BENCH_R1_ELEVENLABS_TP_S1_v1_2.json

music/benchmark/records/BENCH_R1_ELEVENLABS_TP_S1_v1_2.json

{
 "ok": true,
 "schema": "benchmark-slate-row/1.0.0",
 "judge_version": "benchmark-judge/1.0.0",
 "track_id": "BENCH_R1_ELEVENLABS_TP_S1_v1_2",
 "engine": "elevenlabs",
 "engine_label": "ElevenLabs Music v2 (Josh's Starter tier)",
 "prompt_id": "TP-S1-v1",
 "variant": "2",
 "cue_class": "SERENE",
 "class_note": "SERENE (our plans call it SANCTUARY) has NO corpus rows of its own, and the fallbacks do not agree -- which is why this note names all of them. Its melodic axes resolve to the ALL band (n=30, the whole corpus, battle cues included). Its loudness has TWO defensible borrows that differ by 2.4 LU: _default at -11.55 (n=30, used here) and MELANCHOLIC at -13.95 (n=4, what mix_policy.CLASS_MAP gives the SANCTUARY spelling). We use _default because Josh's serene class is peaceful AND UPLIFTING and a lament's level is the wrong reference for it -- but the disagreement is printed rather than resolved, because loudness is informational here anyway. Closing this hole means acquiring serene-class exemplars.",
 "audio": "D:\\audio\\ch02_soundtrack\\CH02_T6_HighlandHearth.wav",
 "sha256": "20f024f70ccb3f8445f6d6d626d6712fb60c235ac48e68a980ff844086d496ca",
 "bytes": 46096654,
 "source_codec": "pcm_s16le",
 "duration_s": 240.0,
 "judged_at": "2026-08-09T22:56:01+00:00",
 "licence": {
  "posture": "PAID-COMMERCIAL, BUT STUDIO GAMES ARE CARVED OUT BELOW ENTERPRISE",
  "shippable_today": false,
  "evidence": "docs/licence_records/elevenlabs/READ_RECORD_2026-08-09.md -- the Model-Specific Terms (Last Updated 26 May 2026) define Studio Games as commercialised video games on more than one platform, and elevenlabs.io/music-api states 'Film, TV, and large studio game rights require an Enterprise plan'. Starter is JUDGING-ONLY for this project",
  "next_read": "the Music Commercial Rights table itself is client-rendered and did not fetch; read it in the browser and pin the Starter row verbatim",
  "melody_input": "NO -- text prompt, ~30 s audio style reference, and a section-by-section composition plan. No MIDI, no melody file",
  "score_export": false,
  "score_export_note": "audio only; the NEEDS-SCORE instruments are unrecoverable for this engine and stay blind spots on every row"
 },
 "honest_tiers": {
  "structural_yield": "AUDIO-COMPLETE",
  "floor_battery": "AUDIO-COMPLETE for the arc/event/segmentation axes; AUDIO-ESTIMATE wherever an instrument needs the extracted line (melodic intelligence, summit tests)",
  "melody_bands": "AUDIO-ESTIMATE -- extraction from dense polyphony; harmonization_density is a LOWER BOUND. RECORDED NEGATIVE (control C11b): the AUDIO tier PASSES the round-4 cue Josh graded down in writing, while the SCORE tier read it LOW on harmonisation. A bands pass on an audio-only row is a FLOOR clearance and no part of a quality claim",
  "groove": "AUDIO-COMPLETE for the seven audio axes; its score axes are unavailable",
  "harmony_fit": "NEEDS-SCORE -- returns UNAVAILABLE on audio and is recorded as a blind spot",
  "loudness": "AUDIO-COMPLETE, and INFORMATIONAL ONLY -- see the header; it fails the corpus",
  "quotation_screen": "AUDIO-ESTIMATE -- runs on the extracted line; a partial seed set, so CLEAR is not a clean-room certificate",
  "cross_track_distinctness": "COHORT -- needs two or more slate tracks; a lone track cannot be distinct, only distinct FROM something",
  "arc_grammar": "SPLIT. `instr_dynamic_arc` (inside the floor battery) reads the build, the holds and the valleys, so movements 1-3's DYNAMICS are AUDIO-COMPLETE. But carrier migration -- the melody passed between instruments -- and whether the ending SETTLES are UNMEASURED BY ANY INSTRUMENT and are graded by ear. See UNMEASURED_BY_ANY_INSTRUMENT, printed on every row"
 },
 "measurements": {
  "structural_yield": {
   "available": true,
   "reason": "",
   "structural_yield": 0.8,
   "boundaries": 16,
   "drops": 20,
   "boundaries_per_min": 4.0,
   "drops_per_min": 5.0,
   "lane_adding_raises_per_min": 4.5,
   "reads_like": "real released music",
   "honest_label": "a GENERATION-DEFECT detector, not a taste oracle -- AUC 0.911 against the round Josh rejected, 0.423 against the corpus's own album siblings"
  },
  "floor_battery": {
   "instruments_loaded": [
    "cycle_law",
    "layer_census",
    "hook_presence",
    "noise_structure",
    "melodic_intelligence",
    "cross_track_distinctness",
    "dynamic_arc",
    "summit_tests"
   ],
   "instruments_failed": [],
   "verdicts": {
    "cycle_law": true,
    "layer_census": true,
    "hook_presence": true,
    "noise_structure": true,
    "melodic_intelligence": false,
    "cross_track_distinctness": null,
    "dynamic_arc": true,
    "summit_tests": true
   },
   "summary": {
    "instruments_run": 8,
    "instruments_that_could_decide": 7,
    "passing": 6,
    "unanimous": false,
    "what_this_does_not_say": "Nothing here is a judgement of quality and no listening test stands behind any of it. Three of the four instruments looked for Josh's defect in their own domain and did not find it: the cycle law passes 17 of the 18 tracks he rejected (within-album AUC 0.501), the noise detector fires on 0 of 18 across both tiers with nothing clearing the multiplicity bar, and the layer census saturates near 8 streams where a real cue runs 24 to 40 parts, so it cannot adjudicate the layer clause at all. Sensory roughness came back at chance (0.4963). Structural yield is the axis that separates, and it separates our generator from real music, not good music from filler."
   },
   "results": {
    "cycle_law": {
     "instrument": "cycle_law",
     "version": "v1",
     "available": true,
     "reason": "",
     "track_id": "BENCH_R1_ELEVENLABS_TP_S1_v1_2",
     "title": "Highland Hearth, serene v1 variation two",
     "period": {
      "period_s": 13.746213151927437,
      "strength": 0.4007538855075836,
      "best_lag_s": 13.746213151927437,
      "best_strength": 0.4007538855075836,
      "ambiguous": false,
      "descended": false,
      "subharmonic_candidate_s": null,
      "method": "audio_ssm_lag_profile",
      "window_s": [
       6.688,
       60.0
      ]
     },
     "period_agreement": {
      "card_section": 14.0485,
      "card_section_method": "card_section_repeat_lag",
      "card_complexity_autocorr": 13.3752
     },
     "escalation": {
      "first_half_power_per_cycle": 1.0287,
      "last_half_power_per_cycle": 1.2268,
      "escalation_ratio": 1.1927,
      "escalation_class": "rising"
     },
     "metrics": {
      "max_cycles_unchanged": 1.8209,
      "cycle_period_s": 13.7462,
      "n_cycles": 17.4594,
      "n_novelty_events": 43,
      "passes_floor": true,
      "passes_target": true,
      "cycle_period_bars": 8.222,
      "n_novelty_moments": 27,
      "novelty_moments_per_cycle": 1.5464,
      "longest_unchanged_span_s": 25.031,
      "longest_unchanged_start_s": 17.369,
      "longest_unchanged_end_s": 42.4,
      "longest_unchanged_where": "interior",
      "max_cycles_unchanged_interior": 1.8209,
      "max_cycles_unchanged_no_tempo_events": 4.25,
      "mean_cycles_between_novelty": 0.6235,
      "median_cycles_between_novelty": 0.5135,
      "law_binding": true,
      "period_ambiguous": false,
      "period_strength": 0.4008,
      "escalation_ratio": 1.1927,
      "structural_novelty_share": 0.2963,
      "max_cycles_unchanged_strict": 4.2521,
      "passes_floor_strict": true,
      "passes_target_strict": false,
      "longest_unchanged_span_strict_s": 58.45,
      "longest_unchanged_start_strict_s": 137.16,
      "longest_unchanged_end_strict_s": 195.61,
      "structural_yield": 0.8,
      "boundaries_per_min": 4.0,
      "drops_per_min": 5.0,
      "lane_adding_raises_per_min": 4.5,
      "n_beat_drop": 7,
      "n_lanes_added": 6,
      "n_lane_entry": 12,
      "n_new_section": 2,
      "n_novelty_peak": 2,
      "n_complexity_step": 6,
      "n_tempo_shift": 8
     },
     "series": {
      "novelty_timeline": [
       {
        "at_s": 0.046,
        "at_cycle": 0.003,
        "kinds": [
         "complexity_step",
         "lane_entry",
         "tempo_shift"
        ],
        "magnitude": 1.0,
        "n_events": 4
       },
       {
        "at_s": 2.577,
        "at_cycle": 0.187,
        "kinds": [
         "complexity_step",
         "lane_entry"
        ],
        "magnitude": 1.0,
        "n_events": 5
       },
       {
        "at_s": 10.728,
        "at_cycle": 0.78,
        "kinds": [
         "new_section"
        ],
        "magnitude": 1.0,
        "n_events": 1
       },
       {
        "at_s": 17.369,
        "at_cycle": 1.264,
        "kinds": [
         "novelty_peak"
        ],
        "magnitude": 0.6275,
        "n_events": 1
       },
       {
        "at_s": 42.4,
        "at_cycle": 3.084,
        "kinds": [
         "tempo_shift"
        ],
        "magnitude": 1.0,
        "n_events": 1
       },
       {
        "at_s": 54.846,
        "at_cycle": 3.99,
        "kinds": [
         "lane_entry"
        ],
        "magnitude": 1.0,
        "n_events": 1
       },
       {
        "at_s": 68.499,
        "at_cycle": 4.983,
        "kinds": [
         "lane_entry"
        ],
        "magnitude": 1.0,
        "n_events": 1
       },
       {
        "at_s": 86.22,
        "at_cycle": 6.272,
        "kinds": [
         "tempo_shift"
        ],
        "magnitude": 0.5598,
        "n_events": 1
       },
       {
        "at_s": 93.855,
        "at_cycle": 6.828,
        "kinds": [
         "lane_entry",
         "lanes_added"
        ],
        "magnitude": 1.0,
        "n_events": 2
       },
       {
        "at_s": 107.485,
        "at_cycle": 7.819,
        "kinds": [
         "lanes_added"
        ],
        "magnitude": 0.3875,
        "n_events": 1
       },
       {
        "at_s": 113.522,
        "at_cycle": 8.258,
        "kinds": [
         "beat_drop",
         "lanes_added"
        ],
        "magnitude": 0.405,
        "n_events": 2
       },
       {
        "at_s": 120.303,
        "at_cycle": 8.752,
        "kinds": [
         "beat_drop",
         "lanes_added"
        ],
        "magnitude": 0.85,
        "n_events": 2
       },
       {
        "at_s": 126.92,
        "at_cycle": 9.233,
        "kinds": [
         "beat_drop"
        ],
        "magnitude": 0.41,
        "n_events": 1
       },
       {
        "at_s": 134.629,
        "at_cycle": 9.794,
        "kinds": [
         "lane_entry"
        ],
        "magnitude": 1.0,
        "n_events": 1
       },
       {
        "at_s": 137.16,
        "at_cycle": 9.978,
        "kinds": [
         "lane_entry"
        ],
        "magnitude": 1.0,
        "n_events": 1
       },
       {
        "at_s": 139.95,
        "at_cycle": 10.181,
        "kinds": [
         "tempo_shift"
        ],
        "magnitude": 0.7097,
        "n_events": 1
       },
       {
        "at_s": 154.6,
        "at_cycle": 11.247,
        "kinds": [
         "tempo_shift"
        ],
        "magnitude": 0.5647,
        "n_events": 1
       },
       {
        "at_s": 161.52,
        "at_cycle": 11.75,
        "kinds": [
         "tempo_shift"
        ],
        "magnitude": 0.4218,
        "n_events": 1
       },
       {
        "at_s": 179.03,
        "at_cycle": 13.024,
        "kinds": [
         "tempo_shift"
        ],
        "magnitude": 0.4745,
        "n_events": 1
       },
       {
        "at_s": 195.582,
        "at_cycle": 14.228,
        "kinds": [
         "beat_drop",
         "complexity_step"
        ],
        "magnitude": 0.41,
        "n_events": 2
       },
       {
        "at_s": 206.82,
        "at_cycle": 15.046,
        "kinds": [
         "lanes_added"
        ],
        "magnitude": 0.4,
        "n_events": 1
       },
       {
        "at_s": 214.018,
        "at_cycle": 15.569,
        "kinds": [
         "lanes_added"
        ],
        "magnitude": 0.39,
        "n_events": 1
       },
       {
        "at_s": 219.02,
        "at_cycle": 15.933,
        "kinds": [
         "complexity_step",
         "tempo_shift"
        ],
        "magnitude": 0.8182,
        "n_events": 3
       },
       {
        "at_s": 226.673,
        "at_cycle": 16.49,
        "kinds": [
         "lane_entry"
        ],
        "magnitude": 1.0,
        "n_events": 1
       },
       {
        "at_s": 229.878,
        "at_cycle": 16.723,
        "kinds": [
         "new_section",
         "novelty_peak"
        ],
        "magnitude": 1.0,
        "n_events": 2
       },
       {
        "at_s": 232.826,
        "at_cycle": 16.937,
        "kinds": [
         "beat_drop",
         "complexity_step"
        ],
        "magnitude": 0.742,
        "n_events": 3
       },
       {
        "at_s": 235.241,
        "at_cycle": 17.113,
        "kinds": [
         "beat_drop"
        ],
        "magnitude": 0.5192,
        "n_events": 1
       }
      ],
      "cycles_between_novelty": [
       0.0033,
       0.1841,
       0.593,
       0.4831,
       1.8209,
       0.9054,
       0.9932,
       1.2892,
       0.5554,
       0.9915,
       0.4392,
       0.4933,
       0.4814,
       0.5608,
       0.1841,
       0.203,
       1.0657,
       0.5034,
       1.2738,
       1.2041,
       0.8175,
       0.5236,
       0.3639,
       0.5567,
       0.2332,
       0.2145,
       0.1757,
       0.3462
      ],
      "unchanged_spans": [
       {
        "start_s": 0.0,
        "end_s": 0.046,
        "cycles": 0.0033,
        "where": "lead_in"
       },
       {
        "start_s": 0.046,
        "end_s": 2.577,
        "cycles": 0.1841,
        "where": "interior"
       },
       {
        "start_s": 2.577,
        "end_s": 10.728,
        "cycles": 0.593,
        "where": "interior"
       },
       {
        "start_s": 10.728,
        "end_s": 17.369,
        "cycles": 0.4831,
        "where": "interior"
       },
       {
        "start_s": 17.369,
        "end_s": 42.4,
        "cycles": 1.8209,
        "where": "interior"
       },
       {
        "start_s": 42.4,
        "end_s": 54.846,
        "cycles": 0.9054,
        "where": "interior"
       },
       {
        "start_s": 54.846,
        "end_s": 68.499,
        "cycles": 0.9932,
        "where": "interior"
       },
       {
        "start_s": 68.499,
        "end_s": 86.22,
        "cycles": 1.2892,
        "where": "interior"
       },
       {
        "start_s": 86.22,
        "end_s": 93.855,
        "cycles": 0.5554,
        "where": "interior"
       },
       {
        "start_s": 93.855,
        "end_s": 107.485,
        "cycles": 0.9915,
        "where": "interior"
       },
       {
        "start_s": 107.485,
        "end_s": 113.522,
        "cycles": 0.4392,
        "where": "interior"
       },
       {
        "start_s": 113.522,
        "end_s": 120.303,
        "cycles": 0.4933,
        "where": "interior"
       },
       {
        "start_s": 120.303,
        "end_s": 126.92,
        "cycles": 0.4814,
        "where": "interior"
       },
       {
        "start_s": 126.92,
        "end_s": 134.629,
        "cycles": 0.5608,
        "where": "interior"
       },
       {
        "start_s": 134.629,
        "end_s": 137.16,
        "cycles": 0.1841,
        "where": "interior"
       },
       {
        "start_s": 137.16,
        "end_s": 139.95,
        "cycles": 0.203,
        "where": "interior"
       },
       {
        "start_s": 139.95,
        "end_s": 154.6,
        "cycles": 1.0657,
        "where": "interior"
       },
       {
        "start_s": 154.6,
        "end_s": 161.52,
        "cycles": 0.5034,
        "where": "interior"
       },
       {
        "start_s": 161.52,
        "end_s": 179.03,
        "cycles": 1.2738,
        "where": "interior"
       },
       {
        "start_s": 179.03,
        "end_s": 195.582,
        "cycles": 1.2041,
        "where": "interior"
       },
       {
        "start_s": 195.582,
        "end_s": 206.82,
        "cycles": 0.8175,
        "where": "interior"
       },
       {
        "start_s": 206.82,
        "end_s": 214.018,
        "cycles": 0.5236,
        "where": "interior"
       },
       {
        "start_s": 214.018,
        "end_s": 219.02,
        "cycles": 0.3639,
        "where": "interior"
       },
       {
        "start_s": 219.02,
        "end_s": 226.673,
        "cycles": 0.5567,
        "where": "interior"
       },
       {
        "start_s": 226.673,
        "end_s": 229.878,
        "cycles": 0.2332,
        "where": "interior"
       },
       {
        "start_s": 229.878,
        "end_s": 232.826,
        "cycles": 0.2145,
        "where": "interior"
       },
       {
        "start_s": 232.826,
        "end_s": 235.241,
        "cycles": 0.1757,
        "where": "interior"
       },
       {
        "start_s": 235.241,
        "end_s": 240.0,
        "cycles": 0.3462,
        "where": "run_out"
       }
      ]
     },
     "verdict": {
      "passes": true,
      "law": "No repeated cycle of a track runs more than five cycles without a novelty event -- a new instrument, a catch, a new melody or a beat drop (Josh, 2026-08-07; the enhanced target is three).",
      "evidence": [
       "cycle period 13.75 s (8.222 bars) by audio_ssm_lag_profile; track is 17.5 cycles long",
       "lag-profile peak at 13.75 s; no subharmonic descent was needed",
       "43 novelty events collapse to 27 moments (beat_drop 7, complexity_step 6, lane_entry 12, lanes_added 6, new_section 2, novelty_peak 2, tempo_shift 8)",
       "worst unchanged span 25.0 s = 1.82 cycles, 17-42 s (interior)",
       "without tempo events the worst span reads 4.25 cycles",
       "STRICT reading, counting only events that ADD (a band arriving, a raise adding lanes, a structural change) and never a drop: worst span 4.25 cycles",
       "structural yield 0.80 (4.00 boundaries/min against 5.00 drops/min) -- a generation-defect axis, not a quality one",
       "novelty power per cycle 1.0287 in the first half against 1.2268 in the second (rising)"
      ]
     }
    },
    "layer_census": {
     "instrument": "layer_census",
     "version": "v1",
     "available": true,
     "reason": "",
     "metrics": {
      "n_bands_active": 9,
      "band_peak_simultaneity": 9.0,
      "band_mean_simultaneity": 6.577,
      "band_headroom": 2.423,
      "band_entrance_spread": 0.1474,
      "n_band_entrances": 12,
      "n_band_subtractions": 13,
      "band_peak_position": 0.2299,
      "band_entrance_front_load": 0.8889,
      "band_active_fraction_mean": 0.7307,
      "est_layers_max": 8.0,
      "est_layers_mean": 4.8154,
      "est_layers_median": 5.0,
      "est_layers_p90": 6.0,
      "entrance_spread": 0.8912,
      "n_entrances": 26,
      "n_subtractions": 21,
      "n_deep_subtractions": 10,
      "subtraction_depth_mean": 1.8095238095238095,
      "layer_peak_position": 0.2216,
      "n_texture_plateaus": 19,
      "time_to_first_full_texture_s": 53.174,
      "time_to_first_full_texture_frac": 0.2216,
      "entrance_front_load": 0.2308,
      "late_entrance_frac": 0.4615,
      "passes_floor": 1,
      "passes_target": 0
     },
     "series": {
      "band_entry_positions": [
       0.0002,
       0.0075,
       0.0107,
       0.0107,
       0.0144,
       0.015,
       0.0173,
       0.0337,
       0.2285
      ],
      "band_exit_positions": [
       0.8146,
       0.9259,
       0.9579,
       0.9682,
       0.9707,
       0.9715,
       0.9722,
       0.9748,
       0.9754
      ],
      "layer_count_over_time": [
       0.0,
       0.0,
       1.0,
       1.0,
       1.0,
       1.0,
       1.0,
       3.0,
       4.0,
       4.0,
       5.0,
       4.0,
       4.0,
       3.0,
       3.0,
       4.0,
       4.0,
       4.0,
       5.0,
       5.0,
       4.0,
       4.0,
       4.0,
       5.0,
       5.0,
       5.0,
       5.0,
       6.0,
       7.0,
       6.0,
       4.0,
       3.0,
       3.0,
       4.0,
       3.0,
       3.0,
       5.0,
       5.0,
       3.0,
       3.0,
       5.0,
       5.0,
       5.0,
       5.0,
       5.0,
       5.0,
       5.0,
       5.0,
       5.0,
       5.0,
       5.0,
       5.0,
       6.0,
       6.0,
       5.0,
       3.0,
       3.0,
       3.0,
       4.0,
       4.0,
       5.0,
       4.0,
       3.0,
       3.0,
       5.0,
       5.0,
       5.0,
       5.0,
       4.0,
       4.0,
       4.0,
       5.0,
       5.0,
       5.0,
       5.0,
       5.0,
       6.0,
       7.0,
       7.0,
       7.0,
       7.0,
       4.0,
       5.0,
       4.0,
       4.0,
       4.0,
       4.0,
       5.0,
       5.0,
       6.0,
       7.0,
       6.0,
       5.0,
       5.0,
       6.0,
       7.0,
       8.0,
       7.0,
       6.0,
       6.0,
       6.0,
       6.0,
       5.0,
       5.0,
       5.0,
       5.0,
       4.0,
       4.0,
       5.0,
       6.0,
       5.0,
       5.0,
       5.0,
       5.0,
       5.0,
       5.0,
       5.0,
       6.0,
       5.0,
       6.0,
       5.0,
       5.0,
       6.0,
       6.0,
       5.0,
       6.0,
       7.0,
       6.0,
       5.0,
       5.0,
       5.0,
       4.0,
       5.0,
       5.0,
       5.0,
       5.0,
       5.0,
       4.0,
       4.0,
       6.0,
       6.0,
       6.0,
       5.0,
       4.0,
       5.0,
       5.0,
       6.0,
       6.0,
       5.0,
       5.0,
       4.0,
       4.0,
       5.0,
       5.0,
       5.0,
       4.0,
       4.0,
       4.0,
       4.0,
       5.0,
       5.0,
       5.0,
       5.0,
       5.0,
       4.0,
       4.0,
       6.0,
       6.0,
       6.0,
       5.0,
       5.0,
       5.0,
       5.0,
       4.0,
       5.0,
       5.0,
       5.0,
       4.0,
       4.0,
       4.0,
       4.0,
       4.0,
       4.0,
       4.0,
       4.0,
       4.0,
       4.0,
       5.0,
       5.0,
       5.0,
       4.0,
       5.0,
       6.0,
       6.0,
       5.0,
       4.0,
       5.0,
       5.0,
       4.0,
       4.0,
       5.0,
       5.0,
       5.0,
       6.0,
       6.0,
       6.0,
       4.0,
       4.0,
       4.0,
       5.0,
       5.0,
       4.0,
       6.0,
       6.0,
       5.0,
       6.0,
       5.0,
       5.0,
       6.0,
       4.0,
       5.0,
       6.0,
       5.0,
       5.0,
       5.0,
       5.0,
       5.0,
       6.0,
       6.0,
       6.0,
       5.0,
       5.0,
       4.0,
       4.0,
       5.0,
       4.0,
       4.0,
       5.0,
       5.0,
       5.0,
       5.0,
       5.0,
       5.0,
       6.0,
       6.0,
       6.0,
       6.0,
       5.0,
       6.0,
       6.0,
       6.0,
       5.0,
       5.0,
       5.0,
       4.0,
       5.0,
       5.0,
       4.0,
       5.0,
       5.0,
       5.0,
       5.0,
       4.0,
       5.0,
       7.0,
       6.0,
       5.0,
       6.0,
       4.0,
       4.0,
       5.0,
       5.0,
       5.0,
       5.0,
       5.0,
       5.0,
       5.0,
       5.0,
       5.0,
       5.0,
       5.0,
       5.0,
       4.0,
       4.0,
       4.0,
       5.0,
       5.0,
       5.0,
       5.0,
       5.0,
       5.0,
       4.0,
       5.0,
       5.0,
       5.0,
       6.0,
       6.0,
       6.0,
       6.0,
       5.0,
       5.0,
       6.0,
       5.0,
       4.0,
       5.0,
       5.0,
       4.0,
       5.0,
       5.0,
       4.0,
       5.0,
       6.0,
       6.0,
       6.0,
       6.0,
       5.0,
       5.0,
       6.0,
       6.0,
       6.0,
       6.0,
       5.0,
       6.0,
       6.0,
       6.0,
       5.0,
       5.0,
       4.0,
       4.0,
       4.0,
       5.0,
       5.0,
       5.0,
       4.0,
       4.0,
       5.0,
       4.0,
       5.0,
       6.0,
       6.0,
       5.0,
       5.0,
       5.0,
       5.0,
       6.0,
       5.0,
       5.0,
       5.0,
       5.0,
       6.0,
       6.0,
       6.0,
       6.0,
       6.0,
       6.0,
       7.0,
       6.0,
       6.0,
       7.0,
       5.0,
       4.0,
       4.0,
       4.0,
       4.0,
       4.0,
       5.0,
       6.0,
       7.0,
       5.0,
       6.0,
       6.0,
       5.0,
       5.0,
       4.0,
       4.0,
       5.0,
       5.0,
       4.0,
       4.0,
       4.0,
       5.0,
       6.0,
       6.0,
       6.0,
       5.0,
       4.0,
       5.0,
       5.0,
       3.0,
       3.0,
       3.0,
       4.0,
       4.0,
       6.0,
       5.0,
       4.0,
       4.0,
       5.0,
       5.0,
       6.0,
       6.0,
       7.0,
       6.0,
       6.0,
       6.0,
       6.0,
       5.0,
       4.0,
       4.0,
       4.0,
       4.0,
       4.0,
       5.0,
       3.0,
       3.0,
       3.0,
       3.0,
       3.0,
       4.0,
       4.0,
       5.0,
       6.0,
       7.0,
       7.0,
       6.0,
       0.0,
       0.0,
       0.0,
       0.0,
       0.0,
       0.0
      ],
      "layer_count_times_s": [
       0.0,
       0.56,
       1.11,
       1.67,
       2.23,
       2.79,
       3.34,
       3.9,
       4.46,
       5.02,
       5.57,
       6.13,
       6.69,
       7.24,
       7.8,
       8.36,
       8.92,
       9.47,
       10.03,
       10.59,
       11.15,
       11.7,
       12.26,
       12.82,
       13.37,
       13.93,
       14.49,
       15.05,
       15.6,
       16.16,
       16.72,
       17.28,
       17.83,
       18.39,
       18.95,
       19.5,
       20.06,
       20.62,
       21.18,
       21.73,
       22.29,
       22.85,
       23.41,
       23.96,
       24.52,
       25.08,
       25.63,
       26.19,
       26.75,
       27.31,
       27.86,
       28.42,
       28.98,
       29.54,
       30.09,
       30.65,
       31.21,
       31.76,
       32.32,
       32.88,
       33.44,
       33.99,
       34.55,
       35.11,
       35.67,
       36.22,
       36.78,
       37.34,
       37.89,
       38.45,
       39.01,
       39.57,
       40.12,
       40.68,
       41.24,
       41.8,
       42.35,
       42.91,
       43.47,
       44.03,
       44.58,
       45.14,
       45.7,
       46.25,
       46.81,
       47.37,
       47.93,
       48.48,
       49.04,
       49.6,
       50.16,
       50.71,
       51.27,
       51.83,
       52.38,
       52.94,
       53.5,
       54.06,
       54.61,
       55.17,
       55.73,
       56.29,
       56.84,
       57.4,
       57.96,
       58.51,
       59.07,
       59.63,
       60.19,
       60.74,
       61.3,
       61.86,
       62.42,
       62.97,
       63.53,
       64.09,
       64.64,
       65.2,
       65.76,
       66.32,
       66.87,
       67.43,
       67.99,
       68.55,
       69.1,
       69.66,
       70.22,
       70.77,
       71.33,
       71.89,
       72.45,
       73.0,
       73.56,
       74.12,
       74.68,
       75.23,
       75.79,
       76.35,
       76.9,
       77.46,
       78.02,
       78.58,
       79.13,
       79.69,
       80.25,
       80.81,
       81.36,
       81.92,
       82.48,
       83.03,
       83.59,
       84.15,
       84.71,
       85.26,
       85.82,
       86.38,
       86.94,
       87.49,
       88.05,
       88.61,
       89.16,
       89.72,
       90.28,
       90.84,
       91.39,
       91.95,
       92.51,
       93.07,
       93.62,
       94.18,
       94.74,
       95.29,
       95.85,
       96.41,
       96.97,
       97.52,
       98.08,
       98.64,
       99.2,
       99.75,
       100.31,
       100.87,
       101.42,
       101.98,
       102.54,
       103.1,
       103.65,
       104.21,
       104.77,
       105.33,
       105.88,
       106.44,
       107.0,
       107.55,
       108.11,
       108.67,
       109.23,
       109.78,
       110.34,
       110.9,
       111.46,
       112.01,
       112.57,
       113.13,
       113.68,
       114.24,
       114.8,
       115.36,
       115.91,
       116.47,
       117.03,
       117.59,
       118.14,
       118.7,
       119.26,
       119.81,
       120.37,
       120.93,
       121.49,
       122.04,
       122.6,
       123.16,
       123.72,
       124.27,
       124.83,
       125.39,
       125.95,
       126.5,
       127.06,
       127.62,
       128.17,
       128.73,
       129.29,
       129.85,
       130.4,
       130.96,
       131.52,
       132.08,
       132.63,
       133.19,
       133.75,
       134.3,
       134.86,
       135.42,
       135.98,
       136.53,
       137.09,
       137.65,
       138.21,
       138.76,
       139.32,
       139.88,
       140.43,
       140.99,
       141.55,
       142.11,
       142.66,
       143.22,
       143.78,
       144.34,
       144.89,
       145.45,
       146.01,
       146.56,
       147.12,
       147.68,
       148.24,
       148.79,
       149.35,
       149.91,
       150.47,
       151.02,
       151.58,
       152.14,
       152.69,
       153.25,
       153.81,
       154.37,
       154.92,
       155.48,
       156.04,
       156.6,
       157.15,
       157.71,
       158.27,
       158.82,
       159.38,
       159.94,
       160.5,
       161.05,
       161.61,
       162.17,
       162.73,
       163.28,
       163.84,
       164.4,
       164.95,
       165.51,
       166.07,
       166.63,
       167.18,
       167.74,
       168.3,
       168.86,
       169.41,
       169.97,
       170.53,
       171.08,
       171.64,
       172.2,
       172.76,
       173.31,
       173.87,
       174.43,
       174.99,
       175.54,
       176.1,
       176.66,
       177.21,
       177.77,
       178.33,
       178.89,
       179.44,
       180.0,
       180.56,
       181.12,
       181.67,
       182.23,
       182.79,
       183.34,
       183.9,
       184.46,
       185.02,
       185.57,
       186.13,
       186.69,
       187.25,
       187.8,
       188.36,
       188.92,
       189.47,
       190.03,
       190.59,
       191.15,
       191.7,
       192.26,
       192.82,
       193.38,
       193.93,
       194.49,
       195.05,
       195.6,
       196.16,
       196.72,
       197.28,
       197.83,
       198.39,
       198.95,
       199.51,
       200.06,
       200.62,
       201.18,
       201.73,
       202.29,
       202.85,
       203.41,
       203.96,
       204.52,
       205.08,
       205.64,
       206.19,
       206.75,
       207.31,
       207.87,
       208.42,
       208.98,
       209.54,
       210.09,
       210.65,
       211.21,
       211.77,
       212.32,
       212.88,
       213.44,
       214.0,
       214.55,
       215.11,
       215.67,
       216.22,
       216.78,
       217.34,
       217.9,
       218.45,
       219.01,
       219.57,
       220.13,
       220.68,
       221.24,
       221.8,
       222.35,
       222.91,
       223.47,
       224.03,
       224.58,
       225.14,
       225.7,
       226.26,
       226.81,
       227.37,
       227.93,
       228.48,
       229.04,
       229.6,
       230.16,
       230.71,
       231.27,
       231.83,
       232.39,
       232.94,
       233.5,
       234.06,
       234.61,
       235.17,
       235.73,
       236.29,
       236.84,
       237.4,
       237.96,
       238.52,
       239.07,
       239.63
      ],
      "entrance_schedule": [
       {
        "at_s": 6.827,
        "position": 0.0284,
        "delta": 2.0
       },
       {
        "at_s": 8.173,
        "position": 0.0341,
        "delta": 1.0
       },
       {
        "at_s": 12.771,
        "position": 0.0532,
        "delta": 1.0
       },
       {
        "at_s": 35.573,
        "position": 0.1482,
        "delta": 2.0
       },
       {
        "at_s": 39.056,
        "position": 0.1627,
        "delta": 1.0
       },
       {
        "at_s": 42.91,
        "position": 0.1788,
        "delta": 2.0
       },
       {
        "at_s": 48.019,
        "position": 0.2001,
        "delta": 1.0
       },
       {
        "at_s": 54.428,
        "position": 0.2268,
        "delta": 1.0
       },
       {
        "at_s": 81.27,
        "position": 0.3386,
        "delta": 1.0
       },
       {
        "at_s": 88.189,
        "position": 0.3675,
        "delta": 1.0
       },
       {
        "at_s": 92.09,
        "position": 0.3837,
        "delta": 1.0
       },
       {
        "at_s": 106.672,
        "position": 0.4445,
        "delta": 2.0
       },
       {
        "at_s": 111.27,
        "position": 0.4636,
        "delta": 1.0
       },
       {
        "at_s": 112.942,
        "position": 0.4706,
        "delta": 1.0
       },
       {
        "at_s": 126.084,
        "position": 0.5254,
        "delta": 2.0
       },
       {
        "at_s": 131.982,
        "position": 0.5499,
        "delta": 1.0
       },
       {
        "at_s": 137.88,
        "position": 0.5745,
        "delta": 1.0
       },
       {
        "at_s": 150.465,
        "position": 0.6269,
        "delta": 1.0
       },
       {
        "at_s": 172.942,
        "position": 0.7206,
        "delta": 1.0
       },
       {
        "at_s": 183.856,
        "position": 0.7661,
        "delta": 1.0
       },
       {
        "at_s": 194.908,
        "position": 0.8121,
        "delta": 1.0
       },
       {
        "at_s": 205.404,
        "position": 0.8558,
        "delta": 2.0
       },
       {
        "at_s": 212.184,
        "position": 0.8841,
        "delta": 2.0
       },
       {
        "at_s": 220.868,
        "position": 0.9203,
        "delta": 2.0
       },
       {
        "at_s": 224.026,
        "position": 0.9334,
        "delta": 1.0
       },
       {
        "at_s": 234.707,
        "position": 0.9779,
        "delta": 4.0
       }
      ],
      "exit_schedule": [
       {
        "at_s": 30.604,
        "position": 0.1275,
        "delta": -2.0
       },
       {
        "at_s": 37.431,
        "position": 0.156,
        "delta": -1.0
       },
       {
        "at_s": 46.811,
        "position": 0.195,
        "delta": -3.0
       },
       {
        "at_s": 57.632,
        "position": 0.2401,
        "delta": -1.0
       },
       {
        "at_s": 84.474,
        "position": 0.352,
        "delta": -1.0
       },
       {
        "at_s": 86.378,
        "position": 0.3599,
        "delta": -1.0
       },
       {
        "at_s": 94.087,
        "position": 0.392,
        "delta": -1.0
       },
       {
        "at_s": 98.592,
        "position": 0.4108,
        "delta": -1.0
       },
       {
        "at_s": 109.83,
        "position": 0.4576,
        "delta": -2.0
       },
       {
        "at_s": 114.753,
        "position": 0.4781,
        "delta": -2.0
       },
       {
        "at_s": 130.589,
        "position": 0.5441,
        "delta": -2.0
       },
       {
        "at_s": 139.459,
        "position": 0.5811,
        "delta": -1.0
       },
       {
        "at_s": 149.258,
        "position": 0.6219,
        "delta": -1.0
       },
       {
        "at_s": 182.184,
        "position": 0.7591,
        "delta": -2.0
       },
       {
        "at_s": 200.388,
        "position": 0.835,
        "delta": -2.0
       },
       {
        "at_s": 208.469,
        "position": 0.8686,
        "delta": -1.0
       },
       {
        "at_s": 209.676,
        "position": 0.8737,
        "delta": -1.0
       },
       {
        "at_s": 216.131,
        "position": 0.9005,
        "delta": -3.0
       },
       {
        "at_s": 226.116,
        "position": 0.9421,
        "delta": -2.0
       },
       {
        "at_s": 229.97,
        "position": 0.9582,
        "delta": -1.0
       },
       {
        "at_s": 236.565,
        "position": 0.9857,
        "delta": -7.0
       }
      ],
      "plateaus": [
       [
        0.0,
        6.827,
        1.0
       ],
       [
        6.827,
        8.173,
        3.0
       ],
       [
        8.173,
        12.771,
        4.0
       ],
       [
        12.771,
        30.604,
        5.0
       ],
       [
        30.604,
        35.573,
        3.0
       ],
       [
        35.573,
        37.431,
        5.0
       ],
       [
        37.431,
        39.056,
        4.0
       ],
       [
        39.056,
        42.91,
        5.0
       ],
       [
        42.91,
        46.811,
        7.0
       ],
       [
        46.811,
        48.019,
        4.0
       ],
       [
        48.019,
        54.428,
        5.0
       ],
       [
        54.428,
        57.632,
        6.0
       ],
       [
        57.632,
        81.27,
        5.0
       ],
       [
        81.27,
        84.474,
        6.0
       ],
       [
        84.474,
        86.378,
        5.0
       ],
       [
        86.378,
        88.189,
        4.0
       ],
       [
        88.189,
        92.09,
        5.0
       ],
       [
        92.09,
        94.087,
        6.0
       ],
       [
        94.087,
        98.592,
        5.0
       ],
       [
        98.592,
        106.672,
        4.0
       ],
       [
        106.672,
        109.83,
        6.0
       ],
       [
        109.83,
        111.27,
        4.0
       ],
       [
        111.27,
        112.942,
        5.0
       ],
       [
        112.942,
        114.753,
        6.0
       ],
       [
        114.753,
        126.084,
        4.0
       ],
       [
        126.084,
        130.589,
        6.0
       ],
       [
        130.589,
        131.982,
        4.0
       ],
       [
        131.982,
        137.88,
        5.0
       ],
       [
        137.88,
        139.459,
        6.0
       ],
       [
        139.459,
        149.258,
        5.0
       ],
       [
        149.258,
        150.465,
        4.0
       ],
       [
        150.465,
        172.942,
        5.0
       ],
       [
        172.942,
        182.184,
        6.0
       ],
       [
        182.184,
        183.856,
        4.0
       ],
       [
        183.856,
        194.908,
        5.0
       ],
       [
        194.908,
        200.388,
        6.0
       ],
       [
        200.388,
        205.404,
        4.0
       ],
       [
        205.404,
        208.469,
        6.0
       ],
       [
        208.469,
        209.676,
        5.0
       ],
       [
        209.676,
        212.184,
        4.0
       ],
       [
        212.184,
        216.131,
        6.0
       ],
       [
        216.131,
        220.868,
        3.0
       ],
       [
        220.868,
        224.026,
        5.0
       ],
       [
        224.026,
        226.116,
        6.0
       ],
       [
        226.116,
        229.97,
        4.0
       ],
       [
        229.97,
        234.707,
        3.0
       ],
       [
        234.707,
        236.565,
        7.0
       ],
       [
        236.565,
        240.001,
        0.0
       ]
      ]
     },
     "verdict": {
      "passes": true,
      "law": "A track runs many distinct layers and stages their entrances and exits across the whole cue rather than arriving as one undifferentiated wall.",
      "evidence": [
       "TIER 1 -- 9 of ten spectral occupancy bands carry content; peak band simultaneity 9.0. Bands are not instruments and this figure is not a layer count.",
       "TIER 2 -- spectral stream estimate, mean 4.82, peak 8. Measured accuracy +-1 over 1-8 concurrent sources on the synthetic ladder (MAE 0.29); it SATURATES near 8 and cannot count dozens.",
       "stream mean 4.82 against a corpus-derived floor of 4.74 and target 5.4264; entrance spread 0.891 against floor 0.640 and target 0.7923"
      ],
      "staging_tier": "spectral_stream_estimate"
     }
    },
    "hook_presence": {
     "instrument": "hook_presence",
     "version": "v1",
     "available": true,
     "reason": "",
     "metrics": {
      "hook_available": true,
      "time_to_hook_s": 2.589,
      "n_returns": 7,
      "transformation_share": 0.7143,
      "structural_transformation_share": 0.7143,
      "max_return_gap_s": 71.518,
      "hook_strength": 0.5586,
      "passes_floor": true,
      "passes_target": false,
      "total_length_s": 240.0,
      "hook_n_notes": 16,
      "hook_vocab_size": 6,
      "hook_range_semitones": 36.0,
      "hook_licensed_leap": 1.0,
      "card_recurrence_lag_s": 0.464,
      "card_self_similarity_lift": 0.1743,
      "hook_reproduces_known_signature": 0.0,
      "max_return_gap_frac": 0.298,
      "returns_per_min": 1.75,
      "mean_return_similarity": 0.6583,
      "transposed_share": 0.0,
      "timescaled_share": 0.7143,
      "distinct_transpositions": 1,
      "contour_return_rate": 9.0,
      "interval_return_rate": 0.0,
      "melodic_salience": 0.88,
      "audio_duration_s": 240.0
     },
     "series": {
      "match_curve_times_s": [
       0.0,
       0.56,
       1.11,
       1.67,
       2.23,
       2.79,
       3.34,
       3.9,
       4.46,
       5.02,
       5.57,
       6.13,
       6.69,
       7.24,
       7.8,
       8.36,
       8.92,
       9.47,
       10.03,
       10.59,
       11.15,
       11.7,
       12.26,
       12.82,
       13.37,
       13.93,
       14.49,
       15.05,
       15.6,
       16.16,
       16.72,
       17.28,
       17.83,
       18.39,
       18.95,
       19.5,
       20.06,
       20.62,
       21.18,
       21.73,
       22.29,
       22.85,
       23.41,
       23.96,
       24.52,
       25.08,
       25.63,
       26.19,
       26.75,
       27.31,
       27.86,
       28.42,
       28.98,
       29.54,
       30.09,
       30.65,
       31.21,
       31.76,
       32.32,
       32.88,
       33.44,
       33.99,
       34.55,
       35.11,
       35.67,
       36.22,
       36.78,
       37.34,
       37.89,
       38.45,
       39.01,
       39.57,
       40.12,
       40.68,
       41.24,
       41.8,
       42.35,
       42.91,
       43.47,
       44.03,
       44.58,
       45.14,
       45.7,
       46.25,
       46.81,
       47.37,
       47.93,
       48.48,
       49.04,
       49.6,
       50.16,
       50.71,
       51.27,
       51.83,
       52.38,
       52.94,
       53.5,
       54.06,
       54.61,
       55.17,
       55.73,
       56.29,
       56.84,
       57.4,
       57.96,
       58.51,
       59.07,
       59.63,
       60.19,
       60.74,
       61.3,
       61.86,
       62.42,
       62.97,
       63.53,
       64.09,
       64.64,
       65.2,
       65.76,
       66.32,
       66.87,
       67.43,
       67.99,
       68.55,
       69.1,
       69.66,
       70.22,
       70.77,
       71.33,
       71.89,
       72.45,
       73.0,
       73.56,
       74.12,
       74.68,
       75.23,
       75.79,
       76.35,
       76.9,
       77.46,
       78.02,
       78.58,
       79.13,
       79.69,
       80.25,
       80.81,
       81.36,
       81.92,
       82.48,
       83.03,
       83.59,
       84.15,
       84.71,
       85.26,
       85.82,
       86.38,
       86.94,
       87.49,
       88.05,
       88.61,
       89.16,
       89.72,
       90.28,
       90.84,
       91.39,
       91.95,
       92.51,
       93.07,
       93.62,
       94.18,
       94.74,
       95.29,
       95.85,
       96.41,
       96.97,
       97.52,
       98.08,
       98.64,
       99.2,
       99.75,
       100.31,
       100.87,
       101.42,
       101.98,
       102.54,
       103.1,
       103.65,
       104.21,
       104.77,
       105.33,
       105.88,
       106.44,
       107.0,
       107.55,
       108.11,
       108.67,
       109.23,
       109.78,
       110.34,
       110.9,
       111.46,
       112.01,
       112.57,
       113.13,
       113.68,
       114.24,
       114.8,
       115.36,
       115.91,
       116.47,
       117.03,
       117.59,
       118.14,
       118.7,
       119.26,
       119.81,
       120.37,
       120.93,
       121.49,
       122.04,
       122.6,
       123.16,
       123.72,
       124.27,
       124.83,
       125.39,
       125.95,
       126.5,
       127.06,
       127.62,
       128.17,
       128.73,
       129.29,
       129.85,
       130.4,
       130.96,
       131.52,
       132.08,
       132.63,
       133.19,
       133.75,
       134.3,
       134.86,
       135.42,
       135.98,
       136.53,
       137.09,
       137.65,
       138.21,
       138.76,
       139.32,
       139.88,
       140.43,
       140.99,
       141.55,
       142.11,
       142.66,
       143.22,
       143.78,
       144.34,
       144.89,
       145.45,
       146.01,
       146.56,
       147.12,
       147.68,
       148.24,
       148.79,
       149.35,
       149.91,
       150.47,
       151.02,
       151.58,
       152.14,
       152.69,
       153.25,
       153.81,
       154.37,
       154.92,
       155.48,
       156.04,
       156.6,
       157.15,
       157.71,
       158.27,
       158.82,
       159.38,
       159.94,
       160.5,
       161.05,
       161.61,
       162.17,
       162.73,
       163.28,
       163.84,
       164.4,
       164.95,
       165.51,
       166.07,
       166.63,
       167.18,
       167.74,
       168.3,
       168.86,
       169.41,
       169.97,
       170.53,
       171.08,
       171.64,
       172.2,
       172.76,
       173.31,
       173.87,
       174.43,
       174.99,
       175.54,
       176.1,
       176.66,
       177.21,
       177.77,
       178.33,
       178.89,
       179.44,
       180.0,
       180.56,
       181.12,
       181.67,
       182.23,
       182.79,
       183.34,
       183.9,
       184.46,
       185.02,
       185.57,
       186.13,
       186.69,
       187.25,
       187.8,
       188.36,
       188.92,
       189.47,
       190.03,
       190.59,
       191.15,
       191.7,
       192.26,
       192.82,
       193.38,
       193.93,
       194.49,
       195.05,
       195.6,
       196.16,
       196.72,
       197.28,
       197.83,
       198.39,
       198.95,
       199.51,
       200.06,
       200.62,
       201.18,
       201.73,
       202.29,
       202.85,
       203.41,
       203.96,
       204.52,
       205.08,
       205.64,
       206.19,
       206.75,
       207.31,
       207.87,
       208.42,
       208.98,
       209.54,
       210.09,
       210.65,
       211.21,
       211.77,
       212.32,
       212.88,
       213.44,
       214.0,
       214.55,
       215.11,
       215.67,
       216.22,
       216.78,
       217.34,
       217.9,
       218.45,
       219.01,
       219.57,
       220.13,
       220.68,
       221.24,
       221.8,
       222.35,
       222.91,
       223.47,
       224.03,
       224.58,
       225.14,
       225.7,
       226.26,
       226.81,
       227.37,
       227.93,
       228.48,
       229.04,
       229.6,
       230.16,
       230.71,
       231.27,
       231.83,
       232.39,
       232.94,
       233.5,
       234.06,
       234.61,
       235.17,
       235.73,
       236.29,
       236.84,
       237.4,
       237.96,
       238.52,
       239.07,
       239.63
      ],
      "match_curve": [
       0.4666,
       0.5286,
       0.6171,
       0.7056,
       0.8518,
       0.9652,
       0.7911,
       0.7129,
       0.6393,
       0.6352,
       0.4447,
       0.2235,
       -0.0388,
       0.0986,
       0.0896,
       0.0602,
       0.0974,
       0.1185,
       0.0939,
       0.1003,
       0.17,
       0.2428,
       0.2879,
       0.286,
       0.2819,
       0.3981,
       0.4119,
       0.4781,
       0.5347,
       0.722,
       0.7562,
       0.718,
       0.7062,
       0.6193,
       0.626,
       0.4392,
       0.1625,
       0.1465,
       0.1874,
       0.1252,
       0.0542,
       0.0291,
       0.089,
       0.0782,
       0.0838,
       0.1768,
       0.2607,
       0.2829,
       0.2783,
       0.3476,
       0.4179,
       0.4507,
       0.4766,
       0.5458,
       0.7742,
       0.7213,
       0.7312,
       0.6659,
       0.6414,
       0.4974,
       0.2503,
       0.0588,
       0.261,
       0.2749,
       0.1535,
       0.1048,
       0.1573,
       0.2661,
       0.3026,
       0.2803,
       0.1852,
       0.1759,
       0.2428,
       0.1981,
       0.2792,
       0.2858,
       0.3085,
       0.3072,
       0.3349,
       0.412,
       0.5064,
       0.4751,
       0.4645,
       0.3043,
       0.2535,
       0.148,
       0.16,
       0.0093,
       0.005,
       0.0413,
       0.0892,
       0.068,
       0.0764,
       0.1281,
       0.0852,
       0.0056,
       0.0026,
       -0.0054,
       0.0079,
       0.0286,
       0.0374,
       0.067,
       0.1001,
       0.1813,
       0.1826,
       0.1716,
       0.1419,
       0.1013,
       0.0848,
       0.0638,
       -0.0173,
       -0.123,
       -0.103,
       -0.0794,
       -0.1637,
       -0.1168,
       -0.1095,
       -0.086,
       -0.0254,
       0.0202,
       0.0391,
       0.0485,
       0.0408,
       0.0796,
       0.1165,
       0.1254,
       0.1487,
       0.1737,
       0.2406,
       0.1843,
       0.1807,
       0.1638,
       0.1295,
       0.0703,
       0.0431,
       -0.1017,
       -0.0654,
       -0.0592,
       -0.0496,
       -0.016,
       -0.0142,
       -0.049,
       -0.0022,
       0.0452,
       0.0821,
       0.1182,
       0.12,
       0.1319,
       0.1725,
       0.2511,
       0.327,
       0.36,
       0.3557,
       0.3718,
       0.4139,
       0.432,
       0.4181,
       0.4081,
       0.2228,
       0.1102,
       0.1689,
       0.1422,
       0.1806,
       0.1033,
       0.1371,
       0.1583,
       0.1496,
       0.1374,
       0.1379,
       0.1557,
       0.188,
       0.1822,
       0.1871,
       0.2134,
       0.2633,
       0.3617,
       0.4169,
       0.5127,
       0.5394,
       0.6003,
       0.6145,
       0.5542,
       0.3846,
       0.2771,
       0.2708,
       0.284,
       0.3029,
       0.2146,
       0.1547,
       0.184,
       0.1854,
       0.1762,
       0.168,
       0.1808,
       0.213,
       0.2263,
       0.2201,
       0.2329,
       0.295,
       0.3873,
       0.4574,
       0.4957,
       0.4992,
       0.5499,
       0.5538,
       0.5724,
       0.4228,
       0.2668,
       0.222,
       0.2627,
       0.2455,
       0.1661,
       0.0521,
       0.1035,
       0.1449,
       0.1521,
       0.1458,
       0.1387,
       0.1604,
       0.2004,
       0.2425,
       0.2741,
       0.3242,
       0.4158,
       0.5041,
       0.5487,
       0.5699,
       0.591,
       0.6202,
       0.5976,
       0.5461,
       0.5176,
       0.3497,
       0.2261,
       0.1939,
       0.1837,
       0.0843,
       0.208,
       0.0333,
       0.0553,
       0.1074,
       0.1278,
       0.152,
       0.1756,
       0.1843,
       0.1411,
       0.1897,
       0.2023,
       0.1849,
       0.1955,
       0.1824,
       0.2511,
       0.2746,
       0.2701,
       0.2456,
       0.2305,
       0.1778,
       0.1312,
       0.0772,
       0.0239,
       -0.0033,
       -0.0512,
       -0.0781,
       -0.0452,
       -0.0253,
       -0.004,
       0.0087,
       0.0151,
       0.0002,
       -0.0432,
       -0.023,
       0.0034,
       0.0351,
       0.09,
       0.1241,
       0.1285,
       0.1685,
       0.1464,
       0.1109,
       0.0775,
       0.0951,
       -0.0506,
       -0.1641,
       -0.1413,
       -0.1621,
       -0.1219,
       -0.0675,
       -0.0457,
       -0.0578,
       -0.0933,
       -0.0644,
       -0.0386,
       -0.0062,
       0.0324,
       0.0569,
       0.0717,
       0.0866,
       0.0817,
       0.0919,
       0.0924,
       0.1102,
       0.1436,
       0.1167,
       0.0969,
       0.1454,
       0.1193,
       0.0439,
       0.0411,
       0.0436,
       0.0487,
       0.1054,
       0.0269,
       -0.0467,
       0.0023,
       0.0439,
       0.0726,
       0.0882,
       0.0956,
       0.1091,
       0.115,
       0.1647,
       0.1795,
       0.2083,
       0.2307,
       0.2589,
       0.3048,
       0.295,
       0.2976,
       0.261,
       0.2499,
       0.177,
       0.0845,
       -0.0271,
       -0.0673,
       -0.0619,
       -0.0511,
       -0.0159,
       0.0395,
       0.0903,
       0.0956,
       0.1084,
       0.1491,
       0.2242,
       0.295,
       0.3366,
       0.3721,
       0.4021,
       0.4282,
       0.4419,
       0.4309,
       0.448,
       0.482,
       0.5105,
       0.5199,
       0.5132,
       0.5099,
       0.5202,
       0.5691,
       0.5455,
       0.5314,
       0.4822,
       0.3379,
       0.2191,
       0.2178,
       0.2726,
       0.2067,
       0.128,
       0.2035,
       0.2531,
       0.2637,
       0.2454,
       0.2057,
       0.1561,
       0.1252,
       0.1644,
       0.272,
       0.3139,
       0.3464,
       0.4138,
       0.4169,
       0.5333,
       0.5763,
       0.639,
       0.6323,
       0.6271,
       0.5611,
       0.2305,
       -0.0254,
       0.0082,
       0.0995,
       0.1746,
       0.2355,
       0.1141,
       -0.0028,
       0.0247,
       0.0152,
       0.0378,
       0.048,
       0.0484,
       0.0491,
       0.0564,
       0.0883,
       0.0964,
       0.165,
       0.1738,
       0.1976,
       0.1698,
       0.1641,
       0.207,
       0.1402,
       0.1928,
       0.2346,
       0.282,
       0.3327,
       0.3685,
       0.3709,
       0.4006,
       0.3598,
       0.3974,
       0.45,
       0.4147,
       0.4304,
       0.4153,
       0.431,
       0.4098,
       0.3582,
       -1.0,
       -1.0,
       -1.0,
       -1.0,
       -1.0
      ],
      "return_times_s": [
       16.533,
       30.093,
       100.496,
       114.242,
       127.431,
       198.949,
       214.181
      ],
      "inter_return_gaps_s": [
       13.944,
       13.56,
       70.403,
       13.746,
       13.189,
       71.518,
       15.232
      ]
     },
     "detail": {
      "hook_geometry": {
       "available": true,
       "onset_s": 2.589,
       "n_notes": 16,
       "vocab_size": 6,
       "range_semitones": 36.0,
       "licensed_leap": true,
       "largest_interval": 31.0,
       "intervals": [
        -3.0,
        -12.0,
        0.0,
        12.0,
        -12.0,
        12.0,
        -28.0,
        31.0,
        -5.0,
        0.0,
        -12.0,
        12.0,
        -31.0,
        31.0,
        -31.0
       ],
       "pitch_contour": "DD-UDUDUD-DUDUD",
       "iv_step_frac": 0.0,
       "iv_repeat_frac": 0.13333333333333333,
       "iv_gapfill_frac": 0.0,
       "iv_entropy": 2.2062389286533897,
       "contour_turns_per_note": 0.6666666666666666
      },
      "hook_strength": {
       "value": 0.5586,
       "terms": {
        "motif_length": 0.8,
        "interval_vocabulary": 0.7778,
        "distinctive_leap": 1.0,
        "compass": 0.0,
        "contour_activity": 0.7407,
        "singability": 0.0333
       },
       "provenance": {
        "motif_length": "CRAFT CONSENSUS",
        "interval_vocabulary": "CRAFT CONSENSUS",
        "distinctive_leap": "CRAFT CONSENSUS",
        "compass": "PHYSICAL, THEN CRAFT",
        "contour_activity": "CRAFT CONSENSUS",
        "singability": "CRAFT CONSENSUS WITH A MEASURED NULL AGAINST IT"
       },
       "definition": "arithmetic mean of six band-scored terms in 0..1; singability is 0.50*step_frac + 0.25*repeat_frac + 0.25*gapfill_frac, which is the stated definition rather than a vibe"
      },
      "hook_originality": {
       "screened": true,
       "verdict": "CLEAR",
       "hits": [],
       "advisories": [],
       "signatures_screened": 13,
       "caveat": "no SEED signature matched. The seed set is partial and its named gaps are listed; CLEAR is not a clean-room certificate."
      },
      "transformation_census": {
       "diminished": 5,
       "literal": 2,
       "re_registered": 1,
       "re_timbred": 4
      },
      "returns": [
       {
        "index": 89,
        "at_s": 16.533,
        "similarity": 0.7864,
        "chroma_cosine": 0.9199,
        "transpose_semitones": 0,
        "time_ratio": 1.0,
        "kinds": [
         "literal"
        ],
        "octave_delta": -0.201,
        "timbre_distance": 0.3996
       },
       {
        "index": 162,
        "at_s": 30.093,
        "similarity": 0.7742,
        "chroma_cosine": 0.9154,
        "transpose_semitones": 0,
        "time_ratio": 1.0,
        "kinds": [
         "literal"
        ],
        "octave_delta": 0.124,
        "timbre_distance": 0.3989
       },
       {
        "index": 541,
        "at_s": 100.496,
        "similarity": 0.6264,
        "chroma_cosine": 0.8687,
        "transpose_semitones": 0,
        "time_ratio": 0.5,
        "kinds": [
         "diminished",
         "re_timbred"
        ],
        "octave_delta": -0.463,
        "timbre_distance": 1.2359
       },
       {
        "index": 615,
        "at_s": 114.242,
        "similarity": 0.5724,
        "chroma_cosine": 0.8497,
        "transpose_semitones": 0,
        "time_ratio": 0.5,
        "kinds": [
         "diminished",
         "re_timbred"
        ],
        "octave_delta": -0.497,
        "timbre_distance": 1.1152
       },
       {
        "index": 686,
        "at_s": 127.431,
        "similarity": 0.626,
        "chroma_cosine": 0.865,
        "transpose_semitones": 0,
        "time_ratio": 0.6667,
        "kinds": [
         "diminished",
         "re_timbred"
        ],
        "octave_delta": -0.499,
        "timbre_distance": 1.1046
       },
       {
        "index": 1071,
        "at_s": 198.949,
        "similarity": 0.5691,
        "chroma_cosine": 0.8425,
        "transpose_semitones": 0,
        "time_ratio": 0.75,
        "kinds": [
         "diminished",
         "re_registered"
        ],
        "octave_delta": -0.534,
        "timbre_distance": 1.1579
       },
       {
        "index": 1153,
        "at_s": 214.181,
        "similarity": 0.6534,
        "chroma_cosine": 0.8782,
        "transpose_semitones": 0,
        "time_ratio": 0.5,
        "kinds": [
         "diminished",
         "re_timbred"
        ],
        "octave_delta": -0.397,
        "timbre_distance": 0.9046
       }
      ],
      "symbolic": {
       "available": true,
       "n_notes": 325,
       "query_intervals": [
        -3,
        -12,
        0,
        12,
        -12,
        12,
        -28,
        31,
        -5,
        0,
        -12,
        12,
        -31,
        31,
        -31
       ],
       "query_len": 15,
       "max_edits_allowed": 4,
       "interval_returns": 0,
       "interval_return_times_s": [],
       "interval_mean_edits": null,
       "contour_returns": 18,
       "contour_return_times_s": [
        13.897,
        18.692,
        20.004,
        21.804,
        22.477,
        25.832,
        28.804,
        30.917,
        33.472,
        38.487,
        42.864,
        45.523,
        87.261,
        88.851,
        94.401,
        96.897,
        100.333,
        102.713
       ],
       "varied_times_s": [],
       "note": "intervals are exact-size matches under an edit budget; the contour variant is blind to interval size and is the ornamentation-tolerant reading",
       "melodic_salience": 0.88,
       "read_first_s": 120.0
      },
      "motif_window_s": 6.114,
      "register_background_median": 0.5132,
      "colour_background_median": 1.2518,
      "background_lift": 0.1776,
      "return_threshold_lift": 0.523,
      "octave_cut": 0.5,
      "timbre_cut": 0.45
     },
     "verdict": {
      "passes": true,
      "law": "A track must state an identifiable motif and bring it back transformed rather than pasted: hooks and complexities, never stacked noise.",
      "evidence": [
       "7 returns, 71% transformed (diminished 5, literal 2, re_registered 1, re_timbred 4)"
      ]
     },
     "thresholds": {
      "floor_returns_per_min": 0.0,
      "floor_transformation_share": 0.0,
      "target_returns_per_min": 0.5852,
      "target_transformation_share": 1.0,
      "derived_from": "30 corpus HITS, audio arm, 2026-08-07",
      "health": "DEGENERATE -- see the sensitivity sweep in the validation artifact"
     },
     "_honest_tier": "MEASURED INSTRUMENT"
    },
    "noise_structure": {
     "instrument": "noise_structure",
     "version": "v1",
     "available": true,
     "reason": "",
     "metrics": {
      "crowding_index": 0.6531,
      "separation_index": 0.8065,
      "roughness_mean": 0.1425,
      "residual_share": 0.0591,
      "peak_structure_score": 26.067,
      "stacked_noise": false,
      "worst_window_start_s": 0.0,
      "worst_window_end_s": 3.99,
      "passes_floor": true,
      "passes_target": true,
      "adjacent_cohesion": 0.6997,
      "distant_cohesion": 0.5463,
      "crowding_retention": 0.7808,
      "lane_duty": 0.7308,
      "mean_lanes": 6.577,
      "register_spacing_octaves_mean": 1.006,
      "card_conjunction": 0.0394,
      "card_conjunction_legs": {
       "crowding": 0.219,
       "noisiness": 0.039,
       "unmelodic": 0.207,
       "simultaneity": 0.298
      },
      "peak_stability": 0.6193,
      "masked_fraction": 0.0704,
      "onset_coherence": 0.5003,
      "voice_independence": 0.4997,
      "audio_flatness": 0.00128,
      "audio_conjunction": 0.0856,
      "audio_conjunction_legs": {
       "noise_residual": 0.137,
       "noise_unpeaked": 0.238,
       "noise_flatness": 0.039,
       "cram_roughness": 0.514,
       "cram_masking": 0.086,
       "cram_unpeaked": 0.238
      },
      "noise_wall_conjunction": 0.0394,
      "crammed_wall_conjunction": 0.0856,
      "worst_window_score": 0.6264,
      "wall_score": 0.2038,
      "wall_score_tier": "audio",
      "wall_score_floor_bar": 0.8814,
      "wall_score_target_bar": 0.383
     },
     "series": {
      "band_distance_profile": {
       "1": 0.6997,
       "2": 0.6408,
       "3": 0.609,
       "4": 0.6163,
       "5": 0.5857,
       "6": 0.519,
       "7": 0.44,
       "8": 0.3338
      },
      "roughness_times_s": [
       0.0,
       0.557,
       1.115,
       1.672,
       2.229,
       2.786,
       3.344,
       3.901,
       4.458,
       5.016,
       5.573,
       6.13,
       6.687,
       7.245,
       7.802,
       8.359,
       8.916,
       9.474,
       10.031,
       10.588,
       11.146,
       11.703,
       12.26,
       12.817,
       13.375,
       13.932,
       14.489,
       15.047,
       15.604,
       16.161,
       16.718,
       17.276,
       17.833,
       18.39,
       18.947,
       19.505,
       20.062,
       20.619,
       21.177,
       21.734,
       22.291,
       22.848,
       23.406,
       23.963,
       24.52,
       25.078,
       25.635,
       26.192,
       26.749,
       27.307,
       27.864,
       28.421,
       28.979,
       29.536,
       30.093,
       30.65,
       31.208,
       31.765,
       32.322,
       32.879,
       33.437,
       33.994,
       34.551,
       35.109,
       35.666,
       36.223,
       36.78,
       37.338,
       37.895,
       38.452,
       39.01,
       39.567,
       40.124,
       40.681,
       41.239,
       41.796,
       42.353,
       42.91,
       43.468,
       44.025,
       44.582,
       45.14,
       45.697,
       46.254,
       46.811,
       47.369,
       47.926,
       48.483,
       49.041,
       49.598,
       50.155,
       50.712,
       51.27,
       51.827,
       52.384,
       52.941,
       53.499,
       54.056,
       54.613,
       55.171,
       55.728,
       56.285,
       56.842,
       57.4,
       57.957,
       58.514,
       59.072,
       59.629,
       60.186,
       60.743,
       61.301,
       61.858,
       62.415,
       62.973,
       63.53,
       64.087,
       64.644,
       65.202,
       65.759,
       66.316,
       66.873,
       67.431,
       67.988,
       68.545,
       69.103,
       69.66,
       70.217,
       70.774,
       71.332,
       71.889,
       72.446,
       73.004,
       73.561,
       74.118,
       74.675,
       75.233,
       75.79,
       76.347,
       76.904,
       77.462,
       78.019,
       78.576,
       79.134,
       79.691,
       80.248,
       80.805,
       81.363,
       81.92,
       82.477,
       83.035,
       83.592,
       84.149,
       84.706,
       85.264,
       85.821,
       86.378,
       86.936,
       87.493,
       88.05,
       88.607,
       89.165,
       89.722,
       90.279,
       90.836,
       91.394,
       91.951,
       92.508,
       93.066,
       93.623,
       94.18,
       94.737,
       95.295,
       95.852,
       96.409,
       96.967,
       97.524,
       98.081,
       98.638,
       99.196,
       99.753,
       100.31,
       100.867,
       101.425,
       101.982,
       102.539,
       103.097,
       103.654,
       104.211,
       104.768,
       105.326,
       105.883,
       106.44,
       106.998,
       107.555,
       108.112,
       108.669,
       109.227,
       109.784,
       110.341,
       110.899,
       111.456,
       112.013,
       112.57,
       113.128,
       113.685,
       114.242,
       114.799,
       115.357,
       115.914,
       116.471,
       117.029,
       117.586,
       118.143,
       118.7,
       119.258,
       119.815,
       120.372,
       120.93,
       121.487,
       122.044,
       122.601,
       123.159,
       123.716,
       124.273,
       124.83,
       125.388,
       125.945,
       126.502,
       127.06,
       127.617,
       128.174,
       128.731,
       129.289,
       129.846,
       130.403,
       130.961,
       131.518,
       132.075,
       132.632,
       133.19,
       133.747,
       134.304,
       134.861,
       135.419,
       135.976,
       136.533,
       137.091,
       137.648,
       138.205,
       138.762,
       139.32,
       139.877,
       140.434,
       140.992,
       141.549,
       142.106,
       142.663,
       143.221,
       143.778,
       144.335,
       144.893,
       145.45,
       146.007,
       146.564,
       147.122,
       147.679,
       148.236,
       148.793,
       149.351,
       149.908,
       150.465,
       151.023,
       151.58,
       152.137,
       152.694,
       153.252,
       153.809,
       154.366,
       154.924,
       155.481,
       156.038,
       156.595,
       157.153,
       157.71,
       158.267,
       158.824,
       159.382,
       159.939,
       160.496,
       161.054,
       161.611,
       162.168,
       162.725,
       163.283,
       163.84,
       164.397,
       164.955,
       165.512,
       166.069,
       166.626,
       167.184,
       167.741,
       168.298,
       168.856,
       169.413,
       169.97,
       170.527,
       171.085,
       171.642,
       172.199,
       172.756,
       173.314,
       173.871,
       174.428,
       174.986,
       175.543,
       176.1,
       176.657,
       177.215,
       177.772,
       178.329,
       178.887,
       179.444,
       180.001,
       180.558,
       181.116,
       181.673,
       182.23,
       182.787,
       183.345,
       183.902,
       184.459,
       185.017,
       185.574,
       186.131,
       186.688,
       187.246,
       187.803,
       188.36,
       188.918,
       189.475,
       190.032,
       190.589,
       191.147,
       191.704,
       192.261,
       192.819,
       193.376,
       193.933,
       194.49,
       195.048,
       195.605,
       196.162,
       196.719,
       197.277,
       197.834,
       198.391,
       198.949,
       199.506,
       200.063,
       200.62,
       201.178,
       201.735,
       202.292,
       202.85,
       203.407,
       203.964,
       204.521,
       205.079,
       205.636,
       206.193,
       206.75,
       207.308,
       207.865,
       208.422,
       208.98,
       209.537,
       210.094,
       210.651,
       211.209,
       211.766,
       212.323,
       212.881,
       213.438,
       213.995,
       214.552,
       215.11,
       215.667,
       216.224,
       216.781,
       217.339,
       217.896,
       218.453,
       219.011,
       219.568,
       220.125,
       220.682,
       221.24,
       221.797,
       222.354,
       222.912,
       223.469,
       224.026,
       224.583,
       225.141,
       225.698,
       226.255,
       226.813,
       227.37,
       227.927,
       228.484,
       229.042,
       229.599,
       230.156,
       230.713,
       231.271,
       231.828,
       232.385,
       232.943,
       233.5,
       234.057,
       234.614,
       235.172,
       235.729,
       236.286,
       236.844,
       237.401,
       237.958,
       238.515,
       239.073,
       239.63
      ],
      "roughness_curve": [
       0.395,
       2.3789,
       1.4823,
       1.3518,
       0.7117,
       0.0748,
       0.0329,
       0.0148,
       0.0227,
       0.0345,
       0.1119,
       0.0394,
       0.1017,
       0.109,
       0.0269,
       0.066,
       0.0323,
       0.0978,
       0.0704,
       0.0996,
       0.1787,
       0.0875,
       0.0312,
       0.0791,
       0.0767,
       0.0468,
       0.0925,
       0.0598,
       0.2422,
       0.1888,
       0.0794,
       0.0592,
       0.0586,
       0.0434,
       0.0904,
       0.0919,
       0.0532,
       0.0882,
       0.089,
       0.063,
       0.043,
       0.114,
       0.0454,
       0.0769,
       0.0806,
       0.0185,
       0.0412,
       0.0897,
       0.0426,
       0.074,
       0.0488,
       0.0891,
       0.0864,
       0.1383,
       0.1126,
       0.0234,
       0.1015,
       0.0505,
       0.0368,
       0.0541,
       0.1824,
       0.0271,
       0.17,
       0.1263,
       0.0722,
       0.0621,
       0.0443,
       0.0993,
       0.0497,
       0.2041,
       0.0567,
       0.0525,
       0.0761,
       0.0725,
       0.0522,
       0.0894,
       0.0909,
       0.1804,
       0.106,
       0.0983,
       0.2621,
       0.0675,
       0.0642,
       0.0656,
       0.0605,
       0.0477,
       0.0625,
       0.2053,
       0.0892,
       0.0904,
       0.1608,
       0.1001,
       0.0771,
       0.1452,
       0.1984,
       0.2148,
       0.1104,
       0.1479,
       0.1406,
       0.2029,
       0.2175,
       0.202,
       0.1471,
       0.2089,
       0.153,
       0.1093,
       0.0654,
       0.084,
       0.1724,
       0.0813,
       0.0656,
       0.0849,
       0.0747,
       0.1694,
       0.1176,
       0.0991,
       0.09,
       0.1644,
       0.1952,
       0.0955,
       0.1797,
       0.0893,
       0.0846,
       0.2457,
       0.1566,
       0.0719,
       0.1614,
       0.1086,
       0.0777,
       0.1214,
       0.1188,
       0.0469,
       0.0808,
       0.0776,
       0.1734,
       0.1183,
       0.1059,
       0.1742,
       0.0783,
       0.1115,
       0.1796,
       0.1381,
       0.1525,
       0.2077,
       0.1077,
       0.2242,
       0.1365,
       0.0649,
       0.0371,
       0.1147,
       0.1435,
       0.0734,
       0.103,
       0.1662,
       0.1096,
       0.1849,
       0.0497,
       0.0376,
       0.0733,
       0.1717,
       0.2845,
       0.1339,
       0.2521,
       0.0751,
       0.1423,
       0.1093,
       0.1144,
       0.2718,
       0.2019,
       0.0942,
       0.1592,
       0.0395,
       0.2122,
       0.3072,
       0.2034,
       0.1031,
       0.2319,
       0.1539,
       0.1267,
       0.1512,
       0.1423,
       0.1685,
       0.1369,
       0.062,
       0.1147,
       0.0956,
       0.1521,
       0.109,
       0.0956,
       0.0485,
       0.1808,
       0.1971,
       0.1805,
       0.1773,
       0.1933,
       0.0797,
       0.2227,
       0.1145,
       0.1441,
       0.0316,
       0.1365,
       0.1052,
       0.1781,
       0.1744,
       0.206,
       0.2129,
       0.0805,
       0.0759,
       0.0917,
       0.1645,
       0.2146,
       0.102,
       0.0805,
       0.1132,
       0.1466,
       0.1641,
       0.0983,
       0.2526,
       0.1369,
       0.0615,
       0.0664,
       0.246,
       0.0703,
       0.2845,
       0.3245,
       0.1142,
       0.1296,
       0.2583,
       0.1465,
       0.1112,
       0.186,
       0.125,
       0.0503,
       0.098,
       0.0665,
       0.1721,
       0.0899,
       0.125,
       0.0971,
       0.0632,
       0.0947,
       0.1027,
       0.1163,
       0.1637,
       0.0821,
       0.1015,
       0.096,
       0.2299,
       0.1974,
       0.1322,
       0.2858,
       0.2593,
       0.1086,
       0.1878,
       0.1009,
       0.0493,
       0.1025,
       0.0515,
       0.0667,
       0.1331,
       0.2572,
       0.065,
       0.1361,
       0.0942,
       0.1408,
       0.2084,
       0.298,
       0.0578,
       0.1722,
       0.1189,
       0.1313,
       0.1313,
       0.0593,
       0.2855,
       0.1174,
       0.0999,
       0.0936,
       0.2301,
       0.2288,
       0.1105,
       0.1822,
       0.0956,
       0.0654,
       0.1604,
       0.1345,
       0.1777,
       0.077,
       0.1068,
       0.1228,
       0.1365,
       0.227,
       0.1138,
       0.1033,
       0.1454,
       0.1363,
       0.159,
       0.1057,
       0.1512,
       0.209,
       0.2889,
       0.2094,
       0.2121,
       0.1962,
       0.2559,
       0.0892,
       0.1488,
       0.0654,
       0.1392,
       0.11,
       0.2794,
       0.16,
       0.1679,
       0.0855,
       0.1994,
       0.1387,
       0.1529,
       0.134,
       0.1834,
       0.1089,
       0.1692,
       0.1457,
       0.1523,
       0.175,
       0.2286,
       0.1858,
       0.3053,
       0.135,
       0.2461,
       0.0539,
       0.0486,
       0.1437,
       0.138,
       0.0635,
       0.173,
       0.0651,
       0.1019,
       0.1985,
       0.0996,
       0.1438,
       0.1231,
       0.3046,
       0.1701,
       0.0815,
       0.162,
       0.1627,
       0.1231,
       0.1356,
       0.2156,
       0.1744,
       0.1844,
       0.2923,
       0.2055,
       0.1613,
       0.122,
       0.2065,
       0.0949,
       0.1705,
       0.1791,
       0.2774,
       0.1104,
       0.1599,
       0.0646,
       0.0986,
       0.1393,
       0.1971,
       0.0884,
       0.1009,
       0.0999,
       0.1016,
       0.1043,
       0.1687,
       0.1988,
       0.09,
       0.2242,
       0.0569,
       0.0843,
       0.1236,
       0.2264,
       0.1151,
       0.1176,
       0.1158,
       0.1565,
       0.1404,
       0.2471,
       0.1187,
       0.137,
       0.0831,
       0.0507,
       0.1275,
       0.1325,
       0.076,
       0.0832,
       0.0492,
       0.1272,
       0.0579,
       0.0926,
       0.0973,
       0.0641,
       0.1387,
       0.2475,
       0.1266,
       0.2887,
       0.1363,
       0.1466,
       0.1808,
       0.0966,
       0.1141,
       0.1442,
       0.1431,
       0.1193,
       0.0799,
       0.1314,
       0.1716,
       0.0966,
       0.0398,
       0.0281,
       0.0937,
       0.065,
       0.1177,
       0.1142,
       0.1359,
       0.1086,
       0.092,
       0.1233,
       0.1987,
       0.0933,
       0.1099,
       0.1459,
       0.1739,
       0.1951,
       0.1818
      ],
      "masked_curve": [
       0.0528,
       0.0517,
       0.0434,
       0.0104,
       0.0731,
       0.0007,
       0.0007,
       0.0344,
       0.0119,
       0.0046,
       0.0447,
       0.007,
       0.0209,
       0.0288,
       0.0177,
       0.0287,
       0.0072,
       0.0724,
       0.0194,
       0.0704,
       0.0947,
       0.3708,
       0.0461,
       0.0613,
       0.039,
       0.0732,
       0.2735,
       0.016,
       0.0579,
       0.1054,
       0.0058,
       0.0511,
       0.0289,
       0.0049,
       0.0065,
       0.0099,
       0.144,
       0.1524,
       0.021,
       0.0176,
       0.0536,
       0.0189,
       0.0645,
       0.0221,
       0.0338,
       0.057,
       0.0074,
       0.2067,
       0.0101,
       0.0375,
       0.0635,
       0.0799,
       0.0253,
       0.0074,
       0.0068,
       0.0109,
       0.0787,
       0.028,
       0.0048,
       0.0233,
       0.0714,
       0.0604,
       0.0699,
       0.0815,
       0.0414,
       0.0181,
       0.0789,
       0.0343,
       0.0107,
       0.0986,
       0.0133,
       0.0511,
       0.0189,
       0.0738,
       0.0177,
       0.0261,
       0.1056,
       0.1672,
       0.0289,
       0.0815,
       0.011,
       0.0107,
       0.0239,
       0.0452,
       0.0357,
       0.0185,
       0.0166,
       0.0321,
       0.0513,
       0.0556,
       0.0418,
       0.1056,
       0.0483,
       0.0643,
       0.1169,
       0.0372,
       0.1265,
       0.0385,
       0.0683,
       0.0265,
       0.0441,
       0.1376,
       0.2303,
       0.0369,
       0.0823,
       0.0645,
       0.0493,
       0.066,
       0.0867,
       0.0469,
       0.0369,
       0.0762,
       0.045,
       0.0379,
       0.2216,
       0.0263,
       0.0779,
       0.1404,
       0.1131,
       0.0982,
       0.0499,
       0.0082,
       0.0237,
       0.0596,
       0.0954,
       0.0687,
       0.0392,
       0.0501,
       0.0094,
       0.0253,
       0.0507,
       0.0208,
       0.0263,
       0.0247,
       0.0875,
       0.0672,
       0.1519,
       0.0593,
       0.0277,
       0.0661,
       0.0401,
       0.161,
       0.1198,
       0.0723,
       0.0525,
       0.1464,
       0.0755,
       0.0694,
       0.0568,
       0.0638,
       0.0993,
       0.0707,
       0.0112,
       0.0905,
       0.0535,
       0.027,
       0.0386,
       0.0335,
       0.0659,
       0.1039,
       0.02,
       0.0269,
       0.0915,
       0.2375,
       0.036,
       0.0554,
       0.0659,
       0.0164,
       0.3137,
       0.1384,
       0.1518,
       0.0764,
       0.0184,
       0.0378,
       0.014,
       0.0796,
       0.1025,
       0.0757,
       0.2784,
       0.0503,
       0.0763,
       0.1005,
       0.0163,
       0.0985,
       0.177,
       0.083,
       0.0576,
       0.0444,
       0.1148,
       0.0966,
       0.1454,
       0.0893,
       0.0095,
       0.1583,
       0.1418,
       0.0739,
       0.0129,
       0.0394,
       0.0171,
       0.0104,
       0.2145,
       0.0689,
       0.2364,
       0.0823,
       0.1543,
       0.0988,
       0.0261,
       0.0672,
       0.0301,
       0.0406,
       0.1882,
       0.0203,
       0.0274,
       0.0539,
       0.1346,
       0.2168,
       0.0523,
       0.115,
       0.0633,
       0.0075,
       0.0382,
       0.0744,
       0.0664,
       0.0604,
       0.1124,
       0.0975,
       0.1029,
       0.0065,
       0.2428,
       0.0092,
       0.0543,
       0.0251,
       0.0376,
       0.0339,
       0.0298,
       0.0639,
       0.0643,
       0.0908,
       0.044,
       0.0295,
       0.0394,
       0.002,
       0.2268,
       0.2136,
       0.0112,
       0.0421,
       0.2445,
       0.0674,
       0.0144,
       0.0188,
       0.0636,
       0.0224,
       0.0309,
       0.0639,
       0.0465,
       0.069,
       0.0287,
       0.031,
       0.0079,
       0.2636,
       0.0621,
       0.0365,
       0.0516,
       0.0439,
       0.1633,
       0.074,
       0.0874,
       0.0992,
       0.0284,
       0.0614,
       0.0448,
       0.139,
       0.0652,
       0.0668,
       0.0455,
       0.263,
       0.0587,
       0.1938,
       0.0701,
       0.049,
       0.0911,
       0.0106,
       0.0865,
       0.1057,
       0.0561,
       0.0387,
       0.0322,
       0.057,
       0.0224,
       0.0085,
       0.2255,
       0.0455,
       0.0581,
       0.0977,
       0.0312,
       0.0787,
       0.1147,
       0.0385,
       0.0972,
       0.0889,
       0.0068,
       0.0076,
       0.0812,
       0.0366,
       0.035,
       0.0244,
       0.0532,
       0.0969,
       0.0899,
       0.0494,
       0.1098,
       0.1544,
       0.0552,
       0.0706,
       0.0035,
       0.0912,
       0.0594,
       0.2336,
       0.0548,
       0.0167,
       0.0837,
       0.0393,
       0.0038,
       0.1039,
       0.0531,
       0.0142,
       0.0562,
       0.1091,
       0.0508,
       0.0296,
       0.1321,
       0.0978,
       0.0688,
       0.0639,
       0.0836,
       0.1568,
       0.0449,
       0.0945,
       0.072,
       0.012,
       0.0361,
       0.0654,
       0.0566,
       0.1108,
       0.036,
       0.0332,
       0.0246,
       0.0404,
       0.0579,
       0.101,
       0.0491,
       0.0565,
       0.0688,
       0.0429,
       0.1275,
       0.0671,
       0.11,
       0.1206,
       0.1074,
       0.031,
       0.0894,
       0.0229,
       0.0073,
       0.2019,
       0.0926,
       0.0077,
       0.0163,
       0.0798,
       0.094,
       0.073,
       0.1131,
       0.1479,
       0.044,
       0.0148,
       0.0146,
       0.1,
       0.1169,
       0.0315,
       0.0218,
       0.0344,
       0.0765,
       0.0867,
       0.2043,
       0.1141,
       0.0316,
       0.0298,
       0.1005,
       0.0398,
       0.032,
       0.0369,
       0.0136,
       0.073,
       0.0334,
       0.0742,
       0.1992,
       0.0168,
       0.0477,
       0.2779,
       0.0421,
       0.0897,
       0.0387,
       0.1588,
       0.0878,
       0.1407,
       0.0384,
       0.2333,
       0.081,
       0.0355,
       0.0078,
       0.0146,
       0.0068,
       0.0765,
       0.1423,
       0.0747,
       0.012,
       0.0196,
       0.0206,
       0.0121,
       0.0044,
       0.0252,
       0.0175,
       0.1389,
       0.0829,
       0.1763,
       0.0335,
       0.1148,
       0.0666,
       0.0466,
       0.1883,
       0.0578,
       0.1858
      ],
      "residual_curve": [
       0.0,
       0.3124,
       0.2894,
       0.3144,
       0.302,
       0.0006,
       0.0004,
       0.0008,
       0.0007,
       0.0014,
       0.0033,
       0.002,
       0.0018,
       0.0032,
       0.0028,
       0.0011,
       0.0008,
       0.0683,
       0.0014,
       0.0222,
       0.0239,
       0.0357,
       0.0039,
       0.0051,
       0.0039,
       0.0065,
       0.0086,
       0.0294,
       0.034,
       0.0274,
       0.0032,
       0.0081,
       0.0066,
       0.0018,
       0.0012,
       0.0016,
       0.0022,
       0.088,
       0.0052,
       0.0064,
       0.0036,
       0.005,
       0.0021,
       0.0027,
       0.0171,
       0.0087,
       0.0154,
       0.0043,
       0.0108,
       0.0064,
       0.0054,
       0.0095,
       0.0147,
       0.0159,
       0.0067,
       0.0016,
       0.0035,
       0.0052,
       0.0005,
       0.0015,
       0.0345,
       0.0035,
       0.0118,
       0.0183,
       0.0048,
       0.0013,
       0.0016,
       0.0017,
       0.003,
       0.1402,
       0.0181,
       0.0046,
       0.0033,
       0.0139,
       0.0157,
       0.0041,
       0.0231,
       0.0701,
       0.0219,
       0.0147,
       0.0995,
       0.0094,
       0.0013,
       0.0169,
       0.0059,
       0.0056,
       0.0025,
       0.0428,
       0.0219,
       0.009,
       0.0058,
       0.0075,
       0.01,
       0.0829,
       0.1847,
       0.1356,
       0.0141,
       0.0888,
       0.0601,
       0.1234,
       0.1376,
       0.0832,
       0.1232,
       0.1047,
       0.1344,
       0.0176,
       0.0053,
       0.1889,
       0.0354,
       0.0561,
       0.0859,
       0.1311,
       0.0305,
       0.0319,
       0.1327,
       0.0105,
       0.0064,
       0.252,
       0.0436,
       0.0312,
       0.114,
       0.0385,
       0.0174,
       0.0571,
       0.0584,
       0.0255,
       0.0888,
       0.2499,
       0.0256,
       0.0092,
       0.0925,
       0.0567,
       0.0027,
       0.0195,
       0.1136,
       0.0261,
       0.0454,
       0.2899,
       0.0439,
       0.027,
       0.1997,
       0.1315,
       0.1147,
       0.0521,
       0.1095,
       0.0617,
       0.0182,
       0.2058,
       0.1016,
       0.0164,
       0.0554,
       0.0124,
       0.0108,
       0.0491,
       0.0251,
       0.051,
       0.0144,
       0.1964,
       0.025,
       0.0578,
       0.1669,
       0.1194,
       0.2058,
       0.1058,
       0.0106,
       0.037,
       0.0171,
       0.1478,
       0.1204,
       0.1342,
       0.0847,
       0.0259,
       0.0626,
       0.0173,
       0.0139,
       0.1306,
       0.049,
       0.1758,
       0.0795,
       0.0134,
       0.0574,
       0.0975,
       0.0475,
       0.013,
       0.0316,
       0.0143,
       0.0245,
       0.0405,
       0.0211,
       0.0066,
       0.1682,
       0.0639,
       0.0854,
       0.1495,
       0.0992,
       0.1092,
       0.0526,
       0.0338,
       0.0092,
       0.0041,
       0.2256,
       0.0265,
       0.0964,
       0.0655,
       0.0691,
       0.1081,
       0.0124,
       0.0206,
       0.0176,
       0.0367,
       0.0747,
       0.0103,
       0.0424,
       0.0125,
       0.0278,
       0.0273,
       0.0194,
       0.1124,
       0.153,
       0.013,
       0.0347,
       0.0149,
       0.0195,
       0.0488,
       0.121,
       0.0537,
       0.0264,
       0.1059,
       0.0375,
       0.0473,
       0.2395,
       0.0153,
       0.0113,
       0.0069,
       0.0356,
       0.0689,
       0.0093,
       0.0986,
       0.0135,
       0.0092,
       0.0675,
       0.0815,
       0.0147,
       0.1786,
       0.027,
       0.0847,
       0.0273,
       0.2242,
       0.0646,
       0.1709,
       0.2035,
       0.0679,
       0.1295,
       0.0279,
       0.1059,
       0.0364,
       0.0121,
       0.1371,
       0.0077,
       0.065,
       0.1035,
       0.0372,
       0.025,
       0.0157,
       0.1139,
       0.1946,
       0.0791,
       0.2351,
       0.1,
       0.0271,
       0.1049,
       0.0961,
       0.0142,
       0.0901,
       0.0977,
       0.0806,
       0.0243,
       0.1532,
       0.1623,
       0.1052,
       0.1544,
       0.0191,
       0.0376,
       0.1239,
       0.0212,
       0.05,
       0.0289,
       0.1979,
       0.0193,
       0.002,
       0.1269,
       0.0318,
       0.0928,
       0.0352,
       0.1492,
       0.0637,
       0.0906,
       0.152,
       0.1539,
       0.0942,
       0.1641,
       0.1165,
       0.121,
       0.052,
       0.1471,
       0.1121,
       0.007,
       0.2021,
       0.0784,
       0.0702,
       0.1815,
       0.1369,
       0.0204,
       0.0632,
       0.151,
       0.0738,
       0.0279,
       0.1634,
       0.0279,
       0.0544,
       0.1989,
       0.0418,
       0.11,
       0.1525,
       0.0849,
       0.0518,
       0.0331,
       0.0818,
       0.0378,
       0.0208,
       0.0999,
       0.0283,
       0.0127,
       0.0797,
       0.0425,
       0.2222,
       0.0209,
       0.1627,
       0.0854,
       0.0735,
       0.1305,
       0.0609,
       0.0351,
       0.0825,
       0.1137,
       0.0572,
       0.022,
       0.2773,
       0.1536,
       0.0588,
       0.0594,
       0.1473,
       0.0541,
       0.0642,
       0.0284,
       0.0709,
       0.058,
       0.062,
       0.1388,
       0.039,
       0.1718,
       0.004,
       0.0048,
       0.012,
       0.0729,
       0.0083,
       0.0428,
       0.0251,
       0.0136,
       0.0216,
       0.09,
       0.1073,
       0.1033,
       0.0153,
       0.0195,
       0.0247,
       0.012,
       0.0202,
       0.0561,
       0.0235,
       0.1104,
       0.0521,
       0.056,
       0.0973,
       0.1076,
       0.0297,
       0.0131,
       0.0034,
       0.0102,
       0.0237,
       0.0122,
       0.013,
       0.0063,
       0.0208,
       0.0129,
       0.0316,
       0.0044,
       0.0117,
       0.0567,
       0.1074,
       0.1535,
       0.1311,
       0.0739,
       0.1501,
       0.0484,
       0.0394,
       0.0443,
       0.015,
       0.0045,
       0.0061,
       0.0103,
       0.0475,
       0.0324,
       0.0131,
       0.0022,
       0.0013,
       0.0011,
       0.0021,
       0.0027,
       0.0069,
       0.0075,
       0.0135,
       0.0211,
       0.0633,
       0.0717,
       0.0542,
       0.05,
       0.1022,
       0.0845,
       0.0788,
       0.1088
      ]
     },
     "verdict": {
      "passes": true,
      "law": "A texture may carry dozens of layers, but it must resolve into separable voices: there cannot just be stacked noise.",
      "evidence": [
       "crowding 0.6531 (far 0.5463 / adjacent 0.6997 = retention 0.7808), corpus pct 0.219",
       "separation 0.8065 from lane_reserve 0.751, melodic_salience 0.793, spectral_peakiness 0.961, voiced_fraction 0.721",
       "density-without-structure conjunction 0.0394 vs bar 0.7536 :: crowding 0.219, noisiness 0.039, simultaneity 0.298, unmelodic 0.207",
       "roughness 0.1425, residual share 0.0591, peak structure 26.067 dB (stability 0.6193), masked fraction 0.0704, voice independence 0.4997",
       "noise-wall conjunction 0.0394 vs bar 0.8652 :: flatness 0.039, residual 0.137, unpeaked 0.238",
       "crammed-wall conjunction 0.0856 vs bar 0.9043 :: masking 0.086, roughness 0.514, unpeaked 0.238",
       "worst window 0.0s to 3.99s at 0.6264 :: roughness 0.991; residual share 0.187; peak structure 23.0 dB; masked fraction 0.033",
       "wall score 0.2038 (audio tier) against floor 0.8814 and target 0.383"
      ]
     }
    },
    "melodic_intelligence": {
     "instrument": "melodic_intelligence",
     "version": "v1",
     "available": true,
     "reason": "",
     "metrics": {
      "interval_entropy": 4.473,
      "interval_bigram_entropy": 7.2991,
      "contour_depth": 8.0,
      "melodic_complexity": 0.3663,
      "n_development_ops": 1,
      "development_share": 1.0,
      "development_kinds": [
       "fragmentation"
      ],
      "phrase_count": 54,
      "phrase_length_variety": 0.7944,
      "phrase_sophistication": 0.7194,
      "n_melodic_voices": 4,
      "counter_melody_presence": 0.7162,
      "dialogue_handoffs": 8,
      "orchestrational_dialogue": 0.5916,
      "passes_floor": false,
      "passes_target": false
     },
     "series": {
      "development_returns": [
       {
        "at_s": 87.261,
        "kind": "fragmentation",
        "error_semitones": 0.333,
        "time_ratio": 0.579,
        "transpose_semitones": -15.0,
        "fragment_intervals": 3
       }
      ],
      "phrase_boundaries_s": [
       8.707,
       10.681,
       16.324,
       18.437,
       26.819,
       40.635,
       42.864,
       45.523,
       48.982,
       52.477,
       55.124,
       58.061,
       62.775,
       63.704,
       66.664,
       73.004,
       75.569,
       77.38,
       79.157,
       81.641,
       85.519,
       86.471,
       89.617,
       93.472,
       95.666,
       96.607,
       98.22,
       102.644,
       103.387,
       105.105,
       106.998,
       108.577,
       111.096,
       114.498,
       117.272,
       118.805,
       120.976,
       125.446,
       131.216,
       135.512,
       138.194,
       140.852,
       142.594,
       144.997,
       150.291,
       151.139,
       153.02,
       156.514,
       157.559,
       159.138,
       163.944,
       166.127,
       172.42
      ],
      "lead_sequence": [
       "soprano",
       "tenor",
       "alto",
       "bass",
       "alto",
       "tenor",
       "alto",
       "tenor",
       "alto"
      ]
     },
     "detail": {
      "line": {
       "extractor": "harmonic-summation predominant melody (rig's block), pYIN cross-check omitted",
       "voiced_fraction": 0.6369,
       "note_count": 475,
       "note_rate_per_s": 2.6389,
       "analysed_s": 180.0
      },
      "complexity": {
       "available": true,
       "interval_entropy": 4.473,
       "interval_bigram_entropy": 7.2991,
       "interval_predictive_information": 0.6717,
       "interval_predictive_information_uncorrected": 1.6468,
       "rhythm_entropy": 2.9514,
       "rhythm_predictive_information": 0.0236,
       "contour_depth": 8.0,
       "pitch_class_alphabet": 6,
       "step_leap_ratio": 0.076,
       "variety": 0.9076,
       "structure": 0.1478,
       "melodic_complexity": 0.3663,
       "definition": "geometric mean of a five-term VARIETY score and a three-term STRUCTURE score; structure is shuffle-corrected predictive information, which is zero for a random line and zero for a constant one"
      },
      "development": {
       "available": true,
       "reason": "",
       "n_returns": 1,
       "n_ops": 1,
       "kinds": [
        "fragmentation"
       ],
       "op_kinds": [
        "fragmentation"
       ],
       "development_share": 1.0,
       "cell_intervals": [
        -3.0,
        -12.0,
        0.0,
        12.0,
        -12.0,
        12.0,
        -28.0,
        31.0,
        -5.0
       ],
       "note": "n_ops counts material-CHANGING operations only; exact repetition, octave transfer and transposition are restatements and are counted in n_returns but not in n_ops"
      },
      "phrases": {
       "available": true,
       "phrase_count": 54,
       "phrase_length_variety": 0.7944,
       "phrase_len_notes_median": 7.0,
       "antecedent_consequent_rate": 0.1132,
       "cadential_differentiation": 0.7645,
       "phrase_hierarchy": 1.0,
       "phrase_sophistication": 0.7194,
       "tonic_pc_estimate": 7,
       "definition": "mean of length-variety score, antecedent-consequent rate, cadential entropy, hierarchy"
      },
      "counter_melody": {
       "available": true,
       "n_melodic_voices": 4,
       "voice_bands": [
        "bass",
        "alto",
        "tenor",
        "soprano"
       ],
       "folded_doublings": [],
       "mean_pairwise_independence": 0.7162,
       "counter_melody_presence": 0.7162,
       "bands_examined": 5,
       "note": "a LOWER bound on voices -- two instruments in one register read as one band"
      },
      "dialogue": {
       "available": true,
       "dialogue_handoffs": 8,
       "handoffs_per_min": 2.667,
       "lead_sequence": [
        "soprano",
        "tenor",
        "alto",
        "bass",
        "alto",
        "tenor",
        "alto",
        "tenor",
        "alto"
       ],
       "lead_share_entropy": 0.6655,
       "distinct_lead_bands": 4,
       "orchestrational_dialogue": 0.5916,
       "windows": 45
      }
     },
     "verdict": {
      "passes": false,
      "law": "A melody must be complex without being random, must return DEVELOPED rather than restated, must be built of shaped phrases that answer one another, and must share the melodic lead with more than one voice across the cue.",
      "tier": "audio",
      "evidence": [
       "line: 475 notes over 180 s (voiced 0.64)",
       "complexity 0.3663 = variety 0.9076 x structure 0.1478",
       "development: 1 operation(s) ['fragmentation'] of 1 returns",
       "phrases: 54 , sophistication 0.7194",
       "voices: 4 melodically active of 5 bands",
       "dialogue: 8 hand-off(s), 0.6655 share entropy"
      ]
     }
    },
    "cross_track_distinctness": {
     "instrument": "cross_track_distinctness",
     "version": "v1",
     "available": false,
     "reason": "no cohort supplied. DISTINCTNESS IS A SET PROPERTY: this instrument grades a set pairwise, and a lone track has nothing to be distinct from. Pass cohort=[...] or use compare_set().",
     "metrics": {
      "worst_similarity": null,
      "worst_similarity_partner": null,
      "worst_transposition": null,
      "matching_run_len": null,
      "n_flagged_pairs": null,
      "declared_reference": null,
      "distinctness": null,
      "passes_floor": null,
      "passes_target": null
     },
     "series": {},
     "verdict": {
      "passes": null,
      "law": "No two tracks may share more melodic material than a declaration licenses: every track its own tune, and a reprise is design only where the plan names the partner and the node that earns it.",
      "evidence": [
       "a single-track verdict is undefined for this axis"
      ]
     },
     "_honest_tier": "MEASURED INSTRUMENT"
    },
    "dynamic_arc": {
     "instrument": "dynamic_arc",
     "version": "v1",
     "available": true,
     "reason": "",
     "metrics": {
      "n_builds": 2,
      "n_holds": 1,
      "n_releases": 3,
      "n_valleys": 0,
      "longest_hold_s": 60.18,
      "deepest_valley_depth": 0.8618,
      "valley_engagement": 1.0917,
      "peak_distinction": 0.5382,
      "arch_type": "multi_arch",
      "arc_class_match": null,
      "dynamic_range_db": 9.43,
      "passes_floor": true,
      "passes_target": false
     },
     "series": {
      "phases": [
       {
        "kind": "BUILD",
        "t0": 0.0,
        "t1": 26.01,
        "dur": 26.75,
        "level": 0.5768,
        "traverse": 0.6627
       },
       {
        "kind": "RELEASE",
        "t0": 26.75,
        "t1": 52.76,
        "dur": 26.75,
        "level": 0.6983,
        "traverse": -0.5005
       },
       {
        "kind": "BUILD",
        "t0": 53.5,
        "t1": 72.82,
        "dur": 20.06,
        "level": 0.7771,
        "traverse": 0.514
       },
       {
        "kind": "RELEASE",
        "t0": 73.56,
        "t1": 133.0,
        "dur": 60.18,
        "level": 0.3903,
        "traverse": -0.7692
       },
       {
        "kind": "HOLD",
        "t0": 133.75,
        "t1": 193.19,
        "dur": 60.18,
        "level": 0.8029,
        "traverse": 0.0266
       },
       {
        "kind": "RELEASE",
        "t0": 193.93,
        "t1": 239.26,
        "dur": 46.07,
        "level": 0.2186,
        "traverse": -0.4776
       }
      ],
      "energy_curve_normalised": [
       -0.25,
       -0.25,
       -0.25,
       -0.0945,
       0.0562,
       0.2385,
       0.428,
       0.6133,
       0.7617,
       0.8536,
       0.8561,
       0.7957,
       0.7569,
       0.7473,
       0.7781,
       0.7705,
       0.735,
       0.6656,
       0.6729,
       0.7144,
       0.8056,
       0.8234,
       0.8289,
       0.8404,
       0.822,
       0.7765,
       0.7767,
       0.7486,
       0.6931,
       0.604,
       0.5498,
       0.5603,
       0.563,
       0.5682,
       0.5852,
       0.621,
       0.6162,
       0.7167,
       0.8323,
       0.9288,
       0.9822,
       0.9976,
       0.9952,
       0.9852,
       0.9975,
       0.9664,
       1.0098,
       0.9222,
       0.819,
       0.7648,
       0.7328,
       0.7132,
       0.7056,
       0.6902,
       0.6259,
       0.6118,
       0.5851,
       0.6013,
       0.6372,
       0.6588,
       0.6376,
       0.6218,
       0.5916,
       0.568,
       0.5777,
       0.5871,
       0.5446,
       0.4929,
       0.4283,
       0.3329,
       0.3288,
       0.33,
       0.3548,
       0.4099,
       0.484,
       0.5765,
       0.6547,
       0.7383,
       0.816,
       0.8981,
       0.9182,
       0.908,
       0.8976,
       0.8684,
       0.7904,
       0.7286,
       0.7073,
       0.7234,
       0.6973,
       0.7201,
       0.7265,
       0.7334,
       0.7873,
       0.856,
       0.9372,
       0.9685,
       0.9981,
       1.0184,
       1.0641,
       1.0477,
       1.0683,
       1.0999,
       1.0337,
       0.9476,
       0.896,
       0.8963,
       0.8584,
       0.8515,
       0.8545,
       0.8581,
       0.8291,
       0.7998,
       0.7905,
       0.7595,
       0.7298,
       0.6468,
       0.6026,
       0.4854,
       0.3747,
       0.3079,
       0.2437,
       0.1542,
       0.0772,
       0.1324,
       0.1419,
       0.1938,
       0.187,
       0.2247,
       0.315,
       0.3201,
       0.4002,
       0.4582,
       0.5415,
       0.5294,
       0.5228,
       0.4813,
       0.4723,
       0.4874,
       0.4476,
       0.3924,
       0.2704,
       0.2774,
       0.2787,
       0.2671,
       0.2739,
       0.3014,
       0.3601,
       0.3605,
       0.3068,
       0.293,
       0.3008,
       0.3196,
       0.313,
       0.302,
       0.2753,
       0.2642,
       0.2103,
       0.2315,
       0.195,
       0.1761,
       0.2633,
       0.2665,
       0.2699,
       0.2399,
       0.2222,
       0.2206,
       0.1762,
       0.0927,
       0.092,
       0.1315,
       0.0862,
       0.0518,
       0.0096,
       -0.0257,
       0.0089,
       -0.001,
       0.0543,
       0.0713,
       0.1395,
       0.21,
       0.2679,
       0.333,
       0.411,
       0.5199,
       0.5524,
       0.5977,
       0.6659,
       0.7767,
       0.8838,
       0.9427,
       0.9888,
       1.0089,
       1.0277,
       1.0408,
       1.0391,
       1.0047,
       0.9265,
       0.8782,
       0.8288,
       0.8052,
       0.7678,
       0.7177,
       0.6859,
       0.6616,
       0.6572,
       0.6869,
       0.7431,
       0.7782,
       0.7938,
       0.8066,
       0.8284,
       0.8609,
       0.9092,
       0.9285,
       0.9473,
       0.9271,
       0.8964,
       0.859,
       0.8347,
       0.7871,
       0.7585,
       0.7226,
       0.6544,
       0.6037,
       0.5962,
       0.6548,
       0.6853,
       0.7235,
       0.7124,
       0.7311,
       0.736,
       0.748,
       0.7614,
       0.7909,
       0.8046,
       0.7888,
       0.8022,
       0.7969,
       0.7937,
       0.797,
       0.8112,
       0.8394,
       0.8802,
       0.9197,
       0.8856,
       0.8354,
       0.7823,
       0.7664,
       0.8065,
       0.808,
       0.8159,
       0.8251,
       0.8444,
       0.8692,
       0.928,
       1.0002,
       1.0668,
       1.0793,
       1.0481,
       1.0465,
       0.9407,
       0.7947,
       0.6883,
       0.5272,
       0.3694,
       0.2244,
       0.1639,
       0.1446,
       0.1313,
       0.109,
       0.143,
       0.2307,
       0.2325,
       0.2925,
       0.3138,
       0.4012,
       0.4239,
       0.435,
       0.4406,
       0.4072,
       0.4202,
       0.4158,
       0.4227,
       0.3657,
       0.3736,
       0.3569,
       0.31,
       0.2843,
       0.2685,
       0.335,
       0.3629,
       0.3127,
       0.2899,
       0.2913,
       0.3644,
       0.3718,
       0.3593,
       0.2617,
       0.1917,
       0.0927,
       0.0455,
       0.0923,
       0.1702,
       0.2702,
       0.2578,
       0.2732,
       0.2942,
       0.3753,
       0.4414,
       0.4565,
       0.3604,
       0.1739,
       -0.08,
       -0.25,
       -0.25,
       -0.25,
       -0.25,
       -0.25,
       -0.25,
       -0.25,
       -0.25,
       -0.25,
       -0.25
      ],
      "sedation_spans": []
     },
     "detail": {
      "hold_share": 0.2515,
      "raw_range": 0.1975,
      "peak": {
       "peak_distinction": 0.5382,
       "peak_position_normalised": 0.3137,
       "near_peak_share": 0.0805,
       "baseline_level": 0.5617
      },
      "valley": {
       "valley_engagement": 1.0917,
       "terms": {
        "pulse_present": 0.8632,
        "contour_lifts": 1.0917,
        "engagement_sustained": 0.625
       },
       "activity_reference": "onset-strength envelope (audio tier)",
       "headline_term": "contour_lifts -- motion of an independent activity signal in the valley, relative to the whole cue. The two level terms are diagnostics only: both were measured running BACKWARDS against the pools because a ratio to the track's own mean rewards a flat cue.",
       "scope": "phases below the valley level",
       "low_share": 0.3065,
       "low_level_mean": 0.1454
      },
      "curve_agreement_spearman": {
       "sim": 0.8768450680551906,
       "cplx": 0.8538545853123858,
       "db": 0.7176925690184541
      },
      "primary_curve": "flow curve (energy; 45% normalised RMS by construction)",
      "audio": {
       "analysed_s": 240.0,
       "card_vs_reimplementation_spearman": 0.9515369839774201,
       "note": "the reimplementation follows acquire_exemplar's published recipe; the agreement above is measured, not assumed"
      },
      "purpose_class": "SERENE",
      "energy_floor": null,
      "honest_label": "a GENERATION-DEFECT detector, not a taste oracle -- AUC 0.982 against the round Josh rejected on the loudness-free lane curve, and NOTHING clears the within-album multiplicity bar"
     },
     "verdict": {
      "passes": true,
      "law": "A cue must BUILD to a peak that stands above its surroundings, HOLD there long enough to be heard as arrival rather than as a spike, and keep something worth following in its valleys, so the listener is lost neither at the top nor at the bottom.",
      "tier": "audio",
      "evidence": [
       "phases: 2 build(s), 1 hold(s), 3 release(s), 0 valley(s) over 239 s",
       "hold share 0.252 (corpus hits 0.407, round 2 0.092); longest hold 60.2 s (hits 41.6, round 2 13.4)",
       "arch type multi_arch; peak distinction 0.5382 at 0.3137, near-peak share 0.0805",
       "valley engagement 1.0917 from {'pulse_present': 0.8632, 'contour_lifts': 1.0917, 'engagement_sustained': 0.625} over phases below the valley level"
      ]
     }
    },
    "summit_tests": {
     "instrument": "summit_tests",
     "version": "v1",
     "available": true,
     "reason": "",
     "metrics": {
      "piano_melody_recovered": 0.8699,
      "singability": 1.0,
      "self_sufficiency": 1.0,
      "transmissibility": 0.8516,
      "reduction_harmonic_interest": 0.9823,
      "piano_test_passes": true,
      "orchestra_lint_findings": null,
      "orchestra_lint_passes": null,
      "longest_unbroken_span_s": null,
      "out_of_range_notes": null,
      "acoustic_core_declared": null,
      "passes_floor": true,
      "passes_target": false
     },
     "series": {
      "phrases_s": [
       [
        2.589,
        48.431
       ],
       [
        48.982,
        54.764
       ],
       [
        55.124,
        55.914
       ],
       [
        55.879,
        57.992
       ],
       [
        58.061,
        59.745
       ],
       [
        59.757,
        61.353
       ],
       [
        61.486,
        61.579
       ],
       [
        62.775,
        63.356
       ],
       [
        63.704,
        65.132
       ],
       [
        65.736,
        66.572
       ],
       [
        66.664,
        69.091
       ],
       [
        69.114,
        75.175
       ],
       [
        75.569,
        76.893
       ],
       [
        76.858,
        77.032
       ],
       [
        77.38,
        78.948
       ],
       [
        79.157,
        81.351
       ],
       [
        81.641,
        86.262
       ],
       [
        86.471,
        94.627
       ],
       [
        94.97,
        95.225
       ],
       [
        95.666,
        97.721
       ],
       [
        98.22,
        104.676
       ],
       [
        105.105,
        106.603
       ],
       [
        106.998,
        108.298
       ],
       [
        108.577,
        112.356
       ],
       [
        113.046,
        113.546
       ],
       [
        114.068,
        118.422
       ],
       [
        118.805,
        125.214
       ],
       [
        125.446,
        126.055
       ],
       [
        126.282,
        129.834
       ],
       [
        130.357,
        130.682
       ],
       [
        131.216,
        134.536
       ],
       [
        134.711,
        135.001
       ],
       [
        135.512,
        138.043
       ],
       [
        138.194,
        139.651
       ],
       [
        139.947,
        140.063
       ],
       [
        140.852,
        142.437
       ],
       [
        142.594,
        144.3
       ],
       [
        144.997,
        145.74
       ],
       [
        145.949,
        147.354
       ],
       [
        147.702,
        148.236
       ],
       [
        148.561,
        149.072
       ],
       [
        149.804,
        150.906
       ],
       [
        151.139,
        152.079
       ],
       [
        152.416,
        152.509
       ],
       [
        153.02,
        155.643
       ],
       [
        155.829,
        155.957
       ],
       [
        156.514,
        158.557
       ],
       [
        159.138,
        159.846
       ],
       [
        160.554,
        161.205
       ],
       [
        161.773,
        161.831
       ],
       [
        162.226,
        162.412
       ],
       [
        163.445,
        163.503
       ],
       [
        163.944,
        165.669
       ],
       [
        166.127,
        166.208
       ],
       [
        166.545,
        167.404
       ],
       [
        167.729,
        167.88
       ],
       [
        168.554,
        168.612
       ],
       [
        169.088,
        169.157
       ],
       [
        169.54,
        169.657
       ],
       [
        170.388,
        170.562
       ],
       [
        172.42,
        172.994
       ],
       [
        173.221,
        175.427
       ],
       [
        175.554,
        175.671
       ],
       [
        176.762,
        177.575
       ],
       [
        177.702,
        180.303
       ]
      ]
     },
     "detail": {
      "reduction": {
       "source": "melody: harmonic-summation predominant melody (rig's block), pYIN cross-check omitted; harmony: 24-triad chroma template match at 1.67 s windows",
       "melodic_salience": 0.8699,
       "line": {
        "extractor": "harmonic-summation predominant melody (rig's block), pYIN cross-check omitted",
        "voiced_fraction": 0.6369,
        "note_count": 475,
        "note_rate_per_s": 2.6389,
        "analysed_s": 180.0,
        "octave_errors_repaired": 334,
        "octave_repair_share": 0.7032
       },
       "chord_margin_median": 0.062,
       "analysed_s": 180.0,
       "extraction_error": "MONOPHONIC EXTRACTION FROM DENSE POLYPHONY IS UNRELIABLE. The melody is a predominant-voice estimate, not a transcription, and where two instruments trade the lead the line jumps between them. The chroma harmony reads the WHOLE MIX INCLUDING THE MELODY, which biases chord-tone agreement UPWARD -- the bias is measured on our own cues, which have both a score and a render, and published in the artifact's EXTRACTION_ERROR block rather than argued about",
       "tier": "audio-extracted",
       "total_s": 180.0,
       "bpm": 143.55,
       "beats_per_bar": 4,
       "tonic_pc": 0,
       "n_melody": 475,
       "n_harmony": 108
      },
      "piano_test": {
       "tier": "audio-extracted",
       "piano_melody_recovered": 0.8699,
       "melody_notes": 475,
       "melody_note_rate_per_s": 2.6389,
       "available": true,
       "judgeable": true,
       "reason": "",
       "singability": {
        "available": true,
        "reason": "",
        "singability": 1.0,
        "components": {
         "compass": 1.0,
         "tessitura": 1.0,
         "step_ratio": 1.0,
         "leap_handling": 1.0,
         "breath": 0.631
        },
        "components_scored": [
         "compass",
         "leap_handling",
         "step_ratio",
         "tessitura"
        ],
        "breath_scored": false,
        "compass_window_s": 6.69,
        "compass_semitones": 7.0,
        "compass_scope": "the note-weighted median PHRASE compass; a singer sings a phrase",
        "whole_cue_compass_semitones": 24.0,
        "tessitura_share": 0.9241,
        "tessitura_centre_midi": 67.0,
        "step_share": 0.6569,
        "largest_leap_semitones": 7.0,
        "largest_leap_scope": "the 98th percentile of within-phrase leaps",
        "max_leap_raw_semitones": 8.0,
        "leaps": 81,
        "leaps_gap_filled": 58,
        "gap_fill_share": 0.716,
        "phrases_in_breath_range": 0.3846,
        "longest_phrase_s": 45.842
       },
       "self_sufficiency": {
        "available": true,
        "reason": "",
        "self_sufficiency": 1.0,
        "components": {
         "chord_tone_share": 1.0,
         "implied_harmony_agreement": 1.0,
         "structural_pitch_variety": 1.0
        },
        "chord_tone_share_raw": 0.8178,
        "implied_harmony_raw": 0.5603,
        "implied_root_agreement": 0.4952,
        "structural_pitch_entropy": 0.8016,
        "structural_notes": 247,
        "spans_judged": 105
       },
       "transmissibility": {
        "available": true,
        "reason": "",
        "transmissibility": 0.8516,
        "components": {
         "pitch_alphabet": 1.0,
         "motivic_economy": 0.526,
         "repetition_structure": 1.0,
         "rhythmic_simplicity": 1.0
        },
        "pitch_alphabet_size": 6,
        "top3_contour_4gram_cover": 0.1146,
        "recurring_contour_4gram_share": 0.5556,
        "duration_classes": 14,
        "rhythm_entropy": 0.5589
       },
       "harmonic_interest": {
        "available": true,
        "reason": "",
        "reduction_harmonic_interest": 0.9823,
        "components": {
         "distinct_chords": 1.0,
         "change_rate_per_min": 1.0,
         "non_tonic_share": 1.0,
         "dwell_balance": 0.931
        },
        "distinct_chords_raw": 7,
        "chord_changes": 54,
        "change_rate_per_min_raw": 18.0,
        "non_tonic_share_raw": 0.4907,
        "dwell_entropy": 0.6986
       },
       "phrase_grammar": {
        "available": true,
        "reason": "",
        "n_phrases": 65,
        "longest_phrase_s": 45.842,
        "longest_phrase_bars": 27.42,
        "longest_novel_phrase_s": 45.842,
        "longest_novel_phrase_bars": 27.42,
        "median_phrase_bars": 0.66,
        "distinct_ideas": 1,
        "idea_detail": {
         "n_ideas": 1,
         "n_shape_classes": 26,
         "ideas": [
          {
           "shape": [
            -3,
            0,
            0,
            0,
            0,
            0,
            -4,
            7,
            -5,
            0,
            0,
            0,
            5,
            -5,
            5,
            -5,
            0,
            0,
            0,
            5,
            -7,
            7,
            0,
            0,
            -2,
            2,
            0,
            -2,
            2,
            0,
            -2,
            -5,
            7,
            -7,
            7,
            -3,
            0,
            0,
            0,
            0,
            0,
            0,
            0,
            3,
            -7,
            7,
            -7,
            4,
            -2,
            5,
            -5,
            0,
            0,
            5,
            -5,
            5,
            -5,
            5,
            -5,
            5,
            -5,
            5,
            0,
            -7,
            7,
            0,
            -2,
            2,
            -2,
            2,
            0,
            -2,
            2,
            -2,
            2,
            -2,
            0,
            2,
            -7,
            7,
            -2,
            -1,
            0,
            0,
            0,
            0,
            -4,
            4,
            -4,
            7,
            -5,
            0,
            0,
            5,
            -7,
            7,
            -5,
            -2,
            2,
            5,
            -2,
            2,
            -2,
            2,
            -2,
            0,
            2,
            -2,
            4,
            -4,
            0,
            0,
            -5,
            5,
            -1,
            3,
            -7,
            4,
            -2,
            5,
            -5,
            5,
            -5,
            5,
            -5,
            5
           ],
           "notes": 137,
           "count": 4,
           "share": 0.3186
          }
         ]
        },
        "cadences": 4,
        "antecedent_consequent_pairs": 0,
        "bar_s": 1.6719,
        "phrases": [
         {
          "start_s": 2.589,
          "end_s": 48.431,
          "span_s": 45.842,
          "n_notes": 127,
          "first_midi": 67.0,
          "last_midi": 67.0,
          "novel_span_s": 45.842,
          "repetitions": 1
         },
         {
          "start_s": 48.982,
          "end_s": 54.764,
          "span_s": 5.782,
          "n_notes": 10,
          "first_midi": 62.0,
          "last_midi": 65.0,
          "novel_span_s": 5.782,
          "repetitions": 1
         },
         {
          "start_s": 55.124,
          "end_s": 55.914,
          "span_s": 0.789,
          "n_notes": 2,
          "first_midi": 65.0,
          "last_midi": 65.0,
          "novel_span_s": 0.263,
          "repetitions": 3
         },
         {
          "start_s": 55.879,
          "end_s": 57.992,
          "span_s": 2.113,
          "n_notes": 4,
          "first_midi": 65.0,
          "last_midi": 64.0,
          "novel_span_s": 2.113,
          "repetitions": 1
         },
         {
          "start_s": 58.061,
          "end_s": 59.745,
          "span_s": 1.683,
          "n_notes": 4,
          "first_midi": 65.0,
          "last_midi": 64.0,
          "novel_span_s": 1.683,
          "repetitions": 1
         },
         {
          "start_s": 59.757,
          "end_s": 61.353,
          "span_s": 1.596,
          "n_notes": 5,
          "first_midi": 64.0,
          "last_midi": 67.0,
          "novel_span_s": 1.596,
          "repetitions": 1
         },
         {
          "start_s": 61.486,
          "end_s": 61.579,
          "span_s": 0.093,
          "n_notes": 1,
          "first_midi": 67.0,
          "last_midi": 67.0
         },
         {
          "start_s": 62.775,
          "end_s": 63.356,
          "span_s": 0.58,
          "n_notes": 3,
          "first_midi": 62.0,
          "last_midi": 67.0,
          "novel_span_s": 0.58,
          "repetitions": 1
         },
         {
          "start_s": 63.704,
          "end_s": 65.132,
          "span_s": 1.428,
          "n_notes": 4,
          "first_midi": 62.0,
          "last_midi": 67.0,
          "novel_span_s": 1.428,
          "repetitions": 1
         },
         {
          "start_s": 65.736,
          "end_s": 66.572,
          "span_s": 0.836,
          "n_notes": 2,
          "first_midi": 67.0,
          "last_midi": 67.0
         },
         {
          "start_s": 66.664,
          "end_s": 69.091,
          "span_s": 2.426,
          "n_notes": 6,
          "first_midi": 65.0,
          "last_midi": 65.0,
          "novel_span_s": 2.426,
          "repetitions": 1
         },
         {
          "start_s": 69.114,
          "end_s": 75.175,
          "span_s": 6.06,
          "n_notes": 14,
          "first_midi": 67.0,
          "last_midi": 67.0,
          "novel_span_s": 6.06,
          "repetitions": 1
         },
         {
          "start_s": 75.569,
          "end_s": 76.893,
          "span_s": 1.324,
          "n_notes": 3,
          "first_midi": 60.0,
          "last_midi": 62.0,
          "novel_span_s": 1.324,
          "repetitions": 1
         },
         {
          "start_s": 76.858,
          "end_s": 77.032,
          "span_s": 0.174,
          "n_notes": 1,
          "first_midi": 67.0,
          "last_midi": 67.0
         },
         {
          "start_s": 77.38,
          "end_s": 78.948,
          "span_s": 1.567,
          "n_notes": 4,
          "first_midi": 62.0,
          "last_midi": 67.0,
          "novel_span_s": 1.567,
          "repetitions": 1
         },
         {
          "start_s": 79.157,
          "end_s": 81.351,
          "span_s": 2.194,
          "n_notes": 8,
          "first_midi": 65.0,
          "last_midi": 67.0,
          "novel_span_s": 2.194,
          "repetitions": 1
         },
         {
          "start_s": 81.641,
          "end_s": 86.262,
          "span_s": 4.621,
          "n_notes": 18,
          "first_midi": 67.0,
          "last_midi": 60.0,
          "novel_span_s": 4.621,
          "repetitions": 1
         },
         {
          "start_s": 86.471,
          "end_s": 94.627,
          "span_s": 8.156,
          "n_notes": 33,
          "first_midi": 60.0,
          "last_midi": 64.0,
          "novel_span_s": 8.156,
          "repetitions": 1
         },
         {
          "start_s": 94.97,
          "end_s": 95.225,
          "span_s": 0.255,
          "n_notes": 1,
          "first_midi": 64.0,
          "last_midi": 64.0
         },
         {
          "start_s": 95.666,
          "end_s": 97.721,
          "span_s": 2.055,
          "n_notes": 10,
          "first_midi": 62.0,
          "last_midi": 64.0,
          "novel_span_s": 2.055,
          "repetitions": 1
         },
         {
          "start_s": 98.22,
          "end_s": 104.676,
          "span_s": 6.455,
          "n_notes": 20,
          "first_midi": 67.0,
          "last_midi": 64.0,
          "novel_span_s": 6.455,
          "repetitions": 1
         },
         {
          "start_s": 105.105,
          "end_s": 106.603,
          "span_s": 1.498,
          "n_notes": 6,
          "first_midi": 67.0,
          "last_midi": 67.0,
          "novel_span_s": 1.498,
          "repetitions": 1
         },
         {
          "start_s": 106.998,
          "end_s": 108.298,
          "span_s": 1.3,
          "n_notes": 6,
          "first_midi": 67.0,
          "last_midi": 64.0,
          "novel_span_s": 1.3,
          "repetitions": 1
         },
         {
          "start_s": 108.577,
          "end_s": 112.356,
          "span_s": 3.779,
          "n_notes": 15,
          "first_midi": 64.0,
          "last_midi": 64.0,
          "novel_span_s": 3.779,
          "repetitions": 1
         },
         {
          "start_s": 113.046,
          "end_s": 113.546,
          "span_s": 0.499,
          "n_notes": 2,
          "first_midi": 65.0,
          "last_midi": 67.0
         },
         {
          "start_s": 114.068,
          "end_s": 118.422,
          "span_s": 4.354,
          "n_notes": 13,
          "first_midi": 60.0,
          "last_midi": 64.0,
          "novel_span_s": 4.354,
          "repetitions": 1
         },
         {
          "start_s": 118.805,
          "end_s": 125.214,
          "span_s": 6.409,
          "n_notes": 20,
          "first_midi": 67.0,
          "last_midi": 64.0,
          "novel_span_s": 6.409,
          "repetitions": 1
         },
         {
          "start_s": 125.446,
          "end_s": 126.055,
          "span_s": 0.61,
          "n_notes": 3,
          "first_midi": 67.0,
          "last_midi": 64.0,
          "novel_span_s": 0.61,
          "repetitions": 1
         },
         {
          "start_s": 126.282,
          "end_s": 129.834,
          "span_s": 3.553,
          "n_notes": 14,
          "first_midi": 67.0,
          "last_midi": 76.0,
          "novel_span_s": 3.553,
          "repetitions": 1
         },
         {
          "start_s": 130.357,
          "end_s": 130.682,
          "span_s": 0.325,
          "n_notes": 1,
          "first_midi": 79.0,
          "last_midi": 79.0
         },
         {
          "start_s": 131.216,
          "end_s": 134.536,
          "span_s": 3.32,
          "n_notes": 10,
          "first_midi": 72.0,
          "last_midi": 79.0,
          "novel_span_s": 3.32,
          "repetitions": 1
         },
         {
          "start_s": 134.711,
          "end_s": 135.001,
          "span_s": 0.29,
          "n_notes": 1,
          "first_midi": 79.0,
          "last_midi": 79.0
         },
         {
          "start_s": 135.512,
          "end_s": 138.043,
          "span_s": 2.531,
          "n_notes": 8,
          "first_midi": 79.0,
          "last_midi": 79.0,
          "novel_span_s": 2.531,
          "repetitions": 1
         },
         {
          "start_s": 138.194,
          "end_s": 139.651,
          "span_s": 1.457,
          "n_notes": 5,
          "first_midi": 77.0,
          "last_midi": 77.0,
          "novel_span_s": 1.457,
          "repetitions": 1
         },
         {
          "start_s": 139.947,
          "end_s": 140.063,
          "span_s": 0.116,
          "n_notes": 1,
          "first_midi": 72.0,
          "last_midi": 72.0
         },
         {
          "start_s": 140.852,
          "end_s": 142.437,
          "span_s": 1.585,
          "n_notes": 5,
          "first_midi": 76.0,
          "last_midi": 76.0,
          "novel_span_s": 0.317,
          "repetitions": 5
         },
         {
          "start_s": 142.594,
          "end_s": 144.3,
          "span_s": 1.707,
          "n_notes": 8,
          "first_midi": 72.0,
          "last_midi": 79.0,
          "novel_span_s": 1.707,
          "repetitions": 1
         },
         {
          "start_s": 144.997,
          "end_s": 145.74,
          "span_s": 0.743,
          "n_notes": 4,
          "first_midi": 74.0,
          "last_midi": 76.0,
          "novel_span_s": 0.743,
          "repetitions": 1
         },
         {
          "start_s": 145.949,
          "end_s": 147.354,
          "span_s": 1.405,
          "n_notes": 6,
          "first_midi": 74.0,
          "last_midi": 79.0,
          "novel_span_s": 1.405,
          "repetitions": 1
         },
         {
          "start_s": 147.702,
          "end_s": 148.236,
          "span_s": 0.534,
          "n_notes": 2,
          "first_midi": 77.0,
          "last_midi": 77.0
         },
         {
          "start_s": 148.561,
          "end_s": 149.072,
          "span_s": 0.511,
          "n_notes": 2,
          "first_midi": 77.0,
          "last_midi": 81.0
         },
         {
          "start_s": 149.804,
          "end_s": 150.906,
          "span_s": 1.103,
          "n_notes": 4,
          "first_midi": 76.0,
          "last_midi": 77.0,
          "novel_span_s": 1.103,
          "repetitions": 1
         },
         {
          "start_s": 151.139,
          "end_s": 152.079,
          "span_s": 0.94,
          "n_notes": 3,
          "first_midi": 72.0,
          "last_midi": 77.0,
          "novel_span_s": 0.94,
          "repetitions": 1
         },
         {
          "start_s": 152.416,
          "end_s": 152.509,
          "span_s": 0.093,
          "n_notes": 1,
          "first_midi": 76.0,
          "last_midi": 76.0
         },
         {
          "start_s": 153.02,
          "end_s": 155.643,
          "span_s": 2.624,
          "n_notes": 8,
          "first_midi": 79.0,
          "last_midi": 84.0,
          "novel_span_s": 2.624,
          "repetitions": 1
         },
         {
          "start_s": 155.829,
          "end_s": 155.957,
          "span_s": 0.128,
          "n_notes": 1,
          "first_midi": 76.0,
          "last_midi": 76.0
         },
         {
          "start_s": 156.514,
          "end_s": 158.557,
          "span_s": 2.043,
          "n_notes": 7,
          "first_midi": 84.0,
          "last_midi": 74.0,
          "novel_span_s": 2.043,
          "repetitions": 1
         },
         {
          "start_s": 159.138,
          "end_s": 159.846,
          "span_s": 0.708,
          "n_notes": 5,
          "first_midi": 74.0,
          "last_midi": 74.0,
          "novel_span_s": 0.708,
          "repetitions": 1
         },
         {
          "start_s": 160.554,
          "end_s": 161.205,
          "span_s": 0.65,
          "n_notes": 2,
          "first_midi": 79.0,
          "last_midi": 79.0
         },
         {
          "start_s": 161.773,
          "end_s": 161.831,
          "span_s": 0.058,
          "n_notes": 1,
          "first_midi": 72.0,
          "last_midi": 72.0
         },
         {
          "start_s": 162.226,
          "end_s": 162.412,
          "span_s": 0.186,
          "n_notes": 1,
          "first_midi": 72.0,
          "last_midi": 72.0
         },
         {
          "start_s": 163.445,
          "end_s": 163.503,
          "span_s": 0.058,
          "n_notes": 1,
          "first_midi": 77.0,
          "last_midi": 77.0
         },
         {
          "start_s": 163.944,
          "end_s": 165.669,
          "span_s": 1.724,
          "n_notes": 3,
          "first_midi": 77.0,
          "last_midi": 77.0,
          "novel_span_s": 0.575,
          "repetitions": 3
         },
         {
          "start_s": 166.127,
          "end_s": 166.208,
          "span_s": 0.081,
          "n_notes": 1,
          "first_midi": 76.0,
          "last_midi": 76.0
         },
         {
          "start_s": 166.545,
          "end_s": 167.404,
          "span_s": 0.859,
          "n_notes": 2,
          "first_midi": 77.0,
          "last_midi": 76.0
         },
         {
          "start_s": 167.729,
          "end_s": 167.88,
          "span_s": 0.151,
          "n_notes": 1,
          "first_midi": 77.0,
          "last_midi": 77.0
         },
         {
          "start_s": 168.554,
          "end_s": 168.612,
          "span_s": 0.058,
          "n_notes": 1,
          "first_midi": 81.0,
          "last_midi": 81.0
         },
         {
          "start_s": 169.088,
          "end_s": 169.157,
          "span_s": 0.07,
          "n_notes": 1,
          "first_midi": 76.0,
          "last_midi": 76.0
         },
         {
          "start_s": 169.54,
          "end_s": 169.657,
          "span_s": 0.116,
          "n_notes": 1,
          "first_midi": 76.0,
          "last_midi": 76.0
         },
         {
          "start_s": 170.388,
          "end_s": 170.562,
          "span_s": 0.174,
          "n_notes": 1,
          "first_midi": 76.0,
          "last_midi": 76.0
         },
         {
          "start_s": 172.42,
          "end_s": 172.994,
          "span_s": 0.575,
          "n_notes": 3,
          "first_midi": 79.0,
          "last_midi": 79.0,
          "novel_span_s": 0.192,
          "repetitions": 3
         },
         {
          "start_s": 173.221,
          "end_s": 175.427,
          "span_s": 2.206,
          "n_notes": 6,
          "first_midi": 79.0,
          "last_midi": 79.0,
          "novel_span_s": 2.206,
          "repetitions": 1
         },
         {
          "start_s": 175.554,
          "end_s": 175.671,
          "span_s": 0.116,
          "n_notes": 1,
          "first_midi": 77.0,
          "last_midi": 77.0
         },
         {
          "start_s": 176.762,
          "end_s": 177.575,
          "span_s": 0.813,
          "n_notes": 2,
          "first_midi": 77.0,
          "last_midi": 79.0
         },
         {
          "start_s": 177.702,
          "end_s": 180.303,
          "span_s": 2.601,
          "n_notes": 6,
          "first_midi": 77.0,
          "last_midi": 76.0,
          "novel_span_s": 2.601,
          "repetitions": 1
         }
        ]
       },
       "axes": {
        "singability": 1.0,
        "self_sufficiency": 1.0,
        "transmissibility": 0.8516,
        "reduction_harmonic_interest": 0.9823,
        "piano_melody_recovered": 0.8699
       },
       "failures": [],
       "passes": true,
       "passes_target": false
      },
      "orchestra_lint": {
       "available": false,
       "reason": "SCORE-ONLY TEST. A lint needs a part; released audio has none. This is stated rather than approximated -- there is no honest way to infer a playable part list from a stereo master, and a fabricated one would make the corpus look calibrated when it is not"
      }
     },
     "verdict": {
      "passes": true,
      "law": "A theme must hold as melody plus harmony on one instrument -- the only route nostalgia travels -- and its score must be playable by real players from real notation.",
      "tier": "audio-extracted",
      "evidence": [
       "piano reduction (audio-extracted): singability 1.000, self-sufficiency 1.000, transmissibility 0.852, harmonic interest 0.982",
       "phrase grammar: longest span of NOVEL material 27.42 bars (unbroken 27.42), 1 distinct idea(s), 4 cadence(s), 0 antecedent-consequent pair(s) -- REPORTED, NOT GATED: extraction cannot support these clauses"
      ]
     }
    }
   }
  },
  "melody_bands": {
   "instrument": "melody_bands",
   "version": "melody-bands/1.0",
   "available": true,
   "reason": "",
   "tier": "audio",
   "metrics": {
    "note_density_per_s": 2.6389,
    "note_density_per_sounding_s": 4.3044,
    "step_share": 0.6435,
    "leap_share": 0.0696,
    "interval_class_count": 8,
    "contour_turning_rate": 0.4884,
    "contour_depth": 6.0,
    "phrase_len_s_median": 2.548,
    "phrase_peak_position": 0.0901,
    "harmonization_density": 0.9236,
    "parallel_harmony_share": 0.48,
    "range_semitones": 24.0,
    "distinct_durations": 11
   },
   "bands_used": {
    "class": "ALL",
    "n": 30,
    "why": "the corpus carries no band for purpose class SERENE; falling back to ALL (n=30)",
    "source": "build/audio/exemplars/instruments/MELODY_BANDS.json"
   },
   "verdict": {
    "passes": true,
    "passes_means": "no axis sits BELOW the corpus p10. It is a FLOOR, not a two-sided gate; see axes_above_band",
    "law": "A composed melody must land inside the note-density, interval-mix, contour, phrase-arc, harmonisation and compass bands that the corpus's own melodies occupy -- a few notes slowly played back to back with nothing sounding under them is outside them.",
    "per_axis": [
     {
      "axis": "note_density_per_s",
      "value": 2.6389,
      "p10": 0.3096,
      "p50": 1.7564,
      "p90": 2.5429,
      "band_source": "ALL",
      "band_n": 29,
      "verdict": "ABOVE_BAND"
     },
     {
      "axis": "note_density_per_sounding_s",
      "value": 4.3044,
      "p10": 2.5369,
      "p50": 4.9857,
      "p90": 7.9299,
      "band_source": "ALL",
      "band_n": 29,
      "verdict": "IN_BAND"
     },
     {
      "axis": "step_share",
      "value": 0.6435,
      "p10": 0.4758,
      "p50": 0.6722,
      "p90": 0.8538,
      "band_source": "ALL",
      "band_n": 29,
      "verdict": "IN_BAND"
     },
     {
      "axis": "leap_share",
      "value": 0.0696,
      "p10": 0.0,
      "p50": 0.0562,
      "p90": 0.1418,
      "band_source": "ALL",
      "band_n": 29,
      "verdict": "IN_BAND"
     },
     {
      "axis": "interval_class_count",
      "value": 8,
      "p10": 6.0,
      "p50": 8.0,
      "p90": 11.0,
      "band_source": "ALL",
      "band_n": 29,
      "verdict": "IN_BAND"
     },
     {
      "axis": "contour_turning_rate",
      "value": 0.4884,
      "p10": 0.2529,
      "p50": 0.3861,
      "p90": 0.5027,
      "band_source": "ALL",
      "band_n": 29,
      "verdict": "IN_BAND"
     },
     {
      "axis": "contour_depth",
      "value": 6.0,
      "p10": 4.0,
      "p50": 6.0,
      "p90": 7.0,
      "band_source": "ALL",
      "band_n": 29,
      "verdict": "IN_BAND"
     },
     {
      "axis": "phrase_len_s_median",
      "value": 2.548,
      "p10": 1.8092,
      "p50": 2.914,
      "p90": 13.6532,
      "band_source": "ALL",
      "band_n": 29,
      "verdict": "IN_BAND"
     },
     {
      "axis": "phrase_peak_position",
      "value": 0.0901,
      "p10": 0.0,
      "p50": 0.1535,
      "p90": 0.3499,
      "band_source": "ALL",
      "band_n": 29,
      "verdict": "IN_BAND"
     },
     {
      "axis": "harmonization_density",
      "value": 0.9236,
      "p10": 0.2737,
      "p50": 0.7446,
      "p90": 0.9488,
      "band_source": "ALL",
      "band_n": 27,
      "verdict": "IN_BAND"
     },
     {
      "axis": "parallel_harmony_share",
      "value": 0.48,
      "p10": 0.1842,
      "p50": 0.4286,
      "p90": 0.7056,
      "band_source": "ALL",
      "band_n": 27,
      "verdict": "IN_BAND"
     },
     {
      "axis": "range_semitones",
      "value": 24.0,
      "p10": 7.298,
      "p50": 18.0,
      "p90": 37.8,
      "band_source": "ALL",
      "band_n": 29,
      "verdict": "IN_BAND"
     },
     {
      "axis": "distinct_durations",
      "value": 11,
      "p10": 5.0,
      "p50": 9.0,
      "p90": 12.0,
      "band_source": "ALL",
      "band_n": 29,
      "verdict": "IN_BAND"
     }
    ],
    "axes_below_band": [],
    "axes_above_band": [
     "note_density_per_s"
    ],
    "evidence": [
     "tier(s): ['audio']",
     "line: 2.6389 notes/s, steps 0.6435, leaps 0.0696, turning 0.4884",
     "harmonisation: 0.9236 of sounding time, parallel 0.48 of lead notes",
     "ABOVE the corpus p90 on: note_density_per_s -- not a failure by itself; on the interval axes it is the measurable form of 'they clash'"
    ]
   },
   "detail": {
    "tiers": {
     "audio": {
      "version": "melody-bands/1.0",
      "tier": "audio",
      "path": "D:/audio/benchmark/elevenlabs/Highland_Hearth_2026-08-09T214613.wav",
      "total_s": 180.0,
      "line": {
       "extractor": "harmonic-summation predominant melody (rig's block), pYIN cross-check omitted",
       "voiced_fraction": 0.6369,
       "note_count": 475,
       "note_rate_per_s": 2.6389,
       "analysed_s": 180.0,
       "octave_errors_repaired": 334,
       "octave_repair_share": 0.7032
      },
      "harmonization": {
       "available": true,
       "harmonization_density": 0.9236,
       "three_plus_density": 0.5869,
       "mean_concurrent_voices": 2.665,
       "max_concurrent_voices": 4,
       "n_sounding_voices": 4,
       "voice_names": [
        "bass",
        "alto",
        "tenor",
        "soprano"
       ],
       "folded_doublings": [],
       "sounding_share_of_cue": 0.9744,
       "definition": "share of frames carrying any melodic voice that carry two or more, after octave/unison doublings are folded; grid 50 ms"
      },
      "parallel": {
       "available": true,
       "parallel_harmony_share": 0.48,
       "doubled_share": 0.4989,
       "lead_notes": 475,
       "harmonising_interval_classes": {
        "3": 3,
        "4": 39,
        "5": 66,
        "7": 155,
        "8": 10,
        "9": 26
       },
       "definition": "share of lead notes with another melodic voice sounding a consonant interval [3, 4, 5, 7, 8, 9] (mod 12, octaves excluded) over >= 50% of the note"
      },
      "counter_melody": {
       "available": true,
       "n_melodic_voices": 4,
       "voice_bands": [
        "bass",
        "alto",
        "tenor",
        "soprano"
       ],
       "mean_pairwise_independence": 0.7162,
       "counter_melody_presence": 0.7162,
       "bands_examined": 5,
       "note": "a LOWER bound on voices -- two instruments in one register read as one band"
      },
      "band_note_counts": {
       "bass": 304,
       "tenor": 599,
       "alto": 324,
       "soprano": 170,
       "high": 0
      },
      "extraction_error": "predominant-melody extraction from dense polyphony is an ESTIMATE, not a transcription; harmonization_density is a LOWER BOUND because two instruments in one register read as one band",
      "cached": true
     }
    },
    "axes": {
     "audio": {
      "available": true,
      "note_count": 475,
      "analysed_s": 180.0,
      "sounding_s": 110.353,
      "melodic_coverage": 0.6131,
      "note_density_per_s": 2.6389,
      "note_density_per_sounding_s": 4.3044,
      "step_share": 0.6435,
      "leap_share": 0.0696,
      "repeat_share": 0.4219,
      "interval_class_count": 8,
      "interval_classes": [
       0,
       1,
       2,
       3,
       4,
       5,
       7,
       8
      ],
      "interval_histogram": {
       "0": 200,
       "1": 20,
       "2": 85,
       "3": 48,
       "4": 23,
       "5": 65,
       "7": 30,
       "8": 3
      },
      "contour_turning_rate": 0.4884,
      "contour_depth": 6.0,
      "range_semitones": 24.0,
      "distinct_durations": 11,
      "duration_classes": [
       -8,
       -7,
       -6,
       -5,
       -4,
       -3,
       -2,
       -1,
       0,
       1,
       2
      ],
      "phrase_count": 46,
      "phrase_len_s_median": 2.548,
      "phrase_peak_position": 0.0901,
      "phrase_len_notes_median": 8.0,
      "definitions": {
       "step_share": "|interval| <= 2 semitones (ECON-05, docs/proposals/music/school_grammars/SNES_JRPG_SCHOOL.md:57)",
       "leap_share": "|interval| >= 7 semitones (ECON-05, docs/proposals/music/school_grammars/SNES_JRPG_SCHOOL.md:57)",
       "interval_class_count": "distinct |interval| sizes, capped at 12+. A COUNT, not an entropy -- entropy points the wrong way on this corpus",
       "contour_turning_rate": "direction changes among moving intervals, per note of the line",
       "distinct_durations": "distinct log2 duration classes (mi._dur_class :490); ECON-07 (docs/proposals/music/school_grammars/SNES_JRPG_SCHOOL.md:59) targets <= 4 IN THE HOOK, and this is the WHOLE LINE -- the two are not the same quantity and the comparison is printed, not enforced",
       "phrase_peak_position": "time of the phrase's highest note, normalised 0..1 within the phrase; 0.5 is an arch centred, 1.0 rises to the last note"
      }
     }
    }
   }
  },
  "groove": {
   "instrument": "groove_instrument",
   "version": "groove-instr/1.0",
   "available": true,
   "reason": "",
   "metrics": {
    "pulse_salience_audio": 0.2671,
    "beat_consistency": 0.9683,
    "syncopation_audio": 0.0,
    "offbeat_weight_share": 0.3667,
    "onset_density_per_s": 1.7278,
    "percussive_energy_share": 0.0993,
    "low_band_pulse_regularity": 0.151,
    "sync_score": null,
    "sync_composite": null,
    "pulse_score": null,
    "interlock": null,
    "onset_synchrony": null,
    "onset_synchrony_max": null
   },
   "detail": {
    "audio": {
     "duration_s": 180.0,
     "hop": 256,
     "sr": 22050,
     "beats_per_bar_assumed": 4,
     "subdiv": 4,
     "low_band_energy_share": 0.1809,
     "onset_env_max": 6.879,
     "onsets_detected": 311,
     "tempo_bpm": 139.67,
     "tempo_source": "tracked, prior 143.55",
     "n_beats": 412,
     "ibi_median_s": 0.4296,
     "ibi_spread_frac": 0.0811,
     "low_band_env_max": 12.229,
     "bars_measured": 73,
     "mean_onsets_per_bar": 4.123,
     "card_total_length_s": 240.0
    },
    "purpose_class": "SERENE",
    "tiers": [
     "audio"
    ],
    "bands_available": true,
    "outside_bands": [],
    "honest_label": "MEASURED INSTRUMENT. Nothing here has been listened to. The score tier has no extraction error; the audio tier inherits the beat tracker's grid and says so."
   },
   "verdict": {
    "passes": true,
    "law": "A cue must carry a pulse a listener can feel -- present, steady, and articulated against the metre by voices that tile rather than pile -- so that its rhythm is a structure and never merely a rate.",
    "tier": "audio",
    "evidence": [
     "audio: 311 onsets over 180.0 s = 1.7278/s; pulse salience 0.2671; beat consistency 0.9683 at 139.67 bpm; LHL syncopation 0.0 over 73 bars",
     "every measured audio axis sits inside its corpus band"
    ]
   }
  },
  "harmony_fit": {
   "instrument": "harmony_fit",
   "version": "harmony-fit/1.0",
   "available": false,
   "reason": "HARMONY FIT IS A SCORE INSTRUMENT AND HAS NO AUDIO TIER. Chord-tone agreement, dissonance classification and parallel-perfect detection all require knowing WHICH NOTES ARE SOUNDING, and docs/proposals/music/craft_research/COUNTERPOINT_AND_VOICE_LEADING.md:559-569 puts exactly those on the not-measurable-from-audio list (GAP 1, polyphonic transcription). Pass --plan. A card-only or audio-only tier here would be an invented proxy for the one thing the research says cannot be recovered from a render.",
   "tier": null,
   "metrics": {
    "chord_tone_share_primary": null,
    "chord_tone_share_all": null,
    "dissonance_classifiability": null,
    "tension_mean": null,
    "tension_p90": null,
    "high_tension_time_share": null,
    "harmonic_rhythm_per_min": null,
    "distinct_chords": null,
    "chord_change_entropy": null,
    "non_functional_ratio": null,
    "supported_share": null,
    "parallel_thirds_sixths_share": null,
    "undeclared_parallel_perfects": null,
    "null_percentile_primary": null
   },
   "verdict": {
    "passes": null,
    "law": "A melody is written AGAINST its harmony: its structural tones are members of the chord sounding beneath them at a rate no random draw from its own mode could reach, its non-chord tones are classifiable dissonances, and something is actually sounding that chord while the tune plays it.",
    "per_axis": [],
    "evidence": [
     "HARMONY FIT IS A SCORE INSTRUMENT AND HAS NO AUDIO TIER. Chord-tone agreement, dissonance classification and parallel-perfect detection all require knowing WHICH NOTES ARE SOUNDING, and docs/proposals/music/craft_research/COUNTERPOINT_AND_VOICE_LEADING.md:559-569 puts exactly those on the not-measurable-from-audio list (GAP 1, polyphonic transcription). Pass --plan. A card-only or audio-only tier here would be an invented proxy for the one thing the research says cannot be recovered from a render."
    ]
   },
   "detail": {}
  },
  "loudness_informational": {
   "file": "D:\\audio\\ch02_soundtrack\\CH02_T6_HighlandHearth.wav",
   "cue_class": "SERENE",
   "integrated_lufs": -12.32,
   "target_lufs": -11.55,
   "deviation_lu": -0.77,
   "tolerance_lu": 2.52,
   "clears_target": true,
   "loudness_range_lu": 4.1,
   "lra_band": [
    1.49,
    21.02
   ],
   "clears_lra_band": true,
   "true_peak_dbtp": -0.02,
   "ceiling_dbtp": -1.0,
   "clears_ceiling": false,
   "target_resolved_from": "_default",
   "target_borrowed": true,
   "policy_derived": true,
   "available": true,
   "gate": false,
   "why_not_a_gate": "the corpus's own masters are pushed into the ceiling -- MIX_POLICY.json _why_ceiling says so, and the control proves it: EX_022 Wind Scene, a track Josh named, reads -7.69 LUFS against a -12.18 target and +0.25 dBTP against a -1.0 ceiling. A gate that fails the music he loves is measuring the wrong population. The -1.0 dBTP ceiling is a delivery convention for OUR renders, which sum with SFX at runtime; a downloaded commercial-engine master is not under that contract until we master it ourselves",
   "corpus_class_distribution": {
    "n": 30,
    "target_lufs": -11.55,
    "min_lufs": -16.34,
    "max_lufs": -7.63,
    "lra_median": 5.12
   },
   "competing_borrow": {
    "class": "MELANCHOLIC",
    "target_lufs": -13.95,
    "n": 4,
    "why_printed": "SERENE has two defensible borrows and they differ by about 2.4 LU. Neither is a measurement of a serene corpus, because there is no serene corpus. Both are printed so the disagreement is visible."
   }
  },
  "quotation_screen": {
   "label": "benchmark_track",
   "verdict": "CLEAR",
   "hits": [],
   "advisories": [],
   "candidate_interval_count": 474,
   "signatures_screened": 13,
   "seed_set_gaps": [
    "LoZ Overworld main phrase",
    "SM64 Main Theme (Bob-omb Battlefield)",
    "SM64 Dire Dire Docks",
    "SMW Athletic",
    "SMB Underwater",
    "SMB3 Overworld",
    "ALttP Hyrule Castle",
    "ALttP Kakariko Village",
    "OoT Title",
    "Hyrule Field",
    "Gerudo Valley",
    "Great Fairy's Fountain",
    "MM Astral Observatory",
    "WW Grandma's Theme"
   ],
   "_zero_means": "no SEED signature matched. The seed set is partial and its named gaps are listed; CLEAR is not a clean-room certificate.",
   "available": true,
   "intervals_screened": 474,
   "honest_limit": "the extracted line is an ESTIMATE from dense polyphony, so a real quote can be missed by extraction error and a spurious run can be produced by it. CLEAR here is not a clean-room certificate -- the seed signature set is partial and names its own gaps in seed_set_gaps"
  }
 },
 "wall_verdict": {
  "instruments_that_could_decide": 9,
  "passing": 8,
  "per_instrument": {
   "cycle_law": true,
   "layer_census": true,
   "hook_presence": true,
   "noise_structure": true,
   "melodic_intelligence": false,
   "dynamic_arc": true,
   "summit_tests": true,
   "melody_bands": true,
   "groove_instrument": true
  },
  "blind_spots": [
   {
    "instrument": "harmony_fit",
    "tier": "NEEDS-SCORE",
    "reason": "HARMONY FIT IS A SCORE INSTRUMENT AND HAS NO AUDIO TIER. Chord-tone agreement, dissonance classification and parallel-perfect detection all require knowing WHICH NOTES ARE SOUNDING, and docs/proposals/music/craft_research/COUNTERPOINT_AND_VOICE_LEADING.md:559-569 puts exactly those on the not-measurable-from-audio list (GAP 1, polyphonic transcription). Pass --plan. A card-only or audio-only tier here would be an invented proxy for the one thing the research says cannot be recovered from a render.",
    "recoverable": false,
    "how": "audio only; the NEEDS-SCORE instruments are unrecoverable for this engine and stay blind spots on every row"
   },
   {
    "instrument": "(none exists)",
    "tier": "UNMEASURED",
    "reason": "carrier migration -- the melody passed BETWEEN instruments on its returns -- no instrument in the battery identifies WHICH instrument is carrying the tune at a given moment. `instr_melody_bands` extracts ONE predominant line and folds octave doublings; `instr_hook_presence` sees the motif return but not who plays it. Source separation would be the honest route and nothing in this program uses it on the melodic layer.",
    "recoverable": false,
    "how": "the single clause Josh named most specifically on 2026-08-09 is graded by EAR ONLY. No wall verdict may be read as evidence for or against it."
   },
   {
    "instrument": "(none exists)",
    "tier": "UNMEASURED",
    "reason": "does the ending SETTLE and hand off to the next track -- `feature_rig.loop_seam` reads the seam and whether a fade was baked in, which is a different question from whether the last phrase resolves. Nothing reads cadence.",
    "recoverable": false,
    "how": "graded by ear. The seam measurement is reported and must not stand in for it."
   }
  ],
  "excluded_from_verdict": [
   {
    "measurement": "loudness_informational",
    "why": "it fails the corpus; see measurements.loudness_informational.why_not_a_gate"
   }
  ],
  "what_a_pass_is_not": "Nothing here is a judgement of quality and no listening test stands behind any of it. Three of the four instruments looked for Josh's defect in their own domain and did not find it: the cycle law passes 17 of the 18 tracks he rejected (within-album AUC 0.501), the noise detector fires on 0 of 18 across both tiers with nothing clearing the multiplicity bar, and the layer census saturates near 8 streams where a real cue runs 24 to 40 parts, so it cannot adjudicate the layer clause at all. Sensory roughness came back at chance (0.4963). Structural yield is the axis that separates, and it separates our generator from real music, not good music from filler."
 },
 "elapsed_s": 50.5
}

Generated by harness/site/structure_site.py — the URL path is the repo path. review root