GENERATED FILE. Rendered from MANIFEST.csv, PLATES.csv, RECS.csv and this board's content.json by harness/boards/render_board.py --board BRD_0016. Do not hand-edit; edit the sources.
board_shape leaf_candidate_sheet (row grain) — 5 rows × up to 4 candidates — approval_state critics_running — private
generation_class living — care_tier standard — generation_tier region_hero — decay_stage present
the four adversarial critics have NOT run on this plate set; critic_verdicts is empty and marketing_eligible computes false
every recommended_candidate in RECS.csv is PROVISIONAL until the REC vision pass runs
ROW:kelimutu-rim-circulation-plan
title: The Kelimutu three-crater-lake rim, with Tiwu Ata Polo
canon_id kelimutu_crater_lakes in build/zones/flores_island.csv — canon_ref zone:kelimutu_crater_lakes@flores_island|beat:CH02_B06
citations: SRC_00457, SRC_00483 (rows of registries/T0_Source_Material_Registry)
lane G · care_tier standard · protected false · care read from build/zones/flores_island.csv @ zone_id kelimutu_crater_lakes
recommended candidate: 1 (PROVISIONAL)
care: The lakes are the epicentre of Patika, a LIVING Lio annual ritual — referenced, never reproduced or invented, so no ceremonial content may be authored into any plate, and staging the rim as a managed tourist viewpoint flattens the sacred_site register even where no ceremony is shown. The colour shifts are held as documented volcanic-lake mineral chemistry AND, held distinct, as the lake-of-the-dead tradition. THE COLOUR TRIPLE IS HELD AUTHORED-PENDING-ACQUISITION: no plate asserts which three colours, only that the three waterlines must be MUTUALLY DISTINCT — so no plate on this row is ratifiable as the palette answer.
REC verdict REGENERATE_ALL
REC reason: All four are monochrome aerial-survey orthophotos of a road-cut farming valley with garbled map lettering — no caldera, no three lakes, no circulation read at all.
REC defects: Text/map-label artifacts in all four (O1 'SAMYSING'/'430'/'80'; O3 'oinnhmalue'); a graded highway corridor runs through every plate (modern infrastructure); wrong subject entirely — no crater rim, no three mutually-distinct waterlines, no walkable circulation diagram; register is survey photo, not a layout plan.
REGENERATED after vision review — 14 superseded plate(s) kept; recommendation void until the review runs again
PENDING (no image) — NOT BARRED — LANE_G. Standard-care Zone-Catalog ground or neutral-ground subject: zone care_tier 'standard' and protected FALSE (build/zones/flores_island.csv), and the entity-side cultural_depiction_required flag is absent or FALSE on every id this row keys or references. Both halves of the predicate are recorded on the row so the refusal stays arithmetic.
ROW:kelimutu-climax-pocket-in-the-wall-section
title: The Kelimutu three-crater-lake rim, with Tiwu Ata Polo
canon_id kelimutu_crater_lakes in build/zones/flores_island.csv — canon_ref zone:kelimutu_crater_lakes@flores_island|beat:CH02_B06
citations: SRC_00457, SRC_00483 (rows of registries/T0_Source_Material_Registry)
lane G · care_tier standard · protected false · care read from build/zones/flores_island.csv @ zone_id kelimutu_crater_lakes
recommended candidate: 4 (PROVISIONAL)
care: The lakes are the epicentre of Patika, a LIVING Lio annual ritual — referenced, never reproduced or invented, so no ceremonial content may be authored into any plate, and staging the rim as a managed tourist viewpoint flattens the sacred_site register even where no ceremony is shown. The colour shifts are held as documented volcanic-lake mineral chemistry AND, held distinct, as the lake-of-the-dead tradition. THE COLOUR TRIPLE IS HELD AUTHORED-PENDING-ACQUISITION: no plate asserts which three colours, only that the three waterlines must be MUTUALLY DISTINCT — so no plate on this row is ratifiable as the palette answer.
REC verdict REGENERATE_ALL
REC reason: Every candidate is a centred waterfall-into-turquoise-pool quarry scene rather than a section through the crater-wall pocket, and each carries a hard defect.
REC defects: Conifers on the rim in O1, O3 and O4 (forbidden species); O2's wall is a collage of manufactured objects (keypad, printed panels, boxes) plus a timber rail; O3 carries garbled wall lettering and a modern building on the horizon; O4 is flat-vector register with hard centred symmetry; none is a section, and the alpine-turquoise water abandons the Kelimutu mineral colour set.
REGENERATED after vision review — 14 superseded plate(s) kept; recommendation void until the review runs again
PENDING (no image) — NOT BARRED — LANE_G. Standard-care Zone-Catalog ground or neutral-ground subject: zone care_tier 'standard' and protected FALSE (build/zones/flores_island.csv), and the entity-side cultural_depiction_required flag is absent or FALSE on every id this row keys or references. Both halves of the predicate are recorded on the row so the refusal stays arithmetic.
ROW:kelimutu-perspective-aerial
title: Kelimutu rim perspective set
caption: The three-lake rim read three ways; the colours are chemistry and the tradition is held separately.
canon_id kelimutu_crater_lakes in build/zones/flores_island.csv — canon_ref zone:kelimutu_crater_lakes@flores_island|beat:CH02_B06|beat:CH02_B08
citations: SRC_00457, SRC_00483 (rows of registries/T0_Source_Material_Registry)
lane G · care_tier standard · protected false · care read from build/zones/flores_island.csv @ zone_id kelimutu_crater_lakes
recommended candidate: 2 (PROVISIONAL)
care: LANE G (RAW GENERATION), standard-care zone. The colour set is rendered as documented volcanic-lake mineral chemistry, never as proof of the supernatural. Patika, the Lio annual ritual whose epicentre is these lakes, is REFERENCED and never reproduced or invented (flores_island.md:445-450) — no ceremonial content is authored anywhere on this row. KEY ADJACENCY DECLARED — NEW PLATES FOR AN EXISTING SUBJECT, NEVER A RE-KEY: D1-03/kelimutu_crater_lakes is already held by the LANDED row kelimutu-three-lakes-rim (PLT_G012_1..4 on BRD_0003), which this row joins on the same leaf and the same key with the rim's three-view perspective set. D1-03's formula is climactic_plates = sites_with_affordance x 3, so the SITE counts once against the floor however many rows hang on it.
REC verdict MIXED — recommended candidate O2
REC reason: O2 is the only candidate that delivers three mutually-distinct waterlines with no text artifact — O1 carries a watermark, O3 and O4 show only two lakes.
REC defects: O1 has a legible 'BAROSAAGE' text artifact on the dark lake; O3 and O4 fail the three-distinct-waterlines requirement; all four sit in a grey-black lunar moonscape webbed with graded haul roads that reads as an open-pit mine and drops the wet cloud-forest green the bible fixes — regenerate O2 with vegetated flanks and no road network.
O1 D1-03/kelimutu_crater_lakes/establishing__c51e9c411e36.png sha256 c1d1c948dd6213d1... plate PLT_A0096_1 licence record docs/licence_records/art_boards_plates/PLT_A0096_1.json
O3 D1-03/kelimutu_crater_lakes/establishing__9aa62cc60998.png sha256 1a348f196d00def4... plate PLT_A0096_3 licence record docs/licence_records/art_boards_plates/PLT_A0096_3.json
O4 D1-03/kelimutu_crater_lakes/establishing__35bea451ec88.png sha256 5c2e76e6f812d0b2... plate PLT_A0096_4 licence record docs/licence_records/art_boards_plates/PLT_A0096_4.json
ROW:kelimutu-perspective-eye-level
title: Kelimutu rim perspective set
caption: The three-lake rim read three ways; the colours are chemistry and the tradition is held separately.
canon_id kelimutu_crater_lakes in build/zones/flores_island.csv — canon_ref zone:kelimutu_crater_lakes@flores_island|beat:CH02_B06|beat:CH02_B08
citations: SRC_00457, SRC_00483 (rows of registries/T0_Source_Material_Registry)
lane G · care_tier standard · protected false · care read from build/zones/flores_island.csv @ zone_id kelimutu_crater_lakes
recommended candidate: 2 (PROVISIONAL)
care: LANE G (RAW GENERATION), standard-care zone. The colour set is rendered as documented volcanic-lake mineral chemistry, never as proof of the supernatural. Patika, the Lio annual ritual whose epicentre is these lakes, is REFERENCED and never reproduced or invented (flores_island.md:445-450) — no ceremonial content is authored anywhere on this row. KEY ADJACENCY DECLARED — NEW PLATES FOR AN EXISTING SUBJECT, NEVER A RE-KEY: D1-03/kelimutu_crater_lakes is already held by the LANDED row kelimutu-three-lakes-rim (PLT_G012_1..4 on BRD_0003), which this row joins on the same leaf and the same key with the rim's three-view perspective set. D1-03's formula is climactic_plates = sites_with_affordance x 3, so the SITE counts once against the floor however many rows hang on it.
REC verdict MIXED — recommended candidate O2
REC reason: O2 is the cleanest rim read — coherent crater wall, no artifacts, correct plain-undyed garment and barefoot child, and no temperate pasture in the background.
REC defects: O4 shows green pasture and track-lined farmland plus a black wound-like blot on the leg; O1 has a dark tube-like object on the shore and temperate brown farmland horizon; O3 puts green sward on the rim; all four render one grey-teal lake in a slate-quarry register with no Flores mineral colour or vegetation. NOTE: the pointed ears are CORRECT — CVD says the protagonist is canonically elf — do not regenerate them out.
O1 D1-03/kelimutu_crater_lakes/angle__8150d66e80aa.png sha256 5afa22e7c212f417... plate PLT_A0097_1 licence record docs/licence_records/art_boards_plates/PLT_A0097_1.json
O3 D1-03/kelimutu_crater_lakes/angle__3272e7f00b50.png sha256 7c227b23e0004a2d... plate PLT_A0097_3 licence record docs/licence_records/art_boards_plates/PLT_A0097_3.json
O4 D1-03/kelimutu_crater_lakes/angle__5aa7697d2eb0.png sha256 ad0e35a502b62c11... plate PLT_A0097_4 licence record docs/licence_records/art_boards_plates/PLT_A0097_4.json
ROW:kelimutu-perspective-low-angle-detail
title: Kelimutu rim perspective set
caption: The three-lake rim read three ways; the colours are chemistry and the tradition is held separately.
canon_id kelimutu_crater_lakes in build/zones/flores_island.csv — canon_ref zone:kelimutu_crater_lakes@flores_island|beat:CH02_B06|beat:CH02_B08
citations: SRC_00457, SRC_00483 (rows of registries/T0_Source_Material_Registry)
lane G · care_tier standard · protected false · care read from build/zones/flores_island.csv @ zone_id kelimutu_crater_lakes
recommended candidate: 3 (PROVISIONAL)
care: LANE G (RAW GENERATION), standard-care zone. The colour set is rendered as documented volcanic-lake mineral chemistry, never as proof of the supernatural. Patika, the Lio annual ritual whose epicentre is these lakes, is REFERENCED and never reproduced or invented (flores_island.md:445-450) — no ceremonial content is authored anywhere on this row. KEY ADJACENCY DECLARED — NEW PLATES FOR AN EXISTING SUBJECT, NEVER A RE-KEY: D1-03/kelimutu_crater_lakes is already held by the LANDED row kelimutu-three-lakes-rim (PLT_G012_1..4 on BRD_0003), which this row joins on the same leaf and the same key with the rim's three-view perspective set. D1-03's formula is climactic_plates = sites_with_affordance x 3, so the SITE counts once against the floor however many rows hang on it.
REC verdict PICK_READY — recommended candidate O3
REC reason: O3 is the strongest plate on either board: sulphur crust, black scoria and yellow mineral water under ash-haze light, with no manufactured object, text or artifact anywhere in frame.
REC defects: O2 has a machined ribbed grille object in the shingle and a blue-sky register off the dry-ash weather profile; O4 has a white plastic grommet ring on the scoria; O1 carries a floating translucent shard with a wire-like line.
O1 D1-03/kelimutu_crater_lakes/detail__6a0e8e64788b.png sha256 efaf3e39c228d074... plate PLT_A0098_1 licence record docs/licence_records/art_boards_plates/PLT_A0098_1.json
O2 D1-03/kelimutu_crater_lakes/detail__f75ec4917e02.png sha256 07980f5643a148ec... plate PLT_A0098_2 licence record docs/licence_records/art_boards_plates/PLT_A0098_2.json