BRD_0024 — NPCs - named persona (D1-09) — Flores Island leaf candidate sheet
GENERATED FILE. Rendered from MANIFEST.csv, PLATES.csv, RECS.csv and this board's content.json by harness/boards/render_board.py --board BRD_0024. Do not hand-edit; edit the sources.
the four adversarial critics have NOT run on this plate set; critic_verdicts is empty and marketing_eligible computes false
every recommended_candidate in RECS.csv is PROVISIONAL until the REC vision pass runs
ROW:char0012-teresa-full-figure
title: Child Teresa, the first human peer
caption: CHAR_0012 — the arc's first human-peer relationship and the first thread of the found family.
canon_id CHAR_0012 in T0_Character_Index/T0_Character_Index — canon_ref entity:CHAR_0012|zone:manggarai_village_edge@flores_island|beat:CH02_B10
citations: SRC_00203, SRC_00230 (rows of registries/T0_Source_Material_Registry)
lane R · care_tier elevated · protected true · care read from build/zones/flores_island.csv @ zone_id manggarai_village_edge
recommended candidate: 1 (PROVISIONAL)
care: LANE-R ACQUISITION, PREVIZ-only: an ordinary village child, cloth as technique and no claimed motif language, no ornament, no adult framing; nothing about her staging is sexualized, ritualized or endangered.
PENDING (no image) — LANE R — ACQUISITION: the plate is filled by an acquired, rights-checked reference item rather than by a model run; the row's bar_reason carries the care arithmetic.
ROW:char0012-teresa-at-work
title: Child Teresa, the first human peer
caption: CHAR_0012 — the arc's first human-peer relationship and the first thread of the found family.
canon_id CHAR_0012 in T0_Character_Index/T0_Character_Index — canon_ref entity:CHAR_0012|zone:manggarai_village_edge@flores_island|beat:CH02_B10
citations: SRC_00203, SRC_00230 (rows of registries/T0_Source_Material_Registry)
lane R · care_tier elevated · protected true · care read from build/zones/flores_island.csv @ zone_id manggarai_village_edge
recommended candidate: 1 (PROVISIONAL)
care: LANE-R ACQUISITION, PREVIZ-only: an ordinary village child, cloth as technique and no claimed motif language, no ornament, no adult framing; nothing about her staging is sexualized, ritualized or endangered.
PENDING (no image) — LANE R — ACQUISITION: the plate is filled by an acquired, rights-checked reference item rather than by a model run; the row's bar_reason carries the care arithmetic.
ROW:char0013-yohanes-full-figure
title: Fisherman Yohanes, coastal fisher
caption: CHAR_0013 — the coastal Manggarai fisher and boat-building tutorial-giver.
canon_id CHAR_0013 in T0_Character_Index/T0_Character_Index — canon_ref entity:CHAR_0013
citations: SRC_00457, SRC_00469 (rows of registries/T0_Source_Material_Registry)
lane R · care_tier ` · protected ` · care read from NO ZONE ROW EXISTS to copy from — the care columns stay empty rather than hand-typed, and the refusal is carried by lane=R
recommended candidate: 1 (PROVISIONAL)
care: LANE-R ACQUISITION, PREVIZ-only: cloth as the ikat technique, motif language unclaimed (the Erb gap); craft materials restricted to attested hardwood, bamboo, rattan and hand-spun cotton line. TWO DECLARATIONS ON THIS ROW: the Zone Catalog carries no coastal or beach zone anywhere in flores_island, so the at-work plate stands on ground the build does not yet have; and the sewn-and-lashed washstrake hull is an Austronesian-general inference with no Manggarai boat record in the processed corpus. CARE COLUMNS EMPTY BY DECLARATION: no zone row exists to copy care_tier and protected from, so both columns stay EMPTY rather than hand-typed, and the refusal is carried by lane=R. They fill the moment a coastal or beach zone (flores_island.md:51-61) is minted in build/zones/flores_island.csv.
PENDING (no image) — LANE R — ACQUISITION: the plate is filled by an acquired, rights-checked reference item rather than by a model run; the row's bar_reason carries the care arithmetic.
ROW:char0013-yohanes-at-work
title: Fisherman Yohanes, coastal fisher
caption: CHAR_0013 — the coastal Manggarai fisher and boat-building tutorial-giver.
canon_id CHAR_0013 in T0_Character_Index/T0_Character_Index — canon_ref entity:CHAR_0013
citations: SRC_00457, SRC_00469 (rows of registries/T0_Source_Material_Registry)
lane R · care_tier ` · protected ` · care read from NO ZONE ROW EXISTS to copy from — the care columns stay empty rather than hand-typed, and the refusal is carried by lane=R
recommended candidate: 1 (PROVISIONAL)
care: LANE-R ACQUISITION, PREVIZ-only: cloth as the ikat technique, motif language unclaimed (the Erb gap); craft materials restricted to attested hardwood, bamboo, rattan and hand-spun cotton line. TWO DECLARATIONS ON THIS ROW: the Zone Catalog carries no coastal or beach zone anywhere in flores_island, so the at-work plate stands on ground the build does not yet have; and the sewn-and-lashed washstrake hull is an Austronesian-general inference with no Manggarai boat record in the processed corpus. CARE COLUMNS EMPTY BY DECLARATION: no zone row exists to copy care_tier and protected from, so both columns stay EMPTY rather than hand-typed, and the refusal is carried by lane=R. They fill the moment a coastal or beach zone (flores_island.md:51-61) is minted in build/zones/flores_island.csv.
PENDING (no image) — LANE R — ACQUISITION: the plate is filled by an acquired, rights-checked reference item rather than by a model run; the row's bar_reason carries the care arithmetic.
ROW:char0014-healer-maria-full-figure
title: Healer Maria, the folk-healer restored
caption: CHAR_0014 — the benevolent herbal knowledge-holder who reads the polo's work and aids against it.
canon_id CHAR_0014 in T0_Character_Index/T0_Character_Index — canon_ref entity:CHAR_0014|zone:lingko_forest_edge@flores_island
citations: SRC_00203, SRC_00230 (rows of registries/T0_Source_Material_Registry)
lane P · care_tier standard · protected false · care read from build/zones/flores_island.csv @ zone_id lingko_forest_edge
recommended candidate: 1 (PROVISIONAL)
care: LANE-R ACQUISITION, PREVIZ-only and HL_0005-critical: the healer is benevolent and is never the corruptor — no cauldron, no bone kit, no horror-witch shorthand, no rite; her tools are plants, a basket and a knife. Cloth as technique, motif language unclaimed. ENTITY-SIDE REFUSAL: the zone's copied care columns read standard/false; the refusal is the living-dress Erb gap (flores_island.md:346-350), carried by lane=R because T0_Character_Index has no subject-side care column today.
released_by_ruling: R-E (director ruling, 2026-08-03) -- SUBJECT-SIDE RELEASE TO LANE P. A MOTIF-FREE TECHNIQUE RENDER IS NOT A DRESS CLAIM. The flores_island.md:346-350 Erb gap withholds the MOTIF VOCABULARY; this pack's cloth sentence renders the resist-dye TECHNIQUE as craft-general (bound-and-resist-dyed warp, soft feathered band edges, hand-spun slub, the natural indigo/morinda range) and claims no motif language, so nothing left in the frame is what the gap withholds. The elevated-care ZONE bar is untouched and stays exactly where it is: these rows move to LANE P (paintover over acquired reference), which is not care-gated, and never to lane G. Lane R is kept for a protected living settlement's ARCHITECTURE and for a named community RITE. And Lane R is the riskier option here, not the cautious one: an acquisition means sourcing rights-clear photographs of real Manggarai people for a commercial game, which raises a likeness problem the motif-free composite does not have.
lane_p_underlay: LANE P UNDERLAY DISCIPLINE, STATED IN THE RECORD: the plate is dispatched as a GENERATED BASE at review tier, and the Lane-P obligation it carries is the PAINTOVER PASS over an acquired, rights-checked reference item -- which is owed and is not yet run (E:/refs_lane_r is empty). What that means for this artifact concretely: the generated base is directional and is never the delivered plate; the acquired reference governs proportion, dress construction and material at the paintover; and the delivered plate's rights value is re-derived at that pass. Recorded here so a reader of the row can tell a Lane-P base from a Lane-G candidate without reading a commit message.
REC verdict MIXED — recommended candidate O1
REC reason: Only candidate where the reserved triad (plants, basket, knife) reads as one coherent working kit in hand; O3 duplicates the blade and O4 breaks the knife into a floating handle plus a grey blob.
REC defects: Winner's blade reads as a polished modern kitchen knife (soften to a village forged parang at paintover); O3 knife duplicated, O4 knife broken; O2 blade tucked edge-up against the body is physically incoherent and its sarong carries a figured hook motif.
O2 D1-09/CHAR_0014/study__02959aeab890.png sha256 8135e077e464c7a6... plate PLT_A0171_2 licence record docs/licence_records/art_boards_plates/PLT_A0171_2.json
O3 D1-09/CHAR_0014/study__6dc141b38ce9.png sha256 ed7ffba79b437616... plate PLT_A0171_3 licence record docs/licence_records/art_boards_plates/PLT_A0171_3.json
O4 D1-09/CHAR_0014/study__e5929f0a0bd1.png sha256 6e4da3b1ec2fc66a... plate PLT_A0171_4 licence record docs/licence_records/art_boards_plates/PLT_A0171_4.json
ROW:char0014-healer-maria-at-work
title: Healer Maria, the folk-healer restored
caption: CHAR_0014 — the benevolent herbal knowledge-holder who reads the polo's work and aids against it.
canon_id CHAR_0014 in T0_Character_Index/T0_Character_Index — canon_ref entity:CHAR_0014|zone:lingko_forest_edge@flores_island
citations: SRC_00203, SRC_00230 (rows of registries/T0_Source_Material_Registry)
lane P · care_tier standard · protected false · care read from build/zones/flores_island.csv @ zone_id lingko_forest_edge
recommended candidate: 1 (PROVISIONAL)
care: LANE-R ACQUISITION, PREVIZ-only and HL_0005-critical: the healer is benevolent and is never the corruptor — no cauldron, no bone kit, no horror-witch shorthand, no rite; her tools are plants, a basket and a knife. Cloth as technique, motif language unclaimed. ENTITY-SIDE REFUSAL: the zone's copied care columns read standard/false; the refusal is the living-dress Erb gap (flores_island.md:346-350), carried by lane=R because T0_Character_Index has no subject-side care column today.
released_by_ruling: R-E (director ruling, 2026-08-03) -- SUBJECT-SIDE RELEASE TO LANE P. A MOTIF-FREE TECHNIQUE RENDER IS NOT A DRESS CLAIM. The flores_island.md:346-350 Erb gap withholds the MOTIF VOCABULARY; this pack's cloth sentence renders the resist-dye TECHNIQUE as craft-general (bound-and-resist-dyed warp, soft feathered band edges, hand-spun slub, the natural indigo/morinda range) and claims no motif language, so nothing left in the frame is what the gap withholds. The elevated-care ZONE bar is untouched and stays exactly where it is: these rows move to LANE P (paintover over acquired reference), which is not care-gated, and never to lane G. Lane R is kept for a protected living settlement's ARCHITECTURE and for a named community RITE. And Lane R is the riskier option here, not the cautious one: an acquisition means sourcing rights-clear photographs of real Manggarai people for a commercial game, which raises a likeness problem the motif-free composite does not have.
lane_p_underlay: LANE P UNDERLAY DISCIPLINE, STATED IN THE RECORD: the plate is dispatched as a GENERATED BASE at review tier, and the Lane-P obligation it carries is the PAINTOVER PASS over an acquired, rights-checked reference item -- which is owed and is not yet run (E:/refs_lane_r is empty). What that means for this artifact concretely: the generated base is directional and is never the delivered plate; the acquired reference governs proportion, dress construction and material at the paintover; and the delivered plate's rights value is re-derived at that pass. Recorded here so a reader of the row can tell a Lane-P base from a Lane-G candidate without reading a commit message.
REC verdict REGENERATE_ALL
REC reason: All four render a white European woman in a buttoned shirt, cargo trousers and hiking boots harvesting kale and leeks in a temperate nursery bed — wrong identity, wrong region, wrong era.
REC defects: Wrong subject identity and register; modern manufactured objects (plastic nursery trays and edging, rubber/riveted knife handles, footwear, finger ring); temperate garden flora and New World crops; no lingko_forest_edge read anywhere.
REGENERATED after vision review — 9 superseded plate(s) kept; recommendation void until the review runs again
O1 D1-09/CHAR_0014/staging__fe232daef850.png sha256 50ad8368abf3172a... plate PLT_C063_1 licence record docs/licence_records/art_boards_plates/PLT_C063_1.json
caption: CHAR_0015 — the economic-web contact and the first hint of a wider world the child cannot reach.
canon_id CHAR_0015 in T0_Character_Index/T0_Character_Index — canon_ref entity:CHAR_0015|zone:wae_rebo_village@flores_island
citations: SRC_00203, SRC_00230 (rows of registries/T0_Source_Material_Registry)
lane R · care_tier elevated · protected true · care read from build/zones/flores_island.csv @ zone_id wae_rebo_village
recommended candidate: 1 (PROVISIONAL)
care: LANE-R ACQUISITION, PREVIZ-only: her goods are the region's attested trade face — ikat and songket cloth, gongs, highland surplus (flores_island.md:831, 837). Both cloths are rendered as their TECHNIQUES, the resist-dyed warp and the supplementary-weft float; no motif language is claimed on any bolt.
PENDING (no image) — LANE R — ACQUISITION: the plate is filled by an acquired, rights-checked reference item rather than by a model run; the row's bar_reason carries the care arithmetic.
ROW:char0015-siti-at-work
title: Merchant Siti, trade-route contact
caption: CHAR_0015 — the economic-web contact and the first hint of a wider world the child cannot reach.
canon_id CHAR_0015 in T0_Character_Index/T0_Character_Index — canon_ref entity:CHAR_0015|zone:wae_rebo_village@flores_island
citations: SRC_00203, SRC_00230 (rows of registries/T0_Source_Material_Registry)
lane R · care_tier elevated · protected true · care read from build/zones/flores_island.csv @ zone_id wae_rebo_village
recommended candidate: 1 (PROVISIONAL)
care: LANE-R ACQUISITION, PREVIZ-only: her goods are the region's attested trade face — ikat and songket cloth, gongs, highland surplus (flores_island.md:831, 837). Both cloths are rendered as their TECHNIQUES, the resist-dyed warp and the supplementary-weft float; no motif language is claimed on any bolt.
PENDING (no image) — LANE R — ACQUISITION: the plate is filled by an acquired, rights-checked reference item rather than by a model run; the row's bar_reason carries the care arithmetic.
ROW:char0008-rangku-wera-full-figure-uncorrupted
title: Rangku Wera in his village context
caption: CHAR_0008 before the hunt — the finest tracker of his highland village, the man the corruption took.
canon_id CHAR_0008 in T0_Character_Index/T0_Character_Index — canon_ref entity:CHAR_0008|zone:mount_inerie_cone_country@flores_island|beat:CH02_B07|boss:BE_0002.P1
citations: SRC_00203, SRC_00230 (rows of registries/T0_Source_Material_Registry)
lane P · care_tier standard · protected false · care read from build/zones/flores_island.csv @ zone_id mount_inerie_cone_country
recommended candidate: 3 (PROVISIONAL)
care: LANE-R ACQUISITION, PREVIZ-only: he is the polo's VICTIM, not its author — this row renders the uncorrupted man of a Manggarai-ADJACENT highland settlement, with the hollowing carried only as a faint behavioural wrongness and never as monster design. Cloth as technique, motif language unclaimed. ENTITY-SIDE REFUSAL: the zone's copied care columns read standard/false; the refusal is the living-dress Erb gap (flores_island.md:346-350), carried by lane=R because T0_Character_Index has no subject-side care column today.
released_by_ruling: R-E (director ruling, 2026-08-03) -- SUBJECT-SIDE RELEASE TO LANE P. A MOTIF-FREE TECHNIQUE RENDER IS NOT A DRESS CLAIM. The flores_island.md:346-350 Erb gap withholds the MOTIF VOCABULARY; this pack's cloth sentence renders the resist-dye TECHNIQUE as craft-general (bound-and-resist-dyed warp, soft feathered band edges, hand-spun slub, the natural indigo/morinda range) and claims no motif language, so nothing left in the frame is what the gap withholds. The elevated-care ZONE bar is untouched and stays exactly where it is: these rows move to LANE P (paintover over acquired reference), which is not care-gated, and never to lane G. Lane R is kept for a protected living settlement's ARCHITECTURE and for a named community RITE. And Lane R is the riskier option here, not the cautious one: an acquisition means sourcing rights-clear photographs of real Manggarai people for a commercial game, which raises a likeness problem the motif-free composite does not have.
lane_p_underlay: LANE P UNDERLAY DISCIPLINE, STATED IN THE RECORD: the plate is dispatched as a GENERATED BASE at review tier, and the Lane-P obligation it carries is the PAINTOVER PASS over an acquired, rights-checked reference item -- which is owed and is not yet run (E:/refs_lane_r is empty). What that means for this artifact concretely: the generated base is directional and is never the delivered plate; the acquired reference governs proportion, dress construction and material at the paintover; and the delivered plate's rights value is re-derived at that pass. Recorded here so a reader of the row can tell a Lane-P base from a Lane-G candidate without reading a commit message.
REC verdict PICK_READY — recommended candidate O3
REC reason: Cleanest motif-free resist read on the shoulder cloth with the complete highland kit (rolled mat, rattan basket, bamboo tube, spear), barefoot and asymmetric, no garment anachronism.
REC defects: O2 carries a modern button placket down the tunic front; O4's shoulder cloth reads as a stiff kilim rug rather than hand-spun cloth; the mirror-polished spearhead reads machine-finished across the whole row.
O1 D1-09/CHAR_0008/study__91607a34af71.png sha256 ee58fe34e263a2eb... plate PLT_A0175_1 licence record docs/licence_records/art_boards_plates/PLT_A0175_1.json
O2 D1-09/CHAR_0008/study__bed15c29d118.png sha256 d2d49818a33bcb33... plate PLT_A0175_2 licence record docs/licence_records/art_boards_plates/PLT_A0175_2.json
O4 D1-09/CHAR_0008/study__aa3690d90406.png sha256 41d8dca536a0feed... plate PLT_A0175_4 licence record docs/licence_records/art_boards_plates/PLT_A0175_4.json
ROW:char0008-rangku-wera-at-work-village-edge
title: Rangku Wera in his village context
caption: CHAR_0008 before the hunt — the finest tracker of his highland village, the man the corruption took.
canon_id CHAR_0008 in T0_Character_Index/T0_Character_Index — canon_ref entity:CHAR_0008|zone:mount_inerie_cone_country@flores_island|beat:CH02_B07|boss:BE_0002.P1
citations: SRC_00203, SRC_00230 (rows of registries/T0_Source_Material_Registry)
lane P · care_tier standard · protected false · care read from build/zones/flores_island.csv @ zone_id mount_inerie_cone_country
recommended candidate: 3 (PROVISIONAL)
care: LANE-R ACQUISITION, PREVIZ-only: he is the polo's VICTIM, not its author — this row renders the uncorrupted man of a Manggarai-ADJACENT highland settlement, with the hollowing carried only as a faint behavioural wrongness and never as monster design. Cloth as technique, motif language unclaimed. ENTITY-SIDE REFUSAL: the zone's copied care columns read standard/false; the refusal is the living-dress Erb gap (flores_island.md:346-350), carried by lane=R because T0_Character_Index has no subject-side care column today.
released_by_ruling: R-E (director ruling, 2026-08-03) -- SUBJECT-SIDE RELEASE TO LANE P. A MOTIF-FREE TECHNIQUE RENDER IS NOT A DRESS CLAIM. The flores_island.md:346-350 Erb gap withholds the MOTIF VOCABULARY; this pack's cloth sentence renders the resist-dye TECHNIQUE as craft-general (bound-and-resist-dyed warp, soft feathered band edges, hand-spun slub, the natural indigo/morinda range) and claims no motif language, so nothing left in the frame is what the gap withholds. The elevated-care ZONE bar is untouched and stays exactly where it is: these rows move to LANE P (paintover over acquired reference), which is not care-gated, and never to lane G. Lane R is kept for a protected living settlement's ARCHITECTURE and for a named community RITE. And Lane R is the riskier option here, not the cautious one: an acquisition means sourcing rights-clear photographs of real Manggarai people for a commercial game, which raises a likeness problem the motif-free composite does not have.
lane_p_underlay: LANE P UNDERLAY DISCIPLINE, STATED IN THE RECORD: the plate is dispatched as a GENERATED BASE at review tier, and the Lane-P obligation it carries is the PAINTOVER PASS over an acquired, rights-checked reference item -- which is owed and is not yet run (E:/refs_lane_r is empty). What that means for this artifact concretely: the generated base is directional and is never the delivered plate; the acquired reference governs proportion, dress construction and material at the paintover; and the delivered plate's rights value is re-derived at that pass. Recorded here so a reader of the row can tell a Lane-P base from a Lane-G candidate without reading a commit message.
REC verdict REGENERATE_ALL
REC reason: Every candidate puts modern manufactured objects in frame (blue plastic tub, plastic drum, corrugated metal roofing, turquoise-painted joinery) under conifer silhouettes, and none carries the ruled Manggarai grammar.
REC defects: Modern plastic/metal props; conifers on the ridge; footwear on O2/O3/O4; generic thatch huts instead of mbaru niang under ijuk with a compang centre; heavy scattered debris artifacts; painterly register clashes with the photoreal study row. O1 is the closest base (barefoot, no metal roof).
REGENERATED after vision review — 12 superseded plate(s) kept; recommendation void until the review runs again
O1 D1-09/CHAR_0008/staging__c0fc6266a677.png sha256 2d566369aa2c5fe4... plate PLT_F064_1 licence record docs/licence_records/art_boards_plates/PLT_F064_1.json
10 subjects this leaf's canon scope names; 4 carry a generated candidate and 6 are held.
char0012-teresa-full-figure — LANE R — ACQUISITION: the plate is filled by an acquired, rights-checked reference item rather than by a model run; the row's bar_reason carries the care arithmetic. (T0_Character_Index/T0_Character_Index)
char0012-teresa-at-work — LANE R — ACQUISITION: the plate is filled by an acquired, rights-checked reference item rather than by a model run; the row's bar_reason carries the care arithmetic. (T0_Character_Index/T0_Character_Index)
char0013-yohanes-full-figure — LANE R — ACQUISITION: the plate is filled by an acquired, rights-checked reference item rather than by a model run; the row's bar_reason carries the care arithmetic. (T0_Character_Index/T0_Character_Index)
char0013-yohanes-at-work — LANE R — ACQUISITION: the plate is filled by an acquired, rights-checked reference item rather than by a model run; the row's bar_reason carries the care arithmetic. (T0_Character_Index/T0_Character_Index)
char0015-siti-full-figure — LANE R — ACQUISITION: the plate is filled by an acquired, rights-checked reference item rather than by a model run; the row's bar_reason carries the care arithmetic. (T0_Character_Index/T0_Character_Index)
char0015-siti-at-work — LANE R — ACQUISITION: the plate is filled by an acquired, rights-checked reference item rather than by a model run; the row's bar_reason carries the care arithmetic. (T0_Character_Index/T0_Character_Index)
Generated by harness/site/structure_site.py — the URL path is the repo path. review root