music/benchmark/rereads/REREAD_INDEX.json
{
"_doc": "THE WO-12 REREAD INDEX -- every banked row, ranked by the character reading",
"_honest_tier": "MEASURED RANK, NEVER A QUALITY CLAIM. The reading orders a slate against four declared composition clauses. It gates nothing, promotes nothing, and every axis prints its own measured separation beside its value -- including the three that read at or below chance.",
"reread_version": "ear-axes/1.0.0",
"source_records": "C:\\dev\\humanity-forgotten\\build\\audio\\benchmark\\records",
"audio_reextracted": false,
"terms": {
"turn_pacing": {
"clause": "structural change EARNED per unit of texture chopping",
"cite": "MUSIC_PRACTICE_GAP_AUDIT.md S3; floor_instruments.py:28-56"
},
"motivic_dev": {
"clause": "developing variation -- how many operations, and how many kinds",
"cite": "MUSIC_PRACTICE_GAP_AUDIT.md S3"
},
"dynamic_breath": {
"clause": "the cue breathes, and its silences are composed rather than dead",
"cite": "MUSIC_PRACTICE_GAP_AUDIT.md S9, S13; PIPE_AUDIO_MUSIC_2026-07-29.md §0"
},
"voice_dialogue": {
"clause": "a second tune-carrying voice, and the melody traded between voices",
"cite": "MUSIC_PRACTICE_GAP_AUDIT.md S6"
}
},
"weights": "EQUAL AND DECLARED. Four terms, each the mean of its axes. Nothing was fitted.",
"refused_axes": {
"boundaries_per_min": "REPORTED; the order assumed FEWER is better and the corpus says the opposite",
"loudness_range_lu": "REFUSED as deciding -- measured INVERTED on the graded set",
"syncopation_audio": "REPORTED -- reads exactly 0.0 on 13 of 19 engine rows and its EXPLORATION p10 is 0.0, so below-band is unreachable; a zero with no positive control on real material is the a-search-that-cannot-match class"
},
"self_declared_degenerate_instruments": {
"layer_census": "floor_instruments.py:248 -- its estimator saturates near 8 streams where a real cue runs 24 to 40 parts, so it cannot adjudicate the layer clause",
"noise_structure": "floor_instruments.py:246-247 -- fires on 0 of 18 across both tiers with nothing clearing the multiplicity bar",
"summit_tests": "floor_instruments.py:124-128 -- its four continuous axes SEPARATE NOTHING on audio; it is a SCORE instrument that degrades honestly",
"hook_presence": "instr_hook_presence.py:200-210 -- the module declares its own floor DEGENERATE and says passes_floor should not be believed"
},
"order": [
{
"rank": 1,
"track_id": "BENCH_R1_ELEVENLABS_EDIT_V2_2",
"cue_class": "EXPLORATION",
"character_reading": 0.757,
"wall_fraction": "2/8",
"interior_dead_space_s": 0,
"edge_dead_space_s": 19.3
},
{
"rank": 2,
"track_id": "BENCH_R1_ELEVENLABS_EDIT_SERENE_V2",
"cue_class": "SERENE",
"character_reading": 0.7054,
"wall_fraction": "6/8",
"interior_dead_space_s": 0,
"edge_dead_space_s": 13.4
},
{
"rank": 3,
"track_id": "BENCH_R1_ELEVENLABS_TP_E1_v4_1",
"cue_class": "EXPLORATION",
"character_reading": 0.6769,
"wall_fraction": "7/9",
"interior_dead_space_s": 0,
"edge_dead_space_s": 20.1
},
{
"rank": 4,
"track_id": "BENCH_R1_ELEVENLABS_EDIT_V2_1",
"cue_class": "EXPLORATION",
"character_reading": 0.625,
"wall_fraction": "7/9",
"interior_dead_space_s": 0,
"edge_dead_space_s": 20.1
},
{
"rank": 5,
"track_id": "BENCH_R1_ELEVENLABS_TP_E1_v6_2",
"cue_class": "EXPLORATION",
"character_reading": 0.6195,
"wall_fraction": "6/9",
"interior_dead_space_s": 20.8,
"edge_dead_space_s": 0
},
{
"rank": 6,
"track_id": "BENCH_R1_ELEVENLABS_TP_E1_v6_1",
"cue_class": "EXPLORATION",
"character_reading": 0.6075,
"wall_fraction": "4/8",
"interior_dead_space_s": 0,
"edge_dead_space_s": 0
},
{
"rank": 7,
"track_id": "BENCH_R1_ELEVENLABS_TP_B2_HYBRID_1",
"cue_class": "BATTLE",
"character_reading": 0.5599,
"wall_fraction": "5/8",
"interior_dead_space_s": 0,
"edge_dead_space_s": 0
},
{
"rank": 8,
"track_id": "BENCH_R1_ELEVENLABS_TP_S1_v1_2",
"cue_class": "SERENE",
"character_reading": 0.5523,
"wall_fraction": "8/9",
"interior_dead_space_s": 0,
"edge_dead_space_s": 0
},
{
"rank": 9,
"track_id": "BENCH_R1_ELEVENLABS_EDIT_BATTLE_V2",
"cue_class": "BATTLE",
"character_reading": 0.5084,
"wall_fraction": "5/8",
"interior_dead_space_s": 0,
"edge_dead_space_s": 0
},
{
"rank": 10,
"track_id": "BENCH_R1_ELEVENLABS_EDIT_V2_3",
"cue_class": "EXPLORATION",
"character_reading": 0.5062,
"wall_fraction": "8/8",
"interior_dead_space_s": 0,
"edge_dead_space_s": 0
},
{
"rank": 11,
"track_id": "BENCH_R1_ELEVENLABS_TP_E1_v5_1",
"cue_class": "EXPLORATION",
"character_reading": 0.4437,
"wall_fraction": "5/9",
"interior_dead_space_s": 0,
"edge_dead_space_s": 20.1
},
{
"rank": 12,
"track_id": "BENCH_R1_ELEVENLABS_TP_E1_v5_2",
"cue_class": "EXPLORATION",
"character_reading": 0.4437,
"wall_fraction": "5/9",
"interior_dead_space_s": 0,
"edge_dead_space_s": 20.1
},
{
"rank": 13,
"track_id": "BENCH_R1_ELEVENLABS_TP_S1_v1_1",
"cue_class": "SERENE",
"character_reading": 0.4353,
"wall_fraction": "6/9",
"interior_dead_space_s": 0,
"edge_dead_space_s": 0
},
{
"rank": 14,
"track_id": "BENCH_R1_INHOUSE_BASELINE_R4",
"cue_class": "EXPLORATION",
"character_reading": 0.4313,
"wall_fraction": "6/9",
"interior_dead_space_s": 0,
"edge_dead_space_s": 0
},
{
"rank": 15,
"track_id": "BENCH_R1_ELEVENLABS_EDIT_T2_MELODY_1",
"cue_class": "EXPLORATION",
"character_reading": 0.4167,
"wall_fraction": "7/9",
"interior_dead_space_s": 0,
"edge_dead_space_s": 0
},
{
"rank": 16,
"track_id": "BENCH_R1_ELEVENLABS_EDIT_V2_4",
"cue_class": "EXPLORATION",
"character_reading": 0.36,
"wall_fraction": "7/9",
"interior_dead_space_s": 0,
"edge_dead_space_s": 0
},
{
"rank": 17,
"track_id": "BENCH_R1_ELEVENLABS_TP_B1_v1_2",
"cue_class": "BATTLE",
"character_reading": 0.2851,
"wall_fraction": "4/7",
"interior_dead_space_s": 0,
"edge_dead_space_s": 0
},
{
"rank": 18,
"track_id": "BENCH_R1_ELEVENLABS_TP_E1_v4_2",
"cue_class": "EXPLORATION",
"character_reading": 0.2781,
"wall_fraction": "6/8",
"interior_dead_space_s": 0,
"edge_dead_space_s": 0
},
{
"rank": 19,
"track_id": "BENCH_R1_ELEVENLABS_TP_B1_v1_1",
"cue_class": "BATTLE",
"character_reading": 0.2343,
"wall_fraction": "4/7",
"interior_dead_space_s": 0,
"edge_dead_space_s": 0
}
]
}