": "a GENERATION-DEFECT detector, never a taste oracle -- near chance against the corpus's own album siblings (0.437), near-perfect against our own generator's output (0.911)",
"not_in_the_decision": "reported beside the verdict and never folded into it -- the KEEP/REJECT stays on the filter round 1 faced"
},
"cue_id": "PASS2_FLORES_CACI",
"public_name": "The Caci Rounds -- the bought champion, and the broker behind him",
"purpose_class": "BATTLE",
"chapter_id": "CH_03",
"theme_id": "REGION_FLORES_ISLAND",
"cue_rows": [
"MC_0058",
"MC_0059"
],
"source_path": "D:/audio/pass2/PASS2_FLORES_CACI/PASS2_FLORES_CACI.wav",
"card": "build/audio/pass2/cards/PASS2_FLORES_CACI.json",
"plan": "build/audio/pass2/plans/PASS2_FLORES_CACI.json",
"parts_planned": 39,
"parts_rendered": 39,
"sections_planned": 21,
"sections_measured": 9,
"novelty_planned": 24,
"seconds": 194.595
},
"PASS2_FLORES_REST": {
"artifact_id": "PASS2_FLORES_REST",
"verdict": "KEEP",
"rejected_on": [],
"unmeasurable": [],
"joint_box": {
"melody_span_semitones": {
"value": 52.33,
"lo": 19.67,
"hi": 57.0,
"inside": true
},
"section_mean_s": {
"value": 10.4348,
"lo": 7.145,
"hi": 63.3454,
"inside": true
},
"X_rest_grammar": {
"value": 5.0,
"lo": 2.6757,
"hi": 17.4281,
"inside": true
}
},
"heldout_rules": [
{
"feature": "section_count",
"threshold": 15.0,
"op": ">=",
"value": 23.0,
"fired": true,
"heldout_test_auc": 0.783
},
{
"feature": "total_length_s",
"threshold": 140.6,
"op": ">=",
"value": 240.0,
"fired": true,
"heldout_test_auc": 0.71
},
{
"feature": "n_drops",
"threshold": 17.0,
"op": ">=",
"value": 20.0,
"fired": true,
"heldout_test_auc": 0.696
},
{
"feature": "bars",
"threshold": 110.0,
"op": ">=",
"value": 92.0,
"fired": false,
"heldout_test_auc": 0.672
},
{
"feature": "note_count",
"threshold": 268.0,
"op": ">=",
"value": 422.0,
"fired": true,
"heldout_test_auc": 0.602
},
{
"feature": "tempo_adjust_n",
"threshold": 11.0,
"op": ">=",
"value": 20.0,
"fired": true,
"heldout_test_auc": 0.594
}
],
"rules_fired": 5,
"bar_axes": [
{
"feature": "section_count",
"value": 23.0,
"direction": "above",
"sibling_median": 9.0,
"hit_median": 17.0,
"on_hit_side": true
},
{
"feature": "total_length_s",
"value": 240.0,
"direction": "above",
"sibling_median": 96.2,
"hit_median": 196.6,
"on_hit_side": true
},
{
"feature": "bars",
"value": 92.0,
"direction": "above",
"sibling_median": 52.0,
"hit_median": 114.0,
"on_hit_side": true
},
{
"feature": "repeat_sim_mean",
"value": 0.9398,
"direction": "above",
"sibling_median": 0.855,
"hit_median": 0.902,
"on_hit_side": true
},
{
"feature": "n_drops",
"value": 20.0,
"direction": "above",
"sibling_median": 6.0,
"hit_median": 19.5,
"on_hit_side": true
},
{
"feature": "novelty_mean",
"value": 0.5098,
"direction": "below",
"sibling_median": 0.678,
"hit_median": 0.556,
"on_hit_side": true
}
],
"axes_on_hit_side": 6,
"v3_envelope": {
"available": true,
"verdict": "REJECT",
"outside_on": [
"drop_depth_max_db"
],
"axes": {
"X_rest_grammar": {
"value": 5.0,
"lo": 2.6757,
"hi": 17.4281,
"inside": true
},
"section_count": {
"value": 23.0,
"lo": 4.0,
"hi": 35.0,
"inside": true
},
"drop_depth_max_db": {
"value": -6.37,
"lo": -101.86,
"hi": -10.73,
"inside": false
}
},
"note": "V3 re-derived the envelope at the live pool (30 hits / 927 controls) and changed TWO of its three axes. It is the current filter; round 1's box is the one these cues are compared on, because that is the box round 1 faced. Both are printed and neither is hidden behind the other."
},
"structural_yield": {
"value": 1.1,
"boundaries": 22,
"drops": 20,
"boundaries_per_min": 5.5,
"hits": 0.76,
"siblings": 1.0,
"round_1": 0.22,
"auc_vs_round_1": 0.911,
"auc_vs_siblings": 0.437,
"honest_label": "a GENERATION-DEFECT detector, never a taste oracle -- near chance against the corpus's own album siblings (0.437), near-perfect against our own generator's output (0.911)",
"not_in_the_decision": "reported beside the verdict and never folded into it -- the KEEP/REJECT stays on the filter round 1 faced"
},
"cue_id": "PASS2_FLORES_REST",
"public_name": "Flores Highlands -- the region at rest",
"purpose_class": "EXPLORATION",
"chapter_id": "CH_03",
"theme_id": "REGION_FLORES_ISLAND",
"cue_rows": [
"MC_0048",
"MC_0050",
"MC_0053"
],
"source_path": "D:/audio/pass2/PASS2_FLORES_REST/PASS2_FLORES_REST.wav",
"card": "build/audio/pass2/cards/PASS2_FLORES_REST.json",
"plan": "build/audio/pass2/plans/PASS2_FLORES_REST.json",
"parts_planned": 32,
"parts_rendered": 32,
"sections_planned": 19,
"sections_measured": 23,
"novelty_planned": 18,
"seconds": 240.0
},
"PASS2_FLORES_WATERFALL": {
"artifact_id": "PASS2_FLORES_WATERFALL",
"verdict": "KEEP",
"rejected_on": [],
"unmeasurable": [],
"joint_box": {
"melody_span_semitones": {
"value": 48.0,
"lo": 19.67,
"hi": 57.0,
"inside": true
},
"section_mean_s": {
"value": 12.1213,
"lo": 7.145,
"hi": 63.3454,
"inside": true
},
"X_rest_grammar": {
"value": 2.8875,
"lo": 2.6757,
"hi": 17.4281,
"inside": true
}
},
"heldout_rules": [
{
"feature": "section_count",
"threshold": 15.0,
"op": ">=",
"value": 12.0,
"fired": false,
"heldout_test_auc": 0.783
},
{
"feature": "total_length_s",
"threshold": 140.6,
"op": ">=",
"value": 145.455,
"fired": true,
"heldout_test_auc": 0.71
},
{
"feature": "n_drops",
"threshold": 17.0,
"op": ">=",
"value": 7.0,
"fired": false,
"heldout_test_auc": 0.696
},
{
"feature": "bars",
"threshold": 110.0,
"op": ">=",
"value": 40.0,
"fired": false,
"heldout_test_auc": 0.672
},
{
"feature": "note_count",
"threshold": 268.0,
"op": ">=",
"value": 205.0,
"fired": false,
"heldout_test_auc": 0.602
},
{
"feature": "tempo_adjust_n",
"threshold": 11.0,
"op": ">=",
"value": 3.0,
"fired": false,
"heldout_test_auc": 0.594
}
],
"rules_fired": 1,
"bar_axes": [
{
"feature": "section_count",
"value": 12.0,
"direction": "above",
"sibling_median": 9.0,
"hit_median": 17.0,
"on_hit_side": true
},
{
"feature": "total_length_s",
"value": 145.455,
"direction": "above",
"sibling_median": 96.2,
"hit_median": 196.6,
"on_hit_side": true
},
{
"feature": "bars",
"value": 40.0,
"direction": "above",
"sibling_median": 52.0,
"hit_median": 114.0,
"on_hit_side": false
},
{
"feature": "repeat_sim_mean",
"value": 0.882,
"direction": "above",
"sibling_median": 0.855,
"hit_median": 0.902,
"on_hit_side": true
},
{
"feature": "n_drops",
"value": 7.0,
"direction": "above",
"sibling_median": 6.0,
"hit_median": 19.5,
"on_hit_side": true
},
{
"feature": "novelty_mean",
"value": 0.4716,
"direction": "below",
"sibling_median": 0.678,
"hit_median": 0.556,
"on_hit_side": true
}
],
"axes_on_hit_side": 5,
"v3_envelope": {
"available": true,
"verdict": "REJECT",
"outside_on": [
"drop_depth_max_db"
],
"axes": {
"X_rest_grammar": {
"value": 2.8875,
"lo": 2.6757,
"hi": 17.4281,
"inside": true
},
"section_count": {
"value": 12.0,
"lo": 4.0,
"hi": 35.0,
"inside": true
},
"drop_depth_max_db": {
"value": -6.26,
"lo": -101.86,
"hi": -10.73,
"inside": false
}
},
"note": "V3 re-derived the envelope at the live pool (30 hits / 927 controls) and changed TWO of its three axes. It is the current filter; round 1's box is the one these cues are compared on, because that is the box round 1 faced. Both are printed and neither is hidden behind the other."
},
"structural_yield": {
"value": 1.5714,
"boundaries": 11,
"drops": 7,
"boundaries_per_min": 4.537,
"hits": 0.76,
"siblings": 1.0,
"round_1": 0.22,
"auc_vs_round_1": 0.911,
"auc_vs_siblings": 0.437,
"honest_label": "a GENERATION-DEFECT detector, never a taste oracle -- near chance against the corpus's own album siblings (0.437), near-perfect against our own generator's output (0.911)",
"not_in_the_decision": "reported beside the verdict and never folded into it -- the KEEP/REJECT stays on the filter round 1 faced"
},
"cue_id": "PASS2_FLORES_WATERFALL",
"public_name": "Mama Klara's Waterfall -- the restoration",
"purpose_class": "SANCTUARY",
"chapter_id": "CH_03",
"theme_id": "REGION_FLORES_ISLAND",
"cue_rows": [
"MC_0051"
],
"source_path": "D:/audio/pass2/PASS2_FLORES_WATERFALL/PASS2_FLORES_WATERFALL.wav",
"card": "build/audio/pass2/cards/PASS2_FLORES_WATERFALL.json",
"plan": "build/audio/pass2/plans/PASS2_FLORES_WATERFALL.json",
"parts_planned": 11,
"parts_rendered": 11,
"sections_planned": 15,
"sections_measured": 12,
"novelty_planned": 12,
"seconds": 145.455
}
}
}