BRD_0028 — Creatures and fauna - species base (D1-15) — Flores Island leaf candidate sheet
GENERATED FILE. Rendered from MANIFEST.csv, PLATES.csv, RECS.csv and this board's content.json by harness/boards/render_board.py --board BRD_0028. Do not hand-edit; edit the sources.
board_shape leaf_candidate_sheet (row grain) — 4 rows × up to 4 candidates — approval_state critics_running — private
generation_class living — care_tier standard — generation_tier region_standard — decay_stage n_a
the four adversarial critics have NOT run on this plate set; critic_verdicts is empty and marketing_eligible computes false
every recommended_candidate in RECS.csv is PROVISIONAL until the REC vision pass runs
ROW:flores-monitor-scale-against-child
title: CR_0005 Flores monitor — the island's other, slighter monitor
canon_id CR_0005 in T0_Creature_Roster/Sheet1 — canon_ref entity:CR_0005
citations: SRC_00169, SRC_00457 (rows of registries/T0_Source_Material_Registry)
lane G · care_tier standard · protected false · care read from DECLARED: T0_Creature_Roster carries no care_tier/protected column and this row names no host zone, so the values are the DEFAULTs the class carries and the basis is the row's own care_notes. Boarded as a registry gap: cultural_depiction_required exists on T0_Creature_Roster and nowhere else, which is why the character-side care route has to be argued and cannot be read.
recommended candidate: 1 (PROVISIONAL)
care: Standard care, no cultural claim attaches. The species must never be drawn at Komodo proportions — the whole point of the set is that this is the island's OTHER monitor and a slight animal. V2-REVISION STRUCTURAL FIX (§3.2b SPLIT + critic MAJOR): one row per live creature_id, raised to D1-15's grain of three.
REC verdict REGENERATE_ALL
REC reason: All four put a bound codex book in the child's hands — a manufactured, era-impossible object on a Ch-2 stranded child, and it is the whole read of every plate.
REC defects: O1-O4 bound book (manufactured object); O1-O4 pointed elf ears on the protagonist (fairy-realm identity leak, HL_0095 reveal discipline); child bare-torso in O1/O3 contrary to the affirmative garment law; monitor rendered heavy-bodied with armoured osteoderm scaling and (O3/O4) a spiny dorsal crest — Komodo bulk, the one thing the row's care line bars; O2/O3/O4 have no shared ground plane so the scale comparison never resolves; O1 carries an orphan lizard-tail fragment lower-left and duplicates the child.
REGENERATED after vision review — 13 superseded plate(s) kept; recommendation void until the review runs again
PENDING (no image) — NOT BARRED — LANE_G. Standard-care Zone-Catalog ground or neutral-ground subject: care read from DECLARED: T0_Creature_Roster carries no care_tier/protected column and this row names no host zone, so the values are the DEFAULTs the class carries and the basis is the row's own care_notes. Boarded as a registry gap: cultural_depiction_required exists on T0_Creature_Roster and nowhere else, which is why the character-side care route has to be argued and cannot be read., and the entity-side cultural_depiction_required flag is absent or FALSE on every id this row keys or references. Both halves of the predicate are recorded on the row so the refusal stays arithmetic.
ROW:timor-deer-study
title: CR_0006 Timor deer — the prey the predator's country is read from
canon_id CR_0006 in T0_Creature_Roster/Sheet1 — canon_ref entity:CR_0006
citations: SRC_00169, SRC_00457 (rows of registries/T0_Source_Material_Registry)
lane G · care_tier standard · protected false · care read from DECLARED: T0_Creature_Roster carries no care_tier/protected column and this row names no host zone, so the values are the DEFAULTs the class carries and the basis is the row's own care_notes. Boarded as a registry gap: cultural_depiction_required exists on T0_Creature_Roster and nowhere else, which is why the character-side care route has to be argued and cannot be read.
recommended candidate: 1 (PROVISIONAL)
care: Standard care, no cultural claim attaches. Prey species, rendered as ecology and never as a trophy or a white-hart fantasy. V2-REVISION STRUCTURAL FIX (§3.2b SPLIT + critic MAJOR): one row per live creature_id, raised to D1-15's grain of three.
REC verdict REGENERATE_ALL
REC reason: Every plate gives the stag palmated fallow/red-deer antlers instead of the three-tined rusa lyre — on a species-base study the antler architecture IS the deliverable.
REC defects: O1-O4 wrong antler architecture (palmated, multi-tined) and heavily white-spotted coats; Rusa timorensis is plain coarse grey-brown with simple three-tine lyre antlers. O1-O4 all place a shed antler / skull-cap bone on the ground and O2 renders a severed antlered head — the row's care line bars the trophy register outright. Strike every bone token; re-render antlers and coat to rusa reference.
REGENERATED after vision review — 10 superseded plate(s) kept; recommendation void until the review runs again
O1 D1-15/CR_0006/study__cf39a40ce575.png sha256 d063177f584cc9da... plate PLT_E079_1 licence record docs/licence_records/art_boards_plates/PLT_E079_1.json
title: CR_0006 Timor deer — the prey the predator's country is read from
canon_id CR_0006 in T0_Creature_Roster/Sheet1 — canon_ref entity:CR_0006
citations: SRC_00169, SRC_00457 (rows of registries/T0_Source_Material_Registry)
lane G · care_tier standard · protected false · care read from DECLARED: T0_Creature_Roster carries no care_tier/protected column and this row names no host zone, so the values are the DEFAULTs the class carries and the basis is the row's own care_notes. Boarded as a registry gap: cultural_depiction_required exists on T0_Creature_Roster and nowhere else, which is why the character-side care route has to be argued and cannot be read.
recommended candidate: 1 (PROVISIONAL)
care: Standard care, no cultural claim attaches. Prey species, rendered as ecology and never as a trophy or a white-hart fantasy. V2-REVISION STRUCTURAL FIX (§3.2b SPLIT + critic MAJOR): one row per live creature_id, raised to D1-15's grain of three.
REC verdict MIXED — recommended candidate O1
REC reason: O1 is the only plate with four distinct, legible behaviour poses, all grounded with cast shadows and none anatomically broken.
REC defects: Coat is white-spotted across the whole row — wrong species register for Rusa timorensis (plain unspotted grey-brown); fix at re-render. O4 rejected: bottom-left figure is a mangled headless rear-view. O3 renders only three of four cells. O2 figures float with no shadow and repeat the grazing pose. On the picked O1 the bottom-right walking figure's near foreleg wants a cleanup pass.
O2 D1-15/CR_0006/strip__47bc86c30f9a.png sha256 ba03c2dbf716871b... plate PLT_A0205_2 licence record docs/licence_records/art_boards_plates/PLT_A0205_2.json
O3 D1-15/CR_0006/strip__fcd62fcfbbda.png sha256 a7260758b6c44d0e... plate PLT_A0205_3 licence record docs/licence_records/art_boards_plates/PLT_A0205_3.json
O4 D1-15/CR_0006/strip__9b1933094dab.png sha256 6017af2c362d30bd... plate PLT_A0205_4 licence record docs/licence_records/art_boards_plates/PLT_A0205_4.json
ROW:timor-deer-scale-against-child
title: CR_0006 Timor deer — the prey the predator's country is read from
canon_id CR_0006 in T0_Creature_Roster/Sheet1 — canon_ref entity:CR_0006
citations: SRC_00169, SRC_00457 (rows of registries/T0_Source_Material_Registry)
lane G · care_tier standard · protected false · care read from DECLARED: T0_Creature_Roster carries no care_tier/protected column and this row names no host zone, so the values are the DEFAULTs the class carries and the basis is the row's own care_notes. Boarded as a registry gap: cultural_depiction_required exists on T0_Creature_Roster and nowhere else, which is why the character-side care route has to be argued and cannot be read.
recommended candidate: 1 (PROVISIONAL)
care: Standard care, no cultural claim attaches. Prey species, rendered as ecology and never as a trophy or a white-hart fantasy. V2-REVISION STRUCTURAL FIX (§3.2b SPLIT + critic MAJOR): one row per live creature_id, raised to D1-15's grain of three.
REC verdict REGENERATE_ALL
REC reason: Every plate gives the protagonist pointed elf ears — an unsupported non-human marker that leaks fairy-realm identity before the Ch-8 reveal.
REC defects: O1-O4 pointed ears on the child (HL_0095 reveal-discipline leak, no canon basis); protagonist identity inconsistent across the board — pale/European here, Southeast-Asian on the CR_0005 row, same figure; O1-O4 wrong antler architecture (palmated fallow/red deer) and spotted coats; O1/O3 coats carry glossy specular blobs and O4 has a torn hole plus a bald patch on the flank. Scale staging and the hooded smock (torso and thighs covered) are the one thing worth carrying forward.
REGENERATED after vision review — 13 superseded plate(s) kept; recommendation void until the review runs again
PENDING (no image) — NOT BARRED — LANE_G. Standard-care Zone-Catalog ground or neutral-ground subject: care read from DECLARED: T0_Creature_Roster carries no care_tier/protected column and this row names no host zone, so the values are the DEFAULTs the class carries and the basis is the row's own care_notes. Boarded as a registry gap: cultural_depiction_required exists on T0_Creature_Roster and nowhere else, which is why the character-side care route has to be argued and cannot be read., and the entity-side cultural_depiction_required flag is absent or FALSE on every id this row keys or references. Both halves of the predicate are recorded on the row so the refusal stays arithmetic.
Canon coverage — what this board does not carry
4 subjects this leaf's canon scope names; 4 carry a generated candidate and 0 are held.
Generated by harness/site/structure_site.py — the URL path is the repo path. review root