BRD_0013 — Familiars (D1-29) — Flores Island leaf candidate sheet
GENERATED FILE. Rendered from MANIFEST.csv, PLATES.csv, RECS.csv and this board's content.json by harness/boards/render_board.py --board BRD_0013. Do not hand-edit; edit the sources.
board_shape leaf_candidate_sheet (row grain) — 5 rows × up to 4 candidates — approval_state critics_running — private
generation_class living — care_tier standard — generation_tier region_standard — decay_stage n_a
the four adversarial critics have NOT run on this plate set; critic_verdicts is empty and marketing_eligible computes false
every recommended_candidate in RECS.csv is PROVISIONAL until the REC vision pass runs
ROW:shell-the-water-familiar-registration
title: Shell (CR_0153 / W1) — registered at the falls, not yet bonded
canon_id FAM_01 in T0_Familiar_Registry/Sheet1 — canon_ref entity:FAM_01|entity:CR_0153|beat:CH02_B04
citations: SRC_00457, SRC_00169 (rows of registries/T0_Source_Material_Registry)
lane G · care_tier standard · protected false
recommended candidate: 1 (PROVISIONAL)
care: The bond is DEFERRED to Ch 3 (Mama Klara's water-source offering protocol) — a plate that stages contact, recognition or a bond breaks the chapter's end-state; no living-tradition claim attaches to the species, so no Manggarai cultural framing may be laid on the animal.
REC verdict REGENERATE_ALL
REC reason: All four render a hard-scuted river terrapin; FAM_01's species_class is the Flores giant softshell (Chitra chitra javanensis), which has a flat leathery scute-less carapace and a tubular snout.
REC defects: Wrong species on all 4 (hard keratin scutes, domed shell); O3/O4 add spiny non-turtle limb tubercles and a malformed forelimb; Shell is not one of the two register-split stylized subjects, so real-species accuracy binds.
REGENERATED after vision review — 12 superseded plate(s) kept; recommendation void until the review runs again
O1 D1-29/FAM_01/board_candidate__9aaf5b81d5f0.png sha256 3fc80be207717773... plate PLT_F041_1 licence record docs/licence_records/art_boards_plates/PLT_F041_1.json
title: Shell (CR_0153 / W1) — registered at the falls, not yet bonded
canon_id FAM_01 in T0_Familiar_Registry/Sheet1 — canon_ref entity:FAM_01|entity:CR_0153|beat:CH02_B04
citations: SRC_00169, SRC_00457 (rows of registries/T0_Source_Material_Registry)
lane G · care_tier standard · protected false · care read from DECLARED: T0_Familiar_Registry carries no care_tier/protected column and this row names no host zone, so the values are the DEFAULTs the class carries and the basis is the row's own care_notes. Boarded as a registry gap: cultural_depiction_required exists on T0_Creature_Roster and nowhere else, which is why the character-side care route has to be argued and cannot be read.
recommended candidate: 1 (PROVISIONAL)
care: The bond is DEFERRED to Ch 3 (Mama Klara's water-source offering protocol) — a plate that stages contact, recognition or a bond breaks the chapter's end-state. No living-tradition claim attaches to the species, so no Manggarai cultural framing may be laid on the animal.
REC verdict REGENERATE_ALL
REC reason: Same wrong-species failure as the registration row, and no candidate actually reads the animal THROUGH water — all four sit the turtle surfaced and fully exposed, so the row's own brief is unmet.
REC defects: Hard-scuted terrapin instead of the canon softshell; subject above water in every option, no refraction/submerged read; spiny limb tubercles inconsistent with the species.
REGENERATED after vision review — 14 superseded plate(s) kept; recommendation void until the review runs again
PENDING (no image) — NOT BARRED — LANE_G. Standard-care Zone-Catalog ground or neutral-ground subject: care read from DECLARED: T0_Familiar_Registry carries no care_tier/protected column and this row names no host zone, so the values are the DEFAULTs the class carries and the basis is the row's own care_notes. Boarded as a registry gap: cultural_depiction_required exists on T0_Creature_Roster and nowhere else, which is why the character-side care route has to be argued and cannot be read., and the entity-side cultural_depiction_required flag is absent or FALSE on every id this row keys or references. Both halves of the predicate are recorded on the row so the refusal stays arithmetic.
ROW:shell-surfacing-snout-study
title: Shell (CR_0153 / W1) — registered at the falls, not yet bonded
canon_id FAM_01 in T0_Familiar_Registry/Sheet1 — canon_ref entity:FAM_01|entity:CR_0153|beat:CH02_B04
citations: SRC_00169, SRC_00457 (rows of registries/T0_Source_Material_Registry)
lane G · care_tier standard · protected false · care read from DECLARED: T0_Familiar_Registry carries no care_tier/protected column and this row names no host zone, so the values are the DEFAULTs the class carries and the basis is the row's own care_notes. Boarded as a registry gap: cultural_depiction_required exists on T0_Creature_Roster and nowhere else, which is why the character-side care route has to be argued and cannot be read.
recommended candidate: 3 (PROVISIONAL)
care: The bond is DEFERRED to Ch 3 (Mama Klara's water-source offering protocol) — a plate that stages contact, recognition or a bond breaks the chapter's end-state. No living-tradition claim attaches to the species, so no Manggarai cultural framing may be laid on the animal.
REC verdict MIXED — recommended candidate O3
REC reason: O3 is the only candidate with a clean snorkel-snout read — correct nostril tube, plausible neck, clean ripple ring — and no text artifact or duplicated head.
REC defects: Whole row greyscale-only with no carapace in frame, so the species cannot be confirmed; necks read gharial-long rather than softshell; O2 carries a scribbled text artifact bottom-left plus a duplicated head in the reflection; O4 grows a serrated dorsal crest.
O1 D1-29/FAM_01/study__8553346fbbb8.png sha256 44c7c5c7be03a0e3... plate PLT_A0078_1 licence record docs/licence_records/art_boards_plates/PLT_A0078_1.json
O2 D1-29/FAM_01/study__51defae5ba1d.png sha256 e6299177addb099e... plate PLT_A0078_2 licence record docs/licence_records/art_boards_plates/PLT_A0078_2.json
O4 D1-29/FAM_01/study__9c947ba7cd52.png sha256 4970095e10a36f0a... plate PLT_A0078_4 licence record docs/licence_records/art_boards_plates/PLT_A0078_4.json
ROW:shell-scale-across-the-pool
title: Shell (CR_0153 / W1) — registered at the falls, not yet bonded
canon_id FAM_01 in T0_Familiar_Registry/Sheet1 — canon_ref entity:FAM_01|entity:CR_0153|beat:CH02_B04
citations: SRC_00169, SRC_00457 (rows of registries/T0_Source_Material_Registry)
lane G · care_tier standard · protected false · care read from DECLARED: T0_Familiar_Registry carries no care_tier/protected column and this row names no host zone, so the values are the DEFAULTs the class carries and the basis is the row's own care_notes. Boarded as a registry gap: cultural_depiction_required exists on T0_Creature_Roster and nowhere else, which is why the character-side care route has to be argued and cannot be read.
recommended candidate: 1 (PROVISIONAL)
care: The bond is DEFERRED to Ch 3 (Mama Klara's water-source offering protocol) — a plate that stages contact, recognition or a bond breaks the chapter's end-state. No living-tradition claim attaches to the species, so no Manggarai cultural framing may be laid on the animal.
REC verdict REGENERATE_ALL
REC reason: Every candidate stages the scale comparison in a modern swimming pool — concrete coping, tiled edge, poolside furniture, chlorinated turquoise water.
REC defects: Modern built pool and poolside furniture in all 4; sea-turtle flippers instead of the softshell's webbed feet; anime/cel register breaks the realistic-ethnographic bar; O2 renders two turtles.
REGENERATED after vision review — 14 superseded plate(s) kept; recommendation void until the review runs again
PENDING (no image) — NOT BARRED — LANE_G. Standard-care Zone-Catalog ground or neutral-ground subject: care read from DECLARED: T0_Familiar_Registry carries no care_tier/protected column and this row names no host zone, so the values are the DEFAULTs the class carries and the basis is the row's own care_notes. Boarded as a registry gap: cultural_depiction_required exists on T0_Creature_Roster and nowhere else, which is why the character-side care route has to be argued and cannot be read., and the entity-side cultural_depiction_required flag is absent or FALSE on every id this row keys or references. Both halves of the predicate are recorded on the row so the refusal stays arithmetic.
ROW:shell-carapace-surface-detail
title: Shell (CR_0153 / W1) — registered at the falls, not yet bonded
canon_id FAM_01 in T0_Familiar_Registry/Sheet1 — canon_ref entity:FAM_01|entity:CR_0153|beat:CH02_B04
citations: SRC_00169, SRC_00457 (rows of registries/T0_Source_Material_Registry)
lane G · care_tier standard · protected false · care read from DECLARED: T0_Familiar_Registry carries no care_tier/protected column and this row names no host zone, so the values are the DEFAULTs the class carries and the basis is the row's own care_notes. Boarded as a registry gap: cultural_depiction_required exists on T0_Creature_Roster and nowhere else, which is why the character-side care route has to be argued and cannot be read.
recommended candidate: 3 (PROVISIONAL)
care: The bond is DEFERRED to Ch 3 (Mama Klara's water-source offering protocol) — a plate that stages contact, recognition or a bond breaks the chapter's end-state. No living-tradition claim attaches to the species, so no Manggarai cultural framing may be laid on the animal.
REC verdict MIXED — recommended candidate O3
REC reason: O3 is the only option carrying the correct leathery scute-less carapace read without the disembodied human hand that mars O1, O2 and O4.
REC defects: O1/O2/O4 insert a floating cropped human hand at wrong scale; O2 grows crab claws; O3's salmon rim reads crustacean and the shells present as dead specimens on white rather than a live animal's back.
O1 D1-29/FAM_01/detail__d07e5d0efb2b.png sha256 0a18ab4d9fdb9264... plate PLT_A0080_1 licence record docs/licence_records/art_boards_plates/PLT_A0080_1.json
O2 D1-29/FAM_01/detail__e4d2ea7073e2.png sha256 dcf010c987019e84... plate PLT_A0080_2 licence record docs/licence_records/art_boards_plates/PLT_A0080_2.json