GENERATED FILE. Rendered from MANIFEST.csv, PLATES.csv, RECS.csv and this board's content.json by harness/boards/render_board.py --board BRD_0015. Do not hand-edit; edit the sources.
board_shape leaf_candidate_sheet (row grain) — 11 rows × up to 4 candidates — approval_state critics_running — private
generation_class living — care_tier standard — generation_tier region_hero — decay_stage present
the four adversarial critics have NOT run on this plate set; critic_verdicts is empty and marketing_eligible computes false
every recommended_candidate in RECS.csv is PROVISIONAL until the REC vision pass runs
ROW:recharge-waterfall-first-water
title: CH02_B04 / VS_CH02_001 — the recharge waterfall and the first water
canon_id VS_CH02_001 in T0_Vril_Site_Registry/Sheet1 — canon_ref site:VS_CH02_001|zone:recharge_waterfall@flores_island|beat:CH02_B04|scene:SC_CH02_first_water
citations: SRC_00483, SRC_00203 (rows of registries/T0_Source_Material_Registry)
lane G · care_tier standard · protected false
recommended candidate: 4 (PROVISIONAL)
care: The impossible-light clause reads NONE PROPOSED and the reason is canon, not caution: the recharge mechanic is the ONLY surface through which the substrate is shown, and it is never declared — so this plate's physics must stay entirely real, and any glow breaks the chapter's L3 discipline (HL_0028: Neophyte vril-trace register only).
REC verdict REGENERATE_ALL
REC reason: CHILD-SAFETY BREACH: O1 and O2 render the child unclothed and O3/O4 put him in modern swim briefs — this is the v1 failure the row's own v2 ruling documents, and no candidate carries the affirmative garment.
REC defects: Unclothed child on O1/O2 (unusable, do not circulate); modern swimwear on O3/O4, explicitly barred; the ruled positive garment — plain soaked mud-caked cloth covering torso and thighs — is absent on all 4. Highest-priority regeneration on the board.
REGENERATED after vision review — 9 superseded plate(s) kept; recommendation void until the review runs again
O1 D1-40/VS_CH02_001/board_candidate__628c7b583f3c.png sha256 f732d86621d5af7b... plate PLT_C047_1 licence record docs/licence_records/art_boards_plates/PLT_C047_1.json
title: CH02_B04 / VS_CH02_001 — the recharge waterfall and the first water
canon_id VS_CH02_001 in T0_Vril_Site_Registry/Sheet1 — canon_ref site:VS_CH02_001|zone:recharge_waterfall@flores_island|beat:CH02_B04|scene:SC_CH02_first_water
citations: SRC_00203, SRC_00483 (rows of registries/T0_Source_Material_Registry)
lane G · care_tier standard · protected false · care read from build/zones/flores_island.csv @ zone_id recharge_waterfall
recommended candidate: 4 (PROVISIONAL)
care: CHILD-SAFETY RULING, v2, binding on every plate in this pack that shows the protagonist: the costume is stated AFFIRMATIVELY and never as a negative. v1's row carried 'no modern swimwear or clothing' as its only wardrobe instruction and named no positive garment; the model resolved that as no clothing at all and produced an unusable plate of an unclothed child. Every v2 plate states the garment positively AND carries the explicit nudity negative. The fairy-realm garment stays deferred to the slice-end pass, so the garment is plain, soaked and mud-caked and reads as STATE, not design. Impossible-light clause NONE PROPOSED: the physics here stays entirely real and any glow breaks the chapter's L3 discipline (HL_0028).
REC verdict REGENERATE_ALL
REC reason: Every candidate sites the falls inside a landscaped built water feature — retaining walls, cut steps, cobble-faced masonry and a timber deck — in a zone the care line declares uninhabited with no built structure.
REC defects: Concrete/timber retaining wall (O1), paved steps and platform (O2), cobble-clad wall and woven panel (O3), painted coping wall plus timber deck and hanging lamp (O4); child bare-torsoed in a waist wrap on all 4 rather than the ruled torso-and-thigh covering garment.
REGENERATED after vision review — 9 superseded plate(s) kept; recommendation void until the review runs again
O1 D1-40/VS_CH02_001/establishing__168cba4e0066.png sha256 e6a3b81b58e18d51... plate PLT_C048_1 licence record docs/licence_records/art_boards_plates/PLT_C048_1.json
title: CH02_B04 / VS_CH02_001 — the recharge waterfall and the first water
canon_id VS_CH02_001 in T0_Vril_Site_Registry/Sheet1 — canon_ref site:VS_CH02_001|zone:recharge_waterfall@flores_island|beat:CH02_B04|scene:SC_CH02_first_water
citations: SRC_00203, SRC_00483 (rows of registries/T0_Source_Material_Registry)
lane G · care_tier standard · protected false · care read from build/zones/flores_island.csv @ zone_id recharge_waterfall
recommended candidate: 4 (PROVISIONAL)
care: CHILD-SAFETY RULING, v2, binding on every plate in this pack that shows the protagonist: the costume is stated AFFIRMATIVELY and never as a negative. v1's row carried 'no modern swimwear or clothing' as its only wardrobe instruction and named no positive garment; the model resolved that as no clothing at all and produced an unusable plate of an unclothed child. Every v2 plate states the garment positively AND carries the explicit nudity negative. The fairy-realm garment stays deferred to the slice-end pass, so the garment is plain, soaked and mud-caked and reads as STATE, not design. Impossible-light clause NONE PROPOSED: the physics here stays entirely real and any glow breaks the chapter's L3 discipline (HL_0028).
REC verdict MIXED — recommended candidate O4
REC reason: O4 gives the cleanest lip-looking-down read on natural irregular basalt with no masonry-like courses and no artifacts.
REC defects: O1/O2 right-hand rock face reads as coursed masonry; O3 carries small text-like scribbles on the lower rock; whole row sits in a flat cel/vector register that drifts from the region's realistic-ethnographic bar.
O1 D1-40/VS_CH02_001/angle__edba66961e06.png sha256 0f756957b9917bbc... plate PLT_A0085_1 licence record docs/licence_records/art_boards_plates/PLT_A0085_1.json
O2 D1-40/VS_CH02_001/angle__ecdd9126f073.png sha256 66cc6e47e67ca500... plate PLT_A0085_2 licence record docs/licence_records/art_boards_plates/PLT_A0085_2.json
O3 D1-40/VS_CH02_001/angle__1e636a9497e3.png sha256 3fe66e9ad0fde68a... plate PLT_A0085_3 licence record docs/licence_records/art_boards_plates/PLT_A0085_3.json
title: CH02_B04 / VS_CH02_001 — the recharge waterfall and the first water
canon_id VS_CH02_001 in T0_Vril_Site_Registry/Sheet1 — canon_ref site:VS_CH02_001|zone:recharge_waterfall@flores_island|beat:CH02_B04|scene:SC_CH02_first_water
citations: SRC_00203, SRC_00483 (rows of registries/T0_Source_Material_Registry)
lane G · care_tier standard · protected false · care read from build/zones/flores_island.csv @ zone_id recharge_waterfall
recommended candidate: 4 (PROVISIONAL)
care: CHILD-SAFETY RULING, v2, binding on every plate in this pack that shows the protagonist: the costume is stated AFFIRMATIVELY and never as a negative. v1's row carried 'no modern swimwear or clothing' as its only wardrobe instruction and named no positive garment; the model resolved that as no clothing at all and produced an unusable plate of an unclothed child. Every v2 plate states the garment positively AND carries the explicit nudity negative. The fairy-realm garment stays deferred to the slice-end pass, so the garment is plain, soaked and mud-caked and reads as STATE, not design. Impossible-light clause NONE PROPOSED: the physics here stays entirely real and any glow breaks the chapter's L3 discipline (HL_0028).
REC verdict MIXED — recommended candidate O4
REC reason: O4 is the only candidate whose left-bank slab reads as a natural limestone ledge rather than a cut stair, and its garment correctly covers torso and thighs.
REC defects: Cut-stone stairs or concrete-like pavers on the left bank in O1/O2/O3; O3 has a malformed hand; the tunic reads as a tailored modern hooded anorak with topstitched seams and the mud-caked state is under-rendered across the row.
O1 D1-40/VS_CH02_001/traversal__8032f4ae6cb9.png sha256 6bb4bef30a3e33b8... plate PLT_A0086_1 licence record docs/licence_records/art_boards_plates/PLT_A0086_1.json
O2 D1-40/VS_CH02_001/traversal__dad8d84cf455.png sha256 fea149194b40a528... plate PLT_A0086_2 licence record docs/licence_records/art_boards_plates/PLT_A0086_2.json
O3 D1-40/VS_CH02_001/traversal__5aa84accd41e.png sha256 c3877dfa74fa8f39... plate PLT_A0086_3 licence record docs/licence_records/art_boards_plates/PLT_A0086_3.json
title: CH02_B04 / VS_CH02_001 — the recharge waterfall and the first water
canon_id VS_CH02_001 in T0_Vril_Site_Registry/Sheet1 — canon_ref site:VS_CH02_001|zone:recharge_waterfall@flores_island|beat:CH02_B04|scene:SC_CH02_first_water
citations: SRC_00203, SRC_00483 (rows of registries/T0_Source_Material_Registry)
lane G · care_tier standard · protected false · care read from build/zones/flores_island.csv @ zone_id recharge_waterfall
recommended candidate: 2 (PROVISIONAL)
care: CHILD-SAFETY RULING, v2, binding on every plate in this pack that shows the protagonist: the costume is stated AFFIRMATIVELY and never as a negative. v1's row carried 'no modern swimwear or clothing' as its only wardrobe instruction and named no positive garment; the model resolved that as no clothing at all and produced an unusable plate of an unclothed child. Every v2 plate states the garment positively AND carries the explicit nudity negative. The fairy-realm garment stays deferred to the slice-end pass, so the garment is plain, soaked and mud-caked and reads as STATE, not design. Impossible-light clause NONE PROPOSED: the physics here stays entirely real and any glow breaks the chapter's L3 discipline (HL_0028).
REC verdict MIXED — recommended candidate O2
REC reason: O4 breaks the dead-centre axis best and carries the truest cold-dawn read — cool blue mist against warm sky through the canopy gap — with no conifers and no glow.
REC defects: All four compose the fall on the vertical centre axis; flat vector register against the region's realistic bar; O4 carries a stray plank-like object floating on the pool; canopy is thin for cloud forest.
O1 D1-40/VS_CH02_001/mood__a4271f75314e.png sha256 7eac9c429835940b... plate PLT_A0087_1 licence record docs/licence_records/art_boards_plates/PLT_A0087_1.json
O3 D1-40/VS_CH02_001/mood__dd535815faf1.png sha256 61c21ff893458d3d... plate PLT_A0087_3 licence record docs/licence_records/art_boards_plates/PLT_A0087_3.json
O4 D1-40/VS_CH02_001/mood__e66d87c81647.png sha256 3fec7dccde7b8cd5... plate PLT_A0087_4 licence record docs/licence_records/art_boards_plates/PLT_A0087_4.json
ROW:falls-high-sun-spray-ring
title: CH02_B04 / VS_CH02_001 — the recharge waterfall and the first water
canon_id VS_CH02_001 in T0_Vril_Site_Registry/Sheet1 — canon_ref site:VS_CH02_001|zone:recharge_waterfall@flores_island|beat:CH02_B04|scene:SC_CH02_first_water
citations: SRC_00203, SRC_00483 (rows of registries/T0_Source_Material_Registry)
lane G · care_tier standard · protected false · care read from build/zones/flores_island.csv @ zone_id recharge_waterfall
recommended candidate: 1 (PROVISIONAL)
care: CHILD-SAFETY RULING, v2, binding on every plate in this pack that shows the protagonist: the costume is stated AFFIRMATIVELY and never as a negative. v1's row carried 'no modern swimwear or clothing' as its only wardrobe instruction and named no positive garment; the model resolved that as no clothing at all and produced an unusable plate of an unclothed child. Every v2 plate states the garment positively AND carries the explicit nudity negative. The fairy-realm garment stays deferred to the slice-end pass, so the garment is plain, soaked and mud-caked and reads as STATE, not design. Impossible-light clause NONE PROPOSED: the physics here stays entirely real and any glow breaks the chapter's L3 discipline (HL_0028).
REC verdict REGENERATE_ALL
REC reason: The row's spray ring has been literalised as a glowing luminous ring or portal disc on all four, which is a direct breach of the NONE-PROPOSED impossible-light clause, and no candidate contains a waterfall at all.
REC defects: Non-physical glowing ring/portal on all 4 (HL_0028 / L3 discipline); subject entirely missing — no falls, no high sun, no spray; O2 shows an arid mountain vista; child staged bare-shouldered in a designed white drape-and-veil costume instead of the ruled plain soaked garment.
REGENERATED after vision review — 9 superseded plate(s) kept; recommendation void until the review runs again
O1 D1-40/VS_CH02_001/mood__59dda2916ffb.png sha256 ef795f3eeec5531b... plate PLT_C049_1 licence record docs/licence_records/art_boards_plates/PLT_C049_1.json
title: CH02_B04 / VS_CH02_001 — the recharge waterfall and the first water
canon_id VS_CH02_001 in T0_Vril_Site_Registry/Sheet1 — canon_ref site:VS_CH02_001|zone:recharge_waterfall@flores_island|beat:CH02_B04|scene:SC_CH02_first_water
citations: SRC_00203, SRC_00483 (rows of registries/T0_Source_Material_Registry)
lane G · care_tier standard · protected false · care read from build/zones/flores_island.csv @ zone_id recharge_waterfall
recommended candidate: 2 (PROVISIONAL)
care: CHILD-SAFETY RULING, v2, binding on every plate in this pack that shows the protagonist: the costume is stated AFFIRMATIVELY and never as a negative. v1's row carried 'no modern swimwear or clothing' as its only wardrobe instruction and named no positive garment; the model resolved that as no clothing at all and produced an unusable plate of an unclothed child. Every v2 plate states the garment positively AND carries the explicit nudity negative. The fairy-realm garment stays deferred to the slice-end pass, so the garment is plain, soaked and mud-caked and reads as STATE, not design. Impossible-light clause NONE PROPOSED: the physics here stays entirely real and any glow breaks the chapter's L3 discipline (HL_0028).
REC verdict MIXED — recommended candidate O2
REC reason: O2 is the only strong dusk green-gold read that is free of conifers, with the richest canyon walls and tree-fern foreground.
REC defects: O1 and O3 put conifers on the skyline (forbidden); the whole row reads temperate-canyon rather than Flores cloud forest — sparse bamboo/tree-fern cover, no karst or volcanic-black material read; flat vector register.
O1 D1-40/VS_CH02_001/mood__f52359b5c5b5.png sha256 0100f4ede36e1b25... plate PLT_A0089_1 licence record docs/licence_records/art_boards_plates/PLT_A0089_1.json
O3 D1-40/VS_CH02_001/mood__e9b4c2a11b59.png sha256 4ce21a3e9111f2a5... plate PLT_A0089_3 licence record docs/licence_records/art_boards_plates/PLT_A0089_3.json
O4 D1-40/VS_CH02_001/mood__9b696ac8c891.png sha256 60b8422cf897fc1a... plate PLT_A0089_4 licence record docs/licence_records/art_boards_plates/PLT_A0089_4.json
ROW:falls-rock-and-spray-material-detail
title: CH02_B04 / VS_CH02_001 — the recharge waterfall and the first water
canon_id VS_CH02_001 in T0_Vril_Site_Registry/Sheet1 — canon_ref site:VS_CH02_001|zone:recharge_waterfall@flores_island|beat:CH02_B04|scene:SC_CH02_first_water
citations: SRC_00203, SRC_00483 (rows of registries/T0_Source_Material_Registry)
lane G · care_tier standard · protected false · care read from build/zones/flores_island.csv @ zone_id recharge_waterfall
recommended candidate: 4 (PROVISIONAL)
care: CHILD-SAFETY RULING, v2, binding on every plate in this pack that shows the protagonist: the costume is stated AFFIRMATIVELY and never as a negative. v1's row carried 'no modern swimwear or clothing' as its only wardrobe instruction and named no positive garment; the model resolved that as no clothing at all and produced an unusable plate of an unclothed child. Every v2 plate states the garment positively AND carries the explicit nudity negative. The fairy-realm garment stays deferred to the slice-end pass, so the garment is plain, soaked and mud-caked and reads as STATE, not design. Impossible-light clause NONE PROPOSED: the physics here stays entirely real and any glow breaks the chapter's L3 discipline (HL_0028).
REC verdict PICK_READY — recommended candidate O4
REC reason: O4 is the cleanest material key — vesicular basalt, cave limestone, wet-margin fern mat and the spray curtain all legible, with no artifacts, text, manufactured objects or glow.
REC defects: Minor only: O4 duplicates the fern-mat cell twice; O2's basalt cell carries over-processed swirl lines and O3's limestone reads as marbled resin.
O1 D1-40/VS_CH02_001/detail__2910678a2de4.png sha256 233470a55789f571... plate PLT_A0090_1 licence record docs/licence_records/art_boards_plates/PLT_A0090_1.json
O2 D1-40/VS_CH02_001/detail__1ea1c1f443c7.png sha256 d5614fcaaffaea2d... plate PLT_A0090_2 licence record docs/licence_records/art_boards_plates/PLT_A0090_2.json
O3 D1-40/VS_CH02_001/detail__dc7a72638894.png sha256 642a613dff6f0194... plate PLT_A0090_3 licence record docs/licence_records/art_boards_plates/PLT_A0090_3.json
caption: The first-water site read three ways; the threshold is physical, never a glow.
canon_id VS_CH02_001 in T0_Vril_Site_Registry/Sheet1 — canon_ref site:VS_CH02_001|zone:recharge_waterfall@flores_island|beat:CH02_B04
citations: SRC_00203, SRC_00483 (rows of registries/T0_Source_Material_Registry)
lane G · care_tier standard · protected false · care read from build/zones/flores_island.csv @ zone_id recharge_waterfall
recommended candidate: 1 (PROVISIONAL)
care: LANE G (RAW GENERATION), standard-care zone, no protected subject; the vril substrate is shown as falling water and cool air alone, with no cast effect and no aura. KEY ADJACENCY DECLARED — NEW PLATES FOR AN EXISTING SUBJECT, NEVER A RE-KEY: D1-40/VS_CH02_001 is already held by the LANDED row recharge-waterfall-first-water (PLT_G007_1..4 on BRD_0015). This row joins that same leaf board on that same key and adds the site's three-view perspective set; the consumers differ (the landed row is CH02_B04's key frame, this set establishes the place from three camera positions), and because D1-40's formula is vril_plates = vril_site_rows x 3 the two rows count as ONE site against the floor. THE VRIL SITE'S NAME IS NOT THE ZONE: T0_Vril_Site_Registry gives VS_CH02_001 the site_name 'Liang Bua Cave waterfall vicinity', which is descriptive of the vicinity, while the ground these plates stand in is the recharge_waterfall zone (care_tier standard, protected false). The two are separate rows at separate coordinates — recharge_waterfall w=120.37085..120.39085 / s=-8.54934..-8.52934 against liang_bua_cave w=120.43329..120.45329 / s=-8.54061..-8.52061, non-overlapping boxes roughly 6.5 km apart (build/zones/flores_island.csv zone_bounds_wgs84) — which is why liang_bua_cave's elevated bar stops at its own zone and this row releases.
REC verdict PICK_READY — recommended candidate O1
REC reason: O1 gives the deepest amphitheatre read with a clear cliff band, plunge pool and outflow stream, in a plausible tropical canopy with no built structure, text or glow.
REC defects: Minor only: O2 has a red man-made-looking object in the top-right canopy and O3 shows mown pasture and hedge blobs at the top-right corner; O1/O4 carry small ambiguous pale corner patches.
O2 D1-40/VS_CH02_001/establishing__81fad0f12c8b.png sha256 65364d39107af673... plate PLT_A0091_2 licence record docs/licence_records/art_boards_plates/PLT_A0091_2.json
O3 D1-40/VS_CH02_001/establishing__f2d2c895cb4a.png sha256 763d01198e28e537... plate PLT_A0091_3 licence record docs/licence_records/art_boards_plates/PLT_A0091_3.json
O4 D1-40/VS_CH02_001/establishing__fc23c197dc53.png sha256 d3d30c6fc0a47eb6... plate PLT_A0091_4 licence record docs/licence_records/art_boards_plates/PLT_A0091_4.json
ROW:waterfall-perspective-eye-level
title: Recharge waterfall perspective set
caption: The first-water site read three ways; the threshold is physical, never a glow.
canon_id VS_CH02_001 in T0_Vril_Site_Registry/Sheet1 — canon_ref site:VS_CH02_001|zone:recharge_waterfall@flores_island|beat:CH02_B04
citations: SRC_00203, SRC_00483 (rows of registries/T0_Source_Material_Registry)
lane G · care_tier standard · protected false · care read from build/zones/flores_island.csv @ zone_id recharge_waterfall
recommended candidate: 1 (PROVISIONAL)
care: LANE G (RAW GENERATION), standard-care zone, no protected subject; the vril substrate is shown as falling water and cool air alone, with no cast effect and no aura. KEY ADJACENCY DECLARED — NEW PLATES FOR AN EXISTING SUBJECT, NEVER A RE-KEY: D1-40/VS_CH02_001 is already held by the LANDED row recharge-waterfall-first-water (PLT_G007_1..4 on BRD_0015). This row joins that same leaf board on that same key and adds the site's three-view perspective set; the consumers differ (the landed row is CH02_B04's key frame, this set establishes the place from three camera positions), and because D1-40's formula is vril_plates = vril_site_rows x 3 the two rows count as ONE site against the floor. THE VRIL SITE'S NAME IS NOT THE ZONE: T0_Vril_Site_Registry gives VS_CH02_001 the site_name 'Liang Bua Cave waterfall vicinity', which is descriptive of the vicinity, while the ground these plates stand in is the recharge_waterfall zone (care_tier standard, protected false). The two are separate rows at separate coordinates — recharge_waterfall w=120.37085..120.39085 / s=-8.54934..-8.52934 against liang_bua_cave w=120.43329..120.45329 / s=-8.54061..-8.52061, non-overlapping boxes roughly 6.5 km apart (build/zones/flores_island.csv zone_bounds_wgs84) — which is why liang_bua_cave's elevated bar stops at its own zone and this row releases.
REC verdict REGENERATE_ALL
REC reason: All four hang polished marble or cast-stone slabs across the frame and O3 adds fluted columns, turning the wild recharge falls into a landscaped spa grotto.
REC defects: Manufactured marble/terrazzo lintels and benches on all 4, fluted stone columns on O3, formal pool coping throughout — built structure barred in this uninhabited water-body zone. Costume and figure are otherwise correct and worth carrying into the regen.
REGENERATED after vision review — 10 superseded plate(s) kept; recommendation void until the review runs again
O1 D1-40/VS_CH02_001/angle__bdb8fc3485fc.png sha256 019c923ba8ce9278... plate PLT_D050_1 licence record docs/licence_records/art_boards_plates/PLT_D050_1.json
caption: The first-water site read three ways; the threshold is physical, never a glow.
canon_id VS_CH02_001 in T0_Vril_Site_Registry/Sheet1 — canon_ref site:VS_CH02_001|zone:recharge_waterfall@flores_island|beat:CH02_B04
citations: SRC_00203, SRC_00483 (rows of registries/T0_Source_Material_Registry)
lane G · care_tier standard · protected false · care read from build/zones/flores_island.csv @ zone_id recharge_waterfall
recommended candidate: 1 (PROVISIONAL)
care: LANE G (RAW GENERATION), standard-care zone, no protected subject; the vril substrate is shown as falling water and cool air alone, with no cast effect and no aura. KEY ADJACENCY DECLARED — NEW PLATES FOR AN EXISTING SUBJECT, NEVER A RE-KEY: D1-40/VS_CH02_001 is already held by the LANDED row recharge-waterfall-first-water (PLT_G007_1..4 on BRD_0015). This row joins that same leaf board on that same key and adds the site's three-view perspective set; the consumers differ (the landed row is CH02_B04's key frame, this set establishes the place from three camera positions), and because D1-40's formula is vril_plates = vril_site_rows x 3 the two rows count as ONE site against the floor. THE VRIL SITE'S NAME IS NOT THE ZONE: T0_Vril_Site_Registry gives VS_CH02_001 the site_name 'Liang Bua Cave waterfall vicinity', which is descriptive of the vicinity, while the ground these plates stand in is the recharge_waterfall zone (care_tier standard, protected false). The two are separate rows at separate coordinates — recharge_waterfall w=120.37085..120.39085 / s=-8.54934..-8.52934 against liang_bua_cave w=120.43329..120.45329 / s=-8.54061..-8.52061, non-overlapping boxes roughly 6.5 km apart (build/zones/flores_island.csv zone_bounds_wgs84) — which is why liang_bua_cave's elevated bar stops at its own zone and this row releases.
REC verdict REGENERATE_ALL
REC reason: No candidate contains the waterfall the perspective set owes, and the staging goes wrong in every option — O3 puts a printed book in the child's hands, O1/O2 lay him prone in water under a looming disembodied pair of adult legs.
REC defects: Printed codex on O3 (manufactured object plus a pre-script-register breach at Ch 2); collapsed-child-in-water staging with a cropped adult standing over him on O1/O2; subject absent (no falls) on all 4; O4 is closest but carries a black wire-like foreign object on the near rock and crops the figure to legs.
REGENERATED after vision review — 9 superseded plate(s) kept; recommendation void until the review runs again
O1 D1-40/VS_CH02_001/detail__f44e4bbf7e5c.png sha256 436a397f7cfc8475... plate PLT_C051_1 licence record docs/licence_records/art_boards_plates/PLT_C051_1.json