GENERATED FILE. Rendered from MANIFEST.csv, PLATES.csv, RECS.csv and this board's content.json by harness/boards/render_board.py --board BRD_0017. Do not hand-edit; edit the sources.
the four adversarial critics have NOT run on this plate set; critic_verdicts is empty and marketing_eligible computes false
every recommended_candidate in RECS.csv is PROVISIONAL until the REC vision pass runs
ROW:first-fire-the-ember-key-frame
title: CH02_B02 — the fire-making night and the improvised shelter
canon_id mount_inerie_cone_country in build/zones/flores_island.csv — canon_ref zone:mount_inerie_cone_country@flores_island|beat:CH02_B02
citations: SRC_00169, SRC_00203, SRC_00230 (rows of registries/T0_Source_Material_Registry)
lane G · care_tier standard · protected false · care read from build/zones/flores_island.csv @ zone_id mount_inerie_cone_country
recommended candidate: 4 (PROVISIONAL)
care: Standard care, no cultural claim: improvised survival craft by a stranger with nothing. It must not read as any Flores people's fire-making tradition or as instructed technique — the community's own craft seeds at Ch 3. THIS IS THE CARE FIX THE V1 SET FAILED: three of four v1 plates seated a present-day-reading local child in modern manufactured clothing at the region's own bamboo fire-saw, which produces exactly the misattribution this note forbids. The child is a stranger with nothing, fully clothed in a plain undyed wrapped tunic and barefoot, in every plate.
REC verdict REGENERATE_ALL
REC reason: All four seat the fire on a planed, machine-sawn lumber board with square finished edges — a manufactured object in a beat where the child has nothing.
REC defects: Milled hearth board in all four (O3's reads as a laminated cutting board with edge banding); conifer/pine forest behind O1 and O2 (forbidden species); O2 also drops to a flat painterly register. Bar 'plank/board/lumber' tokens and specify a split green-bamboo hearth on bare ground.
REGENERATED after vision review — 12 superseded plate(s) kept; recommendation void until the review runs again
O1 D1-04/mount_inerie_cone_country/staging__00d091e80714.png sha256 1d25ba4a0a8c23f2... plate PLT_F054_1 licence record docs/licence_records/art_boards_plates/PLT_F054_1.json
title: CH02_B02 — the fire-making night and the improvised shelter
canon_id mount_inerie_cone_country in build/zones/flores_island.csv — canon_ref zone:mount_inerie_cone_country@flores_island|beat:CH02_B02
citations: SRC_00169, SRC_00203, SRC_00230 (rows of registries/T0_Source_Material_Registry)
lane G · care_tier standard · protected false · care read from build/zones/flores_island.csv @ zone_id mount_inerie_cone_country
recommended candidate: 1 (PROVISIONAL)
care: Standard care, no cultural claim: improvised survival craft by a stranger with nothing. It must not read as any Flores people's fire-making tradition or as instructed technique — the community's own craft seeds at Ch 3. THIS IS THE CARE FIX THE V1 SET FAILED: three of four v1 plates seated a present-day-reading local child in modern manufactured clothing at the region's own bamboo fire-saw, which produces exactly the misattribution this note forbids. The child is a stranger with nothing, fully clothed in a plain undyed wrapped tunic and barefoot, in every plate.
REC verdict REGENERATE_ALL
REC reason: Three of four put a bare-chested child in only a waist wrap, breaking the row's own stated law that the child is fully clothed in a plain undyed wrapped tunic covering torso and thighs.
REC defects: O1, O2, O3 bare-chested and reading as a present-day local village child, not the elf stranger the care note requires; O4 is clothed but has a round-eared local child plus an enamel cooking pot and a white enamel cup (manufactured metal); all four render a neatly rattan-lashed community-grade bamboo A-frame where the beat is a stranger's improvised shelter.
REGENERATED after vision review — 12 superseded plate(s) kept; recommendation void until the review runs again
O1 D1-04/mount_inerie_cone_country/staging__c53741c67e7e.png sha256 9f6a6b14f2c15bec... plate PLT_F055_1 licence record docs/licence_records/art_boards_plates/PLT_F055_1.json
title: CH02_B02 — the fire-making night and the improvised shelter
canon_id mount_inerie_cone_country in build/zones/flores_island.csv — canon_ref zone:mount_inerie_cone_country@flores_island|beat:CH02_B02
citations: SRC_00169, SRC_00203, SRC_00230 (rows of registries/T0_Source_Material_Registry)
lane G · care_tier standard · protected false · care read from build/zones/flores_island.csv @ zone_id mount_inerie_cone_country
recommended candidate: 2 (PROVISIONAL)
care: Standard care, no cultural claim: improvised survival craft by a stranger with nothing. It must not read as any Flores people's fire-making tradition or as instructed technique — the community's own craft seeds at Ch 3. THIS IS THE CARE FIX THE V1 SET FAILED: three of four v1 plates seated a present-day-reading local child in modern manufactured clothing at the region's own bamboo fire-saw, which produces exactly the misattribution this note forbids. The child is a stranger with nothing, fully clothed in a plain undyed wrapped tunic and barefoot, in every plate.
REC verdict REGENERATE_ALL
REC reason: The prompt token 'fire-saw' produced a modern steel carpentry handsaw in every candidate — riveted handle, machine-cut teeth, forged blade.
REC defects: Steel handsaw with riveted wood/composite handle in O1 and O2; bare serrated steel blade embedded in the hearth stone in O3 and O4 (O4's is still an unmistakable toothed blade behind the embers). Forged steel is barred for this region (flores_island.md:840-841). Strike 'saw' from the prompt and describe the split-bamboo edge drawn across a notched tube.
REGENERATED after vision review — 9 superseded plate(s) kept; recommendation void until the review runs again
O1 D1-04/mount_inerie_cone_country/detail__6be61877b5b0.png sha256 769208af8d3b432b... plate PLT_C056_1 licence record docs/licence_records/art_boards_plates/PLT_C056_1.json
title: The Ch-2 agility course — canopy-horizontal traverse and the forest pod
canon_id mount_inerie_cone_country in build/zones/flores_island.csv — canon_ref zone:mount_inerie_cone_country@flores_island|beat:CH02_B07
citations: SRC_00169, SRC_00203, SRC_00230 (rows of registries/T0_Source_Material_Registry)
lane G · care_tier standard · protected false · care read from build/zones/flores_island.csv @ zone_id mount_inerie_cone_country
recommended candidate: 1 (PROVISIONAL)
care: Standard care, no cultural claim: this is uninhabited forest and no community's ground, structure or craft appears in it. THE V1 ROW'S CENTRAL DEFECT WAS A CARE DEFECT: all four plates rendered a community-built rattan-lashed bamboo bridge with regular bindings and spiral-wrapped trunks — a raw-generated Flores vernacular craft form in a zone canon declares craft-free, and real cultural craft is reference-built, never raw-generated (flores_island.md:783-784). The fix is removal, not softening: the route is botany.
REC verdict REGENERATE_ALL
REC reason: The v1 care fix was never applied — all four still lash cordage to the logs, and all four strip the child to a waist wrap.
REC defects: Knotted rope handlines and regular bindings around both logs in all four — the exact community-craft-in-a-craft-free-zone defect the care line orders removed ('the fix is removal, not softening: the route is botany'); bare-chested child in all four against the stated fully-clothed garment law; O2's logs carry metal-grommet-like machined rings.
REGENERATED after vision review — 12 superseded plate(s) kept; recommendation void until the review runs again
O1 D1-04/mount_inerie_cone_country/staging__3d328ec1f8a0.png sha256 07c9c3e46ba8d526... plate PLT_F057_1 licence record docs/licence_records/art_boards_plates/PLT_F057_1.json
title: The Ch-2 agility course — canopy-horizontal traverse and the forest pod
canon_id mount_inerie_cone_country in build/zones/flores_island.csv — canon_ref zone:mount_inerie_cone_country@flores_island|beat:CH02_B07
citations: SRC_00169, SRC_00203, SRC_00230 (rows of registries/T0_Source_Material_Registry)
lane G · care_tier standard · protected false · care read from build/zones/flores_island.csv @ zone_id mount_inerie_cone_country
recommended candidate: 1 (PROVISIONAL)
care: Standard care, no cultural claim: this is uninhabited forest and no community's ground, structure or craft appears in it. THE V1 ROW'S CENTRAL DEFECT WAS A CARE DEFECT: all four plates rendered a community-built rattan-lashed bamboo bridge with regular bindings and spiral-wrapped trunks — a raw-generated Flores vernacular craft form in a zone canon declares craft-free, and real cultural craft is reference-built, never raw-generated (flores_island.md:783-784). The fix is removal, not softening: the route is botany.
REC verdict PICK_READY — recommended candidate O1
REC reason: O1 is the only candidate whose plain undyed tunic actually covers the torso front and back, in a clean botanical pod of arching limbs with no cordage, craft or manufactured object.
REC defects: O2, O3 and O4 render the wrap as a one-shoulder halter leaving most of the back bare, weakening the fully-clothed law; O4 also has dark shoe-like debris on the path. Pointed ears are correct canon (elf protagonist) and are not a defect.
O2 D1-04/mount_inerie_cone_country/staging__affc3fa86558.png sha256 1ef1404dc68cf58d... plate PLT_A0103_2 licence record docs/licence_records/art_boards_plates/PLT_A0103_2.json
O3 D1-04/mount_inerie_cone_country/staging__9f1e413bbd5a.png sha256 669e6aaeb257d734... plate PLT_A0103_3 licence record docs/licence_records/art_boards_plates/PLT_A0103_3.json
O4 D1-04/mount_inerie_cone_country/staging__17c2e86c61d0.png sha256 4f0075f5b9c5c8b5... plate PLT_A0103_4 licence record docs/licence_records/art_boards_plates/PLT_A0103_4.json
ROW:canopy-route-height-read
title: The Ch-2 agility course — canopy-horizontal traverse and the forest pod
canon_id mount_inerie_cone_country in build/zones/flores_island.csv — canon_ref zone:mount_inerie_cone_country@flores_island|beat:CH02_B07
citations: SRC_00169, SRC_00203, SRC_00230 (rows of registries/T0_Source_Material_Registry)
lane G · care_tier standard · protected false · care read from build/zones/flores_island.csv @ zone_id mount_inerie_cone_country
recommended candidate: 4 (PROVISIONAL)
care: Standard care, no cultural claim: this is uninhabited forest and no community's ground, structure or craft appears in it. THE V1 ROW'S CENTRAL DEFECT WAS A CARE DEFECT: all four plates rendered a community-built rattan-lashed bamboo bridge with regular bindings and spiral-wrapped trunks — a raw-generated Flores vernacular craft form in a zone canon declares craft-free, and real cultural craft is reference-built, never raw-generated (flores_island.md:783-784). The fix is removal, not softening: the route is botany.
REC verdict MIXED — recommended candidate O4
REC reason: O4 is the only candidate free of a hard artifact — the other three each carry a text or manufactured-object strike.
REC defects: O1 has open books with ruled pseudo-text lying on the limb (manufactured object plus text artifact); O2 has a machined spoked wheel set into the branch; O3 has a cursive 'WOMEN'-like watermark burned along the limb; O4's remaining notes are a flat wash void that fails to read as height and an incoherent dark collage in the lower left — regenerate O4 with a legible ground plane or scale cue for the drop.
O1 D1-04/mount_inerie_cone_country/traversal__27a9c8d4f4d0.png sha256 2d6f028ea3546f3b... plate PLT_A0104_1 licence record docs/licence_records/art_boards_plates/PLT_A0104_1.json
O2 D1-04/mount_inerie_cone_country/traversal__1c7f1dda8744.png sha256 2a797b6baed5162f... plate PLT_A0104_2 licence record docs/licence_records/art_boards_plates/PLT_A0104_2.json
O3 D1-04/mount_inerie_cone_country/traversal__47336448c9fc.png sha256 0918e8da24ae11e8... plate PLT_A0104_3 licence record docs/licence_records/art_boards_plates/PLT_A0104_3.json
title: Liang Bua — the cool cave, mouth and forest approach (Lane-R acquisition set)
canon_id liang_bua_cave in build/zones/flores_island.csv — canon_ref zone:liang_bua_cave@flores_island|beat:CH02_B01|beat:CH02_B11
citations: SRC_00193 (rows of registries/T0_Source_Material_Registry)
lane R · care_tier elevated · protected true · care read from build/zones/flores_island.csv @ zone_id liang_bua_cave
recommended candidate: 1 (PROVISIONAL)
care: CVD 17.1 elevated-care: Liang Bua is a protected real type-site — referenced, never reproduced, never staged as an active dig, and no Homo floresiensis body reconstruction as a living present-day character (board.md:159). Acquisition must be rights-cleared per item; E:/refs_lane_r is empty, so acquisition is the actual predecessor.
PENDING (no image) — GENERATION BARRED — LANE_R_ACQUISITION. liang_bua_cave carries care_tier ELEVATED and protected TRUE (build/zones/flores_island.csv), and board.md:138 rules that the five elevated-care zones can never dispatch to Lane G at all — the composer refuses and emits a Lane-R plate request instead. board.md:159 adds the site-specific bar: referenced, never reproduced as an active dig, and no Homo floresiensis body reconstruction rendered as a living character in the present. The seven plates are ACQUISITION AND UNDERLAY SPECS at the same grain as the generated rows.
ROW:liang-bua-from-inside-looking-out
title: Liang Bua — the cool cave, mouth and forest approach (Lane-R acquisition set)
canon_id liang_bua_cave in build/zones/flores_island.csv — canon_ref zone:liang_bua_cave@flores_island|beat:CH02_B01|beat:CH02_B11
citations: SRC_00193 (rows of registries/T0_Source_Material_Registry)
lane R · care_tier elevated · protected true · care read from build/zones/flores_island.csv @ zone_id liang_bua_cave
recommended candidate: 1 (PROVISIONAL)
care: CVD 17.1 elevated-care: Liang Bua is a protected real type-site — referenced, never reproduced, never staged as an active dig, and no Homo floresiensis body reconstruction as a living present-day character (board.md:159). Acquisition must be rights-cleared per item; E:/refs_lane_r is empty, so acquisition is the actual predecessor.
PENDING (no image) — GENERATION BARRED — LANE_R_ACQUISITION. liang_bua_cave carries care_tier ELEVATED and protected TRUE (build/zones/flores_island.csv), and board.md:138 rules that the five elevated-care zones can never dispatch to Lane G at all — the composer refuses and emits a Lane-R plate request instead. board.md:159 adds the site-specific bar: referenced, never reproduced as an active dig, and no Homo floresiensis body reconstruction rendered as a living character in the present. The seven plates are ACQUISITION AND UNDERLAY SPECS at the same grain as the generated rows.
ROW:liang-bua-forest-approach-traversal
title: Liang Bua — the cool cave, mouth and forest approach (Lane-R acquisition set)
canon_id liang_bua_cave in build/zones/flores_island.csv — canon_ref zone:liang_bua_cave@flores_island|beat:CH02_B01|beat:CH02_B11
citations: SRC_00193 (rows of registries/T0_Source_Material_Registry)
lane R · care_tier elevated · protected true · care read from build/zones/flores_island.csv @ zone_id liang_bua_cave
recommended candidate: 1 (PROVISIONAL)
care: CVD 17.1 elevated-care: Liang Bua is a protected real type-site — referenced, never reproduced, never staged as an active dig, and no Homo floresiensis body reconstruction as a living present-day character (board.md:159). Acquisition must be rights-cleared per item; E:/refs_lane_r is empty, so acquisition is the actual predecessor.
PENDING (no image) — GENERATION BARRED — LANE_R_ACQUISITION. liang_bua_cave carries care_tier ELEVATED and protected TRUE (build/zones/flores_island.csv), and board.md:138 rules that the five elevated-care zones can never dispatch to Lane G at all — the composer refuses and emits a Lane-R plate request instead. board.md:159 adds the site-specific bar: referenced, never reproduced as an active dig, and no Homo floresiensis body reconstruction rendered as a living character in the present. The seven plates are ACQUISITION AND UNDERLAY SPECS at the same grain as the generated rows.
ROW:liang-bua-dawn-mood
title: Liang Bua — the cool cave, mouth and forest approach (Lane-R acquisition set)
canon_id liang_bua_cave in build/zones/flores_island.csv — canon_ref zone:liang_bua_cave@flores_island|beat:CH02_B01|beat:CH02_B11
citations: SRC_00193 (rows of registries/T0_Source_Material_Registry)
lane R · care_tier elevated · protected true · care read from build/zones/flores_island.csv @ zone_id liang_bua_cave
recommended candidate: 1 (PROVISIONAL)
care: CVD 17.1 elevated-care: Liang Bua is a protected real type-site — referenced, never reproduced, never staged as an active dig, and no Homo floresiensis body reconstruction as a living present-day character (board.md:159). Acquisition must be rights-cleared per item; E:/refs_lane_r is empty, so acquisition is the actual predecessor.
PENDING (no image) — GENERATION BARRED — LANE_R_ACQUISITION. liang_bua_cave carries care_tier ELEVATED and protected TRUE (build/zones/flores_island.csv), and board.md:138 rules that the five elevated-care zones can never dispatch to Lane G at all — the composer refuses and emits a Lane-R plate request instead. board.md:159 adds the site-specific bar: referenced, never reproduced as an active dig, and no Homo floresiensis body reconstruction rendered as a living character in the present. The seven plates are ACQUISITION AND UNDERLAY SPECS at the same grain as the generated rows.
ROW:liang-bua-midday-mood
title: Liang Bua — the cool cave, mouth and forest approach (Lane-R acquisition set)
canon_id liang_bua_cave in build/zones/flores_island.csv — canon_ref zone:liang_bua_cave@flores_island|beat:CH02_B01|beat:CH02_B11
citations: SRC_00193 (rows of registries/T0_Source_Material_Registry)
lane R · care_tier elevated · protected true · care read from build/zones/flores_island.csv @ zone_id liang_bua_cave
recommended candidate: 1 (PROVISIONAL)
care: CVD 17.1 elevated-care: Liang Bua is a protected real type-site — referenced, never reproduced, never staged as an active dig, and no Homo floresiensis body reconstruction as a living present-day character (board.md:159). Acquisition must be rights-cleared per item; E:/refs_lane_r is empty, so acquisition is the actual predecessor.
PENDING (no image) — GENERATION BARRED — LANE_R_ACQUISITION. liang_bua_cave carries care_tier ELEVATED and protected TRUE (build/zones/flores_island.csv), and board.md:138 rules that the five elevated-care zones can never dispatch to Lane G at all — the composer refuses and emits a Lane-R plate request instead. board.md:159 adds the site-specific bar: referenced, never reproduced as an active dig, and no Homo floresiensis body reconstruction rendered as a living character in the present. The seven plates are ACQUISITION AND UNDERLAY SPECS at the same grain as the generated rows.
ROW:liang-bua-interior-site-plan
title: Liang Bua — the cool cave, mouth and forest approach (Lane-R acquisition set)
canon_id liang_bua_cave in build/zones/flores_island.csv — canon_ref zone:liang_bua_cave@flores_island|beat:CH02_B01|beat:CH02_B11
citations: SRC_00193 (rows of registries/T0_Source_Material_Registry)
lane R · care_tier elevated · protected true · care read from build/zones/flores_island.csv @ zone_id liang_bua_cave
recommended candidate: 1 (PROVISIONAL)
care: CVD 17.1 elevated-care: Liang Bua is a protected real type-site — referenced, never reproduced, never staged as an active dig, and no Homo floresiensis body reconstruction as a living present-day character (board.md:159). Acquisition must be rights-cleared per item; E:/refs_lane_r is empty, so acquisition is the actual predecessor.
PENDING (no image) — GENERATION BARRED — LANE_R_ACQUISITION. liang_bua_cave carries care_tier ELEVATED and protected TRUE (build/zones/flores_island.csv), and board.md:138 rules that the five elevated-care zones can never dispatch to Lane G at all — the composer refuses and emits a Lane-R plate request instead. board.md:159 adds the site-specific bar: referenced, never reproduced as an active dig, and no Homo floresiensis body reconstruction rendered as a living character in the present. The seven plates are ACQUISITION AND UNDERLAY SPECS at the same grain as the generated rows.
Canon coverage — what this board does not carry
12 subjects this leaf's canon scope names; 6 carry a generated candidate and 6 are held.
liang-bua-mouth-establishing — GENERATION BARRED — LANE_R_ACQUISITION. liang_bua_cave carries care_tier ELEVATED and protected TRUE (build/zones/flores_island.csv), and board.md:138 rules that the five elevated-care zones can never dispatch to Lane G at all — the composer refuses and emits a Lane-R plate request instead. board.md:159 adds the site-specific bar: referenced, never reproduced as an active dig, and no Homo floresiensis body reconstruction rendered as a living character in the present. The seven plates are ACQUISITION AND UNDERLAY SPECS at the same grain as the generated rows. (build/zones/flores_island.csv)
liang-bua-from-inside-looking-out — GENERATION BARRED — LANE_R_ACQUISITION. liang_bua_cave carries care_tier ELEVATED and protected TRUE (build/zones/flores_island.csv), and board.md:138 rules that the five elevated-care zones can never dispatch to Lane G at all — the composer refuses and emits a Lane-R plate request instead. board.md:159 adds the site-specific bar: referenced, never reproduced as an active dig, and no Homo floresiensis body reconstruction rendered as a living character in the present. The seven plates are ACQUISITION AND UNDERLAY SPECS at the same grain as the generated rows. (build/zones/flores_island.csv)
liang-bua-forest-approach-traversal — GENERATION BARRED — LANE_R_ACQUISITION. liang_bua_cave carries care_tier ELEVATED and protected TRUE (build/zones/flores_island.csv), and board.md:138 rules that the five elevated-care zones can never dispatch to Lane G at all — the composer refuses and emits a Lane-R plate request instead. board.md:159 adds the site-specific bar: referenced, never reproduced as an active dig, and no Homo floresiensis body reconstruction rendered as a living character in the present. The seven plates are ACQUISITION AND UNDERLAY SPECS at the same grain as the generated rows. (build/zones/flores_island.csv)
liang-bua-dawn-mood — GENERATION BARRED — LANE_R_ACQUISITION. liang_bua_cave carries care_tier ELEVATED and protected TRUE (build/zones/flores_island.csv), and board.md:138 rules that the five elevated-care zones can never dispatch to Lane G at all — the composer refuses and emits a Lane-R plate request instead. board.md:159 adds the site-specific bar: referenced, never reproduced as an active dig, and no Homo floresiensis body reconstruction rendered as a living character in the present. The seven plates are ACQUISITION AND UNDERLAY SPECS at the same grain as the generated rows. (build/zones/flores_island.csv)
liang-bua-midday-mood — GENERATION BARRED — LANE_R_ACQUISITION. liang_bua_cave carries care_tier ELEVATED and protected TRUE (build/zones/flores_island.csv), and board.md:138 rules that the five elevated-care zones can never dispatch to Lane G at all — the composer refuses and emits a Lane-R plate request instead. board.md:159 adds the site-specific bar: referenced, never reproduced as an active dig, and no Homo floresiensis body reconstruction rendered as a living character in the present. The seven plates are ACQUISITION AND UNDERLAY SPECS at the same grain as the generated rows. (build/zones/flores_island.csv)
liang-bua-interior-site-plan — GENERATION BARRED — LANE_R_ACQUISITION. liang_bua_cave carries care_tier ELEVATED and protected TRUE (build/zones/flores_island.csv), and board.md:138 rules that the five elevated-care zones can never dispatch to Lane G at all — the composer refuses and emits a Lane-R plate request instead. board.md:159 adds the site-specific bar: referenced, never reproduced as an active dig, and no Homo floresiensis body reconstruction rendered as a living character in the present. The seven plates are ACQUISITION AND UNDERLAY SPECS at the same grain as the generated rows. (build/zones/flores_island.csv)
Generated by harness/site/structure_site.py — the URL path is the repo path. review root