music/benchmark/rereads/BENCH_R1_ELEVENLABS_TP_E1_v6_2.json
{
"schema": "benchmark-reread-row/1.0.0",
"what_this_is": "WO-12's reread of a BANKED row. The banked record is untouched and remains the record of what the wall said; this file is what the character axes say about the same numbers.",
"judge_version": "benchmark-judge/1.0.0",
"reread_version": "ear-axes/1.0.0",
"track_id": "BENCH_R1_ELEVENLABS_TP_E1_v6_2",
"cue_class": "EXPLORATION",
"sha256": "548ab468acbdb8d509c7037cac458a7d221372faac93e74cb78e67f037998286",
"banked_record": "C:\\dev\\humanity-forgotten\\build\\audio\\benchmark\\records\\BENCH_R1_ELEVENLABS_TP_E1_v6_2.json",
"audio_reextracted": false,
"read_from": "the banked judged record plus its cached formula card (raw flow curve, for dead space)",
"wall_verdict_unchanged": {
"cycle_law": false,
"layer_census": true,
"hook_presence": true,
"noise_structure": true,
"melodic_intelligence": false,
"dynamic_arc": false,
"summit_tests": true,
"melody_bands": true,
"groove_instrument": true
},
"wall_fraction_unchanged": "6/9",
"reading": {
"what_this_is": "WO-12's reread. The wall fraction above is UNCHANGED and still gates nothing; this block says which of its votes are scaffolding, which are self-declared unable to separate, and what the character axes read.",
"law_untouched": "FLOOR NEVER VERDICT. No block here promotes a track or claims quality.",
"axis_classes": {
"cross_track_distinctness": {
"class": "FLOOR",
"verdict": null,
"counted": false,
"why": "a generation-defect detector; bounds where the defect is not"
},
"cycle_law": {
"class": "FLOOR",
"verdict": false,
"counted": true,
"why": "a generation-defect detector; bounds where the defect is not"
},
"dynamic_arc": {
"class": "FLOOR",
"verdict": false,
"counted": true,
"why": "a generation-defect detector; bounds where the defect is not"
},
"groove_instrument": {
"class": "FLOOR",
"verdict": true,
"counted": true,
"why": "a generation-defect detector; bounds where the defect is not"
},
"hook_presence": {
"class": "DEGENERATE",
"verdict": true,
"counted": false,
"why": "instr_hook_presence.py:200-210 -- the module declares its own floor DEGENERATE and says passes_floor should not be believed"
},
"layer_census": {
"class": "DEGENERATE",
"verdict": true,
"counted": false,
"why": "floor_instruments.py:248 -- its estimator saturates near 8 streams where a real cue runs 24 to 40 parts, so it cannot adjudicate the layer clause"
},
"melodic_intelligence": {
"class": "FLOOR",
"verdict": false,
"counted": true,
"why": "a generation-defect detector; bounds where the defect is not"
},
"melody_bands": {
"class": "FLOOR",
"verdict": true,
"counted": true,
"why": "a generation-defect detector; bounds where the defect is not"
},
"noise_structure": {
"class": "DEGENERATE",
"verdict": true,
"counted": false,
"why": "floor_instruments.py:246-247 -- fires on 0 of 18 across both tiers with nothing clearing the multiplicity bar"
},
"summit_tests": {
"class": "DEGENERATE",
"verdict": true,
"counted": false,
"why": "floor_instruments.py:124-128 -- its four continuous axes SEPARATE NOTHING on audio; it is a SCORE instrument that degrades honestly"
}
},
"floor_only_fraction": {
"passing": 2,
"of": 5,
"note": "the same arithmetic as wall_verdict with the self-declared-degenerate instruments removed. Still a FLOOR count, still not a verdict.",
"and_it_still_inverts": "MEASURED, and it is the finding: with all four degenerate instruments removed, the restored T2 take reads 0 of 5 and the take Josh rejected reads 3 of 5. Demoting instruments does NOT fix the inversion, because the defect is not a bad selection of voters -- it is that a COUNT OF BAND MEMBERSHIPS is the wrong object for a ruling that was a RANKING. That is why the reread adds a rank beside the count instead of repairing the count."
},
"degenerate_excluded": [
"hook_presence",
"layer_census",
"noise_structure",
"summit_tests"
],
"abstentions": [],
"character_axes": {
"structural_yield": {
"value": 1.0,
"term": "turn_pacing",
"slate_percentile": null,
"corpus_band": {
"n": 8,
"p10": 0.4157,
"p50": 0.8559,
"p90": 2.284,
"provisional": false,
"resolved_from": "EXPLORATION",
"borrowed": false,
"borrow_declared_but_unavailable": null,
"pooled": false,
"honest_tier": "CORPUS-DERIVED"
},
"inside_corpus_band": true,
"direction": "higher is more change per cut, both tails reported",
"honest_tier": "AUDIO-COMPLETE -- a GENERATION-DEFECT DETECTOR, not a taste oracle -- floor_instruments.py:41-45 measures it at AUC 0.423 against album siblings, the regime a slate of edits of one track sits in.",
"auc_over_the_graded_set": 0.9688,
"t2_pair_behaviour": "ORDERS IT CORRECTLY (0.8333 kept / 0.7333 rejected)",
"practice_cite": "docs/proposals/music/MUSIC_PRACTICE_GAP_AUDIT.md S3 (monotony is overcome only by variation); harness/music_gen/floor_instruments.py:28-56",
"slate_percentile_note": "undefined on a one-row slate -- run ear_axes --read"
},
"boundaries_per_min": {
"value": 2.5,
"term": null,
"slate_percentile": null,
"corpus_band": {
"n": 8,
"p10": 4.6279,
"p50": 5.8915,
"p90": 7.2478,
"provisional": false,
"resolved_from": "EXPLORATION",
"borrowed": false,
"borrow_declared_but_unavailable": null,
"pooled": false,
"honest_tier": "CORPUS-DERIVED"
},
"inside_corpus_band": false,
"direction": "REPORTED; the order assumed FEWER is better and the corpus says the opposite",
"honest_tier": "AUDIO-COMPLETE",
"auc_over_the_graded_set": 0.875,
"t2_pair_behaviour": "INVERTS IT (1.304 kept / 2.87 rejected) -- why it is not a term",
"practice_cite": "harness/music_gen/floor_instruments.py:36-38 (hits 5.09, turned-down 2.78)",
"slate_percentile_note": "undefined on a one-row slate -- run ear_axes --read"
},
"dynamic_range_db": {
"value": 21.48,
"term": "dynamic_breath",
"slate_percentile": null,
"corpus_band": {
"n": 8,
"p10": 6.99,
"p50": 10.11,
"p90": 28.979,
"provisional": false,
"resolved_from": "EXPLORATION",
"borrowed": false,
"borrow_declared_but_unavailable": null,
"pooled": false,
"honest_tier": "CORPUS-DERIVED"
},
"inside_corpus_band": true,
"direction": "higher is more breathing, both tails reported",
"honest_tier": "AUDIO-COMPLETE",
"auc_over_the_graded_set": 0.525,
"t2_pair_behaviour": "ORDERS IT CORRECTLY (23.24 kept / 6.65 rejected)",
"practice_cite": "docs/proposals/music/MUSIC_PRACTICE_GAP_AUDIT.md S9 (dynamics are composed, not a humanise knob); PIPE_AUDIO_MUSIC_2026-07-29.md §0",
"slate_percentile_note": "undefined on a one-row slate -- run ear_axes --read"
},
"loudness_range_lu": {
"value": 15.66,
"term": null,
"slate_percentile": null,
"corpus_band": null,
"inside_corpus_band": null,
"direction": "REFUSED as deciding -- measured INVERTED on the graded set",
"honest_tier": "AUDIO-COMPLETE, INFORMATIONAL",
"auc_over_the_graded_set": 0.3,
"t2_pair_behaviour": "orders it correctly (4.37 / 2.99) and inverts five other rulings",
"practice_cite": "harness/music_gen/mix_policy.py:159-168; the exclusion is asserted by benchmark_judge control C8",
"slate_percentile_note": "undefined on a one-row slate -- run ear_axes --read"
},
"dev_ops_per_min": {
"value": 0.0,
"term": "motivic_dev",
"slate_percentile": null,
"corpus_band": null,
"inside_corpus_band": null,
"direction": "higher is more development",
"honest_tier": "AUDIO-ESTIMATE -- runs on the extracted predominant line",
"auc_over_the_graded_set": 0.625,
"t2_pair_behaviour": "ORDERS IT CORRECTLY (47 ops kept / 2 rejected)",
"practice_cite": "docs/proposals/music/MUSIC_PRACTICE_GAP_AUDIT.md S3",
"slate_percentile_note": "undefined on a one-row slate -- run ear_axes --read"
},
"dev_kinds": {
"value": 0.0,
"term": "motivic_dev",
"slate_percentile": null,
"corpus_band": null,
"inside_corpus_band": null,
"direction": "higher is more varied development",
"honest_tier": "AUDIO-ESTIMATE",
"auc_over_the_graded_set": 0.625,
"t2_pair_behaviour": "ORDERS IT CORRECTLY (4 kinds kept / 1 rejected)",
"practice_cite": "docs/proposals/music/MUSIC_PRACTICE_GAP_AUDIT.md S3",
"slate_percentile_note": "undefined on a one-row slate -- run ear_axes --read"
},
"counter_melody_presence": {
"value": 0.684,
"term": "voice_dialogue",
"slate_percentile": null,
"corpus_band": null,
"inside_corpus_band": null,
"direction": "higher is more second-voice presence",
"honest_tier": "AUDIO-ESTIMATE -- register-band proxy, NOT source separation",
"auc_over_the_graded_set": 0.6,
"t2_pair_behaviour": "ORDERS IT CORRECTLY (0.5509 / 0.4907)",
"practice_cite": "docs/proposals/music/MUSIC_PRACTICE_GAP_AUDIT.md S6",
"slate_percentile_note": "undefined on a one-row slate -- run ear_axes --read"
},
"orchestrational_dialogue": {
"value": 0.5523,
"term": "voice_dialogue",
"slate_percentile": null,
"corpus_band": null,
"inside_corpus_band": null,
"direction": "higher is more trading",
"honest_tier": "AUDIO-ESTIMATE -- register-band proxy",
"auc_over_the_graded_set": 0.575,
"t2_pair_behaviour": "INVERTS IT (0.4554 / 0.6349) -- carried anyway, because the term is theory-led",
"practice_cite": "docs/proposals/music/MUSIC_PRACTICE_GAP_AUDIT.md S6; benchmark_judge.UNMEASURED_BY_ANY_INSTRUMENT names carrier migration unmeasured at INSTRUMENT grain, which this proxy does not claim to close",
"slate_percentile_note": "undefined on a one-row slate -- run ear_axes --read"
},
"syncopation_audio": {
"value": 0.0,
"term": null,
"slate_percentile": null,
"corpus_band": null,
"inside_corpus_band": null,
"direction": "REPORTED -- reads exactly 0.0 on 13 of 19 engine rows and its EXPLORATION p10 is 0.0, so below-band is unreachable; a zero with no positive control on real material is the a-search-that-cannot-match class",
"honest_tier": "AUDIO-COMPLETE by construction, UNCONTROLLED in practice",
"auc_over_the_graded_set": 0.525,
"t2_pair_behaviour": "TIE (0.0 / 0.0) -- it cannot see this pair at all",
"practice_cite": "docs/proposals/music/MUSIC_PRACTICE_GAP_AUDIT.md S7 (composite syncopation is the number the empirical literature ties to groove)",
"slate_percentile_note": "undefined on a one-row slate -- run ear_axes --read"
}
},
"character_rank_note": "The character READING is a rank within a slate and cannot be computed from one row. Run `ear_axes.py --read build/audio/benchmark/records` for the rank; the per-axis values above are absolute and stand alone, and every `slate_percentile` here is NULL rather than the 0.5 a pool of one returns.",
"refused_axes": {
"boundaries_per_min": "REPORTED; the order assumed FEWER is better and the corpus says the opposite",
"loudness_range_lu": "REFUSED as deciding -- measured INVERTED on the graded set",
"syncopation_audio": "REPORTED -- reads exactly 0.0 on 13 of 19 engine rows and its EXPLORATION p10 is 0.0, so below-band is unreachable; a zero with no positive control on real material is the a-search-that-cannot-match class"
}
},
"character_reading": 0.6195,
"leave_one_term_out": {
"without_turn_pacing": 0.6316,
"without_motivic_dev": 0.7822,
"without_dynamic_breath": 0.519,
"without_voice_dialogue": 0.5453
},
"dead_space": {
"available": true,
"reason": "",
"interior_spans": [
{
"from_s": 124.1,
"to_s": 144.9,
"duration_s": 20.8,
"mean_energy": 0.1258
}
],
"edge_spans": [],
"energy_floor": 0.2737,
"floor_class": "EXPLORATION",
"known_limitation": "KNOWN-WRONG AND INHERITED, NOT A CLEAN READING. `instr_dynamic_arc.sedation_spans` receives only the rendered curve, so it is PLAN-BLIND: a DECLARED silence window (PASS7_FLORES_FALLS carries one) and composed exploration silence are indistinguishable from a flatline once they run past the 12 s threshold, and the instrument will penalise exactly the design the exemplar lineage validates. Graded WRONG at docs/proposals/music/MUSIC_PRACTICE_GAP_AUDIT.md S13 (\"Composed silence is not sedation\"); the repair is specified and UNBUILT at docs/proposals/music/craft_research/GAME_SCORING_AND_ADAPTIVE_PRACTICE.md R8 (pass the plan, exclude declared silence, report the excluded spans separately so the exclusion cannot hide a real flatline) with the mechanism at its §12.4. Until R8 lands, a span here is a QUESTION for a composer -- 'was this silence composed?' -- and never a defect finding on its own.",
"borrowed_floor": false,
"interior_dead_s": 20.8,
"edge_dead_s": 0,
"analysed_s": 239.3,
"honest_tier": "AUDIO-COMPLETE (card flow curve); a FINDING, never a term",
"fires_on": "1 of 19 engine rows carries an INTERIOR span -- nothing here clears a multiplicity bar, and the low firing rate is the finding's own limit"
},
"slate_rank_of": 19,
"slate_rank": 5,
"_honest_tier": "MEASURED RANK, NEVER A QUALITY CLAIM. The reading orders a slate against four declared composition clauses. It gates nothing, promotes nothing, and every axis prints its own measured separation beside its value -- including the three that read at or below chance.",
"what_this_does_not_say": "Nothing here gates a track up or publishes a quality claim. The reading is a RANK WITHIN THE SLATE READ: adding a track changes every other track's percentile, so no value here is an absolute score and none may be quoted as one. THE POOL IS CLASS-BLIND. A class the corpus says should sit narrow (BATTLE dynamic range p90 11.256 against EXPLORATION's 28.979) reads low on dynamic_breath for behaving correctly; a mixed-class slate is not a like-for-like ranking."
}