music/generated/REVIEW_PICKS.json
{
"_doc": "The review candidates that may be PLAYED ON /review/, grouped by the chapter and theme each would eventually serve. Emitted by harness/music_gen/emit_review_picks.py; do NOT hand-edit.",
"_ruling_served": "Josh, 2026-08-07: \"remember you created this review queue page for me to review before you put stuff on the page and start filling out our page with non polished work.\"",
"_the_switch": "docs/review_candidates.json. A theme is queued only while its music row reads 'ungraded'. Set the row to 'turned_down' and this file emits nothing for it, the site encodes no bytes for it, and the next build has no player to render. The takedown IS the absence of a pick.",
"_gate_relationship": "The 2026-08-06 audio publish gate stays SHUT and this file does not touch it. No chapter page receives anything from here: this file is read by harness/site/review_queue.py and is NOT one of the picks files harness/site/generated_music.py concatenates, so no row here can reach a chapter's Sound section by any path. Graduating an approved track to its chapter is a separate, deliberate act.",
"_tier_honesty": "Register and arrangement candidates, never themes and never the leitmotif. No listening test stands behind any of it.",
"_filter_authority": "build/audio/generated/slice_v1/verdicts.json -- PATTERN_FINDINGS_V2 section 14's joint envelope, necessary-not-sufficient. REJECT cells are kept on disk and never published.",
"emitted_at": "2026-08-09T04:23:35+00:00",
"picks_n": 3,
"refusals_n": 9,
"refusals": [
"T1_EXPLORATION_FLORES: review row SLICE_V1_T1_EXPLORATION_FLORES reads 'turned_down'; nothing is queued for it (this is the takedown, not a failure)",
"T2_BATTLE_CACI: review row SLICE_V1_T2_BATTLE_CACI reads 'turned_down'; nothing is queued for it (this is the takedown, not a failure)",
"T3_TITLE_PROTAGONIST: review row SLICE_V1_T3_TITLE_PROTAGONIST reads 'turned_down'; nothing is queued for it (this is the takedown, not a failure)",
"T4_MELANCHOLIC_HOME_AND_LOSS: review row SLICE_V1_T4_MELANCHOLIC_HOME_AND_LOSS reads 'turned_down'; nothing is queued for it (this is the takedown, not a failure)",
"PASS2_FLORES_REST: review row PASS2_FLORES_REST reads 'turned_down'; nothing is queued for it (this is the takedown, not a failure)",
"PASS2_FLORES_WATERFALL: review row PASS2_FLORES_WATERFALL reads 'turned_down'; nothing is queued for it (this is the takedown, not a failure)",
"PASS5_FLORES_FALLS: review row PASS5_FLORES_FALLS reads 'turned_down'; nothing is queued for it (this is the takedown, not a failure)",
"PASS5_FLORES_ROAD: review row PASS5_FLORES_ROAD reads 'turned_down'; nothing is queued for it (this is the takedown, not a failure)",
"PASS5_FLORES_ROUNDS: review row PASS5_FLORES_ROUNDS reads 'turned_down'; nothing is queued for it (this is the takedown, not a failure)"
],
"coverage": {
"T1_EXPLORATION_FLORES": {
"chapter": "CH_03",
"cells": 8,
"kept": 4,
"review_row": "SLICE_V1_T1_EXPLORATION_FLORES",
"review_state": "turned_down",
"queued": 0
},
"T2_BATTLE_CACI": {
"chapter": "CH_03",
"cells": 8,
"kept": 3,
"review_row": "SLICE_V1_T2_BATTLE_CACI",
"review_state": "turned_down",
"queued": 0
},
"T3_TITLE_PROTAGONIST": {
"chapter": "CH_PROLOGUE",
"cells": 8,
"kept": 4,
"review_row": "SLICE_V1_T3_TITLE_PROTAGONIST",
"review_state": "turned_down",
"queued": 0
},
"T4_MELANCHOLIC_HOME_AND_LOSS": {
"chapter": "CH_13",
"cells": 8,
"kept": 7,
"review_row": "SLICE_V1_T4_MELANCHOLIC_HOME_AND_LOSS",
"review_state": "turned_down",
"queued": 0
},
"PASS2_FLORES_REST": {
"chapter": "CH_03",
"cells": 1,
"kept": 1,
"review_row": "PASS2_FLORES_REST",
"review_state": "turned_down",
"queued": 0
},
"PASS2_FLORES_WATERFALL": {
"chapter": "CH_03",
"cells": 1,
"kept": 1,
"review_row": "PASS2_FLORES_WATERFALL",
"review_state": "turned_down",
"queued": 0
},
"PASS5_FLORES_FALLS": {
"chapter": "CH_03",
"cells": 1,
"kept": 1,
"review_row": "PASS5_FLORES_FALLS",
"review_state": "turned_down",
"queued": 0
},
"PASS5_FLORES_ROAD": {
"chapter": "CH_03",
"cells": 1,
"kept": 1,
"review_row": "PASS5_FLORES_ROAD",
"review_state": "turned_down",
"queued": 0
},
"PASS5_FLORES_ROUNDS": {
"chapter": "CH_03",
"cells": 1,
"kept": 1,
"review_row": "PASS5_FLORES_ROUNDS",
"review_state": "turned_down",
"queued": 0
},
"PASS7_FLORES_FALLS": {
"chapter": "CH_03",
"cells": 1,
"kept": 1,
"review_row": "PASS7_FLORES_FALLS",
"review_state": "ungraded",
"queued": 1
},
"PASS7_FLORES_ROAD": {
"chapter": "CH_03",
"cells": 1,
"kept": 1,
"review_row": "PASS7_FLORES_ROAD",
"review_state": "ungraded",
"queued": 1
},
"PASS7_FLORES_ROUNDS": {
"chapter": "CH_03",
"cells": 1,
"kept": 1,
"review_row": "PASS7_FLORES_ROUNDS",
"review_state": "ungraded",
"queued": 1
}
},
"picks": [
{
"artifact_id": "PASS7_FLORES_FALLS",
"role": "review_candidate",
"source": "pass7",
"display_name": "Flores Highlands -- the light on the water",
"theme_id": "REGION_FLORES_ISLAND",
"picked_by": "harness/music_gen/emit_review_picks.py - every round-4 cue whose review row is ungraded and which carries a KEEP on round 1's own filter",
"tier_label": "round 4 - functional harmony, a second melodic voice, a measured groove, mixed",
"tier_note": "A COMPOSED CANDIDATE, ungraded. Every clause of the round-3 takedown became a measurement before a note was rewritten. CC0 samplers, nobody has heard it. Grade the place and the tune.",
"tier_note_detail": "Round 3 was turned down in one sentence and every clause of it was turned into a measurement before a note was rewritten: a real chord schedule with harmonic rhythm and named cadences, the melody's structural tones snapped onto it, a SECOND MELODIC VOICE in thirds and sixths on its own timbre, pads and arpeggios written as voice-led figures, percussion as a measured groove around the colotomic clock. Three of the complaints traced to one defect in our own code -- the two layers carrying the harmony were sounding two octaves too high, on top of the tune. Not a scoring session: free CC0 samplers, no human touched a note.",
"care_tier": "",
"care_release_ref": "this page's Section 10 documented instruments and technique, reference-composed",
"rung": "",
"rung_rank": 0,
"loop": false,
"serves_nodes": [
"CH_03"
],
"serves_regions": [],
"proxy_percent": null,
"deciding_features": [],
"src_path": "D:\\audio\\pass7\\PASS7_FLORES_FALLS\\PASS7_FLORES_FALLS.wav",
"licence": "VSCO 2 CE, VCSL and the landed CC0 voice and body-percussion sets are CC0; sfizz is BSD-2 and is not redistributed. The room is a SYNTHETIC impulse generated in-repo, so there is no third-party IR licence to read. No sample is a conditioning, fine-tune or LoRA input to any generator.",
"model": "authored score, sfizz + CC0 sampler, mixed and levelled in-repo",
"seed": null,
"prompt_hash": "",
"seconds": 180.0,
"review": {
"row": "PASS7_FLORES_FALLS",
"state": "ungraded",
"theme_key": "PASS7_FLORES_FALLS",
"theme_display": "Flores Highlands -- the light on the water",
"chapter": "CH_03",
"region_page": "_source/02_Tier_2_Region_Pages/flores_island.md",
"variant": "ROUND4",
"rank_in_theme": 1,
"kept_in_theme": 1,
"generated_in_theme": 1,
"held_for_grade": true,
"bpm": 72.0,
"cue_refs": "MC_0051",
"evidence": "build/audio/pass7/ROUND4_STAGING.md",
"order": 2400,
"numbers": {
"rules_fired": 5,
"rules_total": 6,
"rules_named": [],
"axes_on_hit_side": 6,
"axes_total": 6,
"envelope": {
"melodic_span_semitones": {
"value": 34.0,
"lo": 19.67,
"hi": 57.0,
"inside": true
},
"mean_section_s": {
"value": 7.8261,
"lo": 7.145,
"hi": 63.3454,
"inside": true
},
"composed_rest": {
"value": 11.3867,
"lo": 2.6757,
"hi": 17.4281,
"inside": true
}
},
"size": {
"sections": {
"value": 23.0,
"hit_median": 17.0,
"sibling_median": 9.0,
"on_hit_side": true
},
"length_s": {
"value": 180.0,
"hit_median": 196.6,
"sibling_median": 96.2,
"on_hit_side": true
},
"bars": {
"value": 107.0,
"hit_median": 114.0,
"sibling_median": 52.0,
"on_hit_side": true
},
"drops": {
"value": 32.0,
"hit_median": 19.5,
"sibling_median": 6.0,
"on_hit_side": true
},
"self_similarity": {
"value": 0.9348,
"hit_median": 0.902,
"sibling_median": 0.855,
"on_hit_side": true
},
"structural_novelty": {
"value": 0.5601,
"hit_median": 0.556,
"sibling_median": 0.678,
"on_hit_side": true
}
}
},
"planned_vs_measured": {
"parts_planned": 18,
"parts_rendered": 18,
"sections_planned": 14,
"sections_measured": 23,
"novelty_events_planned": 17
},
"structural_yield": {
"value": 0.6875,
"boundaries": 22,
"drops": 32,
"boundaries_per_min": 7.333,
"hits": 0.76,
"siblings": 1.0,
"round_1": 0.22,
"auc_vs_round_1": 0.911,
"auc_vs_siblings": 0.437,
"honest_label": "a GENERATION-DEFECT detector, never a taste oracle -- near chance against the corpus's own album siblings (0.437), near-perfect against our own generator's output (0.911)",
"not_in_the_decision": "reported beside the verdict and never folded into it -- the KEEP/REJECT stays on the filter round 1 faced"
},
"arc": {
"dynamic_arc": true,
"holds": 1,
"longest_hold_s": 31.21,
"hold_share": 0.1736,
"instrument_floor_s": 22.287,
"instrument_floor_hold_share": 0.1434,
"verdict_curve": "flow (0.45 RMS + 0.35 lane simultaneity + 0.20 register)",
"all_four_curves_hold_share": {
"flow": 0.1736,
"db": 0.0,
"sim": 0.1921,
"cplx": 0.3868
},
"instruments_passing": 7,
"instruments_deciding": 7
},
"mix": {
"integrated_lufs": -14.82,
"target_lufs": -13.95,
"clears_target": true,
"loudness_range_lu": 11.4,
"true_peak_dbtp": -1.0,
"room_wet": 0.26,
"room_rt60_s": 2.3,
"room_chosen_by": "the class's declared synthetic room, applied whole"
}
}
},
{
"artifact_id": "PASS7_FLORES_ROAD",
"role": "review_candidate",
"source": "pass7",
"display_name": "Flores Highlands -- the road that keeps count",
"theme_id": "REGION_FLORES_ISLAND",
"picked_by": "harness/music_gen/emit_review_picks.py - every round-4 cue whose review row is ungraded and which carries a KEEP on round 1's own filter",
"tier_label": "round 4 - functional harmony, a second melodic voice, a measured groove, mixed",
"tier_note": "A COMPOSED CANDIDATE, ungraded. Every clause of the round-3 takedown became a measurement before a note was rewritten. CC0 samplers, nobody has heard it. Grade the place and the tune.",
"tier_note_detail": "Round 3 was turned down in one sentence and every clause of it was turned into a measurement before a note was rewritten: a real chord schedule with harmonic rhythm and named cadences, the melody's structural tones snapped onto it, a SECOND MELODIC VOICE in thirds and sixths on its own timbre, pads and arpeggios written as voice-led figures, percussion as a measured groove around the colotomic clock. Three of the complaints traced to one defect in our own code -- the two layers carrying the harmony were sounding two octaves too high, on top of the tune. Not a scoring session: free CC0 samplers, no human touched a note.",
"care_tier": "",
"care_release_ref": "this page's Section 10 documented instruments and technique, reference-composed",
"rung": "",
"rung_rank": 0,
"loop": false,
"serves_nodes": [
"CH_03"
],
"serves_regions": [],
"proxy_percent": null,
"deciding_features": [],
"src_path": "D:\\audio\\pass7\\PASS7_FLORES_ROAD\\PASS7_FLORES_ROAD.wav",
"licence": "VSCO 2 CE, VCSL and the landed CC0 voice and body-percussion sets are CC0; sfizz is BSD-2 and is not redistributed. The room is a SYNTHETIC impulse generated in-repo, so there is no third-party IR licence to read. No sample is a conditioning, fine-tune or LoRA input to any generator.",
"model": "authored score, sfizz + CC0 sampler, mixed and levelled in-repo",
"seed": null,
"prompt_hash": "",
"seconds": 223.448,
"review": {
"row": "PASS7_FLORES_ROAD",
"state": "ungraded",
"theme_key": "PASS7_FLORES_ROAD",
"theme_display": "Flores Highlands -- the road that keeps count",
"chapter": "CH_03",
"region_page": "_source/02_Tier_2_Region_Pages/flores_island.md",
"variant": "ROUND4",
"rank_in_theme": 1,
"kept_in_theme": 1,
"generated_in_theme": 1,
"held_for_grade": true,
"bpm": 116.0,
"cue_refs": "MC_0048, MC_0050, MC_0053",
"evidence": "build/audio/pass7/ROUND4_STAGING.md",
"order": 2401,
"numbers": {
"rules_fired": 4,
"rules_total": 6,
"rules_named": [],
"axes_on_hit_side": 6,
"axes_total": 6,
"envelope": {
"melodic_span_semitones": {
"value": 52.33,
"lo": 19.67,
"hi": 57.0,
"inside": true
},
"mean_section_s": {
"value": 24.8276,
"lo": 7.145,
"hi": 63.3454,
"inside": true
},
"composed_rest": {
"value": 16.82,
"lo": 2.6757,
"hi": 17.4281,
"inside": true
}
},
"size": {
"sections": {
"value": 9.0,
"hit_median": 17.0,
"sibling_median": 9.0,
"on_hit_side": true
},
"length_s": {
"value": 223.448,
"hit_median": 196.6,
"sibling_median": 96.2,
"on_hit_side": true
},
"bars": {
"value": 109.0,
"hit_median": 114.0,
"sibling_median": 52.0,
"on_hit_side": true
},
"drops": {
"value": 54.0,
"hit_median": 19.5,
"sibling_median": 6.0,
"on_hit_side": true
},
"self_similarity": {
"value": 0.8714,
"hit_median": 0.902,
"sibling_median": 0.855,
"on_hit_side": true
},
"structural_novelty": {
"value": 0.4231,
"hit_median": 0.556,
"sibling_median": 0.678,
"on_hit_side": true
}
}
},
"planned_vs_measured": {
"parts_planned": 33,
"parts_rendered": 33,
"sections_planned": 21,
"sections_measured": 9,
"novelty_events_planned": 21
},
"structural_yield": {
"value": 0.1481,
"boundaries": 8,
"drops": 54,
"boundaries_per_min": 2.148,
"hits": 0.76,
"siblings": 1.0,
"round_1": 0.22,
"auc_vs_round_1": 0.911,
"auc_vs_siblings": 0.437,
"honest_label": "a GENERATION-DEFECT detector, never a taste oracle -- near chance against the corpus's own album siblings (0.437), near-perfect against our own generator's output (0.911)",
"not_in_the_decision": "reported beside the verdict and never folded into it -- the KEEP/REJECT stays on the filter round 1 faced"
},
"arc": {
"dynamic_arc": false,
"holds": 1,
"longest_hold_s": 29.72,
"hold_share": 0.1333,
"instrument_floor_s": 22.287,
"instrument_floor_hold_share": 0.1434,
"verdict_curve": "flow (0.45 RMS + 0.35 lane simultaneity + 0.20 register)",
"all_four_curves_hold_share": {
"flow": 0.1333,
"db": 0.5833,
"sim": 0.1922,
"cplx": 0.287
},
"instruments_passing": 5,
"instruments_deciding": 7
},
"mix": {
"integrated_lufs": -13.14,
"target_lufs": -12.18,
"clears_target": true,
"loudness_range_lu": 8.61,
"true_peak_dbtp": -1.0,
"room_wet": 0.16,
"room_rt60_s": 1.35,
"room_chosen_by": "the class's declared synthetic room, applied whole"
}
}
},
{
"artifact_id": "PASS7_FLORES_ROUNDS",
"role": "review_candidate",
"source": "pass7",
"display_name": "Flores Highlands -- the caci rounds",
"theme_id": "REGION_FLORES_ISLAND",
"picked_by": "harness/music_gen/emit_review_picks.py - every round-4 cue whose review row is ungraded and which carries a KEEP on round 1's own filter",
"tier_label": "round 4 - functional harmony, a second melodic voice, a measured groove, mixed",
"tier_note": "A COMPOSED CANDIDATE, ungraded. Every clause of the round-3 takedown became a measurement before a note was rewritten. CC0 samplers, nobody has heard it. Grade the place and the tune.",
"tier_note_detail": "Round 3 was turned down in one sentence and every clause of it was turned into a measurement before a note was rewritten: a real chord schedule with harmonic rhythm and named cadences, the melody's structural tones snapped onto it, a SECOND MELODIC VOICE in thirds and sixths on its own timbre, pads and arpeggios written as voice-led figures, percussion as a measured groove around the colotomic clock. Three of the complaints traced to one defect in our own code -- the two layers carrying the harmony were sounding two octaves too high, on top of the tune. Not a scoring session: free CC0 samplers, no human touched a note.",
"care_tier": "",
"care_release_ref": "this page's Section 10 documented instruments and technique, reference-composed",
"rung": "",
"rung_rank": 0,
"loop": false,
"serves_nodes": [
"CH_03"
],
"serves_regions": [],
"proxy_percent": null,
"deciding_features": [],
"src_path": "D:\\audio\\pass7\\PASS7_FLORES_ROUNDS\\PASS7_FLORES_ROUNDS.wav",
"licence": "VSCO 2 CE, VCSL and the landed CC0 voice and body-percussion sets are CC0; sfizz is BSD-2 and is not redistributed. The room is a SYNTHETIC impulse generated in-repo, so there is no third-party IR licence to read. No sample is a conditioning, fine-tune or LoRA input to any generator.",
"model": "authored score, sfizz + CC0 sampler, mixed and levelled in-repo",
"seed": null,
"prompt_hash": "",
"seconds": 201.081,
"review": {
"row": "PASS7_FLORES_ROUNDS",
"state": "ungraded",
"theme_key": "PASS7_FLORES_ROUNDS",
"theme_display": "Flores Highlands -- the caci rounds",
"chapter": "CH_03",
"region_page": "_source/02_Tier_2_Region_Pages/flores_island.md",
"variant": "ROUND4",
"rank_in_theme": 1,
"kept_in_theme": 1,
"generated_in_theme": 1,
"held_for_grade": true,
"bpm": 148.0,
"cue_refs": "MC_0049, MC_0052",
"evidence": "build/audio/pass7/ROUND4_STAGING.md",
"order": 2402,
"numbers": {
"rules_fired": 6,
"rules_total": 6,
"rules_named": [],
"axes_on_hit_side": 6,
"axes_total": 6,
"envelope": {
"melodic_span_semitones": {
"value": 36.0,
"lo": 19.67,
"hi": 57.0,
"inside": true
},
"mean_section_s": {
"value": 13.4054,
"lo": 7.145,
"hi": 63.3454,
"inside": true
},
"composed_rest": {
"value": 16.2826,
"lo": 2.6757,
"hi": 17.4281,
"inside": true
}
},
"size": {
"sections": {
"value": 15.0,
"hit_median": 17.0,
"sibling_median": 9.0,
"on_hit_side": true
},
"length_s": {
"value": 201.081,
"hit_median": 196.6,
"sibling_median": 96.2,
"on_hit_side": true
},
"bars": {
"value": 120.0,
"hit_median": 114.0,
"sibling_median": 52.0,
"on_hit_side": true
},
"drops": {
"value": 48.0,
"hit_median": 19.5,
"sibling_median": 6.0,
"on_hit_side": true
},
"self_similarity": {
"value": 0.9177,
"hit_median": 0.902,
"sibling_median": 0.855,
"on_hit_side": true
},
"structural_novelty": {
"value": 0.4933,
"hit_median": 0.556,
"sibling_median": 0.678,
"on_hit_side": true
}
}
},
"planned_vs_measured": {
"parts_planned": 36,
"parts_rendered": 36,
"sections_planned": 18,
"sections_measured": 15,
"novelty_events_planned": 21
},
"structural_yield": {
"value": 0.2917,
"boundaries": 14,
"drops": 48,
"boundaries_per_min": 4.177,
"hits": 0.76,
"siblings": 1.0,
"round_1": 0.22,
"auc_vs_round_1": 0.911,
"auc_vs_siblings": 0.437,
"honest_label": "a GENERATION-DEFECT detector, never a taste oracle -- near chance against the corpus's own album siblings (0.437), near-perfect against our own generator's output (0.911)",
"not_in_the_decision": "reported beside the verdict and never folded into it -- the KEEP/REJECT stays on the filter round 1 faced"
},
"arc": {
"dynamic_arc": true,
"holds": 4,
"longest_hold_s": 53.5,
"hold_share": 0.5296,
"instrument_floor_s": 22.287,
"instrument_floor_hold_share": 0.1434,
"verdict_curve": "flow (0.45 RMS + 0.35 lane simultaneity + 0.20 register)",
"all_four_curves_hold_share": {
"flow": 0.5296,
"db": 0.4111,
"sim": 0.0887,
"cplx": 0.3782
},
"instruments_passing": 7,
"instruments_deciding": 7
},
"mix": {
"integrated_lufs": -11.82,
"target_lufs": -9.84,
"clears_target": false,
"loudness_range_lu": 10.42,
"true_peak_dbtp": -1.0,
"room_wet": 0.11,
"room_rt60_s": 0.85,
"room_chosen_by": "the class's declared synthetic room, applied whole"
}
}
}
]
}