GENERATED FILE. Rendered from MANIFEST.csv, PLATES.csv, RECS.csv and this board's content.json by harness/boards/render_board.py --board BRD_0045. Do not hand-edit; edit the sources.
REC reason: The effect is right and the world is not: a tall twisting column of dust with a clod at its top rising out of a cobble-ringed crater, a real escalation over the novice clod. Verified at 1344 on candidate 2, the frame also carries a neat stacked pier of fired bricks, a stack of machine-sawn planks, a dark angular sheet at the foreground edge and utility poles carrying a line along the horizon. Four modern artifacts in one frame is a pattern rather than an incident, and it costs Tremor Stomp its cast ladder.
REC defects: Q6 the acting-surface sentence itself: 'one continuous surface of unworked earth ... and rounded natural fieldstone and river cobbles half-buried in it'; Q7 the period anchor: 'Everything built or made in this frame is hand-worked from sun-dried mud brick, lime plaster, undressed fieldstone, split timber, thatch and plain iron'; Q11 impact_receives as a per-tier dict, and the band-escalating subject noun (one piece / several moving together / the shape of the terrain); Q10 'plain undyed working clothes: a straight-sleeved pullover shirt with its sleeves pushed back above the elbows, straight-cut trousers and flat working boots', dispatched by every staging class
REGENERATED after vision review — 16 superseded plate(s) kept; recommendation void until the review runs again
PENDING (no image) — promised, not yet produced
ROW:tremor-stomp-earth-t5-impact
canon_id A_E_002 in T0_Ability_Tree_Registry/Sheet1 — canon_ref entity:A_E_002
citations: n_a_design_law (rows of registries/T0_Source_Material_Registry)
lane G · care_tier standard · protected false
recommended candidate: 3 (PROVISIONAL)
REC verdict MIXED
REC reason: PICKED. Verified at 1344: the same wall one rung up -- the crack now runs the full height AND a whole panel of lime plaster has shed off it and hangs, with rubble at the foot and the courses opened behind. deciding axis LAW: the adept rung of the band-complete ladder, and the escalation from Y0024 is a state change in one surface rather than a change of distance. Crack and spall are both in plain mud plaster. NAMED FIX: flat grey slabs sit in the wall's top course and a small blue-grey fragment lies in the rubble; both are set dressing, neither is the receiver's damaged face.
REC defects: Q7 the period anchor: 'Everything built or made in this frame is hand-worked from sun-dried mud brick, lime plaster, undressed fieldstone, split timber, thatch and plain iron'; Q10 'plain undyed working clothes: a straight-sleeved pullover shirt with its sleeves pushed back above the elbows, straight-cut trousers and flat working boots', dispatched by every staging class
REGENERATED after vision review — 15 superseded plate(s) kept; recommendation void until the review runs again
O3 D1-27/A_E_002/beat_impact__de873e7f4bc6.png sha256 3da2fc304373fb46... plate PLT_Y0026_3 licence record docs/licence_records/art_boards_plates/PLT_Y0026_3.json
REC reason: DISQUALIFIED ON THE ACTING SURFACE: the mastery crater is cut through a bed of flat CUT SLABS laid in courses, on 4 of 4, and candidate 3 is a stack of dressed slabs at the crater lip. The one clause the whole regeneration was written to enforce is contradicted by the effect's own rim. The crater is also smaller than the adept plume above it, so the cast ladder is non-monotonic as well as disqualified.
REC defects: Q6 the acting-surface sentence itself: 'one continuous surface of unworked earth ... and rounded natural fieldstone and river cobbles half-buried in it'; Q11 impact_receives as a per-tier dict, and the band-escalating subject noun (one piece / several moving together / the shape of the terrain); Q10 'plain undyed working clothes: a straight-sleeved pullover shirt with its sleeves pushed back above the elbows, straight-cut trousers and flat working boots', dispatched by every staging class
REGENERATED after vision review — 16 superseded plate(s) kept; recommendation void until the review runs again
PENDING (no image) — promised, not yet produced
ROW:tremor-stomp-earth-t8-impact
canon_id A_E_002 in T0_Ability_Tree_Registry/Sheet1 — canon_ref entity:A_E_002
citations: n_a_design_law (rows of registries/T0_Source_Material_Registry)
lane G · care_tier standard · protected false
recommended candidate: 4 (PROVISIONAL)
REC verdict MIXED
REC reason: PICKED. Verified at 1344: the same wall two rungs up -- a whole section has come down, brick and mud rubble spilling forward, the cobble coping tumbled, the plain running away past the breach. deciding axis LAW: the mastery rung of the band-complete ladder. Crack, then crack plus shed plaster, then collapse: three states of one surface, monotonic, on one A/B. NAMED FIX: a regular grey course laces the wall along its length -- it reads as a stone levelling course, which is genuine ancient practice, and its units are more regular than hand-worked stone would be.
REC defects: Q7 the period anchor: 'Everything built or made in this frame is hand-worked from sun-dried mud brick, lime plaster, undressed fieldstone, split timber, thatch and plain iron'; Q10 'plain undyed working clothes: a straight-sleeved pullover shirt with its sleeves pushed back above the elbows, straight-cut trousers and flat working boots', dispatched by every staging class
REGENERATED after vision review — 15 superseded plate(s) kept; recommendation void until the review runs again
O4 D1-27/A_E_002/beat_impact__3fea676460a0.png sha256 4446bf9709ea05b3... plate PLT_Y0028_4 licence record docs/licence_records/art_boards_plates/PLT_Y0028_4.json
canon_id A_E_003 in T0_Ability_Tree_Registry/Sheet1 — canon_ref entity:A_E_003
citations: n_a_design_law (rows of registries/T0_Source_Material_Registry)
lane G · care_tier standard · protected false
recommended candidate: 2 (PROVISIONAL)
REC verdict MIXED
REC reason: PICKED. Verified at 1344: two clods of dry earth suspended above a small cobble-ringed crater with soil streaming off the lower one, the caster at the frame edge seen from behind with his hand open, empty and a body-width clear of the material. deciding axis LAW: the separation renders untouched at the smallest rung of the set, and the acting surface is stamped soil, straw and half-buried fieldstone with zero paving and zero brick anywhere in the frame. NAMED FIX: candidates 1 and 3 of this row render the lifted mass as a giant clenched FIST -- the picked candidate carries none of it, and the class is recorded against the row.
REC defects: Q14 P3's fix text itself -- 'standing a full stride out from two open, still, empty hands' -- now inside the EFFECT's own subject noun phrase; Q6 the acting-surface sentence itself: 'one continuous surface of unworked earth ... and rounded natural fieldstone and river cobbles half-buried in it'; Q10 'plain undyed working clothes: a straight-sleeved pullover shirt with its sleeves pushed back above the elbows, straight-cut trousers and flat working boots', dispatched by every staging class
REGENERATED after vision review — 15 superseded plate(s) kept; recommendation void until the review runs again
O2 D1-27/A_E_003/beat_cast__950c0a1d3299.png sha256 ee7df420b06350b7... plate PLT_Y0029_2 licence record docs/licence_records/art_boards_plates/PLT_Y0029_2.json
REC reason: NEAR MISS, disqualified on the receiver's own fabric. Verified at 1344 on candidate 2: a rammed earth wall punched through with earth spilling and dust rising, which is the right impact at the right scale -- and the wall's top plate is a machine-sawn beam carrying a row of protruding square-headed BOLTS, with a grey sharp-edged fragment in the foreground. The bolts are in the wall, and the wall is what the plate exists to brief. Candidate 3's caster wears modern eyeglasses.
REC defects: Q7 the period anchor: 'Everything built or made in this frame is hand-worked from sun-dried mud brick, lime plaster, undressed fieldstone, split timber, thatch and plain iron'; Q10 'plain undyed working clothes: a straight-sleeved pullover shirt with its sleeves pushed back above the elbows, straight-cut trousers and flat working boots', dispatched by every staging class
REGENERATED after vision review — 16 superseded plate(s) kept; recommendation void until the review runs again
PENDING (no image) — promised, not yet produced
ROW:rock-throw-earth-t5-cast
canon_id A_E_003 in T0_Ability_Tree_Registry/Sheet1 — canon_ref entity:A_E_003
citations: n_a_design_law (rows of registries/T0_Source_Material_Registry)
lane G · care_tier standard · protected false
recommended candidate: 2 (PROVISIONAL)
REC verdict MIXED
REC reason: THE PICK OF THE GENERATION, verified at 1344px. A pale cracked limestone mass hangs in open air with wet dark soil clinging to its underside and loose grit and clods dropping from it in a visible fall-line, over the torn open socket it came out of with dust standing in the pit. The caster stands at the right, SEEN FROM BEHIND, arms down, hands relaxed and EMPTY; nothing touches the mass. The acting surface is unworked broken earth with straw, loose limestone cobbles and natural stone -- ZERO paving, zero kerbs, zero modern objects anywhere in frame, which no other row in 96 achieves. The adept band camera is obeyed exactly: the effect claims the whole space, the surface reads for several paces, the person is small at the edge with their back turned. Earth never emits and this reads by occlusion, by carried dirt and by silhouette against a pale sky. THE FIX: the frame reaches the whole adult where the class asks for the top edge at the shoulder line, which is P4's mechanism running in the harmless direction.
REC defects: P4 'the frame's top edge sits at the collarbone', an invariant of the class, against the band_camera authored beside it
REGENERATED after vision review — 15 superseded plate(s) kept; recommendation void until the review runs again
O2 D1-27/A_E_003/beat_cast__26bec875f291.png sha256 8f6f56ab89aa7e41... plate PLT_X0031_2 licence record docs/licence_records/art_boards_plates/PLT_X0031_2.json
REC reason: Disqualified on the same class as Y0030 and verified at 1344: the timber rails through the punctured wall carry regular round bolt heads and machine-drilled holes in three places. The hole is also barely larger than the novice rung's, so the adept step of the impact ladder is the weakest of its three.
REC defects: Q7 the period anchor: 'Everything built or made in this frame is hand-worked from sun-dried mud brick, lime plaster, undressed fieldstone, split timber, thatch and plain iron'; Q10 'plain undyed working clothes: a straight-sleeved pullover shirt with its sleeves pushed back above the elbows, straight-cut trousers and flat working boots', dispatched by every staging class
REGENERATED after vision review — 16 superseded plate(s) kept; recommendation void until the review runs again
PENDING (no image) — promised, not yet produced
ROW:rock-throw-earth-t8-cast
canon_id A_E_003 in T0_Ability_Tree_Registry/Sheet1 — canon_ref entity:A_E_003
citations: n_a_design_law (rows of registries/T0_Source_Material_Registry)
lane G · care_tier standard · protected false
recommended candidate: 3 (PROVISIONAL)
REC verdict MIXED
REC reason: PICKED. Verified at 1344: three masses moving together above an open crater -- a large central one with a fresh split face and earth hanging under it, and two smaller ones flanking -- with the caster at the frame edge, hand empty and clear. deciding axis TIER: the mastery rung of the Rock Throw cast ladder, and the escalation is in the EVENT (one clod, one boulder, several moving together) rather than in the lens. The material reads as broken pale rock with soil clinging, not as plaster. NAMED FIX: candidate 1 of this row renders its three masses as HOLLOW open boxes and is demoted for it; a small stack of sawn planks sits at the far right of the picked frame.
REC defects: Q6 the acting-surface sentence itself: 'one continuous surface of unworked earth ... and rounded natural fieldstone and river cobbles half-buried in it'; Q10 'plain undyed working clothes: a straight-sleeved pullover shirt with its sleeves pushed back above the elbows, straight-cut trousers and flat working boots', dispatched by every staging class
REGENERATED after vision review — 15 superseded plate(s) kept; recommendation void until the review runs again
O3 D1-27/A_E_003/beat_cast__c0c3a2353d9c.png sha256 e585a1a1a13e7cd3... plate PLT_Y0033_3 licence record docs/licence_records/art_boards_plates/PLT_Y0033_3.json
canon_id A_E_003 in T0_Ability_Tree_Registry/Sheet1 — canon_ref entity:A_E_003
citations: n_a_design_law (rows of registries/T0_Source_Material_Registry)
lane G · care_tier standard · protected false
recommended candidate: 4 (PROVISIONAL)
REC verdict MIXED
REC reason: PICKED. Verified at 1344: a thatched mud-brick building with a whole section blown out, timber framing splintered, dust billowing through the breach and rubble across the ground. deciding axis TIER: the mastery rung of the Rock Throw impact ladder and a legible escalation over a puncture and a hole. NAMED FIX: a pale grey perforated block lies in the rubble at the frame edge and the caster appears to wear eyeglasses -- both are set dressing at the frame's margin, and the breach itself is mud brick, timber and thatch throughout. The two lower rungs of this ladder are disqualified on bolts in the receiver, so this is a single-band pick and says so.
REC defects: Q7 the period anchor: 'Everything built or made in this frame is hand-worked from sun-dried mud brick, lime plaster, undressed fieldstone, split timber, thatch and plain iron'; Q10 'plain undyed working clothes: a straight-sleeved pullover shirt with its sleeves pushed back above the elbows, straight-cut trousers and flat working boots', dispatched by every staging class
REGENERATED after vision review — 15 superseded plate(s) kept; recommendation void until the review runs again
O4 D1-27/A_E_003/beat_impact__fca666ac7dc1.png sha256 004243e5a765e7e7... plate PLT_Y0034_4 licence record docs/licence_records/art_boards_plates/PLT_Y0034_4.json
REC reason: The barrier renders as a row of separate stacked BRICK PIERS with gaps between them on 4 of 4 -- built masonry, not lifted ground, and standing already built rather than rising. Candidate 3 is the only one that reads as slabs raised out of the earth, and its slabs are rectangular and dressed.
REC defects: Q15 Stone Wall's own plate_subject, which names a WALL; Q11 impact_receives as a per-tier dict, and the band-escalating subject noun (one piece / several moving together / the shape of the terrain); Q10 'plain undyed working clothes: a straight-sleeved pullover shirt with its sleeves pushed back above the elbows, straight-cut trousers and flat working boots', dispatched by every staging class
REGENERATED after vision review — 16 superseded plate(s) kept; recommendation void until the review runs again
PENDING (no image) — promised, not yet produced
ROW:stone-wall-earth-t5-impact
canon_id A_E_004 in T0_Ability_Tree_Registry/Sheet1 — canon_ref entity:A_E_004
citations: n_a_design_law (rows of registries/T0_Source_Material_Registry)
REC reason: Nothing arrives on any candidate. Candidates 2 and 3 render the wall as a mud panel carrying a regular grid of round holes, which is a dovecote; candidate 1 is a mud-brick building with a doorway and no event at all.
REC defects: Q15 Stone Wall's own plate_subject, which names a WALL; Q5 no clause -- these rows dispatch a subject, a form, a light sentence and four beats, and the beat the plate exists to brief is absent from every candidate; Q11 impact_receives as a per-tier dict, and the band-escalating subject noun (one piece / several moving together / the shape of the terrain)
REGENERATED after vision review — 16 superseded plate(s) kept; recommendation void until the review runs again
PENDING (no image) — promised, not yet produced
Generated by harness/site/structure_site.py — the URL path is the repo path. review root