GENERATED FILE. Rendered from MANIFEST.csv, PLATES.csv, RECS.csv and this board's content.json by harness/boards/render_board.py --board BRD_0031. Do not hand-edit; edit the sources.
board_shape leaf_candidate_sheet (row grain) — 3 rows × up to 4 candidates — approval_state critics_running — private
generation_class living — care_tier standard — generation_tier region_hero — decay_stage present
the four adversarial critics have NOT run on this plate set; critic_verdicts is empty and marketing_eligible computes false
every recommended_candidate in RECS.csv is PROVISIONAL until the REC vision pass runs
ROW:mama-klaras-falls-ritual-chamber-section
title: Mama Klara's waterfall — the ritual chamber, cut in section
caption: site_layout · plate role layout_plan · 4 candidates
canon_id mama_klaras_waterfall in build/zones/flores_island.csv — canon_ref zone:mama_klaras_waterfall@flores_island|site:VS_CH03_001|beat:CH03_B02
citations: SRC_00203, SRC_00469, SRC_00457, SRC_00230 (rows of registries/T0_Source_Material_Registry)
lane G · care_tier standard · protected false · care read from READ from build/zones/flores_island.csv, the row's own care_tier and protected cells, which harness/regen_zone_catalog.py carries verbatim from the region page Zone Catalog.
recommended candidate: 1 (PROVISIONAL)
care: Zone care_tier standard, protected false, read from the mama_klaras_waterfall row. The site is VS_CH03_001, a recharge_ritual that permanently raises the vril-capacity floor, and the recharge is the ONLY surface through which the vril substrate is shown, so the water stays physically lit (art bible field 2: impossible-light clause NONE PROPOSED). The ngoeng-de-tana form is living Manggarai ritual practice: these three rows stage the ROCK, the WATER and the PATH, and the rite itself is staged only on the beat frames that the spine gives it.
canon_note: docs/spine/CH_03.md:83-84 — the site row states mama_klaras_waterfall is terrain water_body with functions learning and transformation, vril_density anchor, climactic_affordance threshold, protected false, and its env line names 'the ritual-recharge waterfall and its caverns - the permanent capacity-floor raise, distinct from Ch 2's passive recharge'. _source/02_Tier_2_Region_Pages/flores_island.md:59 — the Zone Catalog sizes the site as 'ritual falls + cavern 70x50' at meters_per_vertex 2, build_priority 'P1 (capacity-floor raise)'. registries/T0_Vril_Site_Registry, row VS_CH03_001 — canonical_status LOCKED, site_name "Mama Klara's waterfall ritual site", chapter 3. _source/02_Tier_2_Region_Pages/flores_island.md:133-135 — both region vril sites are waterfalls, which AssetGen section 2 routes to TERRAIN rather than to the generative mesh backend, so this plate is a terrain-and-rock read.
REC verdict REGENERATE_ALL
REC reason: All four render the falls as an eye-level view from in front, so the chamber behind the water, which is the only thing this drawing exists to show, is never opened.
REC defects: No candidate carries a cut plane or a hatched cut face. O1 adds scribbled marks across the top of the fall and a white plume artefact; O2 lays a paved stone apron at the pool edge; O4 sets a shaped standing stone at the lower right where the row admits no built shrine, altar or platform.
O1 D1-03/mama_klaras_waterfall/layout_plan__6ef3942eba0d.png sha256 5e801c7bab3cdece... plate PLT_M0001_1 licence record docs/licence_records/art_boards_plates/PLT_M0001_1.json
O2 D1-03/mama_klaras_waterfall/layout_plan__a322b3b84bf3.png sha256 e089c263a6b87aa3... plate PLT_M0001_2 licence record docs/licence_records/art_boards_plates/PLT_M0001_2.json
O3 D1-03/mama_klaras_waterfall/layout_plan__f8a1d7f84729.png sha256 76475c4b6a56f718... plate PLT_M0001_3 licence record docs/licence_records/art_boards_plates/PLT_M0001_3.json
O4 D1-03/mama_klaras_waterfall/layout_plan__c5a8b081dd2c.png sha256 40e83ecf004351e7... plate PLT_M0001_4 licence record docs/licence_records/art_boards_plates/PLT_M0001_4.json
ROW:mama-klaras-falls-approach-and-pool-plan
title: Mama Klara's waterfall — approach, pool and spray margin in plan
caption: site_layout · plate role layout_plan · 4 candidates
canon_id mama_klaras_waterfall in build/zones/flores_island.csv — canon_ref zone:mama_klaras_waterfall@flores_island|site:VS_CH03_001
citations: SRC_00203, SRC_00469, SRC_00457, SRC_00230 (rows of registries/T0_Source_Material_Registry)
lane G · care_tier standard · protected false · care read from READ from build/zones/flores_island.csv, the row's own care_tier and protected cells, which harness/regen_zone_catalog.py carries verbatim from the region page Zone Catalog.
recommended candidate: 4 (PROVISIONAL)
care: Zone care_tier standard, protected false, read from the mama_klaras_waterfall row. The site is VS_CH03_001, a recharge_ritual that permanently raises the vril-capacity floor, and the recharge is the ONLY surface through which the vril substrate is shown, so the water stays physically lit (art bible field 2: impossible-light clause NONE PROPOSED). The ngoeng-de-tana form is living Manggarai ritual practice: these three rows stage the ROCK, the WATER and the PATH, and the rite itself is staged only on the beat frames that the spine gives it.
canon_note: _source/02_Tier_2_Region_Pages/flores_island.md:59 — area_bounds 'ritual falls + cavern 70x50', footfall_surface water-shallow with a stone secondary, environment_grammar_refs EG_0008;EG_0009. docs/spine/CH_03.md:84 — the site hosts CH03_B02 and is layered L1 and L3, so the plan owes a walkable approach and a place to stand through a long ritual. docs/art_bibles/flores_island.md:102-107 — the scale rule reads off meters_per_vertex, which is 2 at this zone, so the plan may carry two-metre detail and no finer.
REC verdict MIXED — recommended candidate O4
REC reason: O4 is the only plan free of drawn annotation: the others carry a ruled dashed guideline, a red seal-like stamp or scribbled text on the sheet, and this one reads as painted terrain throughout.
REC defects: O1 and O3 carry a red stamp mark and faint lettering; O3 also renders the bank steps as a sawn-timber stair with regular treads and sets a pale bowl on the margin; O2 lays a large dressed rectangular slab beside the pool. O4's residue: the upper bowl reads flat and the pool colour runs bluer than the region's water elsewhere.
O1 D1-03/mama_klaras_waterfall/layout_plan__7996e39fe492.png sha256 298b4fcdfb66016b... plate PLT_M0002_1 licence record docs/licence_records/art_boards_plates/PLT_M0002_1.json
O2 D1-03/mama_klaras_waterfall/layout_plan__49f2838fbd6e.png sha256 2a6716bcbc772e3a... plate PLT_M0002_2 licence record docs/licence_records/art_boards_plates/PLT_M0002_2.json
O3 D1-03/mama_klaras_waterfall/layout_plan__ac919bdfa004.png sha256 221e4b8a0bb951c8... plate PLT_M0002_3 licence record docs/licence_records/art_boards_plates/PLT_M0002_3.json
title: Mama Klara's waterfall — establishing, from the approach path at eye level
caption: region_look · plate role establishing · 4 candidates
canon_id mama_klaras_waterfall in build/zones/flores_island.csv — canon_ref zone:mama_klaras_waterfall@flores_island|site:VS_CH03_001|beat:CH03_B02
citations: SRC_00203, SRC_00469, SRC_00457, SRC_00230 (rows of registries/T0_Source_Material_Registry)
lane G · care_tier standard · protected false · care read from READ from build/zones/flores_island.csv, the row's own care_tier and protected cells, which harness/regen_zone_catalog.py carries verbatim from the region page Zone Catalog.
recommended candidate: 2 (PROVISIONAL)
care: Zone care_tier standard, protected false, read from the mama_klaras_waterfall row. The site is VS_CH03_001, a recharge_ritual that permanently raises the vril-capacity floor, and the recharge is the ONLY surface through which the vril substrate is shown, so the water stays physically lit (art bible field 2: impossible-light clause NONE PROPOSED). The ngoeng-de-tana form is living Manggarai ritual practice: these three rows stage the ROCK, the WATER and the PATH, and the rite itself is staged only on the beat frames that the spine gives it.
canon_note: docs/spine/CH_03.md:84 — climactic_affordance threshold, so the establishing read owes a THRESHOLD composition: the frame is divided by the water into an outside and an inside. _source/02_Tier_2_Region_Pages/flores_island.md:139-141 — the region's flora baseline is monsoon and cloud forest, figs, bamboo, rattan, wild tuber and taro, and the volcanic-highland botanicals the healer traditions use. docs/spine/CH_03.md:26 — the beat's own weight: the healer 'leads the child down to her waterfall', so the approach reads as a descent.
REC verdict MIXED — recommended candidate O2
REC reason: O2 is the only one of the four that carries no intruding object: the fall, the stone-lipped pool, the tree ferns and the dark recess behind the water all read, in dry-season raking light.
REC defects: O1 sets an amber moulded-looking blob on the wet rock shelf; O3 pushes the whole frame to saturated monsoon green against the region's dry-season register; O4 places a shaped pale monolith at the lower right, which the row does not admit. O2's residue: the far bank foliage is soft and the plunge basin edge is vague.
O1 D1-03/mama_klaras_waterfall/establishing__6e9c2d101f91.png sha256 1bd0ed42f35e3851... plate PLT_M0003_1 licence record docs/licence_records/art_boards_plates/PLT_M0003_1.json