GENERATED FILE. Rendered from MANIFEST.csv, PLATES.csv, RECS.csv and this board's content.json by harness/boards/render_board.py --board BRD_0043. Do not hand-edit; edit the sources.
REC reason: Dust streams from the lowered fingertips on 4 of 4 -- unchanged from generation 3, and the one place the EMPTY-hands fix could not reach, because the material is at hand scale. The acting surface is the fix working: stamped soil, loose straw and half-buried rounded fieldstone, zero paving on 4 of 4. No face on 4 of 4.
REC defects: Q1 the carried-material subject line, which now names the hands as open, still and EMPTY and states the distance itself instead of delegating it to a tail clause; Q11 impact_receives as a per-tier dict, and the band-escalating subject noun (one piece / several moving together / the shape of the terrain); Q10 'plain undyed working clothes: a straight-sleeved pullover shirt with its sleeves pushed back above the elbows, straight-cut trousers and flat working boots', dispatched by every staging class
REGENERATED after vision review — 16 superseded plate(s) kept; recommendation void until the review runs again
PENDING (no image) — promised, not yet produced
ROW:wind-step-air-t1-impact
canon_id A_A_001 in T0_Ability_Tree_Registry/Sheet1 — canon_ref entity:A_A_001
citations: n_a_design_law (rows of registries/T0_Source_Material_Registry)
REC reason: The reed screen stands on its posts on 4 of 4 and now BOWS on 3 of 4 -- the receiver's verb renders, which corrects generation 3's 1 of 4 on this row. The event is still tiny and the novice rung is the largest of the three, so the ladder is non-monotonic from its first step. Ground clean, backs turned, no face on 4 of 4.
REC defects: Q11 impact_receives as a per-tier dict, and the band-escalating subject noun (one piece / several moving together / the shape of the terrain); Q10 'plain undyed working clothes: a straight-sleeved pullover shirt with its sleeves pushed back above the elbows, straight-cut trousers and flat working boots', dispatched by every staging class
REGENERATED after vision review — 16 superseded plate(s) kept; recommendation void until the review runs again
PENDING (no image) — promised, not yet produced
ROW:wind-step-air-t5-cast
canon_id A_A_001 in T0_Ability_Tree_Registry/Sheet1 — canon_ref entity:A_A_001
citations: n_a_design_law (rows of registries/T0_Source_Material_Registry)
REC reason: The adept event is the biggest thing Wind Step renders anywhere: a corridor of dust standing up off the ground in discrete columns marching away from the caster, 4 of 4, with the separation holding. And candidate 4 terminates those columns in five enormous human HANDS rising out of the ground -- P3's own fix text drawn as an object. Candidates 1 and 2 also put three or four unbriefed figures in the middle distance on a clause that names one adult.
REC defects: Q14 P3's fix text itself -- 'standing a full stride out from two open, still, empty hands' -- now inside the EFFECT's own subject noun phrase; Q11 impact_receives as a per-tier dict, and the band-escalating subject noun (one piece / several moving together / the shape of the terrain); Q10 'plain undyed working clothes: a straight-sleeved pullover shirt with its sleeves pushed back above the elbows, straight-cut trousers and flat working boots', dispatched by every staging class
REGENERATED after vision review — 16 superseded plate(s) kept; recommendation void until the review runs again
PENDING (no image) — promised, not yet produced
ROW:wind-step-air-t5-impact
canon_id A_A_001 in T0_Ability_Tree_Registry/Sheet1 — canon_ref entity:A_A_001
citations: n_a_design_law (rows of registries/T0_Source_Material_Registry)
REC reason: Straw bundles lie fallen against the screen on 4 of 4 and the screen itself stands intact and unbowed on 4 of 4, so the receiver renders its debris and not its verb -- weaker than the novice rung directly below it. Candidate 4 sets the screen on a course of dark grey blockwork. Ground clean otherwise, no face on 4 of 4.
REC defects: Q11 impact_receives as a per-tier dict, and the band-escalating subject noun (one piece / several moving together / the shape of the terrain); Q10 'plain undyed working clothes: a straight-sleeved pullover shirt with its sleeves pushed back above the elbows, straight-cut trousers and flat working boots', dispatched by every staging class
REGENERATED after vision review — 16 superseded plate(s) kept; recommendation void until the review runs again
PENDING (no image) — promised, not yet produced
ROW:wind-step-air-t8-cast
canon_id A_A_001 in T0_Ability_Tree_Registry/Sheet1 — canon_ref entity:A_A_001
citations: n_a_design_law (rows of registries/T0_Source_Material_Registry)
REC reason: The mastery rung is a man walking away down a track with a faint puff of dust at his heels, 4 of 4. The camera is exactly right -- landscape distance, the ground running to a horizon, the figure distant and seen from behind -- and the event inside it is smaller than the novice rung's. This is the clearest non-monotonic ladder in the set.
REC defects: Q11 impact_receives as a per-tier dict, and the band-escalating subject noun (one piece / several moving together / the shape of the terrain); Q10 'plain undyed working clothes: a straight-sleeved pullover shirt with its sleeves pushed back above the elbows, straight-cut trousers and flat working boots', dispatched by every staging class
REGENERATED after vision review — 16 superseded plate(s) kept; recommendation void until the review runs again
PENDING (no image) — promised, not yet produced
ROW:wind-step-air-t8-impact
canon_id A_A_001 in T0_Ability_Tree_Registry/Sheet1 — canon_ref entity:A_A_001
citations: n_a_design_law (rows of registries/T0_Source_Material_Registry)
REC reason: NOTHING IS IN FRAME. A man standing in front of a mud-brick wall with no dust, no screen, no receiver and no effect of any kind, 4 of 4, on a mastery impact row. The purest instance of the beat not being dispatched in four generations.
REC defects: Q5 no clause -- these rows dispatch a subject, a form, a light sentence and four beats, and the beat the plate exists to brief is absent from every candidate; Q11 impact_receives as a per-tier dict, and the band-escalating subject noun (one piece / several moving together / the shape of the terrain); Q10 'plain undyed working clothes: a straight-sleeved pullover shirt with its sleeves pushed back above the elbows, straight-cut trousers and flat working boots', dispatched by every staging class
REGENERATED after vision review — 16 superseded plate(s) kept; recommendation void until the review runs again
PENDING (no image) — promised, not yet produced
ROW:gust-push-air-t1-cast
canon_id A_A_002 in T0_Ability_Tree_Registry/Sheet1 — canon_ref entity:A_A_002
citations: n_a_design_law (rows of registries/T0_Source_Material_Registry)
REC reason: Dust falls from the lowered open hand as a hanging curtain on 4 of 4 -- the same hand-scale failure as Y0001, and the novice rung of the one ability whose adept and mastery rungs both carry the separation. Ground is unworked earth and cobbles on 4 of 4. Candidates 2 and 4 stack machine-sawn planks in the background.
REC defects: Q1 the carried-material subject line, which now names the hands as open, still and EMPTY and states the distance itself instead of delegating it to a tail clause; Q10 'plain undyed working clothes: a straight-sleeved pullover shirt with its sleeves pushed back above the elbows, straight-cut trousers and flat working boots', dispatched by every staging class
REGENERATED after vision review — 16 superseded plate(s) kept; recommendation void until the review runs again
PENDING (no image) — promised, not yet produced
ROW:gust-push-air-t1-impact
canon_id A_A_002 in T0_Ability_Tree_Registry/Sheet1 — canon_ref entity:A_A_002
citations: n_a_design_law (rows of registries/T0_Source_Material_Registry)
REC reason: The reeds bend and blow on 3 of 4, which is the receiver's verb rendering, and on candidates 2 and 3 the caster's own hand is IN the reeds pushing them, so the impact frame stages the caster as the actor. The wall behind is rubble stone set in red fired brick with cement-grey mortar on 2 of 4.
REC defects: Q7 the period anchor: 'Everything built or made in this frame is hand-worked from sun-dried mud brick, lime plaster, undressed fieldstone, split timber, thatch and plain iron'; Q11 impact_receives as a per-tier dict, and the band-escalating subject noun (one piece / several moving together / the shape of the terrain); Q10 'plain undyed working clothes: a straight-sleeved pullover shirt with its sleeves pushed back above the elbows, straight-cut trousers and flat working boots', dispatched by every staging class
REGENERATED after vision review — 16 superseded plate(s) kept; recommendation void until the review runs again
PENDING (no image) — promised, not yet produced
ROW:gust-push-air-t5-cast
canon_id A_A_002 in T0_Ability_Tree_Registry/Sheet1 — canon_ref entity:A_A_002
citations: n_a_design_law (rows of registries/T0_Source_Material_Registry)
lane G · care_tier standard · protected false
recommended candidate: 1 (PROVISIONAL)
REC verdict MIXED
REC reason: THE PICK, re-verified at 1344px. A turning wall of lifted dust and leaf litter stands a full stride clear of two open, still, EMPTY hands -- nothing touching it, no thrown arc, no vessel, no tool -- with twigs and grit carried in it and dust boiling at ground level; the figure is fully clothed, arms spread, seen from behind, no face anywhere in frame, 4 of 4. The Air law is satisfied exactly: visible only by what it carries, no self-lit air. THE FIXES: the acting surface carries rectangular paving slabs laid over the dirt across the whole foreground (P1), and the dust composes as a near-symmetrical arch AROUND the caster rather than as the spread that has crossed the ground and stripped it bare, which the contact sheet flattered.
REC defects: P1 the family plate_setting, which names the BUILT WORLD's materials and never names the materials of the ground the effect acts on
REGENERATED after vision review — 15 superseded plate(s) kept; recommendation void until the review runs again
O1 D1-27/A_A_002/beat_cast__d38e74a18aa9.png sha256 afc40cd6a07dece5... plate PLT_X0009_1 licence record docs/licence_records/art_boards_plates/PLT_X0009_1.json
REC reason: A woven mat hangs slack and motionless between two posts on 4 of 4 with a small dust puff at ground level -- the receiver renders its noun and not its verb, and the adept impact is smaller than the novice impact directly above it. No face on 4 of 4.
REC defects: Q11 impact_receives as a per-tier dict, and the band-escalating subject noun (one piece / several moving together / the shape of the terrain); Q10 'plain undyed working clothes: a straight-sleeved pullover shirt with its sleeves pushed back above the elbows, straight-cut trousers and flat working boots', dispatched by every staging class
REGENERATED after vision review — 16 superseded plate(s) kept; recommendation void until the review runs again
PENDING (no image) — promised, not yet produced
ROW:gust-push-air-t8-cast
canon_id A_A_002 in T0_Ability_Tree_Registry/Sheet1 — canon_ref entity:A_A_002
citations: n_a_design_law (rows of registries/T0_Source_Material_Registry)
lane G · care_tier standard · protected false
recommended candidate: 4 (PROVISIONAL)
REC verdict MIXED
REC reason: deciding axis LAW: Candidate 4 is the only plate in 384 where the lifted material stands clear of an open, still hand -- dust off the floor and an arc of leaf litter carried over the palm with nothing touching either. It reads as an ability and not as someone throwing something, and it satisfies the Air law exactly: the effect is visible only by what it carries and there is no self-lit air anywhere in the frame. Verified at the plate's own 1344px: no face, no jewellery, no ritual object. THE FIX BEFORE IT IS BUILT: this is the mastery row and the event is at arm's reach, so the frame moves back to the courtyard scale the read names, on both palms.
REC defects: M14 the mastery band reads at novice scale; M12 lower face on 3 of the 4 (candidate 4 is clean)
REGENERATED after vision review — 15 superseded plate(s) kept; recommendation void until the review runs again
O4 D1-27/A_A_002/beat_cast__b8e039d0a647.png sha256 e638efdd6038a9cb... plate PLT_W0011_4 licence record docs/licence_records/art_boards_plates/PLT_W0011_4.json
REC reason: A man standing in a yard with a faint haze and no receiver, 4 of 4. Candidate 1 lays a cobbled pavement across the foreground; candidate 2's wall is regular red fired brick with a grey band; candidate 3 runs a thin dark cable across the sky above the ruins.
REC defects: Q5 no clause -- these rows dispatch a subject, a form, a light sentence and four beats, and the beat the plate exists to brief is absent from every candidate; Q6 the acting-surface sentence itself: 'one continuous surface of unworked earth ... and rounded natural fieldstone and river cobbles half-buried in it'; Q7 the period anchor: 'Everything built or made in this frame is hand-worked from sun-dried mud brick, lime plaster, undressed fieldstone, split timber, thatch and plain iron'; Q11 impact_receives as a per-tier dict, and the band-escalating subject noun (one piece / several moving together / the shape of the terrain)
REGENERATED after vision review — 16 superseded plate(s) kept; recommendation void until the review runs again
PENDING (no image) — promised, not yet produced
Generated by harness/site/structure_site.py — the URL path is the repo path. review root