music/generated/journey_world/ranking.json
{
"_doc": "Candidate ranking. Losers are retained deliberately (brief pack section 8).",
"_honest_tier": "GENERATED SCORE - ITERATION",
"_proxy_limits": {
"B1_recall_singback": "needs a naive human listener (doctrine appendix T.1)",
"B2_transformability": "needs the four transformations rendered as separate artifacts",
"B3_combinability": "needs a sibling canon leitmotif; evaluated at cohort close",
"B4_concert_viability": "PARTIAL only -- written-range fit is computed, choral singability is not",
"B5_no_patch_dependence": "a judgement on the arrangement, not a signal property",
"D1_first_notes_identification": "needs a naive human listener",
"D2_notation_free_transmission": "needs a second musician",
"D8_clap_test": "needs a naive human listener",
"D7_anchor_degree_landing": "needs the register card's declared anchor degrees; scored only when the spec supplies them",
"D10_constant_harmonic_rate": "needs chord/colotomic transcription; not attempted"
},
"_reading": "The proxy covers 8 of 13 diagnostics and 0 of 5 binary gates. A win here is the best CANDIDATE, not a passed doctrine gate -- B1/D1/D2/D8 stay open.",
"weights": {
"hummability_proxy_percent": 0.45,
"melodic_salience": 0.2,
"motif_recurrence": 0.1,
"bpm_fidelity": 0.1,
"key_stability": 0.05,
"register_match": 0.05,
"loop_seam": 0.05
},
"theme_id": "JOURNEY_WORLD",
"n_scored": 8,
"ranking": [
{
"rank": 1,
"artifact_id": "JOURNEY_WORLD_C04",
"total": 0.6087,
"carrier": "oboe",
"bpm": 120,
"seed": 4204
},
{
"rank": 2,
"artifact_id": "JOURNEY_WORLD_C02",
"total": 0.5915,
"carrier": "horn",
"bpm": 120,
"seed": 4202
},
{
"rank": 3,
"artifact_id": "JOURNEY_WORLD_C05",
"total": 0.5303,
"carrier": "cello",
"bpm": 112,
"seed": 4205
},
{
"rank": 4,
"artifact_id": "JOURNEY_WORLD_C06",
"total": 0.5203,
"carrier": "cello",
"bpm": 120,
"seed": 4206
},
{
"rank": 5,
"artifact_id": "JOURNEY_WORLD_C03",
"total": 0.5073,
"carrier": "oboe",
"bpm": 112,
"seed": 4203
},
{
"rank": 6,
"artifact_id": "JOURNEY_WORLD_C08",
"total": 0.5003,
"carrier": "flute",
"bpm": 120,
"seed": 4208
},
{
"rank": 7,
"artifact_id": "JOURNEY_WORLD_C07",
"total": 0.4815,
"carrier": "flute",
"bpm": 112,
"seed": 4207
},
{
"rank": 8,
"artifact_id": "JOURNEY_WORLD_C01",
"total": 0.4024,
"carrier": "horn",
"bpm": 112,
"seed": 4201
}
],
"decision": {
"winner": "JOURNEY_WORLD_C04",
"runner_up": "JOURNEY_WORLD_C02",
"margin": 0.0172,
"weighted_gaps_vs_runner_up": {
"hummability_proxy_percent": 0.0442,
"motif_recurrence": 0.0002,
"loop_seam": 0.0,
"register_match": -0.0004,
"bpm_fidelity": -0.0042,
"melodic_salience": -0.01,
"key_stability": -0.0125
},
"deciding_features": [
"hummability_proxy_percent",
"motif_recurrence"
],
"features_lost_on": [
"register_match",
"bpm_fidelity",
"melodic_salience",
"key_stability"
]
},
"candidates": [
{
"artifact_id": "JOURNEY_WORLD_C01",
"carrier": "horn",
"keyscale": "D major",
"bpm": 112,
"seed": 4201,
"audio": "build/audio/generated/journey_world/JOURNEY_WORLD_C01.wav",
"score": {
"components": {
"hummability_proxy_percent": 0.5714,
"melodic_salience": 0.4202,
"motif_recurrence": 0.0248,
"bpm_fidelity": 0.0,
"key_stability": 0.5,
"register_match": 0.6743,
"loop_seam": 0.0
},
"weighted": {
"hummability_proxy_percent": 0.2571,
"melodic_salience": 0.084,
"motif_recurrence": 0.0025,
"bpm_fidelity": 0.0,
"key_stability": 0.025,
"register_match": 0.0337,
"loop_seam": 0.0
},
"total": 0.4024
},
"features": {
"artifact": "C:\\dev\\humanity-forgotten\\build\\audio\\generated\\journey_world\\JOURNEY_WORLD_C01.wav",
"duration_s": 32.0,
"analysis_sr": 22050,
"melodic": {
"melodic_salience": 0.4202,
"extractor": "harmonic-summation predominant melody (polyphony-safe)",
"monophonic_confidence_pyin": 0.0,
"voiced_fraction": 0.0689,
"note_count": 14,
"note_rate_per_s": 0.438,
"pitch_change_rate": 0.6923,
"pitch_spread_semitones": 0.821,
"in_note_pitch_mad_semitones": 0.0,
"median_note_dur_s": 0.0871,
"mean_voiced_peakiness": 0.0549,
"salience_aggregation": "geometric mean of the five components below",
"components": {
"voiced": 0.115,
"rate": 0.417,
"change": 1.0,
"peakiness": 0.349,
"duration": 0.785
}
},
"notes": [
{
"midi": 38.66666666666667,
"onset_s": 3.7384126984126986,
"dur_s": 0.13931972789115646,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 38.33333333333333,
"onset_s": 6.907936507936508,
"dur_s": 0.10448979591836735,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 37.666666666666664,
"onset_s": 7.662585034013605,
"dur_s": 0.058049886621315196,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 38.0,
"onset_s": 8.324353741496598,
"dur_s": 0.058049886621315196,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 37.0,
"onset_s": 12.445895691609977,
"dur_s": 0.13931972789115646,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 37.0,
"onset_s": 12.654875283446712,
"dur_s": 0.058049886621315196,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 39.666666666666664,
"onset_s": 16.335238095238097,
"dur_s": 0.12770975056689343,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 37.333333333333336,
"onset_s": 16.822857142857142,
"dur_s": 0.12770975056689343,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 37.0,
"onset_s": 17.647165532879818,
"dur_s": 0.12770975056689343,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 38.66666666666667,
"onset_s": 21.21142857142857,
"dur_s": 0.058049886621315196,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 38.0,
"onset_s": 22.267936507936508,
"dur_s": 0.058049886621315196,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 36.66666666666667,
"onset_s": 23.219954648526077,
"dur_s": 0.06965986394557823,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 38.0,
"onset_s": 24.961451247165535,
"dur_s": 0.06965986394557823,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 38.66666666666667,
"onset_s": 26.041179138321997,
"dur_s": 0.1741496598639456,
"confidence": 1.0
}
],
"motif_recurrence": {
"self_similarity_peak": 0.9509,
"self_similarity_baseline": 0.9448,
"self_similarity_lift": 0.0062,
"recurrence_lag_s": 0.464,
"interval_3gram_repetition": 0.0909,
"interval_4gram_repetition": 0.0
},
"key": {
"tonic_pc": 6,
"tonic": "F#",
"mode": "minor",
"window_agreement": 0.5,
"windows": 8
},
"tempo": {
"tempo_bpm_global": 129.2,
"tempo_bpm_median_local": 123.05,
"tempo_iqr_bpm": 25.84,
"tempo_stability": 0.16,
"beat_interval_cv": 0.0608,
"target_bpm": 112,
"bpm_rel_error_direct": 0.1536,
"bpm_rel_error_best_octave": 0.1536,
"bpm_best_octave": "1x",
"bpm_recoverable": false,
"bpm_recoverable_direct": false
},
"spectral_register": {
"band_profile": {
"sub": 0.19141,
"low_bass": 0.31479,
"bass": 0.15927,
"low_mid": 0.09947,
"mid": 0.11471,
"upper_mid": 0.05713,
"presence": 0.0209,
"brilliance": 0.00902,
"air": 0.00316,
"ultra": 0.0
},
"spectral_centroid_hz_mean": 1266.1,
"spectral_centroid_hz_std": 717.3,
"spectral_rolloff85_hz_mean": 2694.9,
"spectral_flatness_mean": 0.00384,
"register_match_cosine": 0.6743,
"register_band_deltas": {
"sub": 0.1774,
"low_bass": 0.2246,
"bass": 0.0042,
"low_mid": -0.1174,
"mid": -0.1217,
"upper_mid": -0.0811,
"presence": -0.0585,
"brilliance": -0.0207,
"air": -0.0067
}
},
"loop_seam": {
"measurable": true,
"seam_distance": 0.10152,
"interior_distance_median": 0.06159,
"seam_ratio": 1.648,
"seam_clean": false,
"tail_rms_over_mid": 1.213,
"head_rms_over_mid": 1.1168,
"tail_rms_trend": -0.1249,
"head_rms_trend": -0.1578,
"baked_fade_out": false,
"baked_fade_in": false
},
"hummability_proxy": {
"items": {
"D3_global_contour": {
"score": 0,
"applicable": true,
"detail": "shape=concave thirds=(38.17,37.75,37.83)"
},
"D4_one_licensed_anomaly": {
"score": 1,
"applicable": true,
"detail": "leaps>=6st=0 repeated_runs=0"
},
"D5_tessitura_rule": {
"score": null,
"applicable": false,
"detail": "no leaps landing near a tessitura extreme"
},
"D6_span_tessitura": {
"score": 1,
"applicable": true,
"detail": "span=3.0st middle_third_share=0.29"
},
"D9_periodicity": {
"score": 1,
"applicable": true,
"detail": "ioi_cv=0.779 beat_cv=0.061"
},
"D11_tempo_vs_register_median": {
"score": 2,
"applicable": true,
"detail": "bpm=129.2 register_median=108"
},
"D12_continuation_by_fragmentation": {
"score": 1,
"applicable": true,
"detail": "second_half_vocab_share=0.43 accelerates=True"
},
"D13_non_closure": {
"score": 2,
"applicable": true,
"detail": "final_pc=D# != tonic=F#"
}
},
"applicable_count": 7,
"score": 8,
"max": 14,
"percent": 0.5714,
"zero_scoring_items": [
"D3_global_contour"
],
"proxy_gate_view": {
"doctrine_threshold_percent": 0.77,
"meets_percent_threshold": false,
"no_applicable_zero": false,
"PROXY_ONLY": true,
"covers": "8 of 13 diagnostics (2.3.3); 0 of 5 binary gates (2.3.2)",
"not_computable": {
"B1_recall_singback": "needs a naive human listener (doctrine appendix T.1)",
"B2_transformability": "needs the four transformations rendered as separate artifacts",
"B3_combinability": "needs a sibling canon leitmotif; evaluated at cohort close",
"B4_concert_viability": "PARTIAL only -- written-range fit is computed, choral singability is not",
"B5_no_patch_dependence": "a judgement on the arrangement, not a signal property",
"D1_first_notes_identification": "needs a naive human listener",
"D2_notation_free_transmission": "needs a second musician",
"D8_clap_test": "needs a naive human listener",
"D7_anchor_degree_landing": "needs the register card's declared anchor degrees; scored only when the spec supplies them",
"D10_constant_harmonic_rate": "needs chord/colotomic transcription; not attempted"
},
"reading": "A pass here is NECESSARY-NOT-SUFFICIENT. The doctrine gate is not passed until B1/D1/D2/D8 are run with listeners."
}
}
}
},
{
"artifact_id": "JOURNEY_WORLD_C02",
"carrier": "horn",
"keyscale": "D major",
"bpm": 120,
"seed": 4202,
"audio": "build/audio/generated/journey_world/JOURNEY_WORLD_C02.wav",
"score": {
"components": {
"hummability_proxy_percent": 0.6875,
"melodic_salience": 0.4781,
"motif_recurrence": 0.022,
"bpm_fidelity": 0.788,
"key_stability": 0.375,
"register_match": 0.7344,
"loop_seam": 1.0
},
"weighted": {
"hummability_proxy_percent": 0.3094,
"melodic_salience": 0.0956,
"motif_recurrence": 0.0022,
"bpm_fidelity": 0.0788,
"key_stability": 0.0188,
"register_match": 0.0367,
"loop_seam": 0.05
},
"total": 0.5915
},
"features": {
"artifact": "C:\\dev\\humanity-forgotten\\build\\audio\\generated\\journey_world\\JOURNEY_WORLD_C02.wav",
"duration_s": 32.0,
"analysis_sr": 22050,
"melodic": {
"melodic_salience": 0.4781,
"extractor": "harmonic-summation predominant melody (polyphony-safe)",
"monophonic_confidence_pyin": 0.0011,
"voiced_fraction": 0.0773,
"note_count": 19,
"note_rate_per_s": 0.594,
"pitch_change_rate": 0.7222,
"pitch_spread_semitones": 1.523,
"in_note_pitch_mad_semitones": 0.0,
"median_note_dur_s": 0.0813,
"mean_voiced_peakiness": 0.0569,
"salience_aggregation": "geometric mean of the five components below",
"components": {
"voiced": 0.129,
"rate": 0.764,
"change": 1.0,
"peakiness": 0.369,
"duration": 0.688
}
},
"notes": [
{
"midi": 37.666666666666664,
"onset_s": 0.5572789115646258,
"dur_s": 0.058049886621315196,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 38.0,
"onset_s": 1.9620861678004535,
"dur_s": 0.058049886621315196,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 38.66666666666667,
"onset_s": 3.4017233560090703,
"dur_s": 0.11609977324263039,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 38.66666666666667,
"onset_s": 5.3986394557823125,
"dur_s": 0.08126984126984127,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 38.66666666666667,
"onset_s": 5.7004988662131515,
"dur_s": 0.058049886621315196,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 37.666666666666664,
"onset_s": 8.730702947845804,
"dur_s": 0.16253968253968254,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 38.0,
"onset_s": 10.042630385487529,
"dur_s": 0.23219954648526078,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 39.0,
"onset_s": 11.19201814058957,
"dur_s": 0.058049886621315196,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 38.0,
"onset_s": 12.318185941043083,
"dur_s": 0.10448979591836735,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 43.0,
"onset_s": 13.421133786848072,
"dur_s": 0.11609977324263039,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 38.166666666666664,
"onset_s": 14.512471655328799,
"dur_s": 0.09287981859410431,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 37.333333333333336,
"onset_s": 15.139410430839002,
"dur_s": 0.2438095238095238,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 40.0,
"onset_s": 18.866213151927436,
"dur_s": 0.06965986394557823,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 42.666666666666664,
"onset_s": 24.392562358276646,
"dur_s": 0.06965986394557823,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 38.66666666666667,
"onset_s": 25.18204081632653,
"dur_s": 0.058049886621315196,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 38.0,
"onset_s": 26.377868480725624,
"dur_s": 0.13931972789115646,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 39.0,
"onset_s": 28.258684807256238,
"dur_s": 0.06965986394557823,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 39.0,
"onset_s": 28.409614512471656,
"dur_s": 0.08126984126984127,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 37.333333333333336,
"onset_s": 31.24244897959184,
"dur_s": 0.06965986394557823,
"confidence": 1.0
}
],
"motif_recurrence": {
"self_similarity_peak": 0.9477,
"self_similarity_baseline": 0.9422,
"self_similarity_lift": 0.0055,
"recurrence_lag_s": 13.375,
"interval_3gram_repetition": 0.0,
"interval_4gram_repetition": 0.0
},
"key": {
"tonic_pc": 2,
"tonic": "D",
"mode": "major",
"window_agreement": 0.375,
"windows": 8
},
"tempo": {
"tempo_bpm_global": 117.45,
"tempo_bpm_median_local": 117.45,
"tempo_iqr_bpm": 23.65,
"tempo_stability": 0.1945,
"beat_interval_cv": 0.0881,
"target_bpm": 120,
"bpm_rel_error_direct": 0.0212,
"bpm_rel_error_best_octave": 0.0212,
"bpm_best_octave": "1x",
"bpm_recoverable": true,
"bpm_recoverable_direct": true
},
"spectral_register": {
"band_profile": {
"sub": 0.16918,
"low_bass": 0.2877,
"bass": 0.18273,
"low_mid": 0.11574,
"mid": 0.13084,
"upper_mid": 0.05301,
"presence": 0.0206,
"brilliance": 0.00795,
"air": 0.00373,
"ultra": 0.0
},
"spectral_centroid_hz_mean": 1313.1,
"spectral_centroid_hz_std": 699.5,
"spectral_rolloff85_hz_mean": 2859.5,
"spectral_flatness_mean": 0.00387,
"register_match_cosine": 0.7344,
"register_band_deltas": {
"sub": 0.1541,
"low_bass": 0.1961,
"bass": 0.0281,
"low_mid": -0.1009,
"mid": -0.1053,
"upper_mid": -0.0854,
"presence": -0.0588,
"brilliance": -0.0218,
"air": -0.0062
}
},
"loop_seam": {
"measurable": true,
"seam_distance": 0.07407,
"interior_distance_median": 0.0527,
"seam_ratio": 1.405,
"seam_clean": true,
"tail_rms_over_mid": 1.615,
"head_rms_over_mid": 1.4166,
"tail_rms_trend": 0.105,
"head_rms_trend": -0.3892,
"baked_fade_out": false,
"baked_fade_in": false
},
"hummability_proxy": {
"items": {
"D3_global_contour": {
"score": 1,
"applicable": true,
"detail": "shape=ascent thirds=(38.22,38.92,39.24)"
},
"D4_one_licensed_anomaly": {
"score": 2,
"applicable": true,
"detail": "leaps>=6st=0 repeated_runs=1"
},
"D5_tessitura_rule": {
"score": 2,
"applicable": true,
"detail": "compliant 1/1"
},
"D6_span_tessitura": {
"score": 1,
"applicable": true,
"detail": "span=5.7st middle_third_share=0.05"
},
"D9_periodicity": {
"score": 1,
"applicable": true,
"detail": "ioi_cv=0.760 beat_cv=0.088"
},
"D11_tempo_vs_register_median": {
"score": 2,
"applicable": true,
"detail": "bpm=117.5 register_median=108"
},
"D12_continuation_by_fragmentation": {
"score": 0,
"applicable": true,
"detail": "second_half_vocab_share=0.44 accelerates=False"
},
"D13_non_closure": {
"score": 2,
"applicable": true,
"detail": "final_pc=C# != tonic=D"
}
},
"applicable_count": 8,
"score": 11,
"max": 16,
"percent": 0.6875,
"zero_scoring_items": [
"D12_continuation_by_fragmentation"
],
"proxy_gate_view": {
"doctrine_threshold_percent": 0.77,
"meets_percent_threshold": false,
"no_applicable_zero": false,
"PROXY_ONLY": true,
"covers": "8 of 13 diagnostics (2.3.3); 0 of 5 binary gates (2.3.2)",
"not_computable": {
"B1_recall_singback": "needs a naive human listener (doctrine appendix T.1)",
"B2_transformability": "needs the four transformations rendered as separate artifacts",
"B3_combinability": "needs a sibling canon leitmotif; evaluated at cohort close",
"B4_concert_viability": "PARTIAL only -- written-range fit is computed, choral singability is not",
"B5_no_patch_dependence": "a judgement on the arrangement, not a signal property",
"D1_first_notes_identification": "needs a naive human listener",
"D2_notation_free_transmission": "needs a second musician",
"D8_clap_test": "needs a naive human listener",
"D7_anchor_degree_landing": "needs the register card's declared anchor degrees; scored only when the spec supplies them",
"D10_constant_harmonic_rate": "needs chord/colotomic transcription; not attempted"
},
"reading": "A pass here is NECESSARY-NOT-SUFFICIENT. The doctrine gate is not passed until B1/D1/D2/D8 are run with listeners."
}
}
}
},
{
"artifact_id": "JOURNEY_WORLD_C03",
"carrier": "oboe",
"keyscale": "D major",
"bpm": 112,
"seed": 4203,
"audio": "build/audio/generated/journey_world/JOURNEY_WORLD_C03.wav",
"score": {
"components": {
"hummability_proxy_percent": 0.6875,
"melodic_salience": 0.4533,
"motif_recurrence": 0.02,
"bpm_fidelity": 0.014,
"key_stability": 0.375,
"register_match": 0.7023,
"loop_seam": 1.0
},
"weighted": {
"hummability_proxy_percent": 0.3094,
"melodic_salience": 0.0907,
"motif_recurrence": 0.002,
"bpm_fidelity": 0.0014,
"key_stability": 0.0188,
"register_match": 0.0351,
"loop_seam": 0.05
},
"total": 0.5073
},
"features": {
"artifact": "C:\\dev\\humanity-forgotten\\build\\audio\\generated\\journey_world\\JOURNEY_WORLD_C03.wav",
"duration_s": 32.0,
"analysis_sr": 22050,
"melodic": {
"melodic_salience": 0.4533,
"extractor": "harmonic-summation predominant melody (polyphony-safe)",
"monophonic_confidence_pyin": 0.0022,
"voiced_fraction": 0.0769,
"note_count": 18,
"note_rate_per_s": 0.562,
"pitch_change_rate": 0.4706,
"pitch_spread_semitones": 1.171,
"in_note_pitch_mad_semitones": 0.0,
"median_note_dur_s": 0.0813,
"mean_voiced_peakiness": 0.0566,
"salience_aggregation": "geometric mean of the five components below",
"components": {
"voiced": 0.128,
"rate": 0.694,
"change": 0.856,
"peakiness": 0.366,
"duration": 0.688
}
},
"notes": [
{
"midi": 38.0,
"onset_s": 1.18421768707483,
"dur_s": 0.08126984126984127,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 37.666666666666664,
"onset_s": 1.5441269841269842,
"dur_s": 0.06965986394557823,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 42.666666666666664,
"onset_s": 7.430385487528345,
"dur_s": 0.2089795918367347,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 39.33333333333333,
"onset_s": 8.452063492063493,
"dur_s": 0.058049886621315196,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 39.0,
"onset_s": 9.729160997732427,
"dur_s": 0.058049886621315196,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 38.66666666666667,
"onset_s": 10.205170068027211,
"dur_s": 0.058049886621315196,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 38.66666666666667,
"onset_s": 12.19047619047619,
"dur_s": 0.08126984126984127,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 37.0,
"onset_s": 14.547301587301588,
"dur_s": 0.06965986394557823,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 38.0,
"onset_s": 16.021768707482995,
"dur_s": 0.058049886621315196,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 38.0,
"onset_s": 18.030294784580498,
"dur_s": 0.09287981859410431,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 38.66666666666667,
"onset_s": 20.154920634920636,
"dur_s": 0.09287981859410431,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 38.66666666666667,
"onset_s": 20.305850340136054,
"dur_s": 0.058049886621315196,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 37.333333333333336,
"onset_s": 20.82829931972789,
"dur_s": 0.09287981859410431,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 38.33333333333333,
"onset_s": 24.845351473922904,
"dur_s": 0.058049886621315196,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 38.66666666666667,
"onset_s": 26.064399092970522,
"dur_s": 0.10448979591836735,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 38.66666666666667,
"onset_s": 28.223854875283447,
"dur_s": 0.08126984126984127,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 39.0,
"onset_s": 29.942131519274376,
"dur_s": 0.09287981859410431,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 39.666666666666664,
"onset_s": 31.509478458049887,
"dur_s": 0.1509297052154195,
"confidence": 1.0
}
],
"motif_recurrence": {
"self_similarity_peak": 0.9437,
"self_similarity_baseline": 0.9387,
"self_similarity_lift": 0.005,
"recurrence_lag_s": 6.827,
"interval_3gram_repetition": 0.0667,
"interval_4gram_repetition": 0.0
},
"key": {
"tonic_pc": 2,
"tonic": "D",
"mode": "major",
"window_agreement": 0.375,
"windows": 8
},
"tempo": {
"tempo_bpm_global": 123.05,
"tempo_bpm_median_local": 117.45,
"tempo_iqr_bpm": 21.53,
"tempo_stability": 0.2667,
"beat_interval_cv": 0.064,
"target_bpm": 112,
"bpm_rel_error_direct": 0.0986,
"bpm_rel_error_best_octave": 0.0986,
"bpm_best_octave": "1x",
"bpm_recoverable": false,
"bpm_recoverable_direct": false
},
"spectral_register": {
"band_profile": {
"sub": 0.1645,
"low_bass": 0.30878,
"bass": 0.20382,
"low_mid": 0.12349,
"mid": 0.11012,
"upper_mid": 0.03729,
"presence": 0.01201,
"brilliance": 0.00723,
"air": 0.00333,
"ultra": 0.0
},
"spectral_centroid_hz_mean": 1258.5,
"spectral_centroid_hz_std": 712.6,
"spectral_rolloff85_hz_mean": 2752.0,
"spectral_flatness_mean": 0.00279,
"register_match_cosine": 0.7023,
"register_band_deltas": {
"sub": 0.1495,
"low_bass": 0.2181,
"bass": 0.05,
"low_mid": -0.0928,
"mid": -0.1265,
"upper_mid": -0.1016,
"presence": -0.0676,
"brilliance": -0.0226,
"air": -0.0066
}
},
"loop_seam": {
"measurable": true,
"seam_distance": 0.05832,
"interior_distance_median": 0.0422,
"seam_ratio": 1.382,
"seam_clean": true,
"tail_rms_over_mid": 1.0801,
"head_rms_over_mid": 1.7633,
"tail_rms_trend": -0.4521,
"head_rms_trend": -0.6001,
"baked_fade_out": false,
"baked_fade_in": false
},
"hummability_proxy": {
"items": {
"D3_global_contour": {
"score": 0,
"applicable": true,
"detail": "shape=concave thirds=(39.22,38.17,38.61)"
},
"D4_one_licensed_anomaly": {
"score": 1,
"applicable": true,
"detail": "leaps>=6st=0 repeated_runs=2"
},
"D5_tessitura_rule": {
"score": 2,
"applicable": true,
"detail": "compliant 1/1"
},
"D6_span_tessitura": {
"score": 1,
"applicable": true,
"detail": "span=5.7st middle_third_share=0.22"
},
"D9_periodicity": {
"score": 1,
"applicable": true,
"detail": "ioi_cv=0.767 beat_cv=0.064"
},
"D11_tempo_vs_register_median": {
"score": 2,
"applicable": true,
"detail": "bpm=123.0 register_median=108"
},
"D12_continuation_by_fragmentation": {
"score": 2,
"applicable": true,
"detail": "second_half_vocab_share=0.89 accelerates=True"
},
"D13_non_closure": {
"score": 2,
"applicable": true,
"detail": "final_pc=E != tonic=D"
}
},
"applicable_count": 8,
"score": 11,
"max": 16,
"percent": 0.6875,
"zero_scoring_items": [
"D3_global_contour"
],
"proxy_gate_view": {
"doctrine_threshold_percent": 0.77,
"meets_percent_threshold": false,
"no_applicable_zero": false,
"PROXY_ONLY": true,
"covers": "8 of 13 diagnostics (2.3.3); 0 of 5 binary gates (2.3.2)",
"not_computable": {
"B1_recall_singback": "needs a naive human listener (doctrine appendix T.1)",
"B2_transformability": "needs the four transformations rendered as separate artifacts",
"B3_combinability": "needs a sibling canon leitmotif; evaluated at cohort close",
"B4_concert_viability": "PARTIAL only -- written-range fit is computed, choral singability is not",
"B5_no_patch_dependence": "a judgement on the arrangement, not a signal property",
"D1_first_notes_identification": "needs a naive human listener",
"D2_notation_free_transmission": "needs a second musician",
"D8_clap_test": "needs a naive human listener",
"D7_anchor_degree_landing": "needs the register card's declared anchor degrees; scored only when the spec supplies them",
"D10_constant_harmonic_rate": "needs chord/colotomic transcription; not attempted"
},
"reading": "A pass here is NECESSARY-NOT-SUFFICIENT. The doctrine gate is not passed until B1/D1/D2/D8 are run with listeners."
}
}
}
},
{
"artifact_id": "JOURNEY_WORLD_C04",
"carrier": "oboe",
"keyscale": "D major",
"bpm": 120,
"seed": 4204,
"audio": "build/audio/generated/journey_world/JOURNEY_WORLD_C04.wav",
"score": {
"components": {
"hummability_proxy_percent": 0.7857,
"melodic_salience": 0.4278,
"motif_recurrence": 0.0236,
"bpm_fidelity": 0.746,
"key_stability": 0.125,
"register_match": 0.7269,
"loop_seam": 1.0
},
"weighted": {
"hummability_proxy_percent": 0.3536,
"melodic_salience": 0.0856,
"motif_recurrence": 0.0024,
"bpm_fidelity": 0.0746,
"key_stability": 0.0063,
"register_match": 0.0363,
"loop_seam": 0.05
},
"total": 0.6087
},
"features": {
"artifact": "C:\\dev\\humanity-forgotten\\build\\audio\\generated\\journey_world\\JOURNEY_WORLD_C04.wav",
"duration_s": 32.0,
"analysis_sr": 22050,
"melodic": {
"melodic_salience": 0.4278,
"extractor": "harmonic-summation predominant melody (polyphony-safe)",
"monophonic_confidence_pyin": 0.0,
"voiced_fraction": 0.0631,
"note_count": 19,
"note_rate_per_s": 0.594,
"pitch_change_rate": 0.8333,
"pitch_spread_semitones": 1.814,
"in_note_pitch_mad_semitones": 0.0,
"median_note_dur_s": 0.0697,
"mean_voiced_peakiness": 0.0561,
"salience_aggregation": "geometric mean of the five components below",
"components": {
"voiced": 0.105,
"rate": 0.764,
"change": 1.0,
"peakiness": 0.361,
"duration": 0.494
}
},
"notes": [
{
"midi": 39.666666666666664,
"onset_s": 0.11609977324263039,
"dur_s": 0.1741496598639456,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 44.0,
"onset_s": 2.1710657596371883,
"dur_s": 0.06965986394557823,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 38.66666666666667,
"onset_s": 2.9024943310657596,
"dur_s": 0.2089795918367347,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 38.0,
"onset_s": 4.702040816326531,
"dur_s": 0.08126984126984127,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 39.0,
"onset_s": 12.770975056689343,
"dur_s": 0.10448979591836735,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 42.666666666666664,
"onset_s": 13.583673469387755,
"dur_s": 0.058049886621315196,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 42.666666666666664,
"onset_s": 13.781043083900228,
"dur_s": 0.058049886621315196,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 39.0,
"onset_s": 15.139410430839002,
"dur_s": 0.06965986394557823,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 37.666666666666664,
"onset_s": 15.209070294784581,
"dur_s": 0.058049886621315196,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 38.66666666666667,
"onset_s": 16.207528344671204,
"dur_s": 0.058049886621315196,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 39.33333333333333,
"onset_s": 16.439727891156462,
"dur_s": 0.13931972789115646,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 38.66666666666667,
"onset_s": 18.04190476190476,
"dur_s": 0.058049886621315196,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 39.666666666666664,
"onset_s": 19.818231292517005,
"dur_s": 0.058049886621315196,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 38.0,
"onset_s": 20.259410430839,
"dur_s": 0.06965986394557823,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 38.33333333333333,
"onset_s": 23.394104308390023,
"dur_s": 0.11609977324263039,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 36.66666666666667,
"onset_s": 24.14875283446712,
"dur_s": 0.10448979591836735,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 38.0,
"onset_s": 27.736235827664398,
"dur_s": 0.058049886621315196,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 39.0,
"onset_s": 30.615510204081634,
"dur_s": 0.06965986394557823,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 38.66666666666667,
"onset_s": 31.497868480725625,
"dur_s": 0.06965986394557823,
"confidence": 1.0
}
],
"motif_recurrence": {
"self_similarity_peak": 0.9491,
"self_similarity_baseline": 0.9432,
"self_similarity_lift": 0.0059,
"recurrence_lag_s": 15.0,
"interval_3gram_repetition": 0.0,
"interval_4gram_repetition": 0.0
},
"key": {
"tonic_pc": 6,
"tonic": "F#",
"mode": "minor",
"window_agreement": 0.125,
"windows": 8
},
"tempo": {
"tempo_bpm_global": 123.05,
"tempo_bpm_median_local": 117.45,
"tempo_iqr_bpm": 10.7,
"tempo_stability": 0.6356,
"beat_interval_cv": 0.0722,
"target_bpm": 120,
"bpm_rel_error_direct": 0.0254,
"bpm_rel_error_best_octave": 0.0254,
"bpm_best_octave": "1x",
"bpm_recoverable": true,
"bpm_recoverable_direct": true
},
"spectral_register": {
"band_profile": {
"sub": 0.17505,
"low_bass": 0.27507,
"bass": 0.19669,
"low_mid": 0.12381,
"mid": 0.10985,
"upper_mid": 0.04941,
"presence": 0.02335,
"brilliance": 0.00958,
"air": 0.00325,
"ultra": 0.0
},
"spectral_centroid_hz_mean": 1292.5,
"spectral_centroid_hz_std": 697.5,
"spectral_rolloff85_hz_mean": 2847.6,
"spectral_flatness_mean": 0.00332,
"register_match_cosine": 0.7269,
"register_band_deltas": {
"sub": 0.1612,
"low_bass": 0.1847,
"bass": 0.0436,
"low_mid": -0.0918,
"mid": -0.1263,
"upper_mid": -0.0889,
"presence": -0.0558,
"brilliance": -0.0201,
"air": -0.0066
}
},
"loop_seam": {
"measurable": true,
"seam_distance": 0.04136,
"interior_distance_median": 0.06238,
"seam_ratio": 0.663,
"seam_clean": true,
"tail_rms_over_mid": 1.6483,
"head_rms_over_mid": 1.2491,
"tail_rms_trend": -0.0819,
"head_rms_trend": -0.3845,
"baked_fade_out": false,
"baked_fade_in": false
},
"hummability_proxy": {
"items": {
"D3_global_contour": {
"score": 2,
"applicable": true,
"detail": "shape=descent thirds=(40.33,39.33,38.33)"
},
"D4_one_licensed_anomaly": {
"score": 1,
"applicable": true,
"detail": "leaps>=6st=0 repeated_runs=0"
},
"D5_tessitura_rule": {
"score": null,
"applicable": false,
"detail": "no leaps landing near a tessitura extreme"
},
"D6_span_tessitura": {
"score": 1,
"applicable": true,
"detail": "span=7.3st middle_third_share=0.16"
},
"D9_periodicity": {
"score": 1,
"applicable": true,
"detail": "ioi_cv=1.049 beat_cv=0.072"
},
"D11_tempo_vs_register_median": {
"score": 2,
"applicable": true,
"detail": "bpm=123.0 register_median=108"
},
"D12_continuation_by_fragmentation": {
"score": 2,
"applicable": true,
"detail": "second_half_vocab_share=0.78 accelerates=True"
},
"D13_non_closure": {
"score": 2,
"applicable": true,
"detail": "final_pc=D# != tonic=F#"
}
},
"applicable_count": 7,
"score": 11,
"max": 14,
"percent": 0.7857,
"zero_scoring_items": [],
"proxy_gate_view": {
"doctrine_threshold_percent": 0.77,
"meets_percent_threshold": true,
"no_applicable_zero": true,
"PROXY_ONLY": true,
"covers": "8 of 13 diagnostics (2.3.3); 0 of 5 binary gates (2.3.2)",
"not_computable": {
"B1_recall_singback": "needs a naive human listener (doctrine appendix T.1)",
"B2_transformability": "needs the four transformations rendered as separate artifacts",
"B3_combinability": "needs a sibling canon leitmotif; evaluated at cohort close",
"B4_concert_viability": "PARTIAL only -- written-range fit is computed, choral singability is not",
"B5_no_patch_dependence": "a judgement on the arrangement, not a signal property",
"D1_first_notes_identification": "needs a naive human listener",
"D2_notation_free_transmission": "needs a second musician",
"D8_clap_test": "needs a naive human listener",
"D7_anchor_degree_landing": "needs the register card's declared anchor degrees; scored only when the spec supplies them",
"D10_constant_harmonic_rate": "needs chord/colotomic transcription; not attempted"
},
"reading": "A pass here is NECESSARY-NOT-SUFFICIENT. The doctrine gate is not passed until B1/D1/D2/D8 are run with listeners."
}
}
}
},
{
"artifact_id": "JOURNEY_WORLD_C05",
"carrier": "cello",
"keyscale": "D major",
"bpm": 112,
"seed": 4205,
"audio": "build/audio/generated/journey_world/JOURNEY_WORLD_C05.wav",
"score": {
"components": {
"hummability_proxy_percent": 0.6429,
"melodic_salience": 0.4092,
"motif_recurrence": 0.018,
"bpm_fidelity": 0.513,
"key_stability": 0.375,
"register_match": 0.7457,
"loop_seam": 1.0
},
"weighted": {
"hummability_proxy_percent": 0.2893,
"melodic_salience": 0.0818,
"motif_recurrence": 0.0018,
"bpm_fidelity": 0.0513,
"key_stability": 0.0188,
"register_match": 0.0373,
"loop_seam": 0.05
},
"total": 0.5303
},
"features": {
"artifact": "C:\\dev\\humanity-forgotten\\build\\audio\\generated\\journey_world\\JOURNEY_WORLD_C05.wav",
"duration_s": 32.0,
"analysis_sr": 22050,
"melodic": {
"melodic_salience": 0.4092,
"extractor": "harmonic-summation predominant melody (polyphony-safe)",
"monophonic_confidence_pyin": 0.0,
"voiced_fraction": 0.0635,
"note_count": 12,
"note_rate_per_s": 0.375,
"pitch_change_rate": 0.5455,
"pitch_spread_semitones": 0.822,
"in_note_pitch_mad_semitones": 0.0,
"median_note_dur_s": 0.0987,
"mean_voiced_peakiness": 0.0603,
"salience_aggregation": "geometric mean of the five components below",
"components": {
"voiced": 0.106,
"rate": 0.278,
"change": 0.992,
"peakiness": 0.403,
"duration": 0.978
}
},
"notes": [
{
"midi": 37.333333333333336,
"onset_s": 0.8126984126984127,
"dur_s": 0.1741496598639456,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 39.0,
"onset_s": 1.497687074829932,
"dur_s": 0.13931972789115646,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 37.666666666666664,
"onset_s": 9.229931972789116,
"dur_s": 0.058049886621315196,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 37.666666666666664,
"onset_s": 10.437369614512471,
"dur_s": 0.09287981859410431,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 37.0,
"onset_s": 13.757823129251701,
"dur_s": 0.10448979591836735,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 37.0,
"onset_s": 13.87392290249433,
"dur_s": 0.313469387755102,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 37.333333333333336,
"onset_s": 14.419591836734694,
"dur_s": 0.06965986394557823,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 37.666666666666664,
"onset_s": 14.489251700680272,
"dur_s": 0.06965986394557823,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 39.33333333333333,
"onset_s": 17.937414965986395,
"dur_s": 0.08126984126984127,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 39.0,
"onset_s": 21.501678004535147,
"dur_s": 0.1741496598639456,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 38.33333333333333,
"onset_s": 27.260226757369615,
"dur_s": 0.12770975056689343,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 39.0,
"onset_s": 28.943673469387754,
"dur_s": 0.09287981859410431,
"confidence": 1.0
}
],
"motif_recurrence": {
"self_similarity_peak": 0.9488,
"self_similarity_baseline": 0.9443,
"self_similarity_lift": 0.0045,
"recurrence_lag_s": 13.189,
"interval_3gram_repetition": 0.0,
"interval_4gram_repetition": 0.0
},
"key": {
"tonic_pc": 6,
"tonic": "F#",
"mode": "minor",
"window_agreement": 0.375,
"windows": 8
},
"tempo": {
"tempo_bpm_global": 117.45,
"tempo_bpm_median_local": 117.45,
"tempo_iqr_bpm": 16.85,
"tempo_stability": 0.4261,
"beat_interval_cv": 0.0641,
"target_bpm": 112,
"bpm_rel_error_direct": 0.0487,
"bpm_rel_error_best_octave": 0.0487,
"bpm_best_octave": "1x",
"bpm_recoverable": true,
"bpm_recoverable_direct": true
},
"spectral_register": {
"band_profile": {
"sub": 0.17335,
"low_bass": 0.27689,
"bass": 0.16555,
"low_mid": 0.11845,
"mid": 0.12851,
"upper_mid": 0.06771,
"presence": 0.02574,
"brilliance": 0.00947,
"air": 0.00253,
"ultra": 0.0
},
"spectral_centroid_hz_mean": 1254.5,
"spectral_centroid_hz_std": 633.0,
"spectral_rolloff85_hz_mean": 2647.3,
"spectral_flatness_mean": 0.00434,
"register_match_cosine": 0.7457,
"register_band_deltas": {
"sub": 0.159,
"low_bass": 0.186,
"bass": 0.011,
"low_mid": -0.0977,
"mid": -0.1073,
"upper_mid": -0.0701,
"presence": -0.0534,
"brilliance": -0.0202,
"air": -0.0074
}
},
"loop_seam": {
"measurable": true,
"seam_distance": 0.03088,
"interior_distance_median": 0.05343,
"seam_ratio": 0.578,
"seam_clean": true,
"tail_rms_over_mid": 1.0269,
"head_rms_over_mid": 1.4661,
"tail_rms_trend": -0.214,
"head_rms_trend": 0.1137,
"baked_fade_out": false,
"baked_fade_in": false
},
"hummability_proxy": {
"items": {
"D3_global_contour": {
"score": 0,
"applicable": true,
"detail": "shape=concave thirds=(37.92,37.25,38.92)"
},
"D4_one_licensed_anomaly": {
"score": 2,
"applicable": true,
"detail": "leaps>=6st=0 repeated_runs=1"
},
"D5_tessitura_rule": {
"score": null,
"applicable": false,
"detail": "no leaps landing near a tessitura extreme"
},
"D6_span_tessitura": {
"score": 1,
"applicable": true,
"detail": "span=2.3st middle_third_share=0.08"
},
"D9_periodicity": {
"score": 1,
"applicable": true,
"detail": "ioi_cv=0.926 beat_cv=0.064"
},
"D11_tempo_vs_register_median": {
"score": 2,
"applicable": true,
"detail": "bpm=117.5 register_median=108"
},
"D12_continuation_by_fragmentation": {
"score": 1,
"applicable": true,
"detail": "second_half_vocab_share=0.83 accelerates=False"
},
"D13_non_closure": {
"score": 2,
"applicable": true,
"detail": "final_pc=D# != tonic=F#"
}
},
"applicable_count": 7,
"score": 9,
"max": 14,
"percent": 0.6429,
"zero_scoring_items": [
"D3_global_contour"
],
"proxy_gate_view": {
"doctrine_threshold_percent": 0.77,
"meets_percent_threshold": false,
"no_applicable_zero": false,
"PROXY_ONLY": true,
"covers": "8 of 13 diagnostics (2.3.3); 0 of 5 binary gates (2.3.2)",
"not_computable": {
"B1_recall_singback": "needs a naive human listener (doctrine appendix T.1)",
"B2_transformability": "needs the four transformations rendered as separate artifacts",
"B3_combinability": "needs a sibling canon leitmotif; evaluated at cohort close",
"B4_concert_viability": "PARTIAL only -- written-range fit is computed, choral singability is not",
"B5_no_patch_dependence": "a judgement on the arrangement, not a signal property",
"D1_first_notes_identification": "needs a naive human listener",
"D2_notation_free_transmission": "needs a second musician",
"D8_clap_test": "needs a naive human listener",
"D7_anchor_degree_landing": "needs the register card's declared anchor degrees; scored only when the spec supplies them",
"D10_constant_harmonic_rate": "needs chord/colotomic transcription; not attempted"
},
"reading": "A pass here is NECESSARY-NOT-SUFFICIENT. The doctrine gate is not passed until B1/D1/D2/D8 are run with listeners."
}
}
}
},
{
"artifact_id": "JOURNEY_WORLD_C06",
"carrier": "cello",
"keyscale": "D major",
"bpm": 120,
"seed": 4206,
"audio": "build/audio/generated/journey_world/JOURNEY_WORLD_C06.wav",
"score": {
"components": {
"hummability_proxy_percent": 0.6429,
"melodic_salience": 0.4652,
"motif_recurrence": 0.0328,
"bpm_fidelity": 0.788,
"key_stability": 0.375,
"register_match": 0.742,
"loop_seam": 0.0
},
"weighted": {
"hummability_proxy_percent": 0.2893,
"melodic_salience": 0.093,
"motif_recurrence": 0.0033,
"bpm_fidelity": 0.0788,
"key_stability": 0.0188,
"register_match": 0.0371,
"loop_seam": 0.0
},
"total": 0.5203
},
"features": {
"artifact": "C:\\dev\\humanity-forgotten\\build\\audio\\generated\\journey_world\\JOURNEY_WORLD_C06.wav",
"duration_s": 32.0,
"analysis_sr": 22050,
"melodic": {
"melodic_salience": 0.4652,
"extractor": "harmonic-summation predominant melody (polyphony-safe)",
"monophonic_confidence_pyin": 0.0,
"voiced_fraction": 0.0733,
"note_count": 18,
"note_rate_per_s": 0.562,
"pitch_change_rate": 0.5882,
"pitch_spread_semitones": 1.503,
"in_note_pitch_mad_semitones": 0.0,
"median_note_dur_s": 0.0813,
"mean_voiced_peakiness": 0.0573,
"salience_aggregation": "geometric mean of the five components below",
"components": {
"voiced": 0.122,
"rate": 0.694,
"change": 1.0,
"peakiness": 0.373,
"duration": 0.688
}
},
"notes": [
{
"midi": 39.666666666666664,
"onset_s": 2.403265306122449,
"dur_s": 0.08126984126984127,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 38.0,
"onset_s": 4.957460317460318,
"dur_s": 0.058049886621315196,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 38.0,
"onset_s": 5.050340136054421,
"dur_s": 0.12770975056689343,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 42.666666666666664,
"onset_s": 8.858412698412698,
"dur_s": 0.06965986394557823,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 39.33333333333333,
"onset_s": 9.218321995464853,
"dur_s": 0.08126984126984127,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 39.666666666666664,
"onset_s": 9.47374149659864,
"dur_s": 0.10448979591836735,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 42.666666666666664,
"onset_s": 11.6215873015873,
"dur_s": 0.058049886621315196,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 39.0,
"onset_s": 13.014784580498866,
"dur_s": 0.13931972789115646,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 38.33333333333333,
"onset_s": 15.383219954648526,
"dur_s": 0.06965986394557823,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 38.33333333333333,
"onset_s": 15.754739229024944,
"dur_s": 0.10448979591836735,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 38.66666666666667,
"onset_s": 16.01015873015873,
"dur_s": 0.058049886621315196,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 37.666666666666664,
"onset_s": 16.671927437641724,
"dur_s": 0.11609977324263039,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 37.666666666666664,
"onset_s": 17.04344671201814,
"dur_s": 0.06965986394557823,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 38.0,
"onset_s": 20.921179138321996,
"dur_s": 0.12770975056689343,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 37.0,
"onset_s": 24.671201814058957,
"dur_s": 0.06965986394557823,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 39.33333333333333,
"onset_s": 26.493968253968255,
"dur_s": 0.11609977324263039,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 39.33333333333333,
"onset_s": 26.62167800453515,
"dur_s": 0.058049886621315196,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 38.0,
"onset_s": 30.418140589569163,
"dur_s": 0.3947392290249433,
"confidence": 1.0
}
],
"motif_recurrence": {
"self_similarity_peak": 0.9433,
"self_similarity_baseline": 0.9351,
"self_similarity_lift": 0.0082,
"recurrence_lag_s": 0.464,
"interval_3gram_repetition": 0.1333,
"interval_4gram_repetition": 0.0714
},
"key": {
"tonic_pc": 2,
"tonic": "D",
"mode": "major",
"window_agreement": 0.375,
"windows": 8
},
"tempo": {
"tempo_bpm_global": 117.45,
"tempo_bpm_median_local": 117.45,
"tempo_iqr_bpm": 15.38,
"tempo_stability": 0.4762,
"beat_interval_cv": 0.0749,
"target_bpm": 120,
"bpm_rel_error_direct": 0.0212,
"bpm_rel_error_best_octave": 0.0212,
"bpm_best_octave": "1x",
"bpm_recoverable": true,
"bpm_recoverable_direct": true
},
"spectral_register": {
"band_profile": {
"sub": 0.17798,
"low_bass": 0.27143,
"bass": 0.17395,
"low_mid": 0.10981,
"mid": 0.12728,
"upper_mid": 0.06711,
"presence": 0.03293,
"brilliance": 0.01032,
"air": 0.00343,
"ultra": 0.0
},
"spectral_centroid_hz_mean": 1299.8,
"spectral_centroid_hz_std": 716.9,
"spectral_rolloff85_hz_mean": 2792.9,
"spectral_flatness_mean": 0.00385,
"register_match_cosine": 0.742,
"register_band_deltas": {
"sub": 0.1627,
"low_bass": 0.1786,
"bass": 0.0185,
"low_mid": -0.1073,
"mid": -0.1094,
"upper_mid": -0.0711,
"presence": -0.0462,
"brilliance": -0.0194,
"air": -0.0065
}
},
"loop_seam": {
"measurable": true,
"seam_distance": 0.12885,
"interior_distance_median": 0.05913,
"seam_ratio": 2.179,
"seam_clean": false,
"tail_rms_over_mid": 1.4036,
"head_rms_over_mid": 1.544,
"tail_rms_trend": 0.172,
"head_rms_trend": -0.5779,
"baked_fade_out": false,
"baked_fade_in": false
},
"hummability_proxy": {
"items": {
"D3_global_contour": {
"score": 2,
"applicable": true,
"detail": "shape=descent thirds=(39.56,39.11,38.22)"
},
"D4_one_licensed_anomaly": {
"score": 1,
"applicable": true,
"detail": "leaps>=6st=0 repeated_runs=2"
},
"D5_tessitura_rule": {
"score": null,
"applicable": false,
"detail": "no leaps landing near a tessitura extreme"
},
"D6_span_tessitura": {
"score": 1,
"applicable": true,
"detail": "span=5.7st middle_third_share=0.33"
},
"D9_periodicity": {
"score": 1,
"applicable": true,
"detail": "ioi_cv=0.869 beat_cv=0.075"
},
"D11_tempo_vs_register_median": {
"score": 2,
"applicable": true,
"detail": "bpm=117.5 register_median=108"
},
"D12_continuation_by_fragmentation": {
"score": 1,
"applicable": true,
"detail": "second_half_vocab_share=0.89 accelerates=False"
},
"D13_non_closure": {
"score": 1,
"applicable": true,
"detail": "final note on the tonic but no baked fade"
}
},
"applicable_count": 7,
"score": 9,
"max": 14,
"percent": 0.6429,
"zero_scoring_items": [],
"proxy_gate_view": {
"doctrine_threshold_percent": 0.77,
"meets_percent_threshold": false,
"no_applicable_zero": true,
"PROXY_ONLY": true,
"covers": "8 of 13 diagnostics (2.3.3); 0 of 5 binary gates (2.3.2)",
"not_computable": {
"B1_recall_singback": "needs a naive human listener (doctrine appendix T.1)",
"B2_transformability": "needs the four transformations rendered as separate artifacts",
"B3_combinability": "needs a sibling canon leitmotif; evaluated at cohort close",
"B4_concert_viability": "PARTIAL only -- written-range fit is computed, choral singability is not",
"B5_no_patch_dependence": "a judgement on the arrangement, not a signal property",
"D1_first_notes_identification": "needs a naive human listener",
"D2_notation_free_transmission": "needs a second musician",
"D8_clap_test": "needs a naive human listener",
"D7_anchor_degree_landing": "needs the register card's declared anchor degrees; scored only when the spec supplies them",
"D10_constant_harmonic_rate": "needs chord/colotomic transcription; not attempted"
},
"reading": "A pass here is NECESSARY-NOT-SUFFICIENT. The doctrine gate is not passed until B1/D1/D2/D8 are run with listeners."
}
}
}
},
{
"artifact_id": "JOURNEY_WORLD_C07",
"carrier": "flute",
"keyscale": "D major",
"bpm": 112,
"seed": 4207,
"audio": "build/audio/generated/journey_world/JOURNEY_WORLD_C07.wav",
"score": {
"components": {
"hummability_proxy_percent": 0.625,
"melodic_salience": 0.4902,
"motif_recurrence": 0.024,
"bpm_fidelity": 0.014,
"key_stability": 0.25,
"register_match": 0.7173,
"loop_seam": 1.0
},
"weighted": {
"hummability_proxy_percent": 0.2812,
"melodic_salience": 0.098,
"motif_recurrence": 0.0024,
"bpm_fidelity": 0.0014,
"key_stability": 0.0125,
"register_match": 0.0359,
"loop_seam": 0.05
},
"total": 0.4815
},
"features": {
"artifact": "C:\\dev\\humanity-forgotten\\build\\audio\\generated\\journey_world\\JOURNEY_WORLD_C07.wav",
"duration_s": 32.0,
"analysis_sr": 22050,
"melodic": {
"melodic_salience": 0.4902,
"extractor": "harmonic-summation predominant melody (polyphony-safe)",
"monophonic_confidence_pyin": 0.0015,
"voiced_fraction": 0.0805,
"note_count": 19,
"note_rate_per_s": 0.594,
"pitch_change_rate": 0.6667,
"pitch_spread_semitones": 1.723,
"in_note_pitch_mad_semitones": 0.0,
"median_note_dur_s": 0.0813,
"mean_voiced_peakiness": 0.0601,
"salience_aggregation": "geometric mean of the five components below",
"components": {
"voiced": 0.134,
"rate": 0.764,
"change": 1.0,
"peakiness": 0.401,
"duration": 0.688
}
},
"notes": [
{
"midi": 42.666666666666664,
"onset_s": 6.222947845804988,
"dur_s": 0.06965986394557823,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 37.666666666666664,
"onset_s": 7.627755102040816,
"dur_s": 0.06965986394557823,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 38.33333333333333,
"onset_s": 8.370793650793651,
"dur_s": 0.058049886621315196,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 39.33333333333333,
"onset_s": 8.428843537414966,
"dur_s": 0.058049886621315196,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 38.0,
"onset_s": 10.065850340136054,
"dur_s": 0.06965986394557823,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 43.0,
"onset_s": 10.495419501133787,
"dur_s": 0.06965986394557823,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 38.0,
"onset_s": 11.668027210884354,
"dur_s": 0.09287981859410431,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 37.666666666666664,
"onset_s": 12.004716553287983,
"dur_s": 0.06965986394557823,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 37.333333333333336,
"onset_s": 12.283356009070294,
"dur_s": 0.19736961451247165,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 37.666666666666664,
"onset_s": 12.480725623582767,
"dur_s": 0.2786394557823129,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 39.0,
"onset_s": 13.955192743764172,
"dur_s": 0.09287981859410431,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 39.0,
"onset_s": 16.985396825396826,
"dur_s": 0.08126984126984127,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 42.33333333333333,
"onset_s": 17.066666666666666,
"dur_s": 0.1509297052154195,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 38.0,
"onset_s": 19.237732426303854,
"dur_s": 0.1741496598639456,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 38.66666666666667,
"onset_s": 22.639455782312925,
"dur_s": 0.058049886621315196,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 39.0,
"onset_s": 23.45215419501134,
"dur_s": 0.06965986394557823,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 37.0,
"onset_s": 28.54893424036281,
"dur_s": 0.1509297052154195,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 38.66666666666667,
"onset_s": 29.8724716553288,
"dur_s": 0.10448979591836735,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 39.0,
"onset_s": 30.603900226757368,
"dur_s": 0.13931972789115646,
"confidence": 1.0
}
],
"motif_recurrence": {
"self_similarity_peak": 0.9439,
"self_similarity_baseline": 0.9379,
"self_similarity_lift": 0.006,
"recurrence_lag_s": 1.115,
"interval_3gram_repetition": 0.0,
"interval_4gram_repetition": 0.0
},
"key": {
"tonic_pc": 2,
"tonic": "D",
"mode": "major",
"window_agreement": 0.25,
"windows": 8
},
"tempo": {
"tempo_bpm_global": 123.05,
"tempo_bpm_median_local": 123.05,
"tempo_iqr_bpm": 19.69,
"tempo_stability": 0.36,
"beat_interval_cv": 0.0669,
"target_bpm": 112,
"bpm_rel_error_direct": 0.0986,
"bpm_rel_error_best_octave": 0.0986,
"bpm_best_octave": "1x",
"bpm_recoverable": false,
"bpm_recoverable_direct": false
},
"spectral_register": {
"band_profile": {
"sub": 0.17183,
"low_bass": 0.29444,
"bass": 0.19856,
"low_mid": 0.11297,
"mid": 0.12132,
"upper_mid": 0.05004,
"presence": 0.0165,
"brilliance": 0.00663,
"air": 0.00219,
"ultra": 0.0
},
"spectral_centroid_hz_mean": 1168.4,
"spectral_centroid_hz_std": 584.6,
"spectral_rolloff85_hz_mean": 2470.1,
"spectral_flatness_mean": 0.00228,
"register_match_cosine": 0.7173,
"register_band_deltas": {
"sub": 0.1563,
"low_bass": 0.2022,
"bass": 0.0438,
"low_mid": -0.1041,
"mid": -0.1155,
"upper_mid": -0.0886,
"presence": -0.0631,
"brilliance": -0.0232,
"air": -0.0078
}
},
"loop_seam": {
"measurable": true,
"seam_distance": 0.04715,
"interior_distance_median": 0.07445,
"seam_ratio": 0.633,
"seam_clean": true,
"tail_rms_over_mid": 1.6285,
"head_rms_over_mid": 0.8626,
"tail_rms_trend": 0.3818,
"head_rms_trend": -0.5073,
"baked_fade_out": false,
"baked_fade_in": false
},
"hummability_proxy": {
"items": {
"D3_global_contour": {
"score": 0,
"applicable": true,
"detail": "shape=concave thirds=(39.83,38.11,38.95)"
},
"D4_one_licensed_anomaly": {
"score": 2,
"applicable": true,
"detail": "leaps>=6st=0 repeated_runs=1"
},
"D5_tessitura_rule": {
"score": 2,
"applicable": true,
"detail": "compliant 3/3"
},
"D6_span_tessitura": {
"score": 1,
"applicable": true,
"detail": "span=6.0st middle_third_share=0.26"
},
"D9_periodicity": {
"score": 1,
"applicable": true,
"detail": "ioi_cv=0.962 beat_cv=0.067"
},
"D11_tempo_vs_register_median": {
"score": 2,
"applicable": true,
"detail": "bpm=123.0 register_median=108"
},
"D12_continuation_by_fragmentation": {
"score": 0,
"applicable": true,
"detail": "second_half_vocab_share=0.56 accelerates=False"
},
"D13_non_closure": {
"score": 2,
"applicable": true,
"detail": "final_pc=D# != tonic=D"
}
},
"applicable_count": 8,
"score": 10,
"max": 16,
"percent": 0.625,
"zero_scoring_items": [
"D3_global_contour",
"D12_continuation_by_fragmentation"
],
"proxy_gate_view": {
"doctrine_threshold_percent": 0.77,
"meets_percent_threshold": false,
"no_applicable_zero": false,
"PROXY_ONLY": true,
"covers": "8 of 13 diagnostics (2.3.3); 0 of 5 binary gates (2.3.2)",
"not_computable": {
"B1_recall_singback": "needs a naive human listener (doctrine appendix T.1)",
"B2_transformability": "needs the four transformations rendered as separate artifacts",
"B3_combinability": "needs a sibling canon leitmotif; evaluated at cohort close",
"B4_concert_viability": "PARTIAL only -- written-range fit is computed, choral singability is not",
"B5_no_patch_dependence": "a judgement on the arrangement, not a signal property",
"D1_first_notes_identification": "needs a naive human listener",
"D2_notation_free_transmission": "needs a second musician",
"D8_clap_test": "needs a naive human listener",
"D7_anchor_degree_landing": "needs the register card's declared anchor degrees; scored only when the spec supplies them",
"D10_constant_harmonic_rate": "needs chord/colotomic transcription; not attempted"
},
"reading": "A pass here is NECESSARY-NOT-SUFFICIENT. The doctrine gate is not passed until B1/D1/D2/D8 are run with listeners."
}
}
}
},
{
"artifact_id": "JOURNEY_WORLD_C08",
"carrier": "flute",
"keyscale": "D major",
"bpm": 120,
"seed": 4208,
"audio": "build/audio/generated/journey_world/JOURNEY_WORLD_C08.wav",
"score": {
"components": {
"hummability_proxy_percent": 0.7143,
"melodic_salience": 0.5299,
"motif_recurrence": 0.0224,
"bpm_fidelity": 0.233,
"key_stability": 0.25,
"register_match": 0.6977,
"loop_seam": 0.0
},
"weighted": {
"hummability_proxy_percent": 0.3214,
"melodic_salience": 0.106,
"motif_recurrence": 0.0022,
"bpm_fidelity": 0.0233,
"key_stability": 0.0125,
"register_match": 0.0349,
"loop_seam": 0.0
},
"total": 0.5003
},
"features": {
"artifact": "C:\\dev\\humanity-forgotten\\build\\audio\\generated\\journey_world\\JOURNEY_WORLD_C08.wav",
"duration_s": 32.0,
"analysis_sr": 22050,
"melodic": {
"melodic_salience": 0.5299,
"extractor": "harmonic-summation predominant melody (polyphony-safe)",
"monophonic_confidence_pyin": 0.0,
"voiced_fraction": 0.0751,
"note_count": 23,
"note_rate_per_s": 0.719,
"pitch_change_rate": 0.6364,
"pitch_spread_semitones": 1.358,
"in_note_pitch_mad_semitones": 0.0,
"median_note_dur_s": 0.0929,
"mean_voiced_peakiness": 0.0579,
"salience_aggregation": "geometric mean of the five components below",
"components": {
"voiced": 0.125,
"rate": 1.0,
"change": 1.0,
"peakiness": 0.379,
"duration": 0.881
}
},
"notes": [
{
"midi": 39.0,
"onset_s": 1.5209070294784581,
"dur_s": 0.058049886621315196,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 37.0,
"onset_s": 2.078185941043084,
"dur_s": 0.12770975056689343,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 38.0,
"onset_s": 3.7732426303854876,
"dur_s": 0.09287981859410431,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 37.666666666666664,
"onset_s": 5.851428571428571,
"dur_s": 0.1741496598639456,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 37.666666666666664,
"onset_s": 6.060408163265306,
"dur_s": 0.09287981859410431,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 37.666666666666664,
"onset_s": 6.164897959183674,
"dur_s": 0.11609977324263039,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 38.0,
"onset_s": 6.524807256235827,
"dur_s": 0.058049886621315196,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 38.66666666666667,
"onset_s": 7.058866213151927,
"dur_s": 0.06965986394557823,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 38.66666666666667,
"onset_s": 10.971428571428572,
"dur_s": 0.10448979591836735,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 42.666666666666664,
"onset_s": 11.470657596371883,
"dur_s": 0.058049886621315196,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 39.666666666666664,
"onset_s": 13.676553287981859,
"dur_s": 0.06965986394557823,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 36.66666666666667,
"onset_s": 13.746213151927437,
"dur_s": 0.1509297052154195,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 36.66666666666667,
"onset_s": 13.920362811791383,
"dur_s": 0.08126984126984127,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 39.0,
"onset_s": 14.001632653061224,
"dur_s": 0.09287981859410431,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 40.0,
"onset_s": 22.024126984126983,
"dur_s": 0.058049886621315196,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 40.0,
"onset_s": 24.49705215419501,
"dur_s": 0.058049886621315196,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 37.333333333333336,
"onset_s": 24.810521541950113,
"dur_s": 0.1509297052154195,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 38.0,
"onset_s": 24.961451247165535,
"dur_s": 0.058049886621315196,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 37.0,
"onset_s": 25.414240362811793,
"dur_s": 0.1741496598639456,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 37.333333333333336,
"onset_s": 27.109297052154194,
"dur_s": 0.058049886621315196,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 39.33333333333333,
"onset_s": 27.48081632653061,
"dur_s": 0.10448979591836735,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 37.333333333333336,
"onset_s": 28.606984126984127,
"dur_s": 0.11609977324263039,
"confidence": 1.0
},
{
"midi": 39.0,
"onset_s": 29.628662131519274,
"dur_s": 0.06965986394557823,
"confidence": 1.0
}
],
"motif_recurrence": {
"self_similarity_peak": 0.9475,
"self_similarity_baseline": 0.9419,
"self_similarity_lift": 0.0056,
"recurrence_lag_s": 0.464,
"interval_3gram_repetition": 0.05,
"interval_4gram_repetition": 0.0
},
"key": {
"tonic_pc": 6,
"tonic": "F#",
"mode": "minor",
"window_agreement": 0.25,
"windows": 8
},
"tempo": {
"tempo_bpm_global": 129.2,
"tempo_bpm_median_local": 112.35,
"tempo_iqr_bpm": 29.82,
"tempo_stability": 0.0,
"beat_interval_cv": 0.065,
"target_bpm": 120,
"bpm_rel_error_direct": 0.0767,
"bpm_rel_error_best_octave": 0.0767,
"bpm_best_octave": "1x",
"bpm_recoverable": false,
"bpm_recoverable_direct": false
},
"spectral_register": {
"band_profile": {
"sub": 0.18891,
"low_bass": 0.29088,
"bass": 0.19375,
"low_mid": 0.10638,
"mid": 0.11554,
"upper_mid": 0.048,
"presence": 0.01819,
"brilliance": 0.00817,
"air": 0.00258,
"ultra": 0.0
},
"spectral_centroid_hz_mean": 1237.7,
"spectral_centroid_hz_std": 705.7,
"spectral_rolloff85_hz_mean": 2643.1,
"spectral_flatness_mean": 0.00373,
"register_match_cosine": 0.6977,
"register_band_deltas": {
"sub": 0.1743,
"low_bass": 0.1991,
"bass": 0.0392,
"low_mid": -0.1106,
"mid": -0.1212,
"upper_mid": -0.0906,
"presence": -0.0613,
"brilliance": -0.0216,
"air": -0.0073
}
},
"loop_seam": {
"measurable": true,
"seam_distance": 0.08503,
"interior_distance_median": 0.04578,
"seam_ratio": 1.857,
"seam_clean": false,
"tail_rms_over_mid": 1.8535,
"head_rms_over_mid": 0.6028,
"tail_rms_trend": 0.5369,
"head_rms_trend": 0.2264,
"baked_fade_out": false,
"baked_fade_in": false
},
"hummability_proxy": {
"items": {
"D3_global_contour": {
"score": 2,
"applicable": true,
"detail": "shape=arch thirds=(37.86,38.86,38.37)"
},
"D4_one_licensed_anomaly": {
"score": 2,
"applicable": true,
"detail": "leaps>=6st=0 repeated_runs=1"
},
"D5_tessitura_rule": {
"score": null,
"applicable": false,
"detail": "no leaps landing near a tessitura extreme"
},
"D6_span_tessitura": {
"score": 1,
"applicable": true,
"detail": "span=6.0st middle_third_share=0.39"
},
"D9_periodicity": {
"score": 0,
"applicable": true,
"detail": "ioi_cv=1.383 beat_cv=0.065"
},
"D11_tempo_vs_register_median": {
"score": 2,
"applicable": true,
"detail": "bpm=129.2 register_median=108"
},
"D12_continuation_by_fragmentation": {
"score": 1,
"applicable": true,
"detail": "second_half_vocab_share=0.64 accelerates=False"
},
"D13_non_closure": {
"score": 2,
"applicable": true,
"detail": "final_pc=D# != tonic=F#"
}
},
"applicable_count": 7,
"score": 10,
"max": 14,
"percent": 0.7143,
"zero_scoring_items": [
"D9_periodicity"
],
"proxy_gate_view": {
"doctrine_threshold_percent": 0.77,
"meets_percent_threshold": false,
"no_applicable_zero": false,
"PROXY_ONLY": true,
"covers": "8 of 13 diagnostics (2.3.3); 0 of 5 binary gates (2.3.2)",
"not_computable": {
"B1_recall_singback": "needs a naive human listener (doctrine appendix T.1)",
"B2_transformability": "needs the four transformations rendered as separate artifacts",
"B3_combinability": "needs a sibling canon leitmotif; evaluated at cohort close",
"B4_concert_viability": "PARTIAL only -- written-range fit is computed, choral singability is not",
"B5_no_patch_dependence": "a judgement on the arrangement, not a signal property",
"D1_first_notes_identification": "needs a naive human listener",
"D2_notation_free_transmission": "needs a second musician",
"D8_clap_test": "needs a naive human listener",
"D7_anchor_degree_landing": "needs the register card's declared anchor degrees; scored only when the spec supplies them",
"D10_constant_harmonic_rate": "needs chord/colotomic transcription; not attempted"
},
"reading": "A pass here is NECESSARY-NOT-SUFFICIENT. The doctrine gate is not passed until B1/D1/D2/D8 are run with listeners."
}
}
}
}
]
}