BRD_0036 — Creatures and fauna - species base (Ch 3, Manggarai) — Flores Island leaf candidate sheet
GENERATED FILE. Rendered from MANIFEST.csv, PLATES.csv, RECS.csv and this board's content.json by harness/boards/render_board.py --board BRD_0036. Do not hand-edit; edit the sources.
board_shape leaf_candidate_sheet (row grain) — 5 rows × up to 4 candidates — approval_state critics_running — private
generation_class living — care_tier standard — generation_tier region_standard — decay_stage n_a
the four adversarial critics have NOT run on this plate set; critic_verdicts is empty and marketing_eligible computes false
every recommended_candidate in RECS.csv is PROVISIONAL until the REC vision pass runs
ROW:cr0012-water-buffalo-study
title: CR_0012 — the domestic water buffalo, species study
caption: creature · plate role study · 4 candidates
canon_id CR_0012 in T0_Creature_Roster/Sheet1 — canon_ref entity:CR_0012
citations: SRC_00203, SRC_00469 (rows of registries/T0_Source_Material_Registry)
lane G · care_tier standard · protected false · care read from DECLARED. T0_Creature_Roster carries no care_tier column; it carries cultural_depiction_required and cultural_care_register instead. Standard is read off cultural_care_register being empty or ordinary on this row while cultural_depiction_required is TRUE, which is the ordinary-fauna-with-a-cultural-role case. protected is DECLARED false for the same reason. The registry gap is boarded as finding F-3.
recommended candidate: 1 (PROVISIONAL)
care: care_tier standard, DECLARED. combat_permission on this row is NONE, so no plate stages the animal as an enemy or a hunt. The ceremonial weight is REAL and is carried honestly elsewhere — the bull-sacrifice thread is the chapter's Thread 14 anchor and the region page carries the rite at full weight — but the collective-attribution law puts the specific buffalo slaughter with the Keo, so this Manggarai-ground species plate stages the animal at work and the sacrificial staging is left to a row whose people it belongs to.
canon_note: registries/T0_Creature_Roster, row CR_0012 — creature_name 'Water buffalo (Flores domesticated)', scientific_name Bubalus bubalis, chapters_present CH_03, combat_permission NONE, thread_anchor Thread 14, cultural_significance 'Thread 14 Blood Sacrifice anchor (the Bull-Sacrifice weaving, Weaving 11); agricultural + ceremonial', notes 'domesticated'. docs/spine/CH_03.md:242 — the Asset anchors line names 'the water buffalo (CR_0012, the bull-sacrifice animal of Weaving 11 / Thread 14 Blood Sacrifice and a labor animal, combat_permission none)'. _source/02_Tier_2_Region_Pages/flores_island.md:1599-1602 — the Flores anchor for the cross-cultural sacrifice weave is 'the buffalo slaughter whose shared meat and spilled blood wet the earth so the soil does not shake', which is Keo-attributed and is why this plate stages the ANIMAL and its working life rather than a rite.
REC verdict REGENERATE_ALL
REC reason: No candidate carries the wide backward horn sweep that is this animal's diagnostic, and every candidate puts a second head somewhere in the frame.
REC defects: Short upcurved horns from a tufted poll on all four; the two conditioned candidates lay a severed-looking head and neck on the ground at the animal's feet, which no study row should ever show; the two unconditioned candidates double the head on the standing animal. The bare slate hide, the level back and the smooth un-humped forequarter are correct throughout and should be kept.
O1 D1-15/CR_0012/study__38c878e2aaf6.png sha256 833fba9cccf66f59... plate PLT_M0024_1 licence record docs/licence_records/art_boards_plates/PLT_M0024_1.json
O2 D1-15/CR_0012/study__6da5f6861187.png sha256 b6ae94cfeabcd290... plate PLT_M0024_2 licence record docs/licence_records/art_boards_plates/PLT_M0024_2.json
O3 D1-15/CR_0012/study__45ac2f07233c.png sha256 9f0df9c8087b1dcb... plate PLT_M0024_3 licence record docs/licence_records/art_boards_plates/PLT_M0024_3.json
O4 D1-15/CR_0012/study__edef887c513a.png sha256 e9610f39bf2c1c41... plate PLT_M0024_4 licence record docs/licence_records/art_boards_plates/PLT_M0024_4.json
ROW:cr0013-java-sparrow-study
title: CR_0013 — the Java sparrow of the field margins, species study
caption: creature · plate role study · 4 candidates
canon_id CR_0013 in T0_Creature_Roster/Sheet1 — canon_ref entity:CR_0013
citations: SRC_00203, SRC_00469 (rows of registries/T0_Source_Material_Registry)
lane G · care_tier standard · protected false · care read from DECLARED. T0_Creature_Roster carries no care_tier column; it carries cultural_depiction_required and cultural_care_register instead. Standard is read off cultural_care_register being empty or ordinary on this row while cultural_depiction_required is TRUE, which is the ordinary-fauna-with-a-cultural-role case. protected is DECLARED false for the same reason. The registry gap is boarded as finding F-3.
recommended candidate: 2 (PROVISIONAL)
care: care_tier standard, DECLARED, and this row's hard_line_anchors cell is the settled EMPTY value with its reason written in — no hard line applies. The bird is ordinary living fauna of the worked field margin. It stays wild in every read: the species' real modern status is a caged-songbird trade and the region's own posture on its other flagship bird is 'real ecological weight, never a caged prize', so no plate stages it captive.
canon_note: registries/T0_Creature_Roster, row CR_0013 — creature_name 'Java sparrow', scientific_name Lonchura oryzivora, chapters_present CH_03, cultural_significance 'rice-field bird (with pollinator finches)', hard_line_anchors '(settled EMPTY - no hard line applies)', notes 'bond-lite'. docs/spine/CH_03.md:242 — the Asset anchors line names Java sparrow (CR_0013) in the Ch-3 creatures_and_fauna set. _source/02_Tier_2_Region_Pages/flores_island.md:79-80 — compang_lingko_fields is terrain agricultural with a lodok fan of roughly five hundred metres, which is the ground this bird works.
REC verdict PICK_READY — recommended candidate O2
REC reason: O2 gives one crisp specimen whose thick pink bill, black cap and clean white cheek patch all read at full size, with the flock behind it for context and nothing floating or merged anywhere in the frame.
REC defects: O1 merges the two birds' tails; O3 leaves the right-hand bird's feet gripping nothing and sets pale posts in the far field; O4 scatters dark specks near the stem. O2's residue: the ground flock is soft.
O1 D1-15/CR_0013/study__22bbb1d9678e.png sha256 f7b29d676b35b73c... plate PLT_M0025_1 licence record docs/licence_records/art_boards_plates/PLT_M0025_1.json
O3 D1-15/CR_0013/study__3ced14583928.png sha256 70644865103fe4b2... plate PLT_M0025_3 licence record docs/licence_records/art_boards_plates/PLT_M0025_3.json
O4 D1-15/CR_0013/study__03769f146f11.png sha256 78acdd0fc8f5aae3... plate PLT_M0025_4 licence record docs/licence_records/art_boards_plates/PLT_M0025_4.json
ROW:cr0014-flores-pig-study
title: CR_0014 — the domesticated Flores pig, species study
caption: creature · plate role study · 4 candidates
canon_id CR_0014 in T0_Creature_Roster/Sheet1 — canon_ref entity:CR_0014
citations: SRC_00203, SRC_00469 (rows of registries/T0_Source_Material_Registry)
lane G · care_tier standard · protected false · care read from DECLARED. T0_Creature_Roster carries no care_tier column; it carries cultural_depiction_required and cultural_care_register instead. Standard is read off cultural_care_register being empty or ordinary on this row while cultural_depiction_required is TRUE, which is the ordinary-fauna-with-a-cultural-role case. protected is DECLARED false for the same reason. The registry gap is boarded as finding F-3.
recommended candidate: 1 (PROVISIONAL)
care: care_tier standard, DECLARED. The animal is village-kept livestock and the plate stages it alive and at ease. The ceremonial weight is genuinely present in this island's record and is carried at full weight where it belongs — the feast-precedence rite is KEO, and the collective-attribution law keeps it Keo-attributed rather than staged on Manggarai ground, so this species row is the animal and not the rite. The same record's provision for the incorporated Muslim community is protected by §17.1 exactly as the Keo are, which is a second reason the sacrifice is not staged casually here.
canon_note: registries/T0_Creature_Roster, row CR_0014 — creature_name 'Flores pig (domesticated)', scientific_name Sus scrofa, chapters_present CH_03, cultural_significance 'ceremonial significance', hard_line_anchors HL_0002, notes 'domesticated'. docs/spine/CH_03.md:242 — the Asset anchors line names Flores pig (CR_0014). _source/02_Tier_2_Region_Pages/flores_island.md:453-457 — the pig's ceremonial weight in this island's record is real and is Keo: the nado mere feast precedence apportions the parts of the sacrificial animal's head by rank, and the record carries its own provision for the incorporated Muslim community whose §17.1 protection runs with the Keo's.
REC verdict MIXED — recommended candidate O1
REC reason: O1 is the only candidate with no floating disembodied head and no sheet metal on the shelter: a sow and three piglets on bare earth under a hand-built pole and thatch lean-to.
REC defects: O3 hangs a headless pig's head in the air above the hills; O4 lays a second head on the shelter roof; O2 roofs the shelter in what reads as corrugated sheet and stretches the sow's body. O1's residue: the piglets' markings run pinker than the black and rust of the sow.
O2 D1-15/CR_0014/study__779375c08cee.png sha256 59959e39a3e58ff2... plate PLT_M0026_2 licence record docs/licence_records/art_boards_plates/PLT_M0026_2.json
O3 D1-15/CR_0014/study__8e4da3d1feea.png sha256 f03b32d38f5716cd... plate PLT_M0026_3 licence record docs/licence_records/art_boards_plates/PLT_M0026_3.json
O4 D1-15/CR_0014/study__168599a66a17.png sha256 1fe45b3355d93213... plate PLT_M0026_4 licence record docs/licence_records/art_boards_plates/PLT_M0026_4.json
ROW:cr0015-waterfall-fauna-cohort-study
title: CR_0015 — the sacred waterfall fauna cohort, observe-only study
caption: creature · plate role study · 4 candidates
canon_id CR_0015 in T0_Creature_Roster/Sheet1 — canon_ref entity:CR_0015
citations: SRC_00203, SRC_00469 (rows of registries/T0_Source_Material_Registry)
lane P · care_tier elevated · protected true · care read from DECLARED ELEVATED, and the basis is on the row itself rather than argued: T0_Creature_Roster row CR_0015 carries combat_permission PROTECTED, cultural_care_register 'CVD §6', cultural_significance 'Manggarai water-spirit tradition at waterfalls', hard_line_anchors HL_0005;HL_0002, and notes 'OBSERVE-only group per CVD §6'. A row whose own combat_permission cell reads PROTECTED carries protected true here.
recommended candidate: 3 (PROVISIONAL)
care: ELEVATED, and the elevation is read off the row's own combat_permission PROTECTED cell. The cohort is OBSERVE-ONLY per CVD §6, so no plate stages capture, handling, killing or collection. The eel is the load-bearing member: the region's record holds that an eel in a stream may be the temporary material form of a place-spirit, doubly spiritual as a snake-shaped animal bound to potent water, and that harming one carries a real cost the healer's craft remedies. That belief is carried as the tradition holds it — the animal at rest, unremarkable and unmolested, which is exactly what the belief protects — and never as a debunk and never as a monster.
rekey_basis: lane declared G in the pack, DISPATCHED as P by the executor ruling above
released_by_ruling: EXECUTOR RULING (2026-08-04, the Ch-3 generate lane). The pack declares lane G on this row at care_tier elevated. CONCEPT_ART_PROGRAM 4.4, made arithmetic at harness/read_boards.py T-LANE-CARE, refuses that combination by construction: a living-tradition care tier can never dispatch to Lane G, and the composer emits a Lane-R plate request instead. The care value is NOT what moves -- it is argued on the row and the live T0_Creature_Roster row carries cultural_depiction_required TRUE -- so the LANE moves, to P. Lane P is director ruling R-E's care-by-verification release, authored for exactly this class ('the four v2 HELD entity-care rows RELEASE for dispatch under care-by-verification; care_conditions binding on the row; the image critics verify outputs against each entity's roster care register'), and it is the landed treatment of the BRD_0025/BRD_0026 elevated crowd rows.
lane_p_underlay: Lane P here is generation under a DECLARED verification discipline, not a paintover underlay: the plate is generated on the region mechanism and the image critics verify the output against this entity's own roster care register (cultural_depiction_required TRUE on the live T0_Creature_Roster row). That is the care-by-verification release R-E authored, and the verification is what the row is barred on if it fails.
canon_note: registries/T0_Creature_Roster, row CR_0015 — creature_name 'Sacred waterfall fauna cohort', species_class 'amphibian/insect', chapters_present CH_03, combat_permission PROTECTED, notes 'OBSERVE-only group per CVD §6'. docs/spine/CH_03.md:242 — the Asset anchors line names 'the sacred waterfall fauna cohort (CR_0015, protected)'. _source/02_Tier_2_Region_Pages/flores_island.md:299-304 — the eel-form place-spirit is the region's restraint-and-consequence case: an eel in a stream may be a place-spirit's temporary material form, and a person who injures one confesses to a healer, so the reflex to kill a creature carries an unseen cost. _source/02_Tier_2_Region_Pages/flores_island.md:139-141 — the wet-margin flora is cloud-forest fig, bamboo, rattan, wild tuber and taro with the volcanic-highland botanicals the healer traditions use.
REC verdict MIXED — recommended candidate O3
REC reason: O3 is the only cohort with no duplicated or merged animal, and the only one where the small fish sit at the water's edge rather than stranded on dry gravel.
REC defects: O4 stacks three frogs into one another on the moss and lumps the eel's head; O1 and O2 leave the shoal lying on dry stones, which reads as dead fish. O3's residue: the eel's head is small and its face vague.
O1 D1-15/CR_0015/study__c93a6db4dcad.png sha256 6ecd14c2f29cb2a3... plate PLT_M0027_1 licence record docs/licence_records/art_boards_plates/PLT_M0027_1.json
O2 D1-15/CR_0015/study__aa6b06916ce8.png sha256 5b9f63e1b59111e5... plate PLT_M0027_2 licence record docs/licence_records/art_boards_plates/PLT_M0027_2.json
O4 D1-15/CR_0015/study__167d4759d69b.png sha256 0395389142653966... plate PLT_M0027_4 licence record docs/licence_records/art_boards_plates/PLT_M0027_4.json
ROW:cr0016-orb-weaver-on-the-centre-stone
title: CR_0016 — the Flores orb-weaver on the lodok centre-stone
caption: creature · plate role detail · 4 candidates
canon_id CR_0016 in T0_Creature_Roster/Sheet1 — canon_ref entity:CR_0016
citations: SRC_00203, SRC_00469 (rows of registries/T0_Source_Material_Registry)
lane P · care_tier elevated · protected false · care read from DECLARED ELEVATED. T0_Creature_Roster row CR_0016 carries combat_permission PROTECTED, hard_line_anchors HL_0005;HL_0002, thread_anchor 'Thread 11;Thread 13' and a cultural_significance cell naming the spider as the material form a Manggarai land-owner spirit consumes to give its sign. A creature that IS a living tradition's sign carries the elevated read; protected is DECLARED false because the subject is the animal and the stone rather than a protected settlement.
recommended candidate: 1 (PROVISIONAL)
care: ELEVATED. This spider is a LIVING TRADITION'S SIGN, not a set-dress bug: the Manggarai lord of the land takes the orb-weaver's form on a field's centre-stone to say the land wants its festival, and the record is explicit that this owner is SOLEMN and never a trickster. The plate therefore holds the animal at dignity and stillness and stages no menace, no web-horror register and no jump-scare. The rhyme with the field geometry is left to READ rather than declared: the web and the radiating boundary lines are simply both in frame, which is the show-rather-than-tell line the whole chapter is built on and also the Thread 13 sacred-geometry anchor.
rekey_basis: lane declared G in the pack, DISPATCHED as P by the executor ruling above
released_by_ruling: EXECUTOR RULING (2026-08-04, the Ch-3 generate lane). The pack declares lane G on this row at care_tier elevated. CONCEPT_ART_PROGRAM 4.4, made arithmetic at harness/read_boards.py T-LANE-CARE, refuses that combination by construction: a living-tradition care tier can never dispatch to Lane G, and the composer emits a Lane-R plate request instead. The care value is NOT what moves -- it is argued on the row and the live T0_Creature_Roster row carries cultural_depiction_required TRUE -- so the LANE moves, to P. Lane P is director ruling R-E's care-by-verification release, authored for exactly this class ('the four v2 HELD entity-care rows RELEASE for dispatch under care-by-verification; care_conditions binding on the row; the image critics verify outputs against each entity's roster care register'), and it is the landed treatment of the BRD_0025/BRD_0026 elevated crowd rows.
lane_p_underlay: Lane P here is generation under a DECLARED verification discipline, not a paintover underlay: the plate is generated on the region mechanism and the image critics verify the output against this entity's own roster care register (cultural_depiction_required TRUE on the live T0_Creature_Roster row). That is the care-by-verification release R-E authored, and the verification is what the row is barred on if it fails.
canon_note: registries/T0_Creature_Roster, row CR_0016 — creature_name 'Flores orb-weaver spider', chapters_present CH_02;CH_03, combat_permission PROTECTED, cultural_significance 'the orb-weaver is the material form the mori de tana consumes to give its lodok-stone sign - the mori de tana a solemn owner counted among the ancestors of the land, never a trickster'. _source/02_Tier_2_Region_Pages/flores_island.md:559-562 — 'mori de tana, the lord of the land (Manggarai) ... a spider appears on a field's lodok center-stone and walks a slow circle to say the land wants its festival. It consumes CR_0016 (the Flores orb-weaver) as its material form and is a solemn owner, never a trickster'. _source/02_Tier_2_Region_Pages/flores_island.md:411-413 — the named lingko with its ritual centre-stone, the lodok, and the tu'a teno who reads the field's signs, the spider among them. docs/spine/CH_03.md:242 — the Asset anchors line names 'the Flores orb-weaver (CR_0016, the lingko spider-web resonance)'.
REC verdict REGENERATE_ALL
REC reason: All four hang an excellent web and an excellent spider over English downland, so the plate is in the wrong country even though the subject is correct.
REC defects: Rolling green pasture, hedge lines and a field wall behind the stone on every candidate; the stone itself reads as a random glacial boulder rather than as a flat-topped ceremonial slab.
O1 D1-15/CR_0016/detail__6781c2a69173.png sha256 c11f0fcc95c99a75... plate PLT_M0028_1 licence record docs/licence_records/art_boards_plates/PLT_M0028_1.json
O2 D1-15/CR_0016/detail__324ab27a688e.png sha256 e38e7254798ff4d9... plate PLT_M0028_2 licence record docs/licence_records/art_boards_plates/PLT_M0028_2.json
O3 D1-15/CR_0016/detail__4e3b6364ed73.png sha256 86fb9d4aee84f294... plate PLT_M0028_3 licence record docs/licence_records/art_boards_plates/PLT_M0028_3.json
O4 D1-15/CR_0016/detail__d57cb06fd724.png sha256 11924ad2507c228f... plate PLT_M0028_4 licence record docs/licence_records/art_boards_plates/PLT_M0028_4.json
Generated by harness/site/structure_site.py — the URL path is the repo path. review root